New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Trump's Approval

Arkady

President
This post isn't to recount that Trump is wildly unpopular with the American people. I'm sure you're already conscious of his sub-40% approval ratings. Instead, I'd like to point out how consistent his approval ratings are, which I think is something new.

There was a brief high during his first few days when people still imagined he'd turn the "presidential" switch on and start behaving like an adult. But that was gone in days and since then, we've had months of almost no movement-- 37% to 43% approval in the weekly average Gallup polls, regardless of what's going on. With a margin of error of plus or minus 3 percent, that means ALL the variation we've seen in the last six months could be explained entirely by the margin of error. When you consider all that has happened, the idea that none of it has budged his popularity meaningfully either way is fascinating.

That's not normal. In the same period, Obama was trending meaningfully in the 66% to 54% range -- double the movement we've seen with Trump. Bush's numbers were also moving meaningfully from about 63% to 52%, in that period. Clinton's were even more volatile, from 59% in late February down to 37% in early June. GHW Bush went from 56 in early May to 70 in early June, showing well over twice as much movement in a single month that Trump has in the last six. Reagan varied a lot, too, from 68% in early May to 56% in late July. Carter varied between 75% and 62%.

Keep in mind, this hasn't been an uneventful period. Trump fired the head of the FBI, who was investigating him, attempted healthcare bills failed repeatedly, Trump's inner circle was shown to have colluded with the Russians, Trump reversed himself on a number of key issues (e.g., launching a strike on Syria for the use of chemical weapons), etc., as well as all sorts of behavior that would have been a major scandal during any presidential period before this (remember that what killed Clinton's approval ratings in his early months was the firing of a few employees in the travel office).

So, what explains the strange stability of Trump's approval ratings, in the face of so much sound and fury? I think it comes down to heightened partisanship. At this point, I think people mostly just respond to approval questions with their tribal affiliation, rather than their thoughts about what the president is doing. Almost none of those who voted against Trump are going to tell a pollster they approve of what he's doing, regardless of what that is, and most of those who voted for Trump are going to insist they do approve no matter what. Throw in some non-voters who nevertheless register their disapproval most of the time when asked, and you've got stable polls in the range of the mid 40s to mid 30s.

That's not to say things can't change. Bush had similar polling resilience in the face of calamity for years, but then ultimately broke to new lows when the economy went to crap. Presumably a recession could do the same to Trump. And it's not hard to see him getting a bump if we suffer a big terrorist attack, as Clinton did with OK City or Bush with 9/11. People reflexively line up behind the president to show solidarity when they feel we're threatened. But as long as the economy holds up and there isn't a large-scale attack, we may see steady approval levels indefinitely.
 
Tribalism seems to be a stronger force on the right and I'd guess it has to do with the culture wars.
Nixon had a 30% approval rating when he resigned.
Obama had an opponent in his IL senate race who was a certified mental case yet still captured 27% of the vote.
Some blogger posed the theory that there will consistently be 27% of voters who will vote for the rightwinger regardless.
Now I don't know what percentage behaves the same way on the left, if at all.
 
Tribalism seems to be a stronger force on the right and I'd guess it has to do with the culture wars.
Nixon had a 30% approval rating when he resigned.
Obama had an opponent in his IL senate race who was a certified mental case yet still captured 27% of the vote.
Some blogger posed the theory that there will consistently be 27% of voters who will vote for the rightwinger regardless.
Now I don't know what percentage behaves the same way on the left, if at all.

"If at all"...LOL! You're one of them! So is @Arkady. The lack of introspection you two share is stunning.
 
Tribalism seems to be a stronger force on the right and I'd guess it has to do with the culture wars.
Nixon had a 30% approval rating when he resigned.
Obama had an opponent in his IL senate race who was a certified mental case yet still captured 27% of the vote.
Some blogger posed the theory that there will consistently be 27% of voters who will vote for the rightwinger regardless.
Now I don't know what percentage behaves the same way on the left, if at all.
I'd argue the left is much more willing to look past party lines. Take GW Bush's approval ratings, for example. We tend to remember him for being breathtakingly unpopular by the time the full impact of his poor leadership was being felt by the nation. But it's worth remembering how popular he was at one point: 90% approval according to Gallup. That suggests that fairly recently the majority of people on the left had weak enough tribal instincts that they were willing to say they approved of a hard-right Republican president merely to make a gesture of solidarity. Can you picture something like that for Carter, Clinton, or Obama? No. Most of those on the right are going to say they oppose a Democratic president no matter how well he does, and at least half of them are going to say they support a Republican president no matter how poorly he does.
 
I'd argue the left is much more willing to look past party lines. Take GW Bush's approval ratings, for example. We tend to remember him for being breathtakingly unpopular by the time the full impact of his poor leadership was being felt by the nation. But it's worth remembering how popular he was at one point: 90% approval according to Gallup. That suggests that fairly recently the majority of people on the left had weak enough tribal instincts that they were willing to say they approved of a hard-right Republican president merely to make a gesture of solidarity. Can you picture something like that for Carter, Clinton, or Obama? No. Most of those on the right are going to say they oppose a Democratic president no matter how well he does, and at least half of them are going to say they support a Republican president no matter how poorly he does.

They turned on GHW Bush. Was that the time the religious right entered politics in a serious way? They certainly showed their ugly side as they tried to destroy Clinton. I think that's what made them support GW Bush despite his old-style Republican father. Junior spoke to their "religious" sensibilities. Was that also when the Republican base turned themselves into "movement conservatives?" Either way, normal Republicanism was hijacked. We may be at the beginning of the end with their embrace of Trump.....and their downfall.
 
Tribalism seems to be a stronger force on the right and I'd guess it has to do with the culture wars.
Nixon had a 30% approval rating when he resigned.
Obama had an opponent in his IL senate race who was a certified mental case yet still captured 27% of the vote.
Some blogger posed the theory that there will consistently be 27% of voters who will vote for the rightwinger regardless.
Now I don't know what percentage behaves the same way on the left, if at all.

Obama v mental case who knew that two mental cases could run in a race.
 
They turned on GHW Bush. Was that the time the religious right entered politics in a serious way? They certainly showed their ugly side as they tried to destroy Clinton. I think that's what made them support GW Bush despite his old-style Republican father. Junior spoke to their "religious" sensibilities. Was that also when the Republican base turned themselves into "movement conservatives?" Either way, normal Republicanism was hijacked. We may be at the beginning of the end with their embrace of Trump.....and their downfall.

now I'm sure you're torn with cabinet members having Bible Study weekly!

How Catholic of ya'll
 
Donald Trump's Presidential Job Approval Ratings -- Historical Comparisons
Average for U.S. presidents 53 1938-2017
Average for elected presidents' 2nd quarter 62 various
Other elected presidents in July of first year Barack Obama 57 Jul 2009
George W. Bush 57 Jul 2001
Bill Clinton 43 Jul 1993
George H.W. Bush 66 Jul 1989
Ronald Reagan 59 Jul 1981
Jimmy Carter 65 Jul 1977
Richard Nixon 62 Jul 1969
John Kennedy 75 Jul 1961
Dwight Eisenhower 71 Jul 1953
Gallup

http://www.gallup.com/poll/203198/presidential-approval-ratings-donald-trump.aspx


George Bush out polled.
Obama

Bill Clinton

Jimmy Carter

Funny!
 
Donald Trump's Presidential Job Approval Ratings -- Historical Comparisons
Average for U.S. presidents 53 1938-2017
Average for elected presidents' 2nd quarter 62 various
Other elected presidents in July of first year Barack Obama 57 Jul 2009
George W. Bush 57 Jul 2001
Bill Clinton 43 Jul 1993
George H.W. Bush 66 Jul 1989
Ronald Reagan 59 Jul 1981
Jimmy Carter 65 Jul 1977
Richard Nixon 62 Jul 1969
John Kennedy 75 Jul 1961
Dwight Eisenhower 71 Jul 1953
Gallup

http://www.gallup.com/poll/203198/presidential-approval-ratings-donald-trump.aspx


George Bush out polled.
Obama

Bill Clinton

Jimmy Carter

Funny!
If you check the trend line, you'll see Bush hit his high in his first year, at 90%, when little was yet known about his impact. By the time he left office, when we fully appreciated the harm he'd done to the nation, he was at 34% -- one of the worst numbers for a departing president in history. By comparison, Clinton hit his all-time low of 37% barely over four months into his presidency, before we had a clue what the results of his leadership would be. He was disliked not based on his actions, but because there was a high-priced smear campaign against him and there were not yet actual outcomes to point to in order to counter that. By the time he left office, he was the most popular departing president in the history of modern polling, at 66%.

That kind of sums up the point here. Many people on the left are willing to give Republicans the benefit of the doubt -- sometimes giving them high marks very early on, when they haven't done anything worth crowing about yet. Only over time, as the Republican presidents' results prove tragic for the nation, do lefties ten to turn on Republicans en masse. By comparison, right-wingers start out hating Democrats, even before they're given any cause, and at best they can be slowly won over to a grudging respect with eight years of spectacular successes. That's consistent with the idea that people on the right are simply more tribal.
 
Back
Top