New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Trolls

What kind of egotistical nonsense is this ? Hey guess what. You exist Those voluntary associations exist. Guess who doesn't exist (anymore). The 45 thousand people who died every year in spite of the existence of your preferred policy prescription. And as far as I can tell. It is the choice you asked to be afforded that let it ( actually helped it) happen. And the fact still remains that apathy in pursuit of your own desire to see the state in a decreased role in spite those deaths is not only the very antithesis of empathy.

Actually this response pushes towards another part of the discussion. The narcissism on the right and in today's right. Because even though those people were still dying the policy prescription was great because it was your policy prescription.
Unbelievable. Your initial take ("advocate same policy as I do or you have no empathy") wasn't extreme enough, so you up the ante to "think like me or you are narcissists".

Spectacular. The internet left continues to amaze. :)
 
Mr. Colorforms,

Perhaps he, as learned as he is, has never read Darwin's "On the Origin of the Species."

It would seem to me that and ideology that coins the phrase "social Darwinism", in which the strong prey upon the weak, should at least have some clue to what "Darwinism" is.

The idea that the weak are somehow cared for in nature is absurd on it's face. To claim that nature actually has a moral underpinning borders on religious dogma.
 
So, you're saying that conservatives haven't risen to creating the morals created by those figuring out their own moral code, i.e. liberals?

Each person having their own moral code is, for lack of a better term, anarchy.

Odd though, how many who, as you say, developed their own moral code, i.e. liberals, are in lockstep with one another, despite what, one would argue, would be a appalling lack of evidence that such moral stands are even rational, much less based in reality.

American history suggests "moral code" as a sort of organic and ever-evolving process. Now I'm the last person who'd forward the moral-equivalency, Kumbaya, "we all suck" angle.

BUT....I think we Americans DO share a more common moral code at any point in time, than we might choose to admit. And, our divisions tend to be a little more artificial and counterproductive than we might allow.
 
Machiavellianism (willingness to manipulate and deceive others), (egotism and self-obsession), psychopathy (the lack of remorse and empathy), and sadism (pleasure in the suffering of others).

I know I attack right A LOT. But have to admit.

From the lying and manipulation in its media

The we are the REAL America narcissism

The so what those "others" are suffering or even dying because of our actions or in action we see a benefit and that is what matters lack of empathy and the apparent joy they exuded so often at those prospects.
Ha, Ha, Ha, did you know if you read your post backward it says "I hate conservatives so I think I'll blame them for everything even if it isn't true." Betcha didn't.
 
This is a Troll
images

and this is trolling
300px-Trolling_drawing.jpg
 
It would seem to me that and ideology that coins the phrase "social Darwinism", in which the strong prey upon the weak, should at least have some clue to what "Darwinism" is.

The idea that the weak are somehow cared for in nature is absurd on it's face. To claim that nature actually has a moral underpinning borders on religious dogma.

Stepping into this one somewhat from the side......perhaps you underreach when you link "morality" so specifically to religion? To the extent that morality (moral code) exists, I think you'd agree that it exists among the religious AND the non-religious, at least to some extent.

So....primitive man didn't start out giving a shit about his weakers. Over the millennia though, I think it fair to say that man HAS evolved towards more empathy for the weaker. Maybe that's a function of religion AND/OR nature. Nevertheless, it is.
 
American history suggests "moral code" as a sort of organic and ever-evolving process. Now I'm the last person who'd forward the moral-equivalency, Kumbaya, "we all suck" angle.

BUT....I think we Americans DO share a more common moral code at any point in time, than we might choose to admit. And, our divisions tend to be a little more artificial and counterproductive than we might allow.

I couldn't agree more. I think everyone wants to see people happy and healthy. I think the division comes in how we can best achieve that.
 
Stepping into this one somewhat from the side......perhaps you underreach when you link "morality" so specifically to religion? To the extent that morality (moral code) exists, I think you'd agree that it exists among the religious AND the non-religious, at least to some extent.

So....primitive man didn't start out giving a shit about his weakers. Over the millennia though, I think it fair to say that man HAS evolved towards more empathy for the weaker. Maybe that's a function of religion AND/OR nature. Nevertheless, it is.

I don't link morality strictly to religion. In an earlier post, I also talked about state imposed morality. Frankly, I think the best morality would be that applied by social convention. The only problem with that construct is that it's short lived and fluctuates too easily to pressure.

You're right that morality changes as our environment changes. Today, people have the time and the luxury to think about their morality, and to bend and flex more generously.
 
Unbelievable. Your initial take ("advocate same policy as I do or you have no empathy") wasn't extreme enough, so you up the ante to "think like me or you are narcissists".

Spectacular. The internet left continues to amaze. :)

No the narcissists comment was in response to the denial implicit in the I will save the baby or a private association will comment When the fact show that this was not happening. It was like when the claim was made that private charities would spring up and all of a sudden do 20 times more than what they do today if only the govt would just step out of the way.
 
In nearly every case, religion is the foundation of modern morality. Just because you pick and chose which moral tenets you follow, doesn't mean that the moral tenets don't come from a religious background. You're not choosing from "different" moralities, you're picking and choosing from a common morality, based on religious belief.

Would you say that it's immoral to steal or to kill? Because some religions teach that it is, yet you consider these things immoral. In truth, they're amoral. Everything, at some time, had it's purpose. People decided which was moral and which was immoral, based, in most cases, on religious dogma. Even stoning children, not that I believe there was such a social convention, would have had some moral basis at some period in time for some reason.

So you look at this buffet of morality, pick and choose which you want to keep, and which you want to throw out, but it's all the same morality, based on the same values.
We ALL pick and choose which moral tenets to follow. True moral tenets don't come orignally from any particular religion. They pop up again and again in every religion, and are embraced by non-religious cultures, too. And, with every religion, there was a time before the religion existed, so how did it adopt those moral tenets if they're based on religion?

Would you say that it's immoral to steal or to kill?

Sometimes. Sometimes they're moral. For example, if I were to kill someone who was about to murder a room full of innocents, and killing him were the only option that could stop that, that would be moral. I know that not because any religion has a rule that says "if someone is about to murder a room full of innocents, and killing him is the only way to prevent that mass murder, then killing him is moral." I know it because I have thought about it rationally and concluded that if I have to choose between a course that results in many innocents dying or a course that results in one would-be murderer dying, the latter course involves less overall harm and is superior.
 
We ALL pick and choose which moral tenets to follow. True moral tenets don't come orignally from any particular religion. They pop up again and again in every religion, and are embraced by non-religious cultures, too. And, with every religion, there was a time before the religion existed, so how did it adopt those moral tenets if they're based on religion?



Sometimes. Sometimes they're moral. For example, if I were to kill someone who was about to murder a room full of innocents, and killing him were the only option that could stop that, that would be moral. I know that not because any religion has a rule that says "if someone is about to murder a room full of innocents, and killing him is the only way to prevent that mass murder, then killing him is moral." I know it because I have thought about it rationally and concluded that if I have to choose between a course that results in many innocents dying or a course that results in one would-be murderer dying, the latter course involves less overall harm and is superior.

Yes, that's the conclusion that you came to because you were raised in a moral environment in which killing was wrong under most circumstances. Had you been raised by the kind of people who produce suicide bombers, or who believe that anyone outside of your group is fair game, you may very easily have chosen differently, as many others have.

Individual morality may not be as stringent as group morality, but it has the same underpinnings. Had you decided to choose the morality that others have xhosen and embrace Jihad against others because you came to the conclusion that you were better off killing people, you would not well survive your environment. So either directly or through rationalization, you are in essense adhering to another's morality, not "discovering your own".
 
No the narcissists comment was in response to the denial implicit in the I will save the baby or a private association will comment When the fact show that this was not happening. It was like when the claim was made that private charities would spring up and all of a sudden do 20 times more than what they do today if only the govt would just step out of the way.
Coming to the aid of others is not narcissism. Taking personal, direct, hands-on ownership of being one's brothers' keeper rather than blowing it off to state proxy is not narcissism.

I highly recommend a dictionary...and then a bit of pluralistic human tolerance for thoe who do not share your precise policy prescriptions. :)
 
Yes, that's the conclusion that you came to because you were raised in a moral environment in which killing was wrong under most circumstances. Had you been raised by the kind of people who produce suicide bombers, or who believe that anyone outside of your group is fair game, you may very easily have chosen differently, as many others have.

Maybe. But I was raised in an immoral environment (the United States), where the majority believe that it's OK for the state to execute a person in cold blood for serious crimes, and I disagree with that position. I also grew up in a society where the majority took the immoral position that gay people should be deprived of equal protection under the marriage laws, and yet, for decades now, I've been in favor of legal gay marriage. So, it's possible that if I'd been raised in some society that believed other immoral acts were fine, I'd be a dissenter there, too. My morals are reached through careful thought and analysis, not simply adopting whatever the majority of those around me think, much less adopting what the predominant religion teaches.
 
Coming to the aid of others is not narcissism. Taking personal, direct, hands-on ownership of being one's brothers' keeper rather than blowing it off to state proxy is not narcissism.

I highly recommend a dictionary...and then a bit of pluralistic human tolerance for thoe who do not share your precise policy prescriptions. :)


So you think that this direct aid was addressing the problem and continues to be a viable working solution ?

That is a yes or no question.
 
So you think that this direct aid was addressing the problem and continued to be a viable working solution ?

That is a yes or no question.
My direct aid to others? Yes, I think it is quite effective. As are all the forms of direct aid we render - from simple checks to Children's Hospitals to my entire family volunteering in Soup Kitchens. It is effective in terms of meeting needs. It is effective in terms of instilling proper values and direct ownership of goodness in my children.

Direct aid, undiluted by state agency can be very effective. Where it becomes problematic is when some divorce themselves from hands-on ownership and decide that their votes and tax dollars are enough.
 
I don't link morality strictly to religion. In an earlier post, I also talked about state imposed morality. Frankly, I think the best morality would be that applied by social convention. The only problem with that construct is that it's short lived and fluctuates too easily to pressure.

You're right that morality changes as our environment changes. Today, people have the time and the luxury to think about their morality, and to bend and flex more generously.

This leads into my oft-expressed reference to the Reagan Era "EMTALA" and our previously failed healthcare market. EMTALA is the one that said that essentially, hospitals mustn't turn away emergency patients because they couldn't pay. I realize that's a really broadbrush interpretation of the law, but I don't see the specifics as germane in this context.

I think some people tune me on this one right off the bat, because they think I"m "blaming" Reagan for failing the market. Others think my intent is to draw attention to the fact that it was a Republican thing and not a Democratic one. And yes.....a lot of people ignore it because they refuse to give Reagan CREDIT for something good!

All of those perceptions miss my point. My point is that (especially since the president was a Republican), this is an idea that had become the social norm. Democrats AND Republicans agreed that this was what needed doing.

As to the relevance of this common moral code in the here and now? Well, there are some confront the failed market aspect of our healthcare systems, by suggesting that we should return to a day when suppliers COULD refuse service to customers (patients) who couldn't pay. And my argument is that this angle is moot, since our current "moral code" simply wouldn't accept it.
 
This leads into my oft-expressed reference to the Reagan Era "EMTALA" and our previously failed healthcare market. EMTALA is the one that said that essentially, hospitals mustn't turn away emergency patients because they couldn't pay. I realize that's a really broadbrush interpretation of the law, but I don't see the specifics as germane in this context.

I think some people tune me on this one right off the bat, because they think I"m "blaming" Reagan for failing the market. Others think my intent is to draw attention to the fact that it was a Republican thing and not a Democratic one. And yes.....a lot of people ignore it because they refuse to give Reagan CREDIT for something good!

All of those perceptions miss my point. My point is that (especially since the president was a Republican), this is an idea that had become the social norm. Democrats AND Republicans agreed that this was what needed doing.

As to the relevance of this common moral code in the here and now? Well, there are some confront the failed market aspect of our healthcare systems, by suggesting that we should return to a day when suppliers COULD refuse service to customers (patients) who couldn't pay. And my argument is that this angle is moot, since our current "moral code" simply wouldn't accept it.

I couldn't agree with you more. This is the problem I think repubilcans are facing right now. Any attempt to shrink government LOOKS like the government is abandoning people to the winds of fate. Whether that is true or not, society is at a point where they won't allow others to go without. That is a good thing on its face, however, it has to be balanced with the needs of the middle class. People won't let others starve, we've passed that point. The trick now is caring for people intelligently. This is where the message gets fuzzy, IMHO.
 
My direct aid to others? Yes, I think it is quite effective. As are all the forms of direct aid we render - from simple checks to Children's Hospitals to my entire family volunteering in Soup Kitchens. It is effective in terms of meeting needs. It is effective in terms of instilling proper values and direct ownership of goodness in my children.

Direct aid, undiluted by state agency can be very effective. Where it becomes problematic is when some divorce themselves from hands-on ownership and decide that their votes and tax dollars are enough.

But if not for the state you know for a fact that an untold number of children would die from lack of medical attention and private acts of charity alone would leave an untold number of people in outright deprivation.

Are you going to deny this too ?
 
But if not for the state you know for a fact that an untold number of children would die from lack of medical attention and private acts of charity alone would leave an untold number of people in outright deprivation.

Are you going to deny this too ?
What "denials' do you speak of here? Initially, I took you to task for declaring definitively that all who don't sign on to you preferred state policy lack empathy and caring. Then, I gave you examples of my preferred posture of owning directly the aid to my fellow man. I'm not so much in the business of 'denial' here. Likewise, while I allow that your policy preference is not properly dismissed as non-empathetic, you've made no such allowance - again declaring quite the opposite.
If you ask me whether state aid can be effective, I will say yes. I'm not an absolutist. Direct aid can be effective as well - and is infinitely more personal, gratifying, and community-affirming.

We live in a tough world when folks can't disagree on policy without being cold, or stunted, or ignorant, or evil.
 
Last edited:
I couldn't agree with you more. This is the problem I think repubilcans are facing right now. Any attempt to shrink government LOOKS like the government is abandoning people to the winds of fate. Whether that is true or not, society is at a point where they won't allow others to go without. That is a good thing on its face, however, it has to be balanced with the needs of the middle class. People won't let others starve, we've passed that point. The trick now is caring for people intelligently. This is where the message gets fuzzy, IMHO.

The old saying is that the Democrats are the mommy party and the Republicans are the daddy party. Some Democrats bristle at that one, but I don't....at least in general.

It's the Democrats' "job" to find the hungry people and feed them. It (traditionally) was the Republicans' "job" to work on feeding them in the most efficient manner. "Feed" is the constant. How they're fed, is the variable.

This is where I think the Republicans have been falling down on the job for quite some time now. Some Republicans suggest the answer is to just not feed them. That's not useful since "feed" is the agreed upon constant.

Others DO talking about increased efficiency, but I don't think they do a very good job of "owning" their ideas and following through on them in order that they prove their thinking works.

I know lots of Republicans on the local level, who do a very good job of all this. But on the national level?...not so much. I think they're spending to much time and too many resources, kowtowing to their "just don't feed" cohort.
 
Back
Top