And what did he do to warrant such bad treatment and demonization from those on the left? That's the bigger mystery. Left doesn't like anyone discussing their faith publicly?
If you check my own posting history, you'll see I had no issue with him as a person. For example, here's one from when he was slotted to speak at the GOP convention:
What makes you think Tebow is despised by the left? I'm a Broncos fan and was happy when the team got rid of him, because I could see it was a really strong squad being held back by a guy who wasn't bright enough to read an NFL defense to save his life. But, I never had an issue with him personally. He gave thoughtful, polite interviews, never took a play off, and judging by his physique he must have trained hard. He seemed like a good teammate and a pillar of the community. His religious beliefs were a bit annoying to an atheist like me, but that didn't single him out -- nearly everyone in the NFL is religious, and most are vocal about it. You hear plenty of God talk from guys who actually know how to play quarterback at the NFL level, like Elway and Manning. As for being pro-life, I have no issue at all with that, as long as people don't try to force others to observe their own religious taboos by force of law. I don't know where Tebow stands on that -- whether he's content to encourage people to make what he believes to be the right choice, or whether he wants to deny people a choice altogether.
But, to answer your question, I think there were those on the left who demonized him for the same tribal reasons that caused Zam-Zam to laud him here. There are people who can't really compartmentalize enough to regard separately the question of what political "tribe" someone belongs to and how they feel about the person as a person (or, for that matter, as an athlete/artist/etc.) I don't think it was as simple as the left not liking people to discuss their faith publicly. That kind of thing is practically a universal behavior in pro sports. It's an absolute cliche to hear a pro athlete thanking God for a win, or making a show of kneeling in the end-zone or praying at the 50 yard line, etc. Generally that's not enough on the left or the right to mark an athlete as a member of a political tribe, precisely because it's so common. Tebow went beyond that by making the rounds of political talk shows, doing a Super Bowl ad about abortion, speaking at GOP political events, etc. He clearly aligned himself with the political right, and that caused a strong reaction in a lot of those on the political left.
For my part, I think I'm pretty good at compartmentalizing my tribal instincts from my appraisals of other aspects of a person. For example, Clint Eastwood is emphatically a member of the conservative "tribe" -- having taken a prominent (and embarrassing) role at a GOP political convention. But that doesn't change the fact I regard him as a gifted director and a decent actor. And there are a lot of celebrities whom I quite appreciate as political figures who do absolutely nothing for me as human beings or artists/athletes, etc. (e.g., Angelina Jolie).