New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Tom Brokaw

Zam-Zam

Senator
The former news anchor had this to say the other day:


I think that there’s something else that goes beyond the event that we’ve all been riveted by in the last week. We have to work a lot harder as a motivation here. What prompts a young man to come to this country and still feel alienated from it, to go back to Russia and do whatever he did—and I don’t think we’ve examined that enough? I mean, there was 24/7 coverage on television, a lot of newspaper print and so on, but we have got to look at the roots of all of this because it exists across the whole subcontinent, and the—and the Islamic world around the world. And I think we also have to examine the use of drones that the United States is involved—and there are a lot of civilians who are innocently killed in a drone attack in Pakistan, in Afghanistan, and in Iraq. And I can tell you having spent a lot of time over there, young people will come up to me on the streets and say, we love America, but if you harm one hair on the head of my sister, I will fight you forever and there is this enormous rage against what they see in that part of the world as a presumptuousness of the United States.


http://www.thenation.com/blog/17397...ia-cover-drone-warfare-factor-terror-attacks#



So, Mr. Brokaw is blaming Islamic rage on, at least in part, our use of drone warfare. This administration, of course, loves the drones. Is Brokaw right? Are drones part of the problem? Is our President doing the right thing or not?

I leave it to you.
 
Islamic rage has always been and will always be, with or without drones.

young people will come up to me on the streets and say, we love America

MY ASS


“And KILL them wherever you find them, and drive them out from whence they drove you out, and persecution is severer than slaughter." Sura 2, verse 191


Yes it's the right thing to do.....
 
The former news anchor had this to say the other day:


I think that there’s something else that goes beyond the event that we’ve all been riveted by in the last week. We have to work a lot harder as a motivation here. What prompts a young man to come to this country and still feel alienated from it, to go back to Russia and do whatever he did—and I don’t think we’ve examined that enough? I mean, there was 24/7 coverage on television, a lot of newspaper print and so on, but we have got to look at the roots of all of this because it exists across the whole subcontinent, and the—and the Islamic world around the world. And I think we also have to examine the use of drones that the United States is involved—and there are a lot of civilians who are innocently killed in a drone attack in Pakistan, in Afghanistan, and in Iraq. And I can tell you having spent a lot of time over there, young people will come up to me on the streets and say, we love America, but if you harm one hair on the head of my sister, I will fight you forever and there is this enormous rage against what they see in that part of the world as a presumptuousness of the United States.


http://www.thenation.com/blog/17397...ia-cover-drone-warfare-factor-terror-attacks#



So, Mr. Brokaw is blaming Islamic rage on, at least in part, our use of drone warfare. This administration, of course, loves the drones. Is Brokaw right? Are drones part of the problem? Is our President doing the right thing or not?

I leave it to you.

Are drones part of the problem? Yes. When innocents are killed in the waging of warfare, that is a problem, especially for the families of those innocents. When that killing comes from faceless attacks from the sky, silent, unpredictable, that is a bigger problem especially for those considered "collatoral damage." Does that mean we shouldn't use drones? What's the alternative - sending American military members to die? The administration you say "loves the drones" no doubt loves the ability to wage the war with less loss of American life. Are American lives more precious than non-American lives? The pacifist in me says we are all equal in our right to life; the realist in me says that the country that has the ability to wage war while simultaneously not putting its citizens in harms way will certainly do so.

What's sad is when we (the non-politicians, non-decision makers) lose the humanity to see that a young man who may profess to love America would fight to the death if he lost a family member to an American drone strike. It is human. Sadder still are those who cite out-of-context passages from the Qu'ran and behave as though there are not similar passages in the Bible that can be (and have been) cited to justify American genocide in the past. Sure the past seems far away when seen only in the context of our own short lives, but the past is a harbinger of the future.
 
Gotta love that Blame Americans first crowd.
Or not.............

Apparently giving thoughtful consideration to the fact that people might actually have motivations for what they do is soooooo hard for the black-and-while non thinking crowd. Must be so easy to sleep at night when you never have to think any deeper than a bumper sticker.
 
You don't mean the Tom Brokaw that called Election 2000 before the polls closed? The guy who had done NBC's election night for years and had studio clocks surrounding him. The guy who attempted to shut down voting in the conservative Florida Panhandle. Voter fraud pales in comparison to what that son-of-a-bitch attempted.

And now he's bemoaning Obama's collateral damage drones? Well...at least he's saying something. Not being on NBC's payroll anymore means they probably aren't worried about their broadcast license
 
Are drones part of the problem? Yes. When innocents are killed in the waging of warfare, that is a problem, especially for the families of those innocents. When that killing comes from faceless attacks from the sky, silent, unpredictable, that is a bigger problem especially for those considered "collatoral damage." Does that mean we shouldn't use drones? What's the alternative - sending American military members to die? The administration you say "loves the drones" no doubt loves the ability to wage the war with less loss of American life. Are American lives more precious than non-American lives? The pacifist in me says we are all equal in our right to life; the realist in me says that the country that has the ability to wage war while simultaneously not putting its citizens in harms way will certainly do so.

What's sad is when we (the non-politicians, non-decision makers) lose the humanity to see that a young man who may profess to love America would fight to the death if he lost a family member to an American drone strike. It is human. Sadder still are those who cite out-of-context passages from the Qu'ran and behave as though there are not similar passages in the Bible that can be (and have been) cited to justify American genocide in the past. Sure the past seems far away when seen only in the context of our own short lives, but the past is a harbinger of the future.



You've mirrored many of my thoughts. Drones are a terror weapon, and they kill indiscriminately. The make more enemies for us. That said, what's the alternative?
 
You've mirrored many of my thoughts. Drones are a terror weapon, and they kill indiscriminately. The make more enemies for us. That said, what's the alternative?

there isn't one, it's them or us and if a GI is saved in the process then damn fine by me.
 
You've mirrored many of my thoughts. Drones are a terror weapon, and they kill indiscriminately. The make more enemies for us. That said, what's the alternative?

It's a good question because remote warfare is going to become more, not less, the norm. When those who would wage war with us have drones, and they will, the question will become more immediate (for us). The alternative is, of course, for us all to become not human, because it is a human thing to wage war. We are not immune from waging it nor from suffering from others waging it. (Actually I'd go so far as to say it's a biological thing based on earth life forms' race to further their own genes, but I suspect that's a subject for a different thread.)
 
indeed, and when they are even stupid by standards of that crowd, then you have a recipe for criminal stupdiity -- or what should be
 
You've mirrored many of my thoughts. Drones are a terror weapon, and they kill indiscriminately. The make more enemies for us. That said, what's the alternative?

We could stop running around the world and making war on everybody. It's been pretty stupid all along to make war on whole countries because of something that a couple of their citizens may have done.

Granted, it has been a way for a few of our richest to get a lot richer. It's just a crying shame that so many have to die so that can happen.
 
indeed, and when they are even stupid by standards of that crowd, then you have a recipe for criminal stupdiity -- or what should be

It's the echoing of other's words with no thought that is disappointing. I don't think it's a lack of intelligence per se, just an inability to think critically and form original opinons. Mere cheerleading offers nothing on a politics board.
 
I use to think that bobby, but since their sources for knowledge have long been shown to be sources of misinformation, etc, there are really only two plausible explanations for them going back to the poisoned well and not exercising the deliberation/critical reasoning skills that would lead them to more intelligent conclusions -- either a lack of intelligence or dishonesty born of denial.

Sometimes in the case of rightwingners, or should I say more often than not, it's a mix of those two things. Those like jennifer think they are coming to the "right" conclusions" based upon the "facts" their limited sources provide them, when in reality they are merely reacting to and forming conclusions of the kind their sources intend.

In my estimation you have to be a tad stupid and gullible to be depending on liars to form a world view, which in turn escalates the level of denial one depends on to not look like a gullible fool. The "cheerleading" you wrote of is the product of that.

have a good one dude
 
I use to think that bobby, but since their sources for knowledge have long been shown to be sources of misinformation, etc, there are really only two plausible explanations for them going back to the poisoned well and not exercising the deliberation/critical reasoning skills that would lead them to more intelligent conclusions -- either a lack of intelligence or dishonesty born of denial.

Sometimes in the case of rightwingners, or should I say more often than not, it's a mix of those two things. Those like jennifer think they are coming to the "right" conclusions" based upon the "facts" their limited sources provide them, when in reality they are merely reacting to and forming conclusions of the kind their sources intend.

In my estimation you have to be a tad stupid and gullible to be depending on liars to form a world view, which in turn escalates the level of denial one depends on to not look like a gullible fool. The "cheerleading" you wrote of is the product of that.

have a good one dude

Well, I guess somebody has to be the recipient of the rightwing propaganda, lest the propagandists waste their words. Still pretty disappointing.
 
Well, I guess somebody has to be the recipient of the rightwing propaganda, lest the propagandists waste their words. Still pretty disappointing.

(((((BobbyT))))) ((((((Mytzlplk))))))
It's okay. I didn't read it, but really, it's okay.
I know you guys have a hard time when anyone disagrees with you.
 
The former news anchor had this to say the other day:


I think that there’s something else that goes beyond the event that we’ve all been riveted by in the last week. We have to work a lot harder as a motivation here. What prompts a young man to come to this country and still feel alienated from it, to go back to Russia and do whatever he did—and I don’t think we’ve examined that enough? I mean, there was 24/7 coverage on television, a lot of newspaper print and so on, but we have got to look at the roots of all of this because it exists across the whole subcontinent, and the—and the Islamic world around the world. And I think we also have to examine the use of drones that the United States is involved—and there are a lot of civilians who are innocently killed in a drone attack in Pakistan, in Afghanistan, and in Iraq. And I can tell you having spent a lot of time over there, young people will come up to me on the streets and say, we love America, but if you harm one hair on the head of my sister, I will fight you forever and there is this enormous rage against what they see in that part of the world as a presumptuousness of the United States.


http://www.thenation.com/blog/17397...ia-cover-drone-warfare-factor-terror-attacks#



So, Mr. Brokaw is blaming Islamic rage on, at least in part, our use of drone warfare. This administration, of course, loves the drones. Is Brokaw right? Are drones part of the problem? Is our President doing the right thing or not?

I leave it to you.

Since the beginning of the "War on Terror" I have wondered how a pre-emptive invasion of other people's nations helps diffuse what some in those nations have been calling our nation's imperialism. I have also said that the problem with drones is that it is only a matter of time before what goes around comes around and we're seeing drone wars over our own skies, just as we're now trying to figure out how to keep nukes out of the hands of people who may want to follow our lead and use them.

If you want to disarm people, take away their ammunition and if that proves difficult, at least don't hand ammunition to them then scratch your head about how they loaded their weapons.

http://www.presidentialrhetoric.com/historicspeeches/adams_jq/foreignpolicy.html
http://www.edchange.org/multicultural/speeches/ike_chance_for_peace.html


When you ask people to "bring it on", just what do you expect they are going to do?

If you live by this, what might happen?
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke+6:31&version=NIV

Do we mostly live according to our beliefs or do we tend to come up with a lot of justifications for why living according to them would mean we were stupid?
http://www.kingjamesbibleonline.org/Matthew-Chapter-5/
http://www.sacred-texts.com/bib/kjv/mat026.htm


You would blame "their rage" on what?

Over there, some are yelling, 'death to Americans' or some others, over here, some are yelling, death to "Arabs" or death to Muslims or some others. When everyone is calling for death to someone else, for retribution, for revenge, for no specific reason at all, what sets them apart from one another?
 
there isn't one, it's them or us and if a GI is saved in the process then damn fine by me.

Another Black - White, Them - Us, Good Guy - Bad Guy...................................small brained one.
 
Back
Top