New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Two Facts

Yes, many teachers go above and beyond (not all), and as I pointed out in the top post, this isn't about bashing teachers. This is about bashing the myth that more money equals better results. In Detroit, it does not.

So then, does Detroit represent the rule, or the exception to the rule? When, precisely, was this experiment of throwing money at the problem implemented, and what were the literacy rates prior to the experiment?
 
I wish I had an easy solution to the problem, I'd gladly put it forth. I don't believe there is one. Part of the problem lies with the parents, part with the system itself. I could adopt the attitude that everything is fine, but it isn't. Do you think it is?

If we doubled the salary of all the Detroit area teachers, do you believe the results would improve? If so, why?


Nobody that I know of believes that. It would be a strawman argument if it actually rose to the level of an argument. As it stands -- it is merely a whine.
 
No one disputed Wah's facts. They don't, however, change the reality of the Detroit Public School System. Yes, many teachers go above and beyond (not all), and as I pointed out in the top post, this isn't about bashing teachers. This is about bashing the myth that more money equals better results. In Detroit, it does not.

You do not see anything in the fact that Detroit is mostly poverty stricken, thanks to the loss of jobs in that area.

I spent a lot of time in Detroit and Lincoln Park when they were growing and expanding. It was really a sad sight when I was there the last time.

Teachers work with the children they have and malnutrition does not help the learning process.

Reminds me of the article I read this morning where an employee of a private company made kids throw out their lunches because they had not paid.That is what privitation is doing to both the School system and feeding children! Can you imagine what kind of monster would make a hungry child throw their lunch away? that will stick in their minds for the rest of their lives!The humiliation and anger will never go away!

Then you have the Private Schools in Ohio stealing the Tax Payers blind with scandal after scandal of stolen money. We can rant all we want to about Government waste and over paid Teachers! How about looking at all the Crooks exposed in the last few years and leave the poor teachers alone?

You are doing exactly what the crooks in Congress want you to do! Ignore the real problem and concentrate on the middle class,just like you and I!
 
So then, does Detroit represent the rule, or the exception to the rule? When, precisely, was this experiment of throwing money at the problem implemented, and what were the literacy rates prior to the experiment?

No,no Night! Concentrate on those God awful Teachers who are trying to teach starving kids. You have not been brain washed enough to see only what your master wants you to see!

Those lousy Teachers are just not doing their job! What is wrong with these people,to borrow words from Queen Ann?
 
You've stated your strongly held belief that increasing teacher pay rates is not the solution to this problem. Do you have an alternative solution to offer, or do you simply enjoy bitching? I am also curious as to whether you believe that these teachers are currently overpaid?

Hand raised! Am I allowed to answer? I choose your second choice!
 
On the contrary... You should whine to your heart's content. After all, that's what whiners do.


We both know that your calling me a name doesn't help the situation. Does it make you feel better about yourself? Do you have a need for that?


This started out as a fairly civil conversation. Why you suddenly decided to take it in a different direction is vexing.
 
Your post is not funny!


well, it wasnt meant to be funny, sarcastic? yes,,,,, definitely sarcastic,,,,, and irreverent,,yes, i would definitely say sarcastic and irreverent,,,,perhaps even a little "droll",,,,yea, probably sarcastic, irreverent, and droll.....but not particularly "funny"...{well, not in the sense of "funny ha-ha" but more of a "gee, that dog is acting kinda funny"}..
 
You do not see anything in the fact that Detroit is mostly poverty stricken, thanks to the loss of jobs in that area.


Who said I didn't? Of course that's a contributing factor.



You are doing exactly what the crooks in Congress want you to do! Ignore the real problem and concentrate on the middle class,just like you and I!



No I'm not. I'm pointing out that there is no correlation between teacher's salaries and test results. If there were, we could simply pay teachers more and get better results. It doesn't work that way, however, and anyone saying differently is full of hot air.
 
i'll have to amend my own rants. typically, i use DC as the highest average teachers salary ($87,000 annually) and 60% of DC students fail to graduate.
 
Fact 1: According to the US Department of Education, only 7 percent of the eighth graders in the public schools in Detroit, MI, are grade-level proficient or better in reading.


Source: http://newmediajournal.us/indx.php/item/7756


Fact 2: The Detroit metropolitan area has the highest average public school teacher pay among metropolitan areas for which data are available, at $47.28 per hour.....

Source: http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/cr_50.htm



This is not meant to bash Detroit-area teachers. This is meant to illustrate that you can't fix a problem by simply throwing money at it.

First, some context that conservatives usually leave out in order to make these stories more inflammatory. "Grade-level proficient" is actually a high standard in the NAEP tests. The best public school in the nation is Massachusetts, and even here the majority of students are not able to read at a grade-level-proficient level. Nationally, it's only something like 30%. That's important context.

Second, we don't have a teacher draft. So, to get good teachers, you need to offer them something to get them to voluntarily take those jobs. In a place like Detroit, where the work is discouraging, dangerous, and difficult, that most likely means offering them a pretty rich total compensation package (counting benefits). If you have some other idea for how to get better teachers, I'm all ears. Or if you think the teachers are good enough, but there's some other issue resulting in poor performance, let's identify that.
 
First, some context that conservatives usually leave out in order to make these stories more inflammatory. "Grade-level proficient" is actually a high standard in the NAEP tests. The best public school in the nation is Massachusetts, and even here the majority of students are not able to read at a grade-level-proficient level. Nationally, it's only something like 30%. That's important context.

Second, we don't have a teacher draft. So, to get good teachers, you need to offer them something to get them to voluntarily take those jobs. In a place like Detroit, where the work is discouraging, dangerous, and difficult, that most likely means offering them a pretty rich total compensation package (counting benefits). If you have some other idea for how to get better teachers, I'm all ears. Or if you think the teachers are good enough, but there's some other issue resulting in poor performance, let's identify that.



This was my point:

This is not meant to bash Detroit-area teachers. This is meant to illustrate that you can't fix a problem by simply throwing money at it.


We can spend more money to address this issue, but that won't fix it alone. Paying the teachers more hasn't helped in Detroit, and there is no evidence that paying them even more would produce better results.
 
This is not meant to bash Detroit-area teachers. This is meant to illustrate that you can't fix a problem by simply throwing money at it.

If you pay them less, would you expect the schools to do better or worse? I expect them to do worse. You'd have a harder time attracting people who have any other good options, and so you'd get a larger portion of teachers being a lower quality of worker. And since studies suggest teacher quality is a HUGE factor in education outcomes, I'd expect that means that Detroit would be doing even worse if it weren't paying teachers as well as they do.

What ideas do you have for improving quality?
 
We both know that your calling me a name doesn't help the situation. Does it make you feel better about yourself? Do you have a need for that?


This started out as a fairly civil conversation. Why you suddenly decided to take it in a different direction is vexing.


I didn't "call you a name", Zam-Zam. I merely referenced your behavior.
 
Teacher compensation isn't the answer to all the problem, but it is noteworthy that DPS teacher salaries are not even on par with the other school districts. they get far less, and they have to deal with students in some cases that are harder to reach. Add to that the consolidation of schools throughout DPS, and you see teachers with an even heavier load to carry. More students in each classroom equates to less time spent with each student. How do you mentor someone more when you have less time?
 
And I agree with that portion, because if that were the case the rural school systems would be doing so much better academically. The 'burbs would be earning far more awards than Detroit has been, but you'll see by my other post that Detroit students ARE achieving, just not in the numbers that would be desired. The fact is DPS is not totally failing the student body of Detroit. I would also like to interject that the monies Robert Bobb spent out of the DPS budget, in order to supposedly turn DPS around did not address the problem either. Robert Bobb spents millions on an advisory board, when he was supposed to be the turn around expert. Volunteers in the Detroit area have done more to help students and teachers than all the money he spent.
 
Back
Top