New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Undersupplied Jobs

Arkady

President
Since employment numbers are the result of a match between an open job and an available worker, there are two ways to interpret weak employment numbers (of the sort we've been having, almost without break, since 2001). One, they're the result of undersupplied workers, or two they're the result of undersupplied job openings.

Conservatives have often interpreted them as a shortage of willing labor. This is a main justification for conservative efforts to turn the screws on people. In the words of Paul Ryan, they're concerned that the safety net has become a hammock: that unemployment benefits, food stamps, welfare, and other support from government convince people not to seek jobs, and thus if we make those things stingier, job creation will rise.

As I've pointed out, we have statistical proof that the conservatives are wrong about what's happening, in this instance. If there were an undersupply of willing workers, then employers would be forced to compete each other for that in-demand commodity. They'd bid up the price of work (either wages or benefits), especially among the low-end workers for whom government safety net programs are a closer alternative to the kind of paycheck they could hope to earn. If we saw rising compensation for low-end workers, then maybe the conservatives would be right. But we see the exact opposite: compensation has stagnated or fallen at the low end of the job scale. That's exactly what we'd expect to see if there were an undersupply of jobs (or an oversupply of workers, if you prefer). Turning the screws on people, in that situation, is pointlessly cruel and likely counterproductive.

Just to confirm what the labor report numbers are telling us about labor oversupply, consider what happens when low-end jobs do open up:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox..._per_job_vacancy_at_the_new_urban_stores.html

That's 38 applicants per job vacancy at Walmart. People are clearly not lounging around in a government hammock by choice. They really want to work. Even the crummiest of jobs can have its pick from a big stack of applications for every opening. So if we want to get our job market back in shape, we aren't going to do it through Paul Ryan-style cuts to social spending. It's going to take an effort to get the ball rolling again on creating new job openings. And a good start would be reversing the trend of government austerity, which has resulted in significant reductions in the number of people working for government, at exactly the time when the government should be picking up the slack and employing more people.
 
...releasing government austerity is part of the answer. The other part is to re-start training programs, refund universities and make higher education accessible to the masses and not just the affluent. As a society we are killing our future by cutting college funds, reducing class availability and disenfranchising millions of Americans.

...it is sad that some seem to think it is "good" or somehow better to indirectly subsidize" walmart and other minimum-wage employers under the premise - it is better to have a job than not - they need to think again...
 
...releasing government austerity is part of the answer. The other part is to re-start training programs, refund universities and make higher education accessible to the masses and not just the affluent. As a society we are killing our future by cutting college funds, reducing class availability and disenfranchising millions of Americans.

...it is sad that some seem to think it is "good" or somehow better to indirectly subsidize" walmart and other minimum-wage employers under the premise - it is better to have a job than not - they need to think again...

I read where the Student Loan Bubble is now over a trillion dollars and has the highest percentage of over 90 day defaults ever...

AmericAA- already has the most educated waiters, bartenders and strippers in the world.

 
I read where the Student Loan Bubble is now over a trillion dollars and has the highest percentage of over 90 day defaults ever...

AmericAA- already has the most educated waiters, bartenders and strippers in the world.

/quote]

...you make my point - thank you - higher education is far too costly.
 
Of course its costly... you have trillions of cheap credit available to anybody with enough brains to write their name on a loan app.

Doesn't matter if they never graduate, never pay back the loan, all that matters is big ED gets a check from USGov.com
 
with a 50% drop out rate at inner city high schools, and an epidemic of narcotics use, i think most rational people can figure out why we have a shortage of workers qualified for the job openings.
 
with a 50% drop out rate at inner city high schools, and an epidemic of narcotics use, i think most rational people can figure out why we have a shortage of workers qualified for the job openings.


That was the point of the top post. Evidence indicates that we don't have a shortage of qualified employees, but a shortage of jobs. Your opinion is based upon fear and loathing of your fellow citizens, rather than factual information. That's why you're a Republican.
 
Since employment numbers are the result of a match between an open job and an available worker, there are two ways to interpret weak employment numbers (of the sort we've been having, almost without break, since 2001). One, they're the result of undersupplied workers, or two they're the result of undersupplied job openings.

Conservatives have often interpreted them as a shortage of willing labor. This is a main justification for conservative efforts to turn the screws on people. In the words of Paul Ryan, they're concerned that the safety net has become a hammock: that unemployment benefits, food stamps, welfare, and other support from government convince people not to seek jobs, and thus if we make those things stingier, job creation will rise.

As I've pointed out, we have statistical proof that the conservatives are wrong about what's happening, in this instance. If there were an undersupply of willing workers, then employers would be forced to compete each other for that in-demand commodity. They'd bid up the price of work (either wages or benefits), especially among the low-end workers for whom government safety net programs are a closer alternative to the kind of paycheck they could hope to earn. If we saw rising compensation for low-end workers, then maybe the conservatives would be right. But we see the exact opposite: compensation has stagnated or fallen at the low end of the job scale. That's exactly what we'd expect to see if there were an undersupply of jobs (or an oversupply of workers, if you prefer). Turning the screws on people, in that situation, is pointlessly cruel and likely counterproductive.

Just to confirm what the labor report numbers are telling us about labor oversupply, consider what happens when low-end jobs do open up:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox..._per_job_vacancy_at_the_new_urban_stores.html

That's 38 applicants per job vacancy at Walmart. People are clearly not lounging around in a government hammock by choice. They really want to work. Even the crummiest of jobs can have its pick from a big stack of applications for every opening. So if we want to get our job market back in shape, we aren't going to do it through Paul Ryan-style cuts to social spending. It's going to take an effort to get the ball rolling again on creating new job openings. And a good start would be reversing the trend of government austerity, which has resulted in significant reductions in the number of people working for government, at exactly the time when the government should be picking up the slack and employing more people.


how dare you apply logic and reason in an effort to undermine one of the fav rightwinger lines of BS?

And the creation and maintenance of gov jobs is only permitted under repub admins, don't you know?
 
with a 50% drop out rate at inner city high schools, and an epidemic of narcotics use, i think most rational people can figure out why we have a shortage of workers qualified for the job openings.

Again, we know from the statistics that what we're facing is a shortage of job openings, not a shortage of workers. This isn't so hard to follow. Just think about it. In a job market with relatively few available workers and a lot of job openings (think about the later part of the Clinton or Kennedy/Johnson era), what happens is that employers compete against each other for workers: they raise wages and expand benefits in order to lure applicants away from the competing openings. We've seen such markets before. Between 1993 and 2000, for example, median real household income rose from $47,84 to $55,987 -- a 14.53% increase, even after accounting for inflation. In two years alone, between '67 and '69, there was a 8.19% increase. That's what it looks like when employers are fighting for under-supplied workers. By comparison, in the last five years, median real incomes are DOWN 8.29%. That's what it looks like when employees are under-cutting each other in a desperate fight for under-supplied jobs.

And making reference to high school drop out rates and narcotics use doesn't make sense to explain what's gone wrong. Dropout rates have been falling, and are down since the late Clinton era, so if dropout rates were driving the employment market, we'd expect unemployment rates to be down since 2000, not way up:

http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=16

As for narcotics, they've been an issue for decades, but overall drug use has declined or held steady since the last time we had a strong job market:

http://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/drugfacts/high-school-youth-trends

So, you'll need to look elsewhere to explain what's going on here. If job creation were being impacted by drug use, then we'd expect higher job creation these days than in the 90s.

I'm a big believer in setting aside the pat answers of political orthodoxy and looking in a clear-eyed way at the real-world numbers. Those numbers tell us that although the quality of available workers has been improving, fewer of them are finding work and those who do are being paid less. Theories about what has gone wrong need to be made to fit those measurable facts, rather than vice versa.
 
Last edited:
Robots are cheaper and they don't take breaks.
You make a very important point, since people tend to focus on outsourcing, when automation is by far a bigger factor jeopardizing the American worker. When a new technology lets one person be as productive as 10 used to be, and demand doesn't rise to expand the workload accordingy, that tends to eliminate 90% of those jobs.

It's helpful to think of this in terms of specifics. When I first started as a lawyer, we had three lawyers sharing each secretary, and the old-timers complained about that, since they'd first entered the profession at a time when each lawyer had a dedicated secretary. These days, we have ten lawyers per secretary. Various technological improvements allowed lawyers to handle more of the work previously done by secretaries, and for fewer secretaries to produce more work per unit of time. There's no need to retype a page with a typo, for example, or to type something in manually, etc., thanks to word processing, OCR, etc. With one secretary doing the work that used to be done by ten, there are several things that could have happened:

(1) You could have maintained ten secretaries at the same annual pay, but reduced their hours to four per week per secretary, to meet the same demand (this was the dream of the greatly reduced workweek, which people used to talk about in the 50s and 60s).

(2) You coud have terminated nine secretaries, but given the remaining secretary 10 times her previous pay, to recognize that she was producing ten times as much value.

(3) You could have terminated nine secretaries, and split the savings between the remaining secretary (a raise) and those terminated (some sort of early retirement payout).

(4) You could have terminated nine secretaries, kept the remaining secretary, and handed the savings to the top executives and/or shareholders.

(5) You could have terminated some of the secretaries, kept several others, but at reduced hours, with correspondingly reduced pay, with the savings going to the top executives and/or shareholders.

As a practical matter, what really tends to happen is some combination of 4 and 5, other than in strong economic times, when workers have bargaining power, in which case there's also a little of 2 and 3 in the mix (the economic elites still get most of the savings, but the workers at least get a small cut).

This can be changed with laws requiring more equitable sharing of the savings made possible by automation. But absent such laws, and absent strong economic growth giving workers bargaining power, the senior execs and board members will see to it that the economi elite gets all of the savings (and then some). These days, our secretaries work the same hours for less real income than secretaries a generation ago, despite being vastly more productive.
 
...releasing government austerity is part of the answer. The other part is to re-start training programs, refund universities and make higher education accessible to the masses and not just the affluent. As a society we are killing our future by cutting college funds, reducing class availability and disenfranchising millions of Americans.

...it is sad that some seem to think it is "good" or somehow better to indirectly subsidize" walmart and other minimum-wage employers under the premise - it is better to have a job than not - they need to think again...

Especially at a time when the government can borrow at near-zero interest rates, this seems like a no-brainer to me.
 
I read where the Student Loan Bubble is now over a trillion dollars and has the highest percentage of over 90 day defaults ever...

AmericAA- already has the most educated waiters, bartenders and strippers in the world.


Although I respect knowledge for knowledge's sake, I think the lion's share of the money spent on higher education should be steered towards things that make our workforce more competitive, internationally. People are welcome to compete for some small share of scholarships and subsidized loans earmarked for "pure knowledge" areas of study (fields without immediately obvious value in the job market, such as philosophy and art history), but those opportunities should be there only for an intellectual elite that can beat out most other students to get them. The great bulk of higher-education public spending should, instead, go to fields expected to have immediate practical applications in the job market: engineering, medicine, law, business adminsitration, statistics, finance, chemistry, various I.T. fields, etc. That'll minimize the number of people with publicly-financed degrees in arcane liberal arts fields who are tending bar and working as Starbucks.
 
I think the lion's share of the money spent on higher education should be steered towards things that make our workforce more competitive, internationally

I agree. What i found interseting in the Peter Schiff video interviewing strippers, bartenders, servers..etc, is how many were in their late 20s who had BUSINESS DEGREES and EDUCATION DEGREES. Degrees where one would think is still in demand.

For America to create real wealth, does require we PRODUCE real goods/services that is purchased globally. However, production has been consolidated into the hands of a few international global corporations who are virtually based offshore and have special waivers/immunity from govt regs and taxes.
 
You make a very important point, since people tend to focus on outsourcing, when automation is by far a bigger factor jeopardizing the American worker. When a new technology lets one person be as productive as 10 used to be, and demand doesn't rise to expand the workload accordingy, that tends to eliminate 90% of those jobs.

It's helpful to think of this in terms of specifics. When I first started as a lawyer, we had three lawyers sharing each secretary, and the old-timers complained about that, since they'd first entered the profession at a time when each lawyer had a dedicated secretary. These days, we have ten lawyers per secretary. Various technological improvements allowed lawyers to handle more of the work previously done by secretaries, and for fewer secretaries to produce more work per unit of time. There's no need to retype a page with a typo, for example, or to type something in manually, etc., thanks to word processing, OCR, etc. With one secretary doing the work that used to be done by ten, there are several things that could have happened:

(1) You could have maintained ten secretaries at the same annual pay, but reduced their hours to four per week per secretary, to meet the same demand (this was the dream of the greatly reduced workweek, which people used to talk about in the 50s and 60s).

(2) You coud have terminated nine secretaries, but given the remaining secretary 10 times her previous pay, to recognize that she was producing ten times as much value.

(3) You could have terminated nine secretaries, and split the savings between the remaining secretary (a raise) and those terminated (some sort of early retirement payout).

(4) You could have terminated nine secretaries, kept the remaining secretary, and handed the savings to the top executives and/or shareholders.

(5) You could have terminated some of the secretaries, kept several others, but at reduced hours, with correspondingly reduced pay, with the savings going to the top executives and/or shareholders.

As a practical matter, what really tends to happen is some combination of 4 and 5, other than in strong economic times, when workers have bargaining power, in which case there's also a little of 2 and 3 in the mix (the economic elites still get most of the savings, but the workers at least get a small cut).

This can be changed with laws requiring more equitable sharing of the savings made possible by automation. But absent such laws, and absent strong economic growth giving workers bargaining power, the senior execs and board members will see to it that the economi elite gets all of the savings (and then some). These days, our secretaries work the same hours for less real income than secretaries a generation ago, despite being vastly more productive.


I've been in the automation business for a long time. I was involved in industrial automation since before computers were even part of the picture. I've always felt a twinge of guilt for the labor jobs that I was instrumental in making obsolete, and I have, at times, been harassed by employees who viewed my presence in their factories as being equivalent to that of the Grim Reaper. I could only comfort myself in the knowledge that if it wasn't me doing the automation work, someone else would have done it instead.

Many of the managers of the businesses with whom I have contracted over the years sought to automate their processes primarily for the purpose of reducing labor costs, with visions of their production facility's resulting increase in efficiency leading to promotions and bonuses for themselves. The hourly employees never saw a gain in wages from their own increased productivity.

For instance, at a local paper mill, there were four large paper machines that each required a crew of 16 in order to operate. Just prior to these machines being de-commissioned and sold to a company in China, all four machines were operated by only four employees. In addition, the extensive millwright shop that performed regular maintenance on these machines had long been closed down and all machine work had been outsourced to third party machine shops.

This paper mill employed 2500 people back in the 1980s. In addition, there were numerable outside service jobs generated by the operation of this mill, including hundreds of log truck drivers. The mill now only processes recycled paper and employs about 180 people.

It is ironic that many of these same managers who had celebrated the reduced labor costs brought about by plant-floor automation never considered the possibility that their own offices would soon benefit from automation as well, and that these increases in efficiency would often lead to the elimination their own positions.

We have become a nation capable of producing enormous material wealth with very little human labor input. It is a dilemma. We are wealthier now than we have ever been, and yet we can't provide good quality jobs for our working class citizens. It has been easy enough in the past to simply shrug that off and say; "Let the poor be poor." However, automation has now evolved to the point at which it also eliminates even white collar jobs.
 
I've been in the automation business for a long time. I was involved in industrial automation since before computers were even part of the picture. I've always felt a twinge of guilt for the labor jobs that I was instrumental in making obsolete, and I have, at times, been harassed by employees who viewed my presence in their factories as being equivalent to that of the Grim Reaper. I could only comfort myself in the knowledge that if it wasn't me doing the automation work, someone else would have done it instead.

Many of the managers of the businesses with whom I have contracted over the years sought to automate their processes primarily for the purpose of reducing labor costs, with visions of their production facility's resulting increase in efficiency leading to promotions and bonuses for themselves. The hourly employees never saw a gain in wages from their own increased productivity.

For instance, at a local paper mill, there were four large paper machines that each required a crew of 16 in order to operate. Just prior to these machines being de-commissioned and sold to a company in China, all four machines were operated by only four employees. In addition, the extensive millwright shop that performed regular maintenance on these machines had long been closed down and all machine work had been outsourced to third party machine shops.

This paper mill employed 2500 people back in the 1980s. In addition, there were numerable outside service jobs generated by the operation of this mill, including hundreds of log truck drivers. The mill now only processes recycled paper and employs about 180 people.

It is ironic that many of these same managers who had celebrated the reduced labor costs brought about by plant-floor automation never considered the possibility that their own offices would soon benefit from automation as well, and that these increases in efficiency would often lead to the elimination their own positions.

We have become a nation capable of producing enormous material wealth with very little human labor input. It is a dilemma. We are wealthier now than we have ever been, and yet we can't provide good quality jobs for our working class citizens. It has been easy enough in the past to simply shrug that off and say; "Let the poor be poor." However, automation has now evolved to the point at which it also eliminates even white collar jobs.

I've noticed people are much less aware of the role of automation than outsourcing. When I work on a contract that will send work to India, people often make comments betraying a sense of guilt about what it will do to American jobs, but when I work on a contract that will automate work, people seldom seem to be aware of the impact on American jobs. I feel more guilty about the automation, since at least the outsourcing theoretically shifts the work to poorer people who need it even more, as opposed to the automation that actually eliminates the jobs, for the benefit of the economic elite.

I'm hoping some day we get serious about implementing policies that spread the value of the new productivity more equitably, through some combination of enforced shorter hours and enforced wealth distribution (enhanced government benefits, a guaranteed income, or some such). If your job is eliminated due to automation, you should be entitled to some portion of the savings from that, to bridge you to retirement or to help pay for a move or retraining to get back in the game. As you point, out, we are wealthier now than we've ever been (real GDP per capita compares favorably to the wealthiest part of the Clinton years, and is far and away higher than the wealthiest part of the Reagan, Johnson, Kennedy, and Eisenhower years), yet we don't feel like it, because that wealth is concentrated into the hands of so few people.

One idea would be a Constitutional guarantee of a govenment job with a decent, lower-middle-class income, for anyone who wants one, financed through taxes designed to hit those who enhance profits with automation and outsourcing. Those government jobs could be responsible for social needs that are currently often neglected (child and elder care, practical nursing, maintenance and enhancement of public infrastructure, sorting recycling, cleaning up vacant lots and roadsides, nature conservation work, etc.)

What I'd be trying to do is to avoid any kind of isolationist or luddite solution, which keeps us less efficient and thereby prevents the possibility of rising overall quality of life. If someone comes up with automation that lets fewer people do more work, by all means it should be implemented, but those negatively impacted by it should have a share of the benefit of the savings.
 
Back
Top