Arkady
President
Since employment numbers are the result of a match between an open job and an available worker, there are two ways to interpret weak employment numbers (of the sort we've been having, almost without break, since 2001). One, they're the result of undersupplied workers, or two they're the result of undersupplied job openings.
Conservatives have often interpreted them as a shortage of willing labor. This is a main justification for conservative efforts to turn the screws on people. In the words of Paul Ryan, they're concerned that the safety net has become a hammock: that unemployment benefits, food stamps, welfare, and other support from government convince people not to seek jobs, and thus if we make those things stingier, job creation will rise.
As I've pointed out, we have statistical proof that the conservatives are wrong about what's happening, in this instance. If there were an undersupply of willing workers, then employers would be forced to compete each other for that in-demand commodity. They'd bid up the price of work (either wages or benefits), especially among the low-end workers for whom government safety net programs are a closer alternative to the kind of paycheck they could hope to earn. If we saw rising compensation for low-end workers, then maybe the conservatives would be right. But we see the exact opposite: compensation has stagnated or fallen at the low end of the job scale. That's exactly what we'd expect to see if there were an undersupply of jobs (or an oversupply of workers, if you prefer). Turning the screws on people, in that situation, is pointlessly cruel and likely counterproductive.
Just to confirm what the labor report numbers are telling us about labor oversupply, consider what happens when low-end jobs do open up:
http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox..._per_job_vacancy_at_the_new_urban_stores.html
That's 38 applicants per job vacancy at Walmart. People are clearly not lounging around in a government hammock by choice. They really want to work. Even the crummiest of jobs can have its pick from a big stack of applications for every opening. So if we want to get our job market back in shape, we aren't going to do it through Paul Ryan-style cuts to social spending. It's going to take an effort to get the ball rolling again on creating new job openings. And a good start would be reversing the trend of government austerity, which has resulted in significant reductions in the number of people working for government, at exactly the time when the government should be picking up the slack and employing more people.
Conservatives have often interpreted them as a shortage of willing labor. This is a main justification for conservative efforts to turn the screws on people. In the words of Paul Ryan, they're concerned that the safety net has become a hammock: that unemployment benefits, food stamps, welfare, and other support from government convince people not to seek jobs, and thus if we make those things stingier, job creation will rise.
As I've pointed out, we have statistical proof that the conservatives are wrong about what's happening, in this instance. If there were an undersupply of willing workers, then employers would be forced to compete each other for that in-demand commodity. They'd bid up the price of work (either wages or benefits), especially among the low-end workers for whom government safety net programs are a closer alternative to the kind of paycheck they could hope to earn. If we saw rising compensation for low-end workers, then maybe the conservatives would be right. But we see the exact opposite: compensation has stagnated or fallen at the low end of the job scale. That's exactly what we'd expect to see if there were an undersupply of jobs (or an oversupply of workers, if you prefer). Turning the screws on people, in that situation, is pointlessly cruel and likely counterproductive.
Just to confirm what the labor report numbers are telling us about labor oversupply, consider what happens when low-end jobs do open up:
http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox..._per_job_vacancy_at_the_new_urban_stores.html
That's 38 applicants per job vacancy at Walmart. People are clearly not lounging around in a government hammock by choice. They really want to work. Even the crummiest of jobs can have its pick from a big stack of applications for every opening. So if we want to get our job market back in shape, we aren't going to do it through Paul Ryan-style cuts to social spending. It's going to take an effort to get the ball rolling again on creating new job openings. And a good start would be reversing the trend of government austerity, which has resulted in significant reductions in the number of people working for government, at exactly the time when the government should be picking up the slack and employing more people.