New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Uranium One Alternate Reality

Arkady

President
This is modified from something I used as a reply elsewhere, but I thought it might have broader interest.

Imagine we lived in an alternate universe where Hillary Clinton had intervened in the Uranium One review by the State Department in order to block that deal. How would that look? You see, that would have made the State Department the odd man out in the process, since every other reviewer (and there were a lot of them who had to actively sign off for the deal to go through) said there was no problem with the deal.

Both the Department of Defense and the Department of Homeland Security had reviewed the deal and decided it didn't pose a national security threat. The Justice Department had determined there was no legal objection to it. Commerce had decided there was no economic reason to oppose it. The Energy Department had reviewed it and determined it didn't jeopardize our energy supply. The Office of US Trade Representative had determined it wasn't a problem under our trade deals. The Office of Science and Technology Policy had determined the deal didn't hurt us on that front. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission didn't see a problem with it from their perspective. Neither did Utah's nuclear regulator which also had jurisdiction, nor Canadian regulators who could have blocked the deal.

So, imagine if the State Department had come out against the deal, on the basis that somehow it hurt us diplomatically to allow it to go through (the perspective from which the State Department was meant to review it). Wouldn't that have looked damned suspicious in the face of what was otherwise unanimous agreement that there was no problem with the deal?

Ironically, if we lived in an alternate reality where Clinton had intervened to block the deal on some specious diplomatic reasoning, while every other authority said it was fine, right wingers would still be in here making the exact same case for Clinton corruption despite exactly the opposite action. All that would change is that the conservative media would have handed them some other fig-leaf to base their talking points on.

For example, somewhere in the global economy was doubtless one or more competitors that would prefer for Uranium One not to have survived the review: for example, rival mining companies, that would like to have bought up the US mining rights at fire-sale prices if the Russian-controlled company had to sell them off in a hurry to save the deal. Among the thousands of people with affiliations with such competitors, doubtless some would have donated to the charity the Clintons set up, or hired Bill to speak at an event, or donated to one of the Clinton campaigns, or been a former Clinton staffer, etc. So, it would be just as easy to claim Clinton blocked the deal for corrupt reasons as to claim she approved it for corrupt reasons.

If that was the reality we lived in, the right-wingers would be in here arguing that Hillary Clinton had been paid off to block a deal that everyone knew was no problem. Only, in that alternate reality, those right-wingers would actually be able to make a much more serious argument, since the fact that the State Department came out a different way than all the other reviewers really would demand an answer about why they were different. In that alternate reality, they wouldn't look like imbeciles for making their argument.
 
Last edited:
Who expected your job as Hillary Clinton's human shield would become so demanding after she lost the election?
Do you disagree with the idea it would actually be easier to make a case for corruption by Clinton if her State Department, alone among all the reviewers, had come out and claimed there was some reason to block the deal? Do you disagree with my claim that if she had so conspicuously held up a deal everyone else thought was fine, conservatives would quickly have spun conspiracy theories about how she'd been paid off to do so?

That's the essence of the conservative approach to Clinton. They start with the assumption everything she does it corrupt, and then they work to make the pieces fit that picture. Thus, either of two opposite actions would have been confirmation of their worldview.
 
Yes, I'm sure the Defense Department and Department of Homeland Security got their cut, er, signed off on a semi-hostile power getting control of the mining of nuclear resources. Makes perfect sense!
 
Yes, I'm sure the Defense Department and Department of Homeland Security got their cut, er, signed off on a semi-hostile power getting control of the mining of nuclear resources. Makes perfect sense!

Wow. Russia is a “semi-hostile power” now? I’m sure that means you’re furious with Trump and his toadies for acting in cahoots with Russia then, no?

No?

;-)
 
Yes, I'm sure the Defense Department and Department of Homeland Security got their cut, er, signed off on a semi-hostile power getting control of the mining of nuclear resources. Makes perfect sense!
You're starting to get a sense for how silly the conspiracy theory has to get in order to rescue the right-wing speculation about Clinton being bought off. Once you know how the process actually works, you see bribing Clinton would have been worthless without bribing all the others, too. That would mean bribing:
  1. Department of the Treasury (which chairs the committee and has the most control over it)
  2. Department of Justice
  3. Department of Homeland Security
  4. Department of Commerce
  5. Department of Defense
  6. Department of Energy
  7. Office of the U.S. Trade Representative
  8. Office of Science & Technology Policy
To be safe, you'd also want to bribe the following, who don't have votes but participate in the reviews and thus could whistle-blow on any funny business:
  1. Office of Management & Budget
  2. Council of Economic Advisors
  3. National Security Council
  4. National Economic Council
  5. Homeland Security Council
The Director of National Intelligence and the Secretary of Labor are also non-voting participants, so to be safe, you'd want to buy them off, too. And in the case of Uranium One, the nuclear regulatory commission also had veto power over it, so you'd need to buy them off, too. Plus, it was Jose Fernandez who handled the matter for State, and he says Clinton wasn't involved, so he'd need to be in on the lie, too, so there's another one you have to buy off.

Of course, the dummies have committed to the notion that somehow Clinton was bought off, and they'd rather humiliate themselves by speculating that the other seventeen are in on it, too, including prominent Republicans like Robert Gates (absent even a shred of evidence of that massive conspiracy), than abandon their goofy position.

It's got to be weird to live with that mindset, where the reaction to finding yourself in a dumb position is always to double down.
 
This is modified from something I used as a reply elsewhere, but I thought it might have broader interest.

Imagine we lived in an alternate universe where Hillary Clinton had intervened in the Uranium One review by the State Department in order to block that deal. How would that look? You see, that would have made the State Department the odd man out in the process, since every other reviewer (and there were a lot of them who had to actively sign off for the deal to go through) said there was no problem with the deal.

Both the Department of Defense and the Department of Homeland Security had reviewed the deal and decided it didn't pose a national security threat. The Justice Department had determined there was no legal objection to it. Commerce had decided there was no economic reason to oppose it. The Energy Department had reviewed it and determined it didn't jeopardize our energy supply. The Office of US Trade Representative had determined it wasn't a problem under our trade deals. The Office of Science and Technology Policy had determined the deal didn't hurt us on that front. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission didn't see a problem with it from their perspective. Neither did Utah's nuclear regulator which also had jurisdiction, nor Canadian regulators who could have blocked the deal.

So, imagine if the State Department had come out against the deal, on the basis that somehow it hurt us diplomatically to allow it to go through (the perspective from which the State Department was meant to review it). Wouldn't that have looked damned suspicious in the face of what was otherwise unanimous agreement that there was no problem with the deal?

Ironically, if we lived in an alternate reality where Clinton had intervened to block the deal on some specious diplomatic reasoning, while every other authority said it was fine, right wingers would still be in here making the exact same case for Clinton corruption despite exactly the opposite action. All that would change is that the conservative media would have handed them some other fig-leaf to base their talking points on.

For example, somewhere in the global economy was doubtless one or more competitors that would prefer for Uranium One not to have survived the review: for example, rival mining companies, that would like to have bought up the US mining rights at fire-sale prices if the Russian-controlled company had to sell them off in a hurry to save the deal. Among the thousands of people with affiliations with such competitors, doubtless some would have donated to the charity the Clintons set up, or hired Bill to speak at an event, or donated to one of the Clinton campaigns, or been a former Clinton staffer, etc. So, it would be just as easy to claim Clinton blocked the deal for corrupt reasons as to claim she approved it for corrupt reasons.

If that was the reality we lived in, the right-wingers would be in here arguing that Hillary Clinton had been paid off to block a deal that everyone knew was no problem. Only, in that alternate reality, those right-wingers would actually be able to make a much more serious argument, since the fact that the State Department came out a different way than all the other reviewers really would demand an answer about why they were different. In that alternate reality, they wouldn't look like imbeciles for making their argument.
lots of pay for play with that Russian deal and the CF used as a way to launder the payments.
 
lots of pay for play with that Russian deal and the CF used as a way to launder the payments.
There'd have to be a whole hell of a lot of it. I listed those involved in the review, above. Counting Clinton, you'd need eighteen members of the federal government in on it, minimum, plus potentially having to bribe people in Canada and Utah, as well, since they could also hold it up. These bribes would need to be spread across many departments, including the Defense Department, which was run by a Republican at the time. Somehow, all those very high-level people would need to be convinced to sign off on it, in exchange for some money donated to a charity.

That's one goofy conspiracy theory you've got going there. Keep in mind that even speculating that somehow Clinton could have been bribed with a donation to the charity she set up is a weird theory. She had no role at the foundation, at the time, and her family's role was minimal -- they made up just a small share of board members, and held no executive office, nor did they earn a dime from the charity.... doing all their work pro bono. Plus, the foundation was independently audited.

At the time of the review of that deal, the CEO and chair of the foundation was Bruce Lindsey. The CFO (the man who'd be responsible for making sure none of the foundations money was used to bribe anyone) was Andrew Kessel. In order for your conspiracy theory to work, it wouldn't be enough just to bribe eighteen senior members of the federal government. You'd also need to bribe key people throughout the charitable foundation and its independent auditor, too.

If you want to know what bribery really looks like, you're looking in the wrong direction entirely. Instead of looking at the Clinton Foundation, look at the Trump Foundation. Unlike the Clintons, Trump set up his foundation with the clear goal of making it a family slush fund, rather than an actual charity. He did so by making sure that, unlike the Clinton Foundation, it didn't have anyone other than immediate family members and the Trump Organization's career-long dependents in positions of authority at the foundation, that way he could count on people turning a blind eye. And he didn't get any independent audit of its activity, so the dirt wouldn't be discovered (despite such an audit being legally required). That way he could use the foundation to bribe politicians. The foundation has even admitted to self dealing:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/poli...2b15787add0_story.html?utm_term=.4942ff369294
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...rida-attorney-general/?utm_term=.a3a01b03c76f

Of course, since Trump has the "magic R," that actual use of a "charitable" foundation to bribe a politician will be treated as perfectly fine, whereas even the silliest of speculation that the Clintons did something like that will be treated as a serious matter.
 
You're starting to get a sense for how silly the conspiracy theory has to get in order to rescue the right-wing speculation about Clinton being bought off. Once you know how the process actually works, you see bribing Clinton would have been worthless without bribing all the others, too. That would mean bribing:
  1. Department of the Treasury (which chairs the committee and has the most control over it)
  2. Department of Justice
  3. Department of Homeland Security
  4. Department of Commerce
  5. Department of Defense
  6. Department of Energy
  7. Office of the U.S. Trade Representative
  8. Office of Science & Technology Policy
To be safe, you'd also want to bribe the following, who don't have votes but participate in the reviews and thus could whistle-blow on any funny business:
  1. Office of Management & Budget
  2. Council of Economic Advisors
  3. National Security Council
  4. National Economic Council
  5. Homeland Security Council
The Director of National Intelligence and the Secretary of Labor are also non-voting participants, so to be safe, you'd want to buy them off, too. And in the case of Uranium One, the nuclear regulatory commission also had veto power over it, so you'd need to buy them off, too. Plus, it was Jose Fernandez who handled the matter for State, and he says Clinton wasn't involved, so he'd need to be in on the lie, too, so there's another one you have to buy off.

Of course, the dummies have committed to the notion that somehow Clinton was bought off, and they'd rather humiliate themselves by speculating that the other seventeen are in on it, too, including prominent Republicans like Robert Gates (absent even a shred of evidence of that massive conspiracy), than abandon their goofy position.

It's got to be weird to live with that mindset, where the reaction to finding yourself in a dumb position is always to double down.
All signed off on the deal and all departments are run by the president.
 
This is modified from something I used as a reply elsewhere, but I thought it might have broader interest.

Imagine we lived in an alternate universe where Hillary Clinton had intervened in the Uranium One review by the State Department in order to block that deal. How would that look? You see, that would have made the State Department the odd man out in the process, since every other reviewer (and there were a lot of them who had to actively sign off for the deal to go through) said there was no problem with the deal.

Both the Department of Defense and the Department of Homeland Security had reviewed the deal and decided it didn't pose a national security threat. The Justice Department had determined there was no legal objection to it. Commerce had decided there was no economic reason to oppose it. The Energy Department had reviewed it and determined it didn't jeopardize our energy supply. The Office of US Trade Representative had determined it wasn't a problem under our trade deals. The Office of Science and Technology Policy had determined the deal didn't hurt us on that front. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission didn't see a problem with it from their perspective. Neither did Utah's nuclear regulator which also had jurisdiction, nor Canadian regulators who could have blocked the deal.

So, imagine if the State Department had come out against the deal, on the basis that somehow it hurt us diplomatically to allow it to go through (the perspective from which the State Department was meant to review it). Wouldn't that have looked damned suspicious in the face of what was otherwise unanimous agreement that there was no problem with the deal?

Ironically, if we lived in an alternate reality where Clinton had intervened to block the deal on some specious diplomatic reasoning, while every other authority said it was fine, right wingers would still be in here making the exact same case for Clinton corruption despite exactly the opposite action. All that would change is that the conservative media would have handed them some other fig-leaf to base their talking points on.

For example, somewhere in the global economy was doubtless one or more competitors that would prefer for Uranium One not to have survived the review: for example, rival mining companies, that would like to have bought up the US mining rights at fire-sale prices if the Russian-controlled company had to sell them off in a hurry to save the deal. Among the thousands of people with affiliations with such competitors, doubtless some would have donated to the charity the Clintons set up, or hired Bill to speak at an event, or donated to one of the Clinton campaigns, or been a former Clinton staffer, etc. So, it would be just as easy to claim Clinton blocked the deal for corrupt reasons as to claim she approved it for corrupt reasons.

If that was the reality we lived in, the right-wingers would be in here arguing that Hillary Clinton had been paid off to block a deal that everyone knew was no problem. Only, in that alternate reality, those right-wingers would actually be able to make a much more serious argument, since the fact that the State Department came out a different way than all the other reviewers really would demand an answer about why they were different. In that alternate reality, they wouldn't look like imbeciles for making their argument.
I've not been one to post much on this uranium stuff (nor Benghazi for that matter), but your timing is curious...as is the sheer investment made in text.

Is this still more DNC image rehabilitation in advance of yet another run in 2020?
 
Last edited:
You're starting to get a sense for how silly the conspiracy theory has to get in order to rescue the right-wing speculation about Clinton being bought off. Once you know how the process actually works, you see bribing Clinton would have been worthless without bribing all the others, too. That would mean bribing:
  1. Department of the Treasury (which chairs the committee and has the most control over it)
  2. Department of Justice
  3. Department of Homeland Security
  4. Department of Commerce
  5. Department of Defense
  6. Department of Energy
  7. Office of the U.S. Trade Representative
  8. Office of Science & Technology Policy
To be safe, you'd also want to bribe the following, who don't have votes but participate in the reviews and thus could whistle-blow on any funny business:
  1. Office of Management & Budget
  2. Council of Economic Advisors
  3. National Security Council
  4. National Economic Council
  5. Homeland Security Council
The Director of National Intelligence and the Secretary of Labor are also non-voting participants, so to be safe, you'd want to buy them off, too. And in the case of Uranium One, the nuclear regulatory commission also had veto power over it, so you'd need to buy them off, too. Plus, it was Jose Fernandez who handled the matter for State, and he says Clinton wasn't involved, so he'd need to be in on the lie, too, so there's another one you have to buy off.

Of course, the dummies have committed to the notion that somehow Clinton was bought off, and they'd rather humiliate themselves by speculating that the other seventeen are in on it, too, including prominent Republicans like Robert Gates (absent even a shred of evidence of that massive conspiracy), than abandon their goofy position.

It's got to be weird to live with that mindset, where the reaction to finding yourself in a dumb position is always to double down.

Multi-millions from Russia for CF and $500,000 for Slick
New Investigation may burst libs bubble............
 
I don't know why arkie is trying to push his fantasy on everybody when reality is going to kick the sh!t out of his alternate Reality.

Why post a Novel every reply when world knows CF got Multi-Millions$ from Russia and $500,000 for Slick after Uranium deal.............

He uses more bandwidth that total of all members........to say nothing!
 
I've not been one to post much on this uranium stuff (nor Benghazi for that matter), but your timing is curious...as is the sheer investment made in text.

The timing was driven by Marvin, who brought it up below. After I put the time in to respond, I figured it was worth sharing as a top post.
 
Back
Top