Arkady
President
This is modified from something I used as a reply elsewhere, but I thought it might have broader interest.
Imagine we lived in an alternate universe where Hillary Clinton had intervened in the Uranium One review by the State Department in order to block that deal. How would that look? You see, that would have made the State Department the odd man out in the process, since every other reviewer (and there were a lot of them who had to actively sign off for the deal to go through) said there was no problem with the deal.
Both the Department of Defense and the Department of Homeland Security had reviewed the deal and decided it didn't pose a national security threat. The Justice Department had determined there was no legal objection to it. Commerce had decided there was no economic reason to oppose it. The Energy Department had reviewed it and determined it didn't jeopardize our energy supply. The Office of US Trade Representative had determined it wasn't a problem under our trade deals. The Office of Science and Technology Policy had determined the deal didn't hurt us on that front. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission didn't see a problem with it from their perspective. Neither did Utah's nuclear regulator which also had jurisdiction, nor Canadian regulators who could have blocked the deal.
So, imagine if the State Department had come out against the deal, on the basis that somehow it hurt us diplomatically to allow it to go through (the perspective from which the State Department was meant to review it). Wouldn't that have looked damned suspicious in the face of what was otherwise unanimous agreement that there was no problem with the deal?
Ironically, if we lived in an alternate reality where Clinton had intervened to block the deal on some specious diplomatic reasoning, while every other authority said it was fine, right wingers would still be in here making the exact same case for Clinton corruption despite exactly the opposite action. All that would change is that the conservative media would have handed them some other fig-leaf to base their talking points on.
For example, somewhere in the global economy was doubtless one or more competitors that would prefer for Uranium One not to have survived the review: for example, rival mining companies, that would like to have bought up the US mining rights at fire-sale prices if the Russian-controlled company had to sell them off in a hurry to save the deal. Among the thousands of people with affiliations with such competitors, doubtless some would have donated to the charity the Clintons set up, or hired Bill to speak at an event, or donated to one of the Clinton campaigns, or been a former Clinton staffer, etc. So, it would be just as easy to claim Clinton blocked the deal for corrupt reasons as to claim she approved it for corrupt reasons.
If that was the reality we lived in, the right-wingers would be in here arguing that Hillary Clinton had been paid off to block a deal that everyone knew was no problem. Only, in that alternate reality, those right-wingers would actually be able to make a much more serious argument, since the fact that the State Department came out a different way than all the other reviewers really would demand an answer about why they were different. In that alternate reality, they wouldn't look like imbeciles for making their argument.
Imagine we lived in an alternate universe where Hillary Clinton had intervened in the Uranium One review by the State Department in order to block that deal. How would that look? You see, that would have made the State Department the odd man out in the process, since every other reviewer (and there were a lot of them who had to actively sign off for the deal to go through) said there was no problem with the deal.
Both the Department of Defense and the Department of Homeland Security had reviewed the deal and decided it didn't pose a national security threat. The Justice Department had determined there was no legal objection to it. Commerce had decided there was no economic reason to oppose it. The Energy Department had reviewed it and determined it didn't jeopardize our energy supply. The Office of US Trade Representative had determined it wasn't a problem under our trade deals. The Office of Science and Technology Policy had determined the deal didn't hurt us on that front. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission didn't see a problem with it from their perspective. Neither did Utah's nuclear regulator which also had jurisdiction, nor Canadian regulators who could have blocked the deal.
So, imagine if the State Department had come out against the deal, on the basis that somehow it hurt us diplomatically to allow it to go through (the perspective from which the State Department was meant to review it). Wouldn't that have looked damned suspicious in the face of what was otherwise unanimous agreement that there was no problem with the deal?
Ironically, if we lived in an alternate reality where Clinton had intervened to block the deal on some specious diplomatic reasoning, while every other authority said it was fine, right wingers would still be in here making the exact same case for Clinton corruption despite exactly the opposite action. All that would change is that the conservative media would have handed them some other fig-leaf to base their talking points on.
For example, somewhere in the global economy was doubtless one or more competitors that would prefer for Uranium One not to have survived the review: for example, rival mining companies, that would like to have bought up the US mining rights at fire-sale prices if the Russian-controlled company had to sell them off in a hurry to save the deal. Among the thousands of people with affiliations with such competitors, doubtless some would have donated to the charity the Clintons set up, or hired Bill to speak at an event, or donated to one of the Clinton campaigns, or been a former Clinton staffer, etc. So, it would be just as easy to claim Clinton blocked the deal for corrupt reasons as to claim she approved it for corrupt reasons.
If that was the reality we lived in, the right-wingers would be in here arguing that Hillary Clinton had been paid off to block a deal that everyone knew was no problem. Only, in that alternate reality, those right-wingers would actually be able to make a much more serious argument, since the fact that the State Department came out a different way than all the other reviewers really would demand an answer about why they were different. In that alternate reality, they wouldn't look like imbeciles for making their argument.
Last edited: