New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Under God

BTW, you want to see Rightwingers go nuts on the Pledge?

Have a predominantly Muslim school in the US change it to "under Allah". :)
 
The phrase "under God" does not violate the Amendment that says that government may not force a religion on its people. It is NOT going to cause writhing (or any other form of) pain on any one of the tiny percent of the people who are atheists.

If that is deemed worthy of a fight to atheists then they are certainly lucky that they don't have any truly important things to fight about.
Jen, please revisit the moral question I asked at first. If the majority in this country were atheist would you object to the pledge being modified to say under no god? Would you object to teachers leading your kids in public school in an expression of the belief that there is no God?

Also, the First Amendment doesn't say that Congress can't force people into religion. It says the Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion. That's difficult phrasing, so it's open to argument about what it means. However, picture congress passing laws that encouraged people to make other statements of religious belief that you disagreed with. Picture them passing a law encouraging public students to reject the existence of God, or to express faith in the idea that Mohammed is the one true prophet. That would not force anyone into a Religion. But would you consider it a problem under the First Amendment?
 
I suspect that Eisenhower felt that, for political reasons, he had to appease the evangelical Christians. Remember that in 1953 he also conveniently converted to Presbyterianism and had himself baptized.

I think protestants were the greater power at the time. They've faded and the evangelicals are the ones now.
 
Wow, I really don't know what to say to that, Craig.

Why not? I don't like people who push false or forced patriotism.

Unfamiliar with the history?

...The premium department of The Youth’s Companion sold not only annual subscriptions but ran a thriving mail order business. One of its more popular items was the U.S. flag. Partially to increase sales (and partly due to patriotic sentiment the magazine launched a campaign to get every school in the country to install a flag pole on which to fly their flag, preferably purchased from The Youth’s Companion, in 1888. At the time very few if any schools had a flag pole or displayed the flag in any manner, which up to that time was deemed the province of the government, particularly the federal government.

As part of their campaign, Ford and Upham also lobbied for laws making flag poles at school compulsory. The campaign spread to target private homes, encouraging people to fly the flag on national holidays.

By the beginning of 1892, the premium department had sold over 26,000 flags at $10 per flag, for a total of $260,000 over the four years. Seeing an opportunity in the 400th anniversary of Columbus’ “discovery” of the Americas, the magazine and the National Education Association (NEA) organized a committee promoting the National Celebration of the Public Schools for Columbus Day. Its chairman was none other than Edward Bellamy’s cousin Francis.

To make the occasion more ceremonial, Francis, composed a pledge to the flag and the republic, choosing words through which he hoped to impart a spirit of comrade citizenship and civic responsibility. Nation versus Capital, in a subtle way. The pledge he initially wrote was this: “I pledge allegiance to my Flag and the Republic for which it stands, one Nation, indivisible, with Liberty, Equality, Fraternity, and Justice for all.”

With this wording, the emphasis on Nation and the Republic was clear. The words “liberty, equality, fraternity” were borrowed from France, which had so recently given us the Statue of Liberty, for whom they were the national slogan, adopted from the Cordeliers Clubs during their own revolution. The stress on “indivisible” and “one” Nation was twofold: first, that the country would never again be divided, and two, that the time for lingering animosities was long past.

The words “equality, fraternity” were struck out before the Pledge of Allegiance was even published. It would have been rather embarrassing to call for equality at the height of Jim Crow, and part of the goal was to sell flags.


http://www.chattanoogan.com/2012/7/11/230070/The-Surprising-Story-Of-The-Pledge-Of.aspx
 
Jen, please revisit the moral question I asked at first. If the majority in this country were atheist would you object to the pledge being modified to say under no god? Would you object to teachers leading your kids in public school in an expression of the belief that there is no God?

Also, the First Amendment doesn't say that Congress can't force people into religion. It says the Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion. That's difficult phrasing, so it's open to argument about what it means. However, picture congress passing laws that encouraged people to make other statements of religious belief that you disagreed with. Picture them passing a law encouraging public students to reject the existence of God, or to express faith in the idea that Mohammed is the one true prophet. That would not force anyone into a Religion. But would you consider it a problem under the First Amendment?

As you said. The pledge is idolatry. Gotta go. Put God in there it can stay. I think you'll find that spiritual Christians pushed to far will become cultural Christians for better or for worse.
 
It doesn't leave anyone out. It's not saying, "if you don't believe in God, you can't play". That's really reaching Arkady. Like I said, I don't believe in God, and yet I don't have a problem, nor do I feel excluded. The pledge isn't about your belief in God, it's about your faith in the nation and your devotion to its ideals.
Would you object then, if the pledge included a religious statement that you disagreed with? For example, if the pledge said under no God would you object? Or, if it said, under all the gods? Or, if it said, under Lord Lucifer bringer of light and nemesis of Yahweh? Would that be a problem? If you were consistent and believed that it's perfectly fine for Congress to include in the pledge any religious dogma they choose to promote, then I won't call you a hypocrite. If, however, you're only okay with Congress promoting religious dogmas that don't offend you, personally, then you're operating out of self interest, not out of principle.
 
Liberals haven't been using it for indoctrination for 400 or so decades. Using humanities to push political ideology is fairly recent.

You wrote this:

The point of school is to indoctrinate children. Liberals know that and have used it to their advantage for decades. It's why we have "labor studies" and "liberal arts" courses.


As Arkady, myself, and John Adams have pointed out...the "liberal arts" are ancient and a high calling indicating a wealthy and peaceful society. These courses have been studied for thousands of years and of course education has been used to push ideology.
 
Would you object then, if the pledge included a religious statement that you disagreed with? For example, if the pledge said under no God would you object? Or, if it said, under all the gods? Or, if it said, under Lord Lucifer bringer of light and nemesis of Yahweh? Would that be a problem? If you were consistent and believed that it's perfectly fine for Congress to include in the pledge any religious dogma they choose to promote, then I won't call you a hypocrite. If, however, you're only okay with Congress promoting religious dogmas that don't offend you, personally, then you're operating out of self interest, not out of principle.
Nobody's religious dogma offends me. People believe what they believe. If the country was founded under the tenets of Lucifer, or Cernunnos, or whomever, it wouldn't offend me.

By the way, did you know that the image the Christians use for Satan is the horned god Cernunnos? It's kind of comical, and yet I am supposed to endure people whining about having to say "God".
 
BTW, you want to see Rightwingers go nuts on the Pledge?

Have a predominantly Muslim school in the US change it to "under Allah". :)
That's part of what I don't think most of those here have thought through. This country is getting less and less Christian with time. It won't be long until individual school districts start to be majority Muslim majority Hindu of majority atheist. And at some point the entire country might be. The rules that they are establishing now when they happen to benefit them, will be the same rules available to be used against them and their children and grandchildren, when somebody else is in the majority. Heck, already, there are majority Catholic districts where, if Catholics were as obnoxious in asserting their peculiar religious views as montheists are as a whole, they could have a pledge with words including something about the infallibility of the Pope -- and screw the Protestant minority.
 
Nobody's religious dogma offends me. People believe what they believe. If the country was founded under the tenets of Lucifer, or Cernunnos, or whomever, it wouldn't offend me.

By the way, did you know that the image the Christians use for Satan is the horned god Cernunnos? It's kind of comical, and yet I am supposed to endure people whining about having to say "God".
I'm sure you'll have some reward in the afterlife for your long endurance of the whining. Your life is very, very hard. Now trundle off and let the grown-ups talk.
 
I'm sure you'll have some reward in the afterlife for your long endurance of the whining. Your life is very, very hard. Now trundle off and let the grown-ups talk.
I would, but since all we have here are people too childish to endure the word "God", I feel somewhat grown-up in comparison.
 
I would, but since all we have here are people too childish to endure the word "God", I feel someone grown-up in comparison.

Easy to endure, not so easy to pledge to...once one knows all of the angles.

Just for that different pov...I say the childish folks are the religious ones who felt the need to put God there in the first place.
 
Easy to endure, not so easy to pledge to...once one knows all of the angles.

Just for that different pov...I say the childish folks are the religious ones who felt the need to put God there in the first place.
Possibly, but then how are you any different than them?
 
That's part of what I don't think most of those here have thought through. This country is getting less and less Christian with time. It won't be long until individual school districts start to be majority Muslim majority Hindu of majority atheist. And at some point the entire country might be. The rules that they are establishing now when they happen to benefit them, will be the same rules available to be used against them and their children and grandchildren, when somebody else is in the majority. Heck, already, there are majority Catholic districts where, if Catholics were as obnoxious in asserting their peculiar religious views as montheists are as a whole, they could have a pledge with words including something about the infallibility of the Pope -- and screw the Protestant minority.

Some rightwing Christians wouldn't mind a theocracy....as long as it was THEIR religion in charge.
 
As most of you probably know, the Pledge of Allegiance includes the theological assertion that our nation exists "under God" because during the Red Scare politicians modified the Pledge to incorporate that religious test. There have been several challenges to it, on the obvious grounds that Congress has no business encouraging citizens to make a statement of religious dogma that way, but thus far, no court has had the guts to overturn that law. I'm not expecting that to change, but there is a new challenge in the works, in Massachusetts, with a slight variation: they'll make a claim based on equal protection, rather than the first amendment's prohibition on laws respecting an establishment of religion.

Setting aside the legal question, consider the matter from a moral perspective. Morally, you should not do unto others things that you wouldn't want them to do unto you. So, if you're a monotheist, the test for the morality of supporting the "under God" phrase is to picture yourself and your kids in a society where monotheists were in the minority. If you were in a majority-atheist country, for example, would you want that majority to pass a law encouraging citizens (including your kids in public school) to recite the Pledge with the phrase "under no God." If not, then it is immoral for you to support a similar law with the phrase "under God," since that is doing unto the atheist minority (and assorted other non-monotheists) something you would not want done unto you if the roles were reversed.


I always wondered what "under God" meant. Does it imply that we as a nation have special favor in God's eyes? Or does it mean that as a people we uniformly revere God?

Personally, I really don't think God really cares too much about our puny human geopolitical organizations.
 
Back
Top