New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Tom Brokaw

(((((BobbyT))))) ((((((Mytzlplk))))))
It's okay. I didn't read it, but really, it's okay.
I know you guys have a hard time when anyone disagrees with you.

Case in point. Some people block out information because they worry it might penetrate their denial, then still believe they are in command of all the relevant facts to judge others.
 
You've mirrored many of my thoughts. Drones are a terror weapon, and they kill indiscriminately. The make more enemies for us. That said, what's the alternative?

"Peace does not mean simply the absence of war. A true peace, a lasting peace, must be based on economic justice."-Gerry Adams
 
"Peace does not mean simply the absence of war. A true peace, a lasting peace, must be based on economic justice."-Gerry Adams

Indeed. But as long as there is a means to 'get more,' there will be those who stop at nothing to do so. The rich do indeed get richer, and it ain't just by working harder than the other guy. And they convince themselves that they 'deserve' their riches. When the blackout comes (or whatever catastrophe) there will be hoarders and there will be sharers. The hoarders may well prosper, but at what cost to their soul? But in two generations, those who came from 'hoarders' will be rich and believe themselves to be more worthy than the descendents of sharers (I'm looking at you Rothschild, Kennedy, Bush, Carnegie, etc.). It is ever thus.
 
Doesn't Brokaw think that the invasions and 10+ year occupations of Afghanistan and Iraq might be a much greater factor in their motivation? Cons are more that happy, tho, to blame it on the drones only.
 
Doesn't Brokaw think that the invasions and 10+ year occupations of Afghanistan and Iraq might be a much greater factor in their motivation? Cons are more that happy, tho, to blame it on the drones only.


Which portion of "part of the problem" did you have a problem comprehending?
 
We could stop running around the world and making war on everybody. It's been pretty stupid all along to make war on whole countries because of something that a couple of their citizens may have done.

Granted, it has been a way for a few of our richest to get a lot richer. It's just a crying shame that so many have to die so that can happen.

Excellent! Thanx, Bolt.
 
Since the beginning of the "War on Terror" I have wondered how a pre-emptive invasion of other people's nations helps diffuse what some in those nations have been calling our nation's imperialism.

...When you ask people to "bring it on", just what do you expect they are going to do?

...You would blame "their rage" on what?

Over there, some are yelling, 'death to Americans' or some others, over here, some are yelling, death to "Arabs" or death to Muslims or some others. When everyone is calling for death to someone else, for retribution, for revenge, for no specific reason at all, what sets them apart from one another?

Great post, Knot! Well said.
 
The part where you/he don't mention the "military actions" as a greater part of "the problem"...



It seems obvious to me that we can't do anything about what has happened in the past, except argue about it, which produces no good fruit. We can, however, do something about what our policy is from this point forward. It makes more sense to me to put our focus there.

Incidentally, good luck making the case that Tom Brokaw is a 'con'........
 
The younger brother made it clear the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan is the reason.

So,who is responsible for those 2 wars,Zam? One should have never been started! It was based on lies! How much hatred do you think all those needless deaths have caused?
 
It seems obvious to me that we can't do anything about what has happened in the past, except argue about it, which produces no good fruit. We can, however, do something about what our policy is from this point forward. It makes more sense to me to put our focus there.

Incidentally, good luck making the case that Tom Brokaw is a 'con'........

You are right on the fact that we cannot change the ignorant actions of the past,but we can sure as hell make sure they do not happen again!

And,yes,Brokaw has leaned so far right since his retirement he may fall over.With his popular book about WW2, Brokaw became enamored with himself.He should have stayed retired!
 
The former news anchor had this to say the other day:


I think that there’s something else that goes beyond the event that we’ve all been riveted by in the last week. We have to work a lot harder as a motivation here. What prompts a young man to come to this country and still feel alienated from it, to go back to Russia and do whatever he did—and I don’t think we’ve examined that enough? I mean, there was 24/7 coverage on television, a lot of newspaper print and so on, but we have got to look at the roots of all of this because it exists across the whole subcontinent, and the—and the Islamic world around the world. And I think we also have to examine the use of drones that the United States is involved—and there are a lot of civilians who are innocently killed in a drone attack in Pakistan, in Afghanistan, and in Iraq. And I can tell you having spent a lot of time over there, young people will come up to me on the streets and say, we love America, but if you harm one hair on the head of my sister, I will fight you forever and there is this enormous rage against what they see in that part of the world as a presumptuousness of the United States.


http://www.thenation.com/blog/17397...ia-cover-drone-warfare-factor-terror-attacks#



So, Mr. Brokaw is blaming Islamic rage on, at least in part, our use of drone warfare. This administration, of course, loves the drones. Is Brokaw right? Are drones part of the problem? Is our President doing the right thing or not?

I leave it to you.


I'm going to answer this in the context of the Boston Marathon atrocity specifically, since that was the context of Brokaw's commentary. Frankly, I see his words as typical faux introspection. It is self-serving, image-fulfillment stuff, and it is altogether false. Trust me, we've seen plenty of this bogus, highbrow, interviewed leg-crossery wherein the interviewee soul-searches aloud, tapping his quivering chin and pondering the national psyche. Anguishing...seeking broader social causation for nearly everything. Even the psychology of atrocity must be reflexively collectivized. See how sophisticated and thoughtful the old lion is? It's old hat. It's boilerplate. It's tired as heck.

Do drones net us enemies - particularly when innocents are hit? I have no doubt. Do those who would be our enemy regardless cynically milk this stuff to whip up rank and file hatred? Yep. Would any normal, sane, rational, and decent human being (irrespective of faith or nationality) set up ball bearing laden backpack bombs and sit them next to 8 year old children at a running event? Absolutely not.

Let me state this clearly. If someone killed my family member, I would not seek out third graders for retribution...specifically targeted...and at celebratory events. Categorically, I would not do this. Neither would I go on a carjacking spree. These things don't reconcile to tit-for-tat equivalence rhetoric.

In my estimation there are proper applications for drones and improper ones. There are proper miltary targets and improper ones. There are acceptable risks and prohibitive ones. There are both appropriate causes for war and inappropriate, indefensible ones.

There is plenty of room for measured, sophisticated pondering of cause and effect. There are also cases where simplicity and clarity is called for. I have neither sympathy nor need to plumb the depths of the Tsarnaevs souls. Certainly, I see no benefit to telescoping blame. Careful consideration of American conduct (means/methods as well as conditions) in war is always called for. Idiotic reflexive paralytic self-analysis in every doggone case of atrocity is not. In fact, it's often not just ill-conceived and irrational, but it serves to dilute the evil.

Sometimes, nasty things need to remain stark.
 
We could stop running around the world and making war on everybody. It's been pretty stupid all along to make war on whole countries because of something that a couple of their citizens may have done.

Granted, it has been a way for a few of our richest to get a lot richer. It's just a crying shame that so many have to die so that can happen.

That is exactly what we need to do,Bolt! If we could clean out all the Arm Chair Warriors in our Government. McCain and Graham would have us fighting the whole world.Thank goodness we now have a President,who is saying,"NO!"
 
We're just fortunate he didn't cite Jodie Foster as causative. Because the deranged (in this case, who specifically target and blow up 8 year olds, setting bombs directly beside them in full view) are always sincere in their assignment of reasons.

Who are we to judge?
 
You are right on the fact that we cannot change the ignorant actions of the past,but we can sure as hell make sure they do not happen again!

And,yes,Brokaw has leaned so far right since his retirement he may fall over.With his popular book about WW2, Brokaw became enamored with himself.He should have stayed retired!





Brokaw's commentary is more in line with what Code Pink would say. If you want to make the argument that's a right-wing group, good luck with that.




Speaking of WWII, it occurs to me we dropped the ultimate terror weapon on Japan. We also locked up Japanese-Americans for no reason other than that they were Japanese-Americans. Yet, no Japanese terrorists. Why is that?

Maybe, just maybe, it isn't all our fault after all.
 
Brokaw's commentary is more in line with what Code Pink would say. If you want to make the argument that's a right-wing group, good luck with that.




Speaking of WWII, it occurs to me we dropped the ultimate terror weapon on Japan. We also locked up Japanese-Americans for no reason other than that they were Japanese-Americans. Yet, no Japanese terrorists. Why is that?

Maybe, just maybe, it isn't all our fault after all.

You are using a very selective memory on WW2! We were attacked on December 7TH,1941!

I am just old enough to remember that speech by FDR on the radio! I was also here when Bush/Cheney, and the Neocons told lie after lie to take us into war with Iraq!

Do not try to change history on this old lady,or I will add you to that other group! I know you know better!

Yes,much of the hate is the fault of those who lied us into war with Iraq! Spraying Perfume on a pile of S*** does not make it smell less!
 
You are using a very selective memory on WW2! We were attacked on December 7TH,1941!

I am just old enough to remember that speech by FDR on the radio! I was also here when Bush/Cheney, and the Neocons told lie after lie to take us into war with Iraq!

Do not try to change history on this old lady,or I will add you to that other group! I know you know better!

Yes,much of the hate is the fault of those who lied us into war with Iraq! Spraying Perfume on a pile of S*** does not make it smell less!



You're missing my point. Why were there no Japanese terrorists in the aftermath of WWII?
 
Back
Top