New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Underestimating the possibilities.

Gramps

Mayor
Perhaps we err if we do.

According to some late reports NK's intentions aren't over whether there'll be a war but when.

Scary if you look back into history.

NK isn't a super power by any means. In fact, based on land mass and population it's hardly more than a grain of sand on civilization's beach.

As was Germany under Hitler's guidence. And Japan when they lashed out at a nation much larger then they having to realize that by doing so they would draw other nations into a bloc to defeat them.

Still, they barged ahead and the consequences of their actions were horrendous.

It's comforting to ignore their threats as "silly" which in some ways is how the SKoreans are handling things' a been there, done that mindset.

And they are the ones most likely to be harvested if NK goes on the rampage.

BUT can anyone actually imagine what the fallout from a single assault on, let's say as an example, an American installation that is within reach of their missles?

Maybe we'd best reconsuder the possibilities here. Should they attack us would we respond in a manner that our arsenal of weapons provides and take them out or would be hold back in the face of asntagonizing other nations that we are, again, the bad guys.

Gramps
 
While I see NK's most recent acts as pure grand staging, there is a very serious threat that NK brings with it. It is their nuclear capability. Now if they used one on Tokyo, or Seoul that would be a bad day, but still manageable in the broader scope of things. World markets would suffer, and we would be set back into a deep recession.

However, there is a serious capability that even just ONE nuclear weapon poses which I have not heard mentioned on any level. The devastating effects of that nuclear weapons being detonated high above a continent, ie North America, or Europe. The resulting EMP from even a small-moderate sized nuclear blast high enough over a continent would be FAR worse than any single city being wiped off the map, and the resulting conventional conflict.

NA and Europes power grids, and national infastructure are not refined, or seperated enough to protect a nation from the devastating effects of a properly placed EMP. The worst part about it is that delivery method could be anything, a lower kiloton weapon could have been smuggled out years ago, and held in "reserve" some where other than NK. Or purchased from any of the former soviet bloc countries during and after the fall of the Soviet Union.


A Sa-300, could be capable of firing a nuclear tipped missle into high into the atmosphere, say over California. I had read an interesting report on the matter a few years back. It could be fired from a cargo ship parked off the coast, with the missle itself disguised as a conex or multiple conexes. Or even a civilian air liner, hollowed out and carrying a nuclear weapon.


It is a very serious threat to our country, and the government realizes that. It is why the hardening of important US military assets and some larger civilian facilities has taken place over the past few years.


Either way add up the economic and human toll from such an attack, and we would have wished they would have taken out Tokyo or Seoul.
 
An excellent response.

There is more to consider than just the immediate fallout. And as I see it now after taking time to re-consider it we really don't know what their intentions are. It's a guessing game from our standpoint while it isn't from theirs. Going back to the days leading up to WWII, Hitler had the edge in knowing what his long range plans were while the Chamberlain's of that era could only guess and as a result they made some bad moves based on what they wanted tgo acheive as opposed tgo Hitler's scheme to deceive them. All of this clenched fist hype and marching in lockstep to display their might can be interpreted in several ways. Again, they know, we don't.

I really think that, so far, we are responding in a practical way to the threats if that is what they are. Big IF, huh?

Gramps




While I see NK's most recent acts as pure grand staging, there is a ver
y serious threat that NK brings with it. It is their nuclear capability. Now if they used one on Tokyo, or Seoul that would be a bad day, but still manageable in the broader scope of things. World markets would suffer, and we would be set back into a deep recession.

However, there is a serious capability that even just ONE nuclear weapon poses which I have not heard mentioned on any level. The devastating effects of that nuclear weapons being detonated high above a continent, ie North America, or Europe. The resulting EMP from even a small-moderate sized nuclear blast high enough over a continent would be FAR worse than any single city being wiped off the map, and the resulting conventional conflict.

NA and Europes power grids, and national infastructure are not refined, or seperated enough to protect a nation from the devastating effects of a properly placed EMP. The worst part about it is that delivery method could be anything, a lower kiloton weapon could have been smuggled out years ago, and held in "reserve" some where other than NK. Or purchased from any of the former soviet bloc countries during and after the fall of the Soviet Union.


A Sa-300, could be capable of firing a nuclear tipped missle into high into the atmosphere, say over California. I had read an interesting report on the matter a few years back. It could be fired from a cargo ship parked off the coast, with the missle itself disguised as a conex or multiple conexes. Or even a civilian air liner, hollowed out and carrying a nuclear weapon.


It is a very serious threat to our country, and the government realizes that. It is why the hardening of important US military assets and some larger civilian facilities has taken place over the past few years.


Either way add up the economic and human toll from such an attack, and we would have wished they would have taken out Tokyo or Seoul.
 
There is more to consider than just the immediate fallout. And as I see it now after taking time to re-consider it we really don't know what their intentions are. It's a guessing game from our standpoint while it isn't from theirs. Going back to the days leading up to WWII, Hitler had the edge in knowing what his long range plans were while the Chamberlain's of that era could only guess and as a result they made some bad moves based on what they wanted tgo acheive as opposed tgo Hitler's scheme to deceive them. All of this clenched fist hype and marching in lockstep to display their might can be interpreted in several ways. Again, they know, we don't.

I really think that, so far, we are responding in a practical way to the threats if that is what they are. Big IF, huh?

Gramps

Gramps, you are right in that we are guessing and N.Korea knows what their intentions are. My guess is that they are trying to get embargoes lifted and extort more aid from other countries. However, if my guess is wrong and they do launch an atomic attack against any of our facilities or S. Korea I believe the retaliation will be immediate and horrendous. I would bet that ALL their atomic sites and military installations are already programmed targets for our ICBMs. Followup by the B-2 bombers already positioned would get the stragglers.

If we or S.Korea were attacked by this imbecile I have no doubt that Obama would authorize immediate retaliation. My guess is that he has already delegated the authority to immediately retaliate if certain events happen. I think any consultation with China and Russia has already been made
 
There is more to consider than just the immediate fallout. And as I see it now after taking time to re-consider it we really don't know what their intentions are. It's a guessing game from our standpoint while it isn't from theirs. Going back to the days leading up to WWII, Hitler had the edge in knowing what his long range plans were while the Chamberlain's of that era could only guess and as a result they made some bad moves based on what they wanted tgo acheive as opposed tgo Hitler's scheme to deceive them. All of this clenched fist hype and marching in lockstep to display their might can be interpreted in several ways. Again, they know, we don't.

I really think that, so far, we are responding in a practical way to the threats if that is what they are. Big IF, huh?

Gramps

I'd agree with most of that. I would say that the administrations response of flexing of military muscle is not needed, and escalated the situation to more than it needs to be. We have the best military in the world, by far, and no two nations could even come close to representing an actual rival. North Korea knows that, we did not need to prove a point. Our South Korean and Japanese allies know we will stand by them through thick and thing, including provocations from China let alone North Korea.

It's the same concept as Bush's flop of labeling NK, and Iran as part of the "axis of evil", which to this day has very minimally been taken back by the US in its stance in foreign policy. It backed one nuclear and one aspiring nuclear nation into a corner, and what's their option? Nuclear deterance is their ONLY option, unless the capitulate to US demands. We made worse an already bad situation, and have done very little to nothing to repair it. At this point repairing the relationships could also be seen, by foreign and domestic alike, individuals to be "appeasement" such as Chamberlain participated in. It puts us in a mighty sticky situation, one which is best resolved through any other means other than warfare.


I'm sure there are reasonable people within the North Korean government, and I am sure that reason is represented in discussions. However, they are in the place that they have made for themselves and we have also forced them to remain in that place.


One mistake is all those countries need to go at each others throats, and we are closer now than we have been since 1953. Quite frankly I am amazed at South Koreas restraint in the matter, and particularely after losing a ship and people to shelling. We wouldn't tolerate that from our government, but we always expect our allies to, Turkey being another example over the past 6 months.
 
Back
Top