Arkady
President
This is a public service for the conservatives on the board -- an attempt to help you conservatives step into liberal shoes to understand a bit better how the world looks from our perspective. I'll do it in the context of Benghazi, but a similar exercise could be done with any of countless topics.
OK, as a reminder, the conservatives spent years holding hearings about Benghazi. There were seven separate investigations on the topic, dragging out for four years. Oddly, a huge amount of time in those hearings was spent not on the core public policy issues (e.g. foreign policy towards Libya, or how to secure our diplomatic missions better), but rather based on a small side-issue that conservative media had fixated on: some incorrect messaging by the Obama administration in the weeks directly after the attacks, about whether they'd been related to the attack on our Cairo embassy earlier the same day. For a short time after the attacks, the Obama administration's spokespeople, although quick to point out that it was a heavily armed act of terror, had said that initial indications were that the event had started out as a spontaneous demonstration possibly inspired by the same anti-Muslim video that had just inspired the attack on our Cairo embassy -- something that ended up not being true.
In the course of the countless hearings on the subject, Clinton was asked why she hadn't prioritized nailing down these facts with certainty, in the initial aftermath of the attack, and she asked the question that pretty much everyone on the left was wondering about -- what difference, at that point, did it make? It's not like our understanding of whether or not there'd been a spontaneous protest ended up mattering during the little window of time when there was confusion over the question. We didn't launch a war or pass a law based on bad information. The harm merely involved Sunday show viewers briefly being encouraged to think something that wound up not being true, regarding a not-terribly-important detail of the big story. Yet Republicans argued that the administration should have known it wasn't true, at the time, since better information was available within the administration, which conflicted with what State Department spokespeople were saying.
So, here's the part where I ask you to step into our shoes. Imagine that Donald Trump said something that was flat-out untrue, with relevance to a major story. Imagine that those in the administration knew it was untrue, and that had been communicated to Trump, whether or not he understood it, before he made the contradictory claim. For example, imagine if Trump, in arguing for tariffs, had tweeted that we have a large trade deficit with Canada, when, in fact, his administration was well aware that we have a trade surplus with Canada. Now, imagine that the Democrats held four years of hearings on the topic, grilling him again and again, under oath, demanding access to all his emails and those of his advisers, to nail down what he knew and when he knew it.
Obviously, that's not really a hypothetical, since Trump did in fact claim we had a large trade deficit with Canada when he knew or should have known we have a surplus with them. Now, can you imagine that bit of messaging confusion resulting in seven Congressional investigations and a front-page scandal for four years? No, neither can I. Although we liberals chalk this up as yet another deliberate lie by Trump, rather than dismissing it as an honest mistake resulting from garbled communications, we don't treat it as a nation-shaking scandal. In the end, it just didn't matter -- the facts were cleared up quickly enough.
I'd argue that the Trump deficit untruth matters a lot more than the Susan Rice untruth regarding how the Benghazi attack started. For starters, Trump's untruth came from the president himself, not from an undersecretary of state or ambassador, or similarly minor figure. Moreover, Trump's untruth was very clearly a key consideration when it came to evaluating a major policy change that he was pushing. By comparison, during the period of messaging confusion over Benghazi, there was no major policy change being pushed. Yet, even with the Trump untruth being worse than the untruth about Benghazi, the latter is treated by conservatives as a major outrage justifying years of screaming headlines, while the former is treated by liberals as just another footnote in Trump's track record of dishonesty.
OK, as a reminder, the conservatives spent years holding hearings about Benghazi. There were seven separate investigations on the topic, dragging out for four years. Oddly, a huge amount of time in those hearings was spent not on the core public policy issues (e.g. foreign policy towards Libya, or how to secure our diplomatic missions better), but rather based on a small side-issue that conservative media had fixated on: some incorrect messaging by the Obama administration in the weeks directly after the attacks, about whether they'd been related to the attack on our Cairo embassy earlier the same day. For a short time after the attacks, the Obama administration's spokespeople, although quick to point out that it was a heavily armed act of terror, had said that initial indications were that the event had started out as a spontaneous demonstration possibly inspired by the same anti-Muslim video that had just inspired the attack on our Cairo embassy -- something that ended up not being true.
In the course of the countless hearings on the subject, Clinton was asked why she hadn't prioritized nailing down these facts with certainty, in the initial aftermath of the attack, and she asked the question that pretty much everyone on the left was wondering about -- what difference, at that point, did it make? It's not like our understanding of whether or not there'd been a spontaneous protest ended up mattering during the little window of time when there was confusion over the question. We didn't launch a war or pass a law based on bad information. The harm merely involved Sunday show viewers briefly being encouraged to think something that wound up not being true, regarding a not-terribly-important detail of the big story. Yet Republicans argued that the administration should have known it wasn't true, at the time, since better information was available within the administration, which conflicted with what State Department spokespeople were saying.
So, here's the part where I ask you to step into our shoes. Imagine that Donald Trump said something that was flat-out untrue, with relevance to a major story. Imagine that those in the administration knew it was untrue, and that had been communicated to Trump, whether or not he understood it, before he made the contradictory claim. For example, imagine if Trump, in arguing for tariffs, had tweeted that we have a large trade deficit with Canada, when, in fact, his administration was well aware that we have a trade surplus with Canada. Now, imagine that the Democrats held four years of hearings on the topic, grilling him again and again, under oath, demanding access to all his emails and those of his advisers, to nail down what he knew and when he knew it.
Obviously, that's not really a hypothetical, since Trump did in fact claim we had a large trade deficit with Canada when he knew or should have known we have a surplus with them. Now, can you imagine that bit of messaging confusion resulting in seven Congressional investigations and a front-page scandal for four years? No, neither can I. Although we liberals chalk this up as yet another deliberate lie by Trump, rather than dismissing it as an honest mistake resulting from garbled communications, we don't treat it as a nation-shaking scandal. In the end, it just didn't matter -- the facts were cleared up quickly enough.
I'd argue that the Trump deficit untruth matters a lot more than the Susan Rice untruth regarding how the Benghazi attack started. For starters, Trump's untruth came from the president himself, not from an undersecretary of state or ambassador, or similarly minor figure. Moreover, Trump's untruth was very clearly a key consideration when it came to evaluating a major policy change that he was pushing. By comparison, during the period of messaging confusion over Benghazi, there was no major policy change being pushed. Yet, even with the Trump untruth being worse than the untruth about Benghazi, the latter is treated by conservatives as a major outrage justifying years of screaming headlines, while the former is treated by liberals as just another footnote in Trump's track record of dishonesty.
Last edited: