\I don't know -- you introduced it when you introduced the fallacy of FFLs converting their inventory to private stock and then selling them without background checks.
How is it a fallacy? How does logging the sale accomplish the same thing as a background check? I guess you must be in Europe. Too early for cocktails here
It's a fallacy because dealer's can't legally take their inventory and turn it into private stock as easily as you aver. I never said logging the sale was the same as a background check. Of course, the only way to prove universal background checks have taken place is via some form of registration -- at least that's the only thing ever offered as real legislation.
Simple -- under that ruling, the felon could not legally be forced to undergo a background check. Doing so would be forcing him to admit he was violating the law -- a violation of his 5th Amendment rights as cited in the court case Hayne v. U.S.
Absolute rubbish. Do you have any court rulings that background checks are unconstitutional?
Yes, Haynes v. U.S. which has already been cited. From the wikipedia entry regarding the case, "The National Firearms Act of 1934 required the registration of certain types of firearms. Miles Edward Haynes was a convicted felon who was charged with failing to register a firearm under the Act. Haynes argued that, because he was a convicted felon and thus prohibited from owning a firearm, requiring him to register was essentially requiring him to make an open admission to the government that he was in violation of the law, which was thus a violation of his right not to incriminate himself."
If registering the weapon meant he was incriminating himself, then submitting his name for a background check would ALSO be incriminating himself -- at least in any world where either common sense or legal consistency apply.
I know of no "loopholes" on background checks. I don't acknowledge the idea that my private transactions should be subject to such checks -- that doesn't mean I'm using a loophole if I sell one of my guns.
Having a law that says gun sales require a background check EXCEPT......establishes loopholes. Playing semantics with me isn't going to win any debating points. The purpose of the background checks is clear. The exceptions defeat that purpose.
No -- I'm not exercising a loophole. I'm complying with the law. Exceptions are built into all sorts of laws, and not every exception is a loophole. There's a purpose to the background checks? I don't see any, especially as the real-world examples of Cho, Holmes, Loughner and Alexis show that the background checks don't work.
http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-103hr1025enr/pdf/BILLS-103hr1025enr.pdf
There's the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention act which put the system in place. Show me where it indicates an intent for the background check. It doesn't. It merely sets the check as a requirement for new gun sales. Old gun sales were exempted not as a "loophole" but in recognition that there were too many to capture, and that the background checks on new guns would gradually reduce the number of guns circulated without background checks via sheer attrition. This may have worked, too, had the Clinton administration not then acted to reduce the number of FFLs, cutting them by 2/3 via a system of zoning investigations and increased fees. Essentially this created a greater underground market -- instead of trading guns in to licensed dealers, people kept them.