New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Under God

No. My point isn't that I know the universe is not whatever Christians think it is. They might conceivably be right. Or maybe it's the Zoroastrians. Or the Muslims. Or the Scythians, worshipping their snake-woman goddess. Or the animists. Or the Jains. Or the Branch Davidians. Or the Scientologists. But, absent any evidence, it would be foolish for me to assume any of them are right. And that's where Christians, and all the rest, go wrong. They have no more evidence than me, but cling to one of the infinite number of possibilities. That's the difference between faith and reason. It isn't that I have faith that the Scientologists are wrong, in their stories about an alien blowing people up with nukes in a volcano, etc. I just don't have faith that they're right. Absent any such theism, I am a-theistic.

Have you ever read the book "Contact" by Carl Sagan? Or seen the movie? The premise is that we're contacted by aliens, and in the course of the book we discover that the universe we're living in was actually intelligently designed by some aliens who far predate the ones who contacted us. There is evidence within the order of the universe which essentially proves it had to be designed (e.g., when you work pi out to a certain number of figures and arrange it in a certain way, it creates a perfect circular design in a manner that would be infinitely improbable to have occurred randomly). If we found evidence of that sort, in sufficient abundance and without more probable explanations, I would be convinced that the universe was intelligently designed (just like the atheist character in the book is). But, absent any evidence, it would be a mistake to simply assume it was.
Why would it be any more of a mistake to assume the the universe was intelligently designed than it is to assume it isn't?

I did see "Contact" by the way, and one of Sagan's points was that of the preacher and Foster's character, who both new the truth of their message, and yet were laughed off by others. That was one of the important messages of the film. If you knew the truth and could definitively tell people what it was, unequivocally, who would believe you?

I am not saying the Christians are right, but I can't say that they're wrong. Nor can I do that with the snake cult. For all we know, Raamsdonk could be right and we are all living a video game and our death is the reset mechanism.
 
Why would it be any more of a mistake to assume the the universe was intelligently designed than it is to assume it isn't?

I did see "Contact" by the way, and one of Sagan's points was that of the preacher and Foster's character, who both new the truth of their message, and yet were laughed off by others. That was one of the important messages of the film. If you knew the truth and could definitively tell people what it was, unequivocally, who would believe you?

I am not saying the Christians are right, but I can't say that they're wrong. Nor can I do that with the snake cult. For all we know, Raamsdonk could be right and we are all living a video game and our death is the reset mechanism.
I don't assume the universe wasn't intelligently designed. I just don't assume it was. I focus on what we can observe, and work from there.
 
I don't assume the universe wasn't intelligently designed. I just don't assume it was. I focus on what we can observe, and work from there.
I try and do the same thing, however, I have seen things that I doubt science has the capacity to explain.

What it comes down to for me is that I believe what makes sense to me and what makes me feel empowered. I may be right or wrong, and it really doesn't matter to me.
 
Speaking of terminology, I've oft-whined about how non-conservatives have co-opted the word "conservative" and non-progressives have co-opted the term "progressive"

To my mind...the term "Atheist" is somewhat similar. For what exactly IS an Atheist? . My purely anecdotal "feeling" is that most people who claim Atheism are more in the vein of Agnostics in that they don't claim certitude one way or another. Then, there are those self-described Atheists who choose to believe that there is no God, until and unless they're offered concrete proof of a God. But, what's the difference between them and most believers who choose to believe that there IS a God, until and unless it's proven that there isn't one? Or...what's the difference between them and the Agnostic who choosed to straddle the fence until and unless the question is answered once and for all?

And then,,,there are the Atheists who are absolutely convinced - absent any actual evidence - that there is NO God. So...what's the difference between them and the fundamentalist who's absolutely convinced that there IS a God, absent any actual evidence?
I use the term atheism literally. A person who embraces the existence of one or more divinities is a theist. A person who doesn't is a non-theist or, atheist. Some would be more comfortable with the term agnostic, but for me that isn't strong enough. To me, "agnostic" suggests that I've seen some evidence but just not enough, yet, to win me over, rather than that I've seen no evidence at all.

I'm agnostic about the idea that fusion power will one day be an economically practical generation source: I know that nuclear fusion is possible, and that on paper it can produce vast amounts of energy, and nothing about economically viable fusion violates any of the laws we see in the universe, and so it doesn't seem like much of a stretch to think that the current large obstacles against it being economically practical will eventually be overcome. But, it's also possible that those obstacles will prove insurmountable. As such, I don't have conviction (faith) that the obstacles will be overcome -- I'm ambivalent about it. Agnostic.

Now compare that to the idea that one day our power grid will be fueled by unobtainium (the fictional substance mined in the movie Avatar, which allows for floating mountains, among other wonders). I wouldn't say that I'm merely agnostic about that. Unobtainium is an element in a work of fiction that we have no science to support, and picturing a power grid being run off the stuff is a much greater stretch than picturing one being run on fusion reactors. As such, I'm not merely ambivalent about it -- it's not that I see some evidence to support the possibility and just haven't seen enough to be convinced, yet; it's that I've seen no evidence to support even beginning to speculate in that direction.

The idea of God is much closer to the idea of unobtainium-powered generation than it is to the idea of economically-viable fusion reactors. As with unobtainium, God is an entity that exists in a lot of stories, but that we have absolutely no evidence to support in the real world, and which would be dramatically at odds with what we have seen about the world. It's not that we have hints of God and just haven't yet been convinced, due to a relative paucity of evidence (which would be agnosticism, in my terminology) -- talk about God is just blind, inventive speculation, just like talk of unobtainium. That's why I go with the stronger term of atheism.
 
I try and do the same thing, however, I have seen things that I doubt science has the capacity to explain.

What it comes down to for me is that I believe what makes sense to me and what makes me feel empowered. I may be right or wrong, and it really doesn't matter to me.
That's where we differ then. I believe what makes sense to me regardless of whether it makes me feel empowered, and it matters deeply to me whether I'm right or wrong.
 
That's where we differ then. I believe what makes sense to me regardless of whether it makes me feel empowered, and it matters deeply to me whether I'm right or wrong.
That's too bad, since you're never going to know if you're right or wrong. To me, that's too much anxiety.
 
That's too bad, since you're never going to know if you're right or wrong. To me, that's too much anxiety.
True. But I'll at least know whether my reasoning was good or bad. I can live with holding a wrong belief for the right reasons. For example, is spending $1000 to buy lottery tickets a good investment? I can do the math and decide that no, it isn't. It may turn out that I was wrong -- that if I'd done so, I'd have beaten the odds and won the lottery. But the best we can do is focus on what is known. Given what was knowable at the time of the purchase, the correct economic move was not to buy the tickets, even if the incorrect move was actually going to be more profitable. In the same sense, right now the correct move is to proceed without faith in the idea that there's a God (or a flying spaghetti monster, or super-intelligent aliens that designed the universe, or what have you), whether or not that actually ends up being correct.
 
True. But I'll at least know whether my reasoning was good or bad. I can live with holding a wrong belief for the right reasons. For example, is spending $1000 to buy lottery tickets a good investment? I can do the math and decide that no, it isn't. It may turn out that I was wrong -- that if I'd done so, I'd have beaten the odds and won the lottery. But the best we can do is focus on what is known. Given what was knowable at the time of the purchase, the correct economic move was not to buy the tickets, even if the incorrect move was actually going to be more profitable. In the same sense, right now the correct move is to proceed without faith in the idea that there's a God (or a flying spaghetti monster, or super-intelligent aliens that designed the universe, or what have you), whether or not that actually ends up being correct.
When you think about the lottery, do you "know" you're not going to win? Or do you "believe" you're not going to win? How can you know something will happen that hasn't happened? So your decision to buy or not buy the ticket comes down to belief. You can base your belief on the odds of winning and then act accordingly, in which case you know you can't win, so you have just created your fate based on belief, not knowledge. Otherwise you can buy the ticket and trust in your luck. In which case, you won't know your fate until the numbers are announced.

Belief is a very powerful tool, especially when you take into consideration that what we know is often just as much based on the belief of others.
 
I use the term atheism literally. A person who embraces the existence of one or more divinities is a theist. A person who doesn't is a non-theist or, atheist. Some would be more comfortable with the term agnostic, but for me that isn't strong enough. To me, "agnostic" suggests that I've seen some evidence but just not enough, yet, to win me over, rather than that I've seen no evidence at all.

I'm agnostic about the idea that fusion power will one day be an economically practical generation source: I know that nuclear fusion is possible, and that on paper it can produce vast amounts of energy, and nothing about economically viable fusion violates any of the laws we see in the universe, and so it doesn't seem like much of a stretch to think that the current large obstacles against it being economically practical will eventually be overcome. But, it's also possible that those obstacles will prove insurmountable. As such, I don't have conviction (faith) that the obstacles will be overcome -- I'm ambivalent about it. Agnostic.

Now compare that to the idea that one day our power grid will be fueled by unobtainium (the fictional substance mined in the movie Avatar, which allows for floating mountains, among other wonders). I wouldn't say that I'm merely agnostic about that. Unobtainium is an element in a work of fiction that we have no science to support, and picturing a power grid being run off the stuff is a much greater stretch than picturing one being run on fusion reactors. As such, I'm not merely ambivalent about it -- it's not that I see some evidence to support the possibility and just haven't seen enough to be convinced, yet; it's that I've seen no evidence to support even beginning to speculate in that direction.

The idea of God is much closer to the idea of unobtainium-powered generation than it is to the idea of economically-viable fusion reactors. As with unobtainium, God is an entity that exists in a lot of stories, but that we have absolutely no evidence to support in the real world, and which would be dramatically at odds with what we have seen about the world. It's not that we have hints of God and just haven't yet been convinced, due to a relative paucity of evidence (which would be agnosticism, in my terminology) -- talk about God is just blind, inventive speculation, just like talk of unobtainium. That's why I go with the stronger term of atheism.

I'll allow of course, that you're not making the case that a thing CALLED unobtanium doesn't exist and assume thgat what you mean is that something AKIN to that fictional unobtainium doesn't exist.

And...I would agree with you. But then, how do we know what we think we know as to this subject? We know what we think we know, based on our knowledge of the objective, observable, and testable science.

Nevertheless, we COULD be wrong. Something akin to unotanium could exist somewhere in the universe. But, what good would it do us to choose to believe that it exists? For most of us, I can't think of any positives and one pretty significant negative. We consumers, and the markets, and the science might be seriously diverted from pursuing those sources of energy that are actually plausible in our time.

God is different in that even as we lack the observable, objective, and testable science suggesting that God DOES exist, so too, we lack the science suggesting that God does NOT exist.

In any case, despite the contradiction between the two that I refer to, the question remains as to cost vs. benefit. Has the majority of the world's belief - throughout human history - been a net negative or positive?
 
When you think about the lottery, do you "know" you're not going to win? Or do you "believe" you're not going to win? How can you know something will happen that hasn't happened? So your decision to buy or not buy the ticket comes down to belief. You can base your belief on the odds of winning and then act accordingly, in which case you know you can't win, so you have just created your fate based on belief, not knowledge. Otherwise you can buy the ticket and trust in your luck. In which case, you won't know your fate until the numbers are announced.

Belief is a very powerful tool, especially when you take into consideration that what we know is often just as much based on the belief of others.

With the lottery ticket, you don't believe either way......you just hope you win. Nothing to do with belief, more like hoping for good luck. When you win, some thank god, but you lose you don't blame him.
 
If you don't think that we have the gist of the universe, how can you say that what you were told as a child are "fairy stories" or that they are not grounded in some truth? That's kind of my point. You say you don't have evidence for the existence of God, while Christians say we are living in evidence of the existence of God. The big difference is that, if I am gleaning your position correctly, that you don't know what the nature of the universe is, but it's not whatever Christians think it is. Again, how do you know? Atheism is just as faith based as Christianity, but it's worse in the fact that it spends it's time trying to tell everyone else that they're idiots for believing. For all we know, believing may be how the universe works.

What is faith based about atheism? Atheists do not spend all their time telling everyone they're idiots, on the contrary it's religious people who tell atheists all these ridiculous things like they will burn in hell, and they have no moral compass..a little defensive?
 
When you think about the lottery, do you "know" you're not going to win? Or do you "believe" you're not going to win? How can you know something will happen that hasn't happened? So your decision to buy or not buy the ticket comes down to belief. You can base your belief on the odds of winning and then act accordingly, in which case you know you can't win, so you have just created your fate based on belief, not knowledge. Otherwise you can buy the ticket and trust in your luck. In which case, you won't know your fate until the numbers are announced.

Belief is a very powerful tool, especially when you take into consideration that what we know is often just as much based on the belief of others.


I like your lottery analogy because even as we know our odds are incredibly remote, they aren't absolute zero - unless we don't buy a ticket. In that case, there definitely IS the potential for "harm", if we don't buy a ticket - we have zero chance of winning a $Zillion. Amd, there's an infinite difference between zero and 1-in-7 Million (or whatever).

But...does this mean that "investing" in the lottery is necessarily "good"? Well, first posit that the cost of one ticket , isn't of any espeical significance to our accounts. In that case, buying ONE ticket is almost imeasurably better than not buying one at all.

But...what if we were to buy 10 tickets, or 50 tickets? In that case, the answer isn't quite so simple. For we know that in terms of the math, buying 10 tickets is a waste of $9 (assuming $1 per ticket) and buying 50 tickets is a waste of $49. And in those cases - considering the remoteness of our odds - we might be better off keeping the $10 or $50 in our pockets.

I think the same considerations should apply to people's beliefs.
 
I'll allow of course, that you're not making the case that a thing CALLED unobtanium doesn't exist and assume thgat what you mean is that something AKIN to that fictional unobtainium doesn't exist.

And...I would agree with you. But then, how do we know what we think we know as to this subject? We know what we think we know, based on our knowledge of the objective, observable, and testable science.

Nevertheless, we COULD be wrong. Something akin to unotanium could exist somewhere in the universe. But, what good would it do us to choose to believe that it exists? For most of us, I can't think of any positives and one pretty significant negative. We consumers, and the markets, and the science might be seriously diverted from pursuing those sources of energy that are actually plausible in our time.

God is different in that even as we lack the observable, objective, and testable science suggesting that God DOES exist, so too, we lack the science suggesting that God does NOT exist.

In any case, despite the contradiction between the two that I refer to, the question remains as to cost vs. benefit. Has the majority of the world's belief - throughout human history - been a net negative or positive?
I see God the same way you describe unobtanium. Something like that could, in theory, exist, despite the current complete lack of evidence. But there are negative consequences to simply assuming that it exists, in that it could divert us from more productive endeavors. Just as with unobtainium, with God we lack observable, objective, testable science suggesting the existence of such a thing, and, in both cases, the thing being proposed would be dramatically at odds with what we'd expect to discover based on what we already know.

To that last point, based on what we already know, it's not completely absurd to imagine we might find a new insect that can run at 20 miles per hour. That would be very weird, since it would be several times as fast as any insect we know of can run, but we know of other things that can run that fast, and the biomechanics of it aren't impossible according to the physics and biology principles we do understand. By comparison, it is almost unimaginable that we'd find an insect that can sustain flight at supersonic speeds. Nothing natural we know of can fly at anywhere close to those speeds, and the biomechanics of it create such tremendous problems, according to all the rules we know, and it would be so wildly improbable from a natural selection perspective, that it would force a complete reevaluation of absolutely everything we thought we understood. The speculation about a God is more like that supersonic insect than like the one that runs at 20 mph. What we know about science strongly suggests that a supersonic insect does not exist, though we cannot prove it doesn't exist, and in the same sense what we know about science strongly suggests that a being akin to what most people mean when they talk about a god (like Yahweh of the scriptures) does not exist. I can't say with any certainty that God and the supersonic insect don't exist, but I can say they seem extremely improbable.

As for whether faith has been a net positive or negative, I'll go with the latter. I think it has distracted people from more productive paths, lengthening dark ages, and slowing our progress towards greater happiness and fulfillment. I think it's also one of the most common causes of war.
 
Last edited:
What is faith based about atheism? Atheists do not spend all their time telling everyone they're idiots, on the contrary it's religious people who tell atheists all these ridiculous things like they will burn in hell, and they have no moral compass..a little defensive?
Good point. The atheist message to the theist amounts to "you're wasting your time and hurting your society. If you relinquished your faith in things for which you have no evidence, you and your society would be better off." That may be a bit blunt and condescending, but compare it to the theists' message to the atheists, which (at least for a lot of faiths) amounts to "you're going to be subject to unimaginable torture forever, for not submitting to my faith, and you'll deserve it (by definition, since that is the order ordained by a perfect being)." That goes way beyond blunt and condescending. It's sociopathic.
 
A coupla quick points...What difference would it make if some DID believe than an insect could fly at supersonic speeds? My question is NOT rhetorical. I think it would be an issue if we diverted resources from more worthwhile causes, based on that belief, or in the same vein, if we diverted significant intellectual capacity based on that belief. OR, it might be an issue if based on that beleif, we caused tangible harm to that which we know to be real. But otherwise.....what difference would it make?

And...everytime I hear someone link "faith" to war, I wonder if those people have ever pondered the question of how much war DIDN'T happen, due to faith.
 
I know you're a Religious Righty

Depends on your definition of a "religious righty".. I've had people call me a "Religious Lefty" in some areas.

But a few of us still want a secular government and the 1st Amendment.


I'm all for the 1st Amendment.. which includes allowing people to proclaim their religion in any way they want, through any channels they want.

You can't claim to be a "free-thinker" while at the same time attempting to silence people of religion.
 
Good point. The atheist message to the theist amounts to "you're wasting your time and hurting your society. If you relinquished your faith in things for which you have no evidence, you and your society would be better off." That may be a bit blunt and condescending, but compare it to the theists' message to the atheists, which (at least for a lot of faiths) amounts to "you're going to be subject to unimaginable torture forever, for not submitting to my faith, and you'll deserve it (by definition, since that is the order ordained by a perfect being)." That goes way beyond blunt and condescending. It's sociopathic.

That's pretty much just the outspoken, American Protestant Evangelists.

As for me, I base my faith on many things.. But your atheist message is claiming to know what is better for the majority of people than they do. Correct?
 
Religious Righties are working very hard to establish the US as a Christian Nation. Hence they will have the power and anyone not Christian is subjugated, made to be second class, made to be wrong, open to being removed, etc because they do not belong to the Ruling Religion. That to me is dangerous and far more oppressive than anything else debated on this thread thus far!
 
Back
Top