New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Trump's Crazy Budget

Arkady

President
The one area of our budget most clearly calling out for deep cuts is our "defense" budget. There's never been a nation in history that has spent even close to as much on its military relative to its contemporaries as the US does. So, of course, with such a compelling case for cuts, Trump wants to hike spending.

Specifically, he's pushing for a $54 billion increase. To put that in perspective, the increase alone is roughly equal to the world's fifth-highest defense budget, belonging to the UK. It comes close to Russia's entire defense budget of $65.6 billion. This would take us to the point where we would spend over three times as much as China and Russia combined.

For those of you who spent the Obama years freaking out about federal debt, how do you feel about Trump simultaneously pushing for multi-trillion-dollar tax cuts and an enormous increase in the largest area of discretionary spending? We're looking at over $1 trillion in increased debt per year, between the $9.5 trillion/decade tax cut and the $54 billion defense cut. That's on top of the deficit that was already projected before he took power, and it doesn't even count the $22 billion price tag to build his wall, plus the ongoing maintenance and operation cost for it.
 
As has been pointed out, we already have a huge defense budget; the problem is we've been spending it on shit that doesn't matter. And we've been wasting the rest..... I spent 20 years watching the US Army piss away time and money on bullshit.
 
The one area of our budget most clearly calling out for deep cuts is our "defense" budget. There's never been a nation in history that has spent even close to as much on its military relative to its contemporaries as the US does. So, of course, with such a compelling case for cuts, Trump wants to hike spending.

Specifically, he's pushing for a $54 billion increase. To put that in perspective, the increase alone is roughly equal to the world's fifth-highest defense budget, belonging to the UK. It comes close to Russia's entire defense budget of $65.6 billion. This would take us to the point where we would spend over three times as much as China and Russia combined.

For those of you who spent the Obama years freaking out about federal debt, how do you feel about Trump simultaneously pushing for multi-trillion-dollar tax cuts and an enormous increase in the largest area of discretionary spending? We're looking at over $1 trillion in increased debt per year, between the $9.5 trillion/decade tax cut and the $54 billion defense cut. That's on top of the deficit that was already projected before he took power, and it doesn't even count the $22 billion price tag to build his wall, plus the ongoing maintenance and operation cost for it.

I personally do not see the need, wouldn't do it were I in control.

However, with that being said, I also should point out that AT LEAST the military is one of the very few things our federal government is given the power to oversee. The sad truth of the matter is that we also spend many "ions" of money on things that some people may need, want, feel entitled to, whatever, but that are not specifically defined as a requirement of the federal government, (other people's monies), to provide, so perhaps we can cut/eliminate some of those to help with the increased cost here?
 
I'm against it.
It's frustrating that those who pose as deficit hawks tend to focus on relative trivia, instead of big-ticket items like these. For the one-year cost of just the increase on the military budget being pushed by Trump, you could fund the Corporation for Public Broadcasting at its current levels for the next 120 years. And for the one-year cost of his upper-class tax cuts, you could fund CPB for over 2000 years.
 
trump is ready to cut PBS!...Which will save on .001% of the Federal Budget...Yee Haw
 
As has been pointed out, we already have a huge defense budget; the problem is we've been spending it on shit that doesn't matter. And we've been wasting the rest..... I spent 20 years watching the US Army piss away time and money on bullshit.
Part of the reason is that the military is the one group that never really has to sharpen its pencil and cut out waste -- Congress is always there with buckets of money to fix any problems. Since they never have to make tough choices, ridiculous waste can persist decade after decade.

If you bench-mark the US government budgets against our peer nations, in terms of our per-capita or per-GDP spending on various priorities, you'll find that most areas of our budget are are pretty lean compared to the international norm. For example, our per-GDP spending on public broadcasting is a joke next to the UK's. Our overall social spending, according to the OECD, is 19.3% of GDP, compared to a 21.0% average for developed nations, and most of those with even less than us are the poorer developed nations (Slovak Republic, Estonia, Ireland, Israel, Latvia, Korea, Mexico, Chile). Because of that relative austerity, other government functions are forever having to find ways to do more with less, which mercilessly weeds out the least cost effective programs. The military, though, is in a position where it's funded at levels three or more times what's typical of a developed nation in per-GDP terms. That kind of excess, over such long periods, means a lot of waste accumulates.
 
Last edited:
I personally do not see the need, wouldn't do it were I in control.

However, with that being said, I also should point out that AT LEAST the military is one of the very few things our federal government is given the power to oversee.

It's given power to oversee a great many things, most of which fit ultimately under the category of interstate commerce, and the overall mission statement of promoting the general welfare. Granted, the Founders wouldn't have envisioned our federal government being as active as it is today when it comes to social spending. But they also didn't envision it being anywhere near as active when it comes to the military. They were deathly afraid of standing armies, and pictured the defense function mostly being handled by state-level militias, with the federal government stepping up only occasionally in the event of a declared war.

Anyway, if you benchmark us against our peers (other developed nations), we VASTLY overspend on the military, but somewhat under-spend on other areas of government. We should be cutting military spending in half and somewhat boosting other areas of spending with the proceeds.
 
It's interesting how he's so consistently wrong about just about everything. I guess it comes from being an imbecile.
It is the advice he is getting from creeps like Bannon....Under trump it wont take long for America to be hated and resented by most of the world
 
ark - I agree that there are plenty of opportunities to tackle waste, fraud, and abuse. as well as automate most of the 10 desk jobs it takes to put every combat soldier in the field.

that said, measuring "military budgets against your neighbors" is precisely the wrong measure (plus, you're incorrect - the roman empire spent more on military matters than all their contemporaries combined)

rather, the accepted measure is expense as a percentage of GDP. This is takes into account the production and personnel expenses attendant to high living standard countries vs. communist dictatorships vs. 3rd world autocracies.

by that measure, Russia (5%) vastly outspends the USA (3.3%). And let's not forget that the USA pays almost all of the NATO budget. NATO could not exist, if it weren't for the USA.

other countries with "off the charts" current military expenses include:

Saudi Arabia (13%)
"south sudan" (11%)
Oman (14%)
Iraq (7%)
Algeria (6%)
Azerbaijan (6%)
Lebanon (5%)
Israel (5%)
Namibia (5%)

current data is spotty on many nations, but here's what a few were spending 2 decades ago:

angola (22%)
Syria (8%)
Cuba (7%)
Pakistan (7%)
Iran (6%)
Ethiopia (6%)
Kuwait (8%)
Mongolia (9%)


Your grade for this paper is "D" (for deceptive). You're capable of better work. Prove it.

http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/MS.MIL.XPND.GD.ZS
 
ark - I agree that there are plenty of opportunities to tackle waste, fraud, and abuse. as well as automate most of the 10 desk jobs it takes to put every combat soldier in the field.

that said, measuring "military budgets against your neighbors" is precisely the wrong measure (plus, you're incorrect - the roman empire spent more on military matters than all their contemporaries combined)

rather, the accepted measure is expense as a percentage of GDP. This is takes into account the production and personnel expenses attendant to high living standard countries vs. communist dictatorships vs. 3rd world autocracies.

by that measure, Russia (5%) vastly outspends the USA (3.3%). And let's not forget that the USA pays almost all of the NATO budget. NATO could not exist, if it weren't for the USA.

other countries with "off the charts" current military expenses include:

Saudi Arabia (13%)
"south sudan" (11%)
Oman (14%)
Iraq (7%)
Algeria (6%)
Azerbaijan (6%)
Lebanon (5%)
Israel (5%)
Namibia (5%)

current data is spotty on many nations, but here's what a few were spending 2 decades ago:

angola (22%)
Syria (8%)
Cuba (7%)
Pakistan (7%)
Iran (6%)
Ethiopia (6%)
Kuwait (8%)
Mongolia (9%)


Your grade for this paper is "D" (for deceptive). You're capable of better work. Prove it.

http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/MS.MIL.XPND.GD.ZS

And poor people in the valley might have to spend a higher percentage of income of housing than the rich people on the hill. That sure doesn't mean the expenditures are comparable other than as an statistic.
 
The one area of our budget most clearly calling out for deep cuts is our "defense" budget. There's never been a nation in history that has spent even close to as much on its military relative to its contemporaries as the US does. So, of course, with such a compelling case for cuts, Trump wants to hike spending.

Specifically, he's pushing for a $54 billion increase. To put that in perspective, the increase alone is roughly equal to the world's fifth-highest defense budget, belonging to the UK. It comes close to Russia's entire defense budget of $65.6 billion. This would take us to the point where we would spend over three times as much as China and Russia combined.

For those of you who spent the Obama years freaking out about federal debt, how do you feel about Trump simultaneously pushing for multi-trillion-dollar tax cuts and an enormous increase in the largest area of discretionary spending? We're looking at over $1 trillion in increased debt per year, between the $9.5 trillion/decade tax cut and the $54 billion defense cut. That's on top of the deficit that was already projected before he took power, and it doesn't even count the $22 billion price tag to build his wall, plus the ongoing maintenance and operation cost for it.

The amount of waste in the government is absolutely unbelievable. Cut all departments by 20% and you won't notice any difference in services.
 
ark - I agree that there are plenty of opportunities to tackle waste, fraud, and abuse. as well as automate most of the 10 desk jobs it takes to put every combat soldier in the field.

that said, measuring "military budgets against your neighbors" is precisely the wrong measure (plus, you're incorrect - the roman empire spent more on military matters than all their contemporaries combined)

rather, the accepted measure is expense as a percentage of GDP. This is takes into account the production and personnel expenses attendant to high living standard countries vs. communist dictatorships vs. 3rd world autocracies.

by that measure, Russia (5%) vastly outspends the USA (3.3%). And let's not forget that the USA pays almost all of the NATO budget. NATO could not exist, if it weren't for the USA.

other countries with "off the charts" current military expenses include:

Saudi Arabia (13%)
"south sudan" (11%)
Oman (14%)
Iraq (7%)
Algeria (6%)
Azerbaijan (6%)
Lebanon (5%)
Israel (5%)
Namibia (5%)

current data is spotty on many nations, but here's what a few were spending 2 decades ago:

angola (22%)
Syria (8%)
Cuba (7%)
Pakistan (7%)
Iran (6%)
Ethiopia (6%)
Kuwait (8%)
Mongolia (9%)


Your grade for this paper is "D" (for deceptive). You're capable of better work. Prove it.

http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/MS.MIL.XPND.GD.ZS

When my step son was recruited for the Army they said there were 36 jobs for every one person that carried a gun.
 
When my step son was recruited for the Army they said there were 36 jobs for every one person that carried a gun.

That can't be right unless you are bringing in all civilian employees of the Pentagon as well as those working in the defense industry. Simply divide the total number of active duty military by 36....you'd have about 13,000 soldiers who carry a weapon....
 
That can't be right unless you are bringing in all civilian employees of the Pentagon as well as those working in the defense industry. Simply divide the total number of active duty military by 36....you'd have about 13,000 soldiers who carry a weapon....

You would have to include all people that make it possible to put the soldier on the field.
 
When my step son was recruited for the Army they said there were 36 jobs for every one person that carried a gun.

I'm not sure how that figure is arrived at. Probably includes a lot of ancillary and satellite entities that work for the military but are not military per se. Stuff like materiel vendors, transportation, resupply, etc.

There's a lot of redundancy built into the military. Some of it is necessary and some isn't; it's a legacy from the days when systems were way more prone to error than they are today (and of course, pre-internet era).
 
Back
Top