New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Under God

Hardly. There is nothing wholly good and nothing wholly evil. Indoctrination can be used for both. It's in everything we see and hear, from saying the pledge to watching a Pepsi commercial. You're equating the pledge to a Pepsi commercial, and that just isn't the case.

I find the pledge far worse than a Pepsi commercial. And sorry...it was originally used to sell flags.
 
I can't dispute the Christian socialist position. they have it absolutely right.

Christian socialism is a form of religious socialism based on the teachings of Jesus. Many Christian socialists believe capitalism to be idolatrous and rooted in greed, which some Christian denominations consider a mortal sin.[1] Christian socialists identify the cause of inequality to be associated with the greed that they associate with capitalism.[1]

The problem with your kind is rather than ask for socialism (i.e. charity) you would take it. Christ would not force someone to be 'socialist'. It is a matter of free will and is where seperation of church and state truly lies.
 
Personally, being someone who doesn't worship a God, so to speak, I don't care if the phrase is in the pledge or not. It's not going to convert non-believers, and it's not pushing a state run religion.

People who have a problem with this phrase need to take courses in creative relaxation.
It is pushing a state religion -- just a very vague one. If we narrow it down a bit, that's obvious. Picture a Pledge of Allegiance that says "one nation, under Allah, as revealed to us by his Prophet Mohammed". That, obviously, would be improper government promotion of religion. However, the only difference between that and "under God" is how narrow the dogma being described is. The reference to Allah leaves out all people who do not believe in that particular God. However, the reference to God likewise leaves out to anybody who does not believe in a monotheistic God. The only difference is the percentage of the population being left out. In each case, it is inappropriate for the government to be encouraging citizens to pledge themselves to a religious concept.
 
Ugh.

Another "Let's ignore all American tradition and history" thread questioning how anyone could dare utter the word "God".

Yawn. You can't separate an egg and a yolk once they have been mixed. Christianity heavily influenced and pretty much built Western Society.. and America was no exception.

However, today America doesn't rule by the Ten Commandments, force people to pray, force reading the bible... it just happens to reference a major, if not the most, prominent influence in its pledge. My goodness!
Have you thought about the moral question? If the shoe were on the other foot would you want the society doing unto you and unto your children as you are doing unto the people and the children who do not believe in God? In what way do you excuse your immoral behavior?
 
It is pushing a state religion -- just a very vague one. If we narrow it down a bit, that's obvious. Picture a Pledge of Allegiance that says "one nation, under Allah, as revealed to us by his Prophet Mohammed". That, obviously, would be improper government promotion of religion. However, the only difference between that and "under God" is how narrow the dogma being described is. The reference to Allah leaves out all people who do not believe in that particular God. However, the reference to God likewise leaves out to anybody who does not believe in a monotheistic God. The only difference is the percentage of the population being left out. In each case, it is inappropriate for the government to be encouraging citizens to pledge themselves to a religious concept.
It doesn't leave anyone out. It's not saying, "if you don't believe in God, you can't play". That's really reaching Arkady. Like I said, I don't believe in God, and yet I don't have a problem, nor do I feel excluded. The pledge isn't about your belief in God, it's about your faith in the nation and your devotion to its ideals.
 
I disagree. I believe the point of the pledge is to indoctrinate children...and to sell flags.
It's especially hard since pledging allegiance to an image like the flag is, definitionally, idolatry. Therefore, if people were thinking clearly, it would be the religious people who would be objecting to it most strongly.
 
The problem with your kind is rather than ask for socialism (i.e. charity) you would take it. Christ would not force someone to be 'socialist'. It is a matter of free will and is where seperation of church and state truly lies.

the problem with your kind is you don't know what is socialism and what is capitalism or know that high functioning societies have a blend. socialism isn't charity.
 
"In 1954, in response to the Communist threat of the times, President Eisenhower encouraged Congress to add the words "under God," creating the 31-word pledge we say today."

...reading about Eisenhower, it is hard to think that he would imagine how we have devolved into our current state of being. If he had, I expect he never would have supported the change...

...I agree with CF above, "...It's not going to convert non-believers, and it's not pushing a state run religion.

People who have a problem with this phrase need to take courses in creative relaxation."
I suspect that Eisenhower felt that, for political reasons, he had to appease the evangelical Christians. Remember that in 1953 he also conveniently converted to Presbyterianism and had himself baptized.
 
It's especially hard since pledging allegiance to an image like the flag is, definitionally, idolatry. Therefore, if people were thinking clearly, it would be the religious people who would be objecting to it most strongly.
God, Family, Country. In that order. Religious people are sufficiently flexible. Come to think of it the idolatry of the flag is probably what may have prompted "under God" to begin with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
It's so generic I'm not sure it matters.

On religion as a whole, I don't see how one God should be considered "the God" whereas another person born in another country with a different prevailing religion should have their God deemed less valid than another. For me, I'm not a fan of organized religion as a political mantra of any kind, nor the fables, control mechanisms, greed, and problems (wars) that history has shown them to promote/incite. It's foolish.

If someone wishes to believe in a God, more power to them. If they wish to organize with like minded people and then move to promote a cause (politically) which induces a controlling focus on others who do not share their religion/views then they should become a taxed organization. I look at religion just like sexual preferences, I don't care nor do I wish to have it pushed in my face, nor be considered a villain if I don't openly support your religion, sex, race, or any other claims for special treatment.
It looks generic only from the perspective of a monotheist. From the perspective of a polytheist, or atheist, it's no more generic then an express statement about the divinity of Christ would be to a Jew. In each case we're talking about a specific article of religious dogma that has been asserted and which leaves out the percentage of the population. The only difference is how big that percentage is.
 
God, Family, Country. In that order. Religious people are sufficiently flexible. Come to think of it the idolatry of the flag is probably what may have prompted "under God" to begin with.

Not sufficiently flexible enough to have a pledge without God in it...so they had to edit God in...
 
the problem with your kind is you don't know what is socialism and what is capitalism or know that high functioning societies have a blend. socialism isn't charity.

I've spoken to the blend. But that the larger part has to be capitalist. Again, it is the thieving nature not to call socialism for what it is - charity.
 
Back
Top