New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Trivia Question

Here's a little story from my own life. I was once hired for a summer job that involved sending out thousands of letters on behalf of an organization. The organization wasn't terribly technically sophisticated and they thought it would take me all summer. But I realized on day one that the vast majority of the work could be automated with a few macros and a mail merge, turning it into two weeks of work (with much better accuracy than doing it the slow way). At the end of two weeks, they were overjoyed and gave me a decent bonus -- and then I was out of work. The next job I found didn't pay nearly as much, so even after the bonus I would have been much better off not to have come up with my bright idea.

Had pretty much the same happen to me, twice. (no tech - I was young before you were born).
 
No. Ike, Nixon, Ford, Reagan, Bush, Bush. Kennedy, Johnson, Carter, Clinton, Obama. 6 to 5. There simply weren't a lot more Republican presidents than Democratic ones. Where'd you get that idea, anyway?

As for total time in office, you've got about 26.5 years of Dems versus 35.5 of Republicans. If recessions were equally likely to happen any given year, we'd expect a ratio of around 1.3 to 1, rather than 9 to 1. You can't explain it away with somewhat greater Republican occupation of the White House.

Now, if you think there's equally strong skewing of the stats in favor of recessions starting with Democratic control of Congress, let's see the numbers. But first research them, since right off the bat you left out Republican control of the Senate for part of Reagan's presidency. I think what you'll find is that the recession distribution, between Republican and Democratic Congresses, is about what we'd expect based on the distribution of those parties being in control, rather than tilting one way or the other.

The numbers I'd use are the same you use -- and for the entirety of the time span you chose (arbitrarily), the Democrats were on control of both houses of Congress for all but one brief period in the early '80s. Any criticism of the economy during that period would have to fall at least equally on Congress, and in that case, there's only one party to criticize, as only one party had control.
 
Again, what we're talking about is a DRAMATIC skewing on the presidential front. If you compare "chance of a recession starting during a year with a Republican president" to "chance of a recession starting during a year with a Democratic president" we've got 9/35.5 vs. 1/26.5 -- the probability of a recession starting when we have a Republican in the White House is nearly seven times as high, based on what happened in that time period.

Now, in that same time period, Republicans had control over both houses of Congress from 2001-2006, only. Six years, one recession. There was also mixed control from 1981-1986. Six years, one recession. The overall time period I mentioned is 62.5 years long, of which 50.5 of them had Democrats in control of both houses of Congress, with 8 recessions starting during those Democrat-controlled years. So, on average, one recession every 6.3125 years.

In other words, recessions were slightly more likely to start, per year, in years with partial or total Republican control of Congress, than in years when Democrats controlled both houses. Obviously, that's not nearly as dramatic a skewing as we see on the presidential front. If we were to try to set our course by the data, though, it would tell us this: if you don't like recessions, it'll help a little if you vote for Democrats in Congress, but it'll help a LOT if you vote for Democrats for the presidency.
 
Back
Top