New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Trust me...

1. I cited my sources on this; go back and read my posts
2. Cite your source on this, please
3. The problem today is the same as it ever was... criminals.
1. No, I'm not going to search all of your posts for a link.
2. There are no uniform crime stats for the period. Feel free to think for a moment. The murder rate was significantly higher. The anecdotal stories of machineguns used in crimes are common....remember "machinegun Kelly"? How about the St Valentine's day massacre? The murder rate at the peak of the prohibition era was 9 per 100,000 population, it is 4.8 now.

In 1993 (the only year I could find) there were 582,000 crimes committed with guns. Over 70% of all murders were committed with guns and you think there is no need for anyone to want new legislation?

According to the 1991 Survey of State Prison Inmates, among those inmates who possessed a handgun, 9% had acquired it through theft, and
28% had acquired it through an illegal market such as a drug dealer or fence.
 
1. No, I'm not going to search all of your posts for a link.
2. There are no uniform crime stats for the period. Feel free to think for a moment. The murder rate was significantly higher. The anecdotal stories of machineguns used in crimes are common....remember "machinegun Kelly"? How about the St Valentine's day massacre? The murder rate at the peak of the prohibition era was 9 per 100,000 population, it is 4.8 now.

In 1993 (the only year I could find) there were 582,000 crimes committed with guns. Over 70% of all murders were committed with guns and you think there is no need for anyone to want new legislation?

According to the 1991 Survey of State Prison Inmates, among those inmates who possessed a handgun, 9% had acquired it through theft, and
28% had acquired it through an illegal market such as a drug dealer or fence.
1. Then don't claim I haven't provided the info...
2. If you had read my posts, you'd see that I addressed both of those examples...
3. You can do better than this BS....
 
1. No, I'm not going to search all of your posts for a link.
2. There are no uniform crime stats for the period. Feel free to think for a moment. The murder rate was significantly higher. The anecdotal stories of machineguns used in crimes are common....remember "machinegun Kelly"? How about the St Valentine's day massacre? The murder rate at the peak of the prohibition era was 9 per 100,000 population, it is 4.8 now.

Make up your mind. If there is no data, how can you confirm that the murder rate was higher? There is either data, or you are speculating, and I can discern which. There is no uniform data, and you are speculating.

Nor are anecdotal accounts of machinegun use worthwhile. Yes, I can name, from the 1920s and 30s, six incidents in which I can confirm that machineguns were used criminally. Bonnie and Clyde, when they were raided by the FBI outside St. Joseph, Mo.; the St. Valentines Day Massacre; the attempted arrest of "Pretty Boy" Floyd; the Kansas City Massacre (in this there is no confirmation that machinegun fire killed anyone); the strafing of Capone's Cicero headquaraters (again, no deaths) and the shootout between federal agents and the Barker gang.

These were all high-profile incidents that were picked up by new mass media, radio, as well as being in most nationwide newspapers. The actual use of full auto then was much like it is now -- extremely rare, for reasons already cited.

In 1993 (the only year I could find) there were 582,000 crimes committed with guns. Over 70% of all murders were committed with guns and you think there is no need for anyone to want new legislation?

Yes, I feel there is no need for new legislation. You are ascribing the problem to the guns, in the face of data from other countries like Switzerland where gun ownership is common, and there is no high murder rate. The higher murder rate in America isn't caused by the presence of firearms, or it would be mirrored elsewhere where firearms are common. Legislation is also no panacea. Mexico effectively outlaws all guns -- and has an extremely high rate if violent crime involving guns.

According to the 1991 Survey of State Prison Inmates, among those inmates who possessed a handgun, 9% had acquired it through theft, and
28% had acquired it through an illegal market such as a drug dealer or fence.

So in other words, they're already using methods that are illegal, and you want to insert a new layer of laws to make their activities illegal. Huh?
 
Clearly the murder rate statistic is available. I can find no information on the use of machineguns in crimes. If you can then go for it, but your "make up your mind" comment is just being argumentative.

Switzerland? Ok, let's implement their system. Let's register all guns and all ammunition purchases.

Switzerland keeps only a small standing army, and relies much more heavily on its militia system for national defense. This means that most able-bodied civilian men of military age keep weapons at home in case of a national emergency. These weapons are fully automatic, military assault rifles, and by law they must be kept locked up. Their issue of 72 rounds of ammunition must be sealed, and it is strictly accounted for. This complicates their use for criminal purposes, in that they are difficult to conceal, and their use will be eventually discovered by the authorities.

As for civilian weapons, the cantons (states) issue licenses for handgun purchases on a "must issue" basis. Most, but not all, cantons require handgun registration. Any ammunition bought on the private market is also registered. Ammunition can be bought unregistered at government subsidized shooting ranges, but, by law, one must use all the ammunition at the range. (Unfortunately, this law is not really enforced, and gives Swiss gun owners a way to collect unregistered ammunition.) Because so many people own rifles, there is no regulation on carrying them, but 15 of the 26 cantons have regulations on carrying handguns.

The laws in place can only impact gun use in crimes if there is a certainty of capture and prosecution. Universal Background checks offer the opportunity to prevent guns being available for use in a crime. Why is that a problem for you? You can pass a background check, I presume. Therefore your right to bear arms is preserved.
 
Clearly the murder rate statistic is available. I can find no information on the use of machineguns in crimes. If you can then go for it, but your "make up your mind" comment is just being argumentative.

I was pointing out the contradiction in your statement, Mid, not being argumentative. First you said there was a higher murder rate at the time, then you said there was no data. Both statements can't be true.


Switzerland? Ok, let's implement their system. Let's register all guns and all ammunition purchases.

I'd be happy to implement the Swiss system here -- it does not register either weapons or ammunition.

As for civilian weapons, the cantons (states) issue licenses for handgun purchases on a "must issue" basis. Most, but not all, cantons require handgun registration.

They issue licenses, and the state must show a reason for rejecting the license. There is no national registry of handguns. In this, Swiss practice mirrors the U.S. -- whether or not their is a registry is left up to the individual state (canton), not up to the national government.

Any ammunition bought on the private market is also registered. Ammunition can be bought unregistered at government subsidized shooting ranges, but, by law, one must use all the ammunition at the range.

I don't know where you got this information, but it is in error. There is no registry of ammunition. A purchaser must sign for ammunition, but the record of the sale is not registered with the government, it is merely retained by the merchant.

Further, your incorrect information ignores long-arms and their purchase. Anyone over age 18 may purchase a long arm, including semi-automatic rifles such as the AR-15. If you purchase from a private citizen, the law requires a written contract, but that contract is not registered with the government, it is retained by the seller of the firearm.

The laws in place can only impact gun use in crimes if there is a certainty of capture and prosecution. Universal Background checks offer the opportunity to prevent guns being available for use in a crime. Why is that a problem for you? You can pass a background check, I presume. Therefore your right to bear arms is preserved

I see no evidence that a "universal" background check would have any impact on guns being available for use in a crime. Criminals will steal the weapons they need, and the ammo to service them.

You know full well why I oppose this -- because enforcement requires national gun registration. My guns are unregistered. They will remain so.
 
By the way, Norway has about the sort of registration system you seem to desire. That didn't keep Anders Behring Breivik from running amok with an AR-15.
 
By the way, Norway has about the sort of registration system you seem to desire. That didn't keep Anders Behring Breivik from running amok with an AR-15.

So only a perfect solution should be considered? How many gun crimes are committed in Norway each year?
 
So only a perfect solution should be considered? How many gun crimes are committed in Norway each year?

I dont't know, and frankly I don't care. Norway may be your ideal government, it isn't mine. Mine encompasses my owning my arms collection as a right, and not being interfered with unless I hurt someone.
 
And you seem to forget - I'd accept even a registry if I thought that people opposed to my ownership of firearms would stop there, if there was a line in the sand saying "these laws are enough, and no more." That's never offered, so I can count on the next tragedy being politicized into a new restriction even as the Newtown massacre has been politicized into the current bills before the Congress.
 
Or is it you can't explain?
Fair enough; you possess a shitload of similarities with my dad: Native American, from up North, MRFV vet, you questioned the amount of MA training I had on an earlier thread, while actually having a lot less than I do, and you often come across as very condescending to me, while at the same time its obvious that you don't know as much as you think. So it was wrong of me to let my personal shit spill over onto you and I apologize for that.
 
First of all people on the internet can be a lot of things they actually are not, just like in the real world. I draw your attention to Stolen Valor. There have been a whole lot of posters, that comes to boards like this masquerade, so if my questioning disturbs you I apologize. But, and this I say in all honesty, if I do not know who I am responding to I will question them. If you take that as condescending, that is your choice. When you explained to me, I readily accepted it.

Now, if you recall, you got all over me and turned around a comment I made in a previous post; and you made it sound as if I was talking down vets. So maybe I should have taken offense at that. And you have talked down to me a number of times as well, and I've seen a whole lot of shit in my life, so I'm not talking out of my ass or being paranoid "bordering on lunacy".

I won't let my personal shit spill over on you, I'll keep it inside. But if you think I was condescending, I apologize. But for me we are all responsible for our fellow man, even those who may have brought harm to us. So I do take some issues as more important than just some personal interest.

Now as far as the martial arts, you may feel I've had less training than you, but I specialized in a specific art form. I didn't add any boxing or wrestling to it either. And just because someone has stopped studying in a dojo doesn't mean they still don't tear apart kata's to understand the varied purposes of the moves. As an example, Sherm Harrill studied under Shimabuku on Okinawa for about 14 months. Does that mean he did not train very much? No, because Sherm dedicated his life to tearing down the kata's into their purest form, and then began to teach seminars across the country. I was fortunate to take part in some of those seminars. I can't tell you how impressed I was with the little effort he put into a move, and how much pain it produced. I miss him.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sSDS60pywS4

So don't think that because someone has left a dojo, that they are no longer training.
 
First of all people on the internet can be a lot of things they actually are not, just like in the real world. I draw your attention to Stolen Valor. There have been a whole lot of posters, that comes to boards like this masquerade, so if my questioning disturbs you I apologize. But, and this I say in all honesty, if I do not know who I am responding to I will question them. If you take that as condescending, that is your choice. When you explained to me, I readily accepted it.

Now, if you recall, you got all over me and turned around a comment I made in a previous post; and you made it sound as if I was talking down vets. So maybe I should have taken offense at that. And you have talked down to me a number of times as well, and I've seen a whole lot of shit in my life, so I'm not talking out of my ass or being paranoid "bordering on lunacy".

I won't let my personal shit spill over on you, I'll keep it inside. But if you think I was condescending, I apologize. But for me we are all responsible for our fellow man, even those who may have brought harm to us. So I do take some issues as more important than just some personal interest.

Now as far as the martial arts, you may feel I've had less training than you, but I specialized in a specific art form. I didn't add any boxing or wrestling to it either. And just because someone has stopped studying in a dojo doesn't mean they still don't tear apart kata's to understand the varied purposes of the moves. As an example, Sherm Harrill studied under Shimabuku on Okinawa for about 14 months. Does that mean he did not train very much? No, because Sherm dedicated his life to tearing down the kata's into their purest form, and then began to teach seminars across the country. I was fortunate to take part in some of those seminars. I can't tell you how impressed I was with the little effort he put into a move, and how much pain it produced. I miss him.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sSDS60pywS4

So don't think that because someone has left a dojo, that they are no longer training.
Thank you, I apologize if I ever seem condescending, or come off as abrasive; to be honest I'm a little freaked at the way people address each other on the 'net. I only spend time on one other board, and its a gun board that is absolutely dedicated to good manners; no bashing, no flaming, no baiting or trolling; be civil or be gone. So when I decided that I "needed to get out more" I found my way here, and got caught in that same bad behavior for a bit, till I caught myself. It still surprises me what I see on here everyday; the folks here say things to one another that would get them stomped in a lot of places, stabbed in a few more, and shot in a couple. We are all Americans, (mostly), but its pretty clear we are not all living in the same society; I spend my time in places where you don't say you can do something unless you can; because your claims will be tested, usually on the spot. This circumstance cuts down on people questioning a persons creds, and seriously ups the the level of response when they do. "Big Boy Rules" It also sounds like braggadocio to people who don't play by these rules. So I think a lot of my problems communicating here, might be cultural; I'll work on it....
 
Apparently your dad has touched a nerve with you as well.

LOL, ya think? He's a Navy guy, right? So right after HS I go to join the Marines just to piss him off; lucky for me, my head wouldn't fit in the jar, and I ended up going Airborne instead. :)
 
First of all people on the internet can be a lot of things they actually are not, just like in the real world. I draw your attention to Stolen Valor. There have been a whole lot of posters, that comes to boards like this masquerade, so if my questioning disturbs you I apologize. But, and this I say in all honesty, if I do not know who I am responding to I will question them. If you take that as condescending, that is your choice. When you explained to me, I readily accepted it.

Now, if you recall, you got all over me and turned around a comment I made in a previous post; and you made it sound as if I was talking down vets. So maybe I should have taken offense at that. And you have talked down to me a number of times as well, and I've seen a whole lot of shit in my life, so I'm not talking out of my ass or being paranoid "bordering on lunacy".

I won't let my personal shit spill over on you, I'll keep it inside. But if you think I was condescending, I apologize. But for me we are all responsible for our fellow man, even those who may have brought harm to us. So I do take some issues as more important than just some personal interest.

Now as far as the martial arts, you may feel I've had less training than you, but I specialized in a specific art form. I didn't add any boxing or wrestling to it either. And just because someone has stopped studying in a dojo doesn't mean they still don't tear apart kata's to understand the varied purposes of the moves. As an example, Sherm Harrill studied under Shimabuku on Okinawa for about 14 months. Does that mean he did not train very much? No, because Sherm dedicated his life to tearing down the kata's into their purest form, and then began to teach seminars across the country. I was fortunate to take part in some of those seminars. I can't tell you how impressed I was with the little effort he put into a move, and how much pain it produced. I miss him.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sSDS60pywS4

So don't think that because someone has left a dojo, that they are no longer training.

Thanks for the link BTW, here's one of a guy I've been wanting to meet for about 15 years. I hope I get to before he dies...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vPSv05AeXVc
 
Many of these people came from a place called KFS. When that shut down I had decided to not join any boards, because of the trash talk that was always thrown around. But someone had contacted me, and said people were looking for me here, where was I. So I thought I'd give it a try. Well.... there are those who are polite, and really want to discuss the issues, and then there's others who just want to trash talk. Many cons see you as a 'Lib' if you don't agree with every issue they push, and that irritates me as it does Knot. There's a big difference between a conservative and a neoconservative, and some you have to deal with are neocons; the same people Ken Mehlman said have taken over the Republican party, back during the convention in the early 2000's, and their goal was to push what they called RINO's out. They can't tell me they have an all inclusive party with an attitude like that. My parents were Republicans, back when most Republicans had common sense. In fact one of my ancestral relatives went to Jackson when the Republican party was formed. But that's been a lot of years ago, and a lot of water under the bridge..

Let's just try to talk sensibly about issues.
 
You're welcome. So many instructors who teach kata seem to think that each move has a specific purpose, and nothing else, but if you had the good fortune to spend the day with Sherm you realized each move of the hands or feet could have thousands of possibilities.

Thank you for the link, he's definitely a man who takes a fight seriously. No fancy moves, just get the job done.
 
Back
Top