Colorforms
Senator
Why would it be any more of a mistake to assume the the universe was intelligently designed than it is to assume it isn't?No. My point isn't that I know the universe is not whatever Christians think it is. They might conceivably be right. Or maybe it's the Zoroastrians. Or the Muslims. Or the Scythians, worshipping their snake-woman goddess. Or the animists. Or the Jains. Or the Branch Davidians. Or the Scientologists. But, absent any evidence, it would be foolish for me to assume any of them are right. And that's where Christians, and all the rest, go wrong. They have no more evidence than me, but cling to one of the infinite number of possibilities. That's the difference between faith and reason. It isn't that I have faith that the Scientologists are wrong, in their stories about an alien blowing people up with nukes in a volcano, etc. I just don't have faith that they're right. Absent any such theism, I am a-theistic.
Have you ever read the book "Contact" by Carl Sagan? Or seen the movie? The premise is that we're contacted by aliens, and in the course of the book we discover that the universe we're living in was actually intelligently designed by some aliens who far predate the ones who contacted us. There is evidence within the order of the universe which essentially proves it had to be designed (e.g., when you work pi out to a certain number of figures and arrange it in a certain way, it creates a perfect circular design in a manner that would be infinitely improbable to have occurred randomly). If we found evidence of that sort, in sufficient abundance and without more probable explanations, I would be convinced that the universe was intelligently designed (just like the atheist character in the book is). But, absent any evidence, it would be a mistake to simply assume it was.
I did see "Contact" by the way, and one of Sagan's points was that of the preacher and Foster's character, who both new the truth of their message, and yet were laughed off by others. That was one of the important messages of the film. If you knew the truth and could definitively tell people what it was, unequivocally, who would believe you?
I am not saying the Christians are right, but I can't say that they're wrong. Nor can I do that with the snake cult. For all we know, Raamsdonk could be right and we are all living a video game and our death is the reset mechanism.