Nothing you just said.....explains away the illogic.
What's interesting is that often we see people, including non-Christians, (maybe especially non-Christians) use teaching and principles from the Bible to manufacture hypocrisy in the conservative viewpoint. When it's an argument about public services in the way of financial assistance, people will eagerly go through Scripture and find what they need to interpet the meaning they want to create. And they'll come up with all these arguments for why Jesus would support OWS, or be a fan of public assistance, just from the words He DID speak. But Jesus never mentioned OWS. He never mentioned government assistance. But you won't hear these people that ascribe certain points of view to Jesus complaining that Jesus never actually spoke the specific words "protest" and "welfare".
And then again, when it comes to abortion, many of the same people will spin right around and say "Nowhere in the Bible can you find the word 'abortion'".
Clearly, when it suits these people, they'll interpret and derive an understanding from the Word. When it suits them, they'll depend on the literal Word.
And atheists who want to argue with believers will often complain about both approaches and cite both for explanation of their disbelief. It just depends on who they're arguing against. If they're arguing against more fundamental literalist beliefs, they'll complain about how harsh and unforgiving God is for not having mercy on the person who doesn't know Him. If they're arguing against Catholics, what they'll do, as is illustrated here, is fight against our belief in God's mercy for the person ignorant of Him. And when they can't quite make God out to be that hard case, they'll move the argument. Now that they can't make that case for how unsympathetic God is, it's about either He's a liar or the Church has it wrong and God really is that hard case they talk about elsewhere.
Gordon, the need for purification before entering the Kingdom is discussed throughout the Bible. If JV's got the patience to go look up the Verse numbers for you, God bless him/her. Personally, I think it's futile. I don't think you're interested in learning anything about what a faith you purport to curious about believes. I'm more inclined to agree with JV about your quest for what you feel you can turn inside out. But if you're really curious, you are capable of doing the research yourself. Is the word " Purgatory" in the Bible? You know what? I really don't know. Is the place of the dead and necessity for what goes on in Purgatory discussed in the Bible? Absolutely.
You also have to be careful. If you're not comfortable with poking fun at and criticizing the "irrationality" of Judaism, you might want to rethink and verify some of the things you claim about Catholicism. Purgatory and indulgences are just two of our beliefs that originate with Judaism. Jesus doesn't deny these. His coming changes them. And maybe before we make ignorant comments about indulgences, we might want to look into what they actually are and how they're "purchased". They most certainly are "transferable".