New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Violent Cities

Your faulty "reasoning" is called the Gambler's Fallacy. It's been taking money from stupid people like you for centuries.


I'd let it go. There are some Atheists who are tolerant of people of Faith, and some who are less so. The ones who choose not to be are going to look at anyone who does not agree with them as someone who is inferior to themselves, and will disregard any argument by them as one that is unworthy. Until he is willing to surrender his bigotry, you're unlikely to make any inroads. Leave him be.
 
I'd let it go. There are some Atheists who are tolerant of people of Faith, and some who are less so. The ones who choose not to be are going to look at anyone who does not agree with them as someone who is inferior to themselves, and will disregard any argument by them as one that is unworthy. Until he is willing to surrender his bigotry, you're unlikely to make any inroads. Leave him be.

Perhaps you're right. In the face of such bigotry, ignoring it may be the best option, until it becomes truly dangerous.
 
Your faulty "reasoning" is called the Gambler's Fallacy. It's been taking money from stupid people like you for centuries.
No. You misunderstand the gambler's fallacy. The gambler's fallacy is almost the opposite of what I'm presenting. It's the belief that if something has been happening infrequently, it's "due" -- for example, if you flip the coin and get three straight "heads" you should bet "tails" next time, because it's more likely to come up. That's irrational.

What I'm talking about, instead, is using rational thought to draw inferences from available data, and then acting on those inferences.

Say I've got a die, and you don't know how many sides it has -- it could be a normal six-sided die, or one of the less common ones used in gaming (4-sided, eight-sided, ten, twelve, twenty). You are allowed to see the results of ten of my rolls, but not the die: 1, 3, 4, 4, 2, 1, 1, 4, 2, 3. You now have a chance to make a bet. If you wager $10, and the next roll is 1, 2, 3, or 4, you win $40. If it's anything else, you lose. Is it a good bet to take, knowing what you know?

If I'm holding in my hand a 20-sided die, it's a bad bet. Then, you'd have a 4-in-20 chance of winning $40, which makes the bet statistically worth $8, with a cost of $10. But what are the chances I'm holding a 20-sided die? Effectively zero.

In fact, the chance I'm holding anything other than a four-sided die is really low. Rolling a six-sided die ten times without getting a five or six will happen a little under 2% of the time. An eight-sided die will fail to hit five, six, seven, or eight on ten rolls a little under 0.1% of the time, and so on, up to about a hundred-thousandth of a percent chance of only getting the first four numbers with ten rolls of a 20-sided die. All told, if you bet 1, 2, 3, or 4, your probability of winning is well over 99%. In fact, the estimated value of the bet is around $39.75, for a cost of $10. You'd be a fool not to take it.

That doesn't require faith. It doesn't require a mystical belief that certain results are "due" to come up, the way an irrational gambler would think. It just requires understanding what the available data tell us about what is likely to be going on, and based on that what is likely to happen in the future. Right-wingers, who so often are crippled by faith, are frequently incapable of that kind of inductive reasoning.
 
FAITH: I flip a coin 100 times. It comes up heads 51 times and tails 49 times. I conclude, based on fairy tales I was fed as a child, that God dictates every outcome in the world, and that the reason it came out that way was because He willed it. Based on that, I conclude that I should have no expectation at all about how subsequent flips will tend to come out, except to the extent that I can influence them through prayer.

Of course you are confusing prayer with magic.

"I" don't influence anything through prayer. If there is any influencing to be done it is done by God.

Why is it not possible that God created probability? Or truth?

And what kind of lesson would God be teaching his children if he were to influence a coin flip in such a trivial scenario?

You also seem to be confusing the rational Christian God with the capricious Muslim Allah. God may work in mysterious ways but He is not capricious or cruel.
 
Of course you are confusing prayer with magic.

There are people who don't think prayer can influence anything. But there are a great many who think it can... such as Jesus of Nazareth, who led his followers in a prayer that included an invocation to the deity to provide the daily bread.

Why is it not possible that God created probability? Or truth?

It's possible that God, or a committee of flying unicorns, or a time-traveling future Kim Kardashian created probability. Absolutely disproving any of those things cannot be done. But, in each case, we have no reason to believe in the existence of such beings, much less to ascribe to them certain acts.

And what kind of lesson would God be teaching his children if he were to influence a coin flip in such a trivial scenario?

Why would we assume he would only act to teach?

You also seem to be confusing the rational Christian God with the capricious Muslim Allah

The Christian God is no more rational than any other. And, yes, the God of the Bible is both capricious and cruel. Read the story of Job.
 
There are people who don't think prayer can influence anything. But there are a great many who think it can... such as Jesus of Nazareth, who led his followers in a prayer that included an invocation to the deity to provide the daily bread.
You're changing the subject. People have no command over God's ability to change the flip of a coin. Prayer is not control.

It's possible that God, or a committee of flying unicorns, or a time-traveling future Kim Kardashian created probability. Absolutely disproving any of those things cannot be done. But, in each case, we have no reason to believe in the existence of such beings, much less to ascribe to them certain acts.

Nor is there any reason to believe that your mom loves you or that you love your mom. And yet you and just about all but the most cynical atheists persist in your BELIEF in spite of the lack of evidence.

Face it. In spite of the lack of evidence, you are a believer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You're changing the subject. People have no command over God's ability to change the flip of a coin

That's an assertion without evidence. Just as it's impossible to prove 100% that there is no God, it's also impossible to prove 100% that people have no command over God's ability to change the flip of a coin. You have your theological assumptions about what prayer can and can't do, based on absolutely no evidence. Others can believe otherwise, using those same non-existent standards.

Nor is there any reason to believe that your mom loves you or that you love your mom. And yet you and just about all but the most cynical atheists persist in your BELIEF in spite of the lack of evidence.

Incorrect. My behavior towards my mother and hers towards me is consistent with what we would expect from two people who love each other. That's evidence. It may not be proof, but it's something. It's the simplest explanation for what we can observe. By comparison, faith is belief without evidence.
 
That's an assertion without evidence. Just as it's impossible to prove 100% that there is no God, it's also impossible to prove 100% that people have no command over God's ability to change the flip of a coin.
This isn't about proof. It's about belief.

Nobody is trying to prove God. Having said that, you do have a problem with definitions. If I have some sort of power over God then God is not God. You have forced a circular reasoning by re-defining God.

You have your theological assumptions about what prayer can and can't do, based on absolutely no evidence.

No evidence is required. This is about faith. Evidence is highly subjective.

Incorrect. My behavior towards my mother and hers towards me is consistent with what we would expect from two people who love each other. That's evidence.

Bullshit. Bill and Hillary express love publicly but it could very well be a lie. In fact, I worked with a guy who was secret service in the 90s and would totally back me up on this.

Billions of failed relationships fail because of lies about love.

Your behavior towards your mother and vice versa could be a total lie and can therefore NOT be submitted as evidence. You can't prove love. It requires faith.

It may not be proof, but it's something.
It is nothing without faith.
 
If I have some sort of power over God then God is not God. You have forced a circular reasoning by re-defining God.

If you define God as "that which no other thing can have power over," then, of course, you can't have power over God. But that's just a definitional game. It's logically possible to imagine a non-omnipotent God (an omnipotent one is logically impossible, since that runs into the classic problem of such a God not being able to create a rock so heavy that he can't lift it). Once you've dreamed up a non-omnipotent God, then why is it any more legitimate to imagine that the God isn't governed by rules requiring him to do certain things in response to prayer? You are, of course, free to dream up such a God, who is free from the constraints of prayer, but that's just your own invented definition.

Bill and Hillary express love publicly but it could very well be a lie.

It could, indeed. For an outsider, it's impossible to say for sure whether they really do love each other or they're just putting on a decent act. All we can do is take the best educated guess based on a close examination of the available evidence. That is, of course, very different from faith, which has nothing at all to do with evidence.

Say I'm walking through the woods and find a clearing where there's a circle of stones and in the middle there's a pile of wood ashes. I will conclude that someone had a campfire there. That's what the evidence points towards. Could it be wrong? Of course. Maybe someone made the circle of stones then added a pile of wood ashes brought in from some other location in order to trick people into thinking there was a campfire there. Maybe someone made a circle of stones, piled up some wood intending to have a campfire, but then left, and later that dry wood caught fire naturally. Maybe someone built a circle of stones around a sapling he'd planted, to protect it, then it grew up and was struck by lightning and burned down, leaving the ash. Those are all possible. But it doesn't take faith to look at it and conclude, by inductive reasoning, that the first possibility is the most likely, given what we know about the real world. By comparison, if I were to look at that circle of stones and pile of ash and conclude that it was built by an invisible man who lives in the sky, as a place to roast the souls of the unworthy -- well, that would be a matter of faith. Faith doesn't mean believing something that can't be absolutely proven. It means strong belief without a rational basis.
 
If you define God as "that which no other thing can have power over," then, of course, you can't have power over God. But that's just a definitional game. It's logically possible to imagine a non-omnipotent God (an omnipotent one is logically impossible, since that runs into the classic problem of such a God not being able to create a rock so heavy that he can't lift it).

I can't believe you actually used that old saw.

That's as stupid as saying: God is love. Love is blind. Therefore, God is blind.

These are goofy logical games serving no purpose. God created logic. He is not bound by logic but to be a kind and merciful God He is rational. He knows a logic not known to man. Now before you scoff consider all that you thought was true at one time but now are better educated.

I can easily remember a time before I knew what Special Relativity is. I can remember how I thought the world worked before I knew what Quantum Mechanics is. I remember how I thought politics operated in the United States before I realized how Republicans are part of the problem too.

Perhaps coincidences are nothing but chance. But that was before my adopted daughter came into the world and made it tougher to believe in chance than it is to believe in the hand of God at work.

Now, surely you don't have all the answers. And you never will. So give your arrogance a break, come down off your high horse, and realize you might not have all the answers as to why things happen the way they do.

For an outsider, it's impossible to say for sure whether they really do love each other or they're just putting on a decent act.
Then there is no evidence.

Your example of ashes and rocks is evidence that anyone can see. But nobody can see into the heart of Bill and Hillary. Not even Bill and Hillary. Which is why love is a matter of faith i.e. trust. "I have faith in God" equals "I trust in God."

All we can do is take the best educated guess based on a close examination of the available evidence. That is, of course, very different from faith, which has nothing at all to do with evidence.
Nonsense. If you want to continue on this path I can tell you I have plenty of evidence that God exists. It's all subjective--that is it is dependent on my own observation--but given your assessment of Bill and Hillary, given your assessment of you and your mom, so what? Apparently, evidence is subjective.

Not in my book. Evidence is available for all to see. Everyone can see the ashes and rocks. Nobody can see the black hearted desire for Bill and Hillary to kill each other but instead put on amicable faces for purely expedient and pragmatic goals.

It takes a certain amount of critical thinking to look beyond the available evidence and address the underlying assumptions realizing that not all assumptions are false.

Thomas Aquinas said that there is a God because we ask the question, "Is there a God." He has been roundly criticized for employing circular logic fallacy. But that doesn't make it false, just logically unsupportable.

It is a matter of faith. Belief. Trust. Trust is required to believe in God.

Trust is required to believe in love.

If you believe in love but not God based on some sort of "evidence" that exists with love but not with God you are being radically inconsistent. There is no evidence for either. If you embrace love you embrace God.
 
God is love. Love is blind. Therefore, God is blind.

If God were love and love were blind then of course God would have to be blind. The only way God isn't blind is if God and love are not the same, or love is not actually blind.

But nobody can see into the heart of Bill and Hillary

Agreed. We can only see their actions. Those actions include some factors that we would interpret as consistent with two people who love each other (e.g., choosing to spend their lives together, choosing to raise a child together, being extremely supportive of one another's ambitions), and some that are inconsistent (e.g., Bill's infidelities). We can't know for sure whether or not they love each other. But we have evidence from which to assess the question. I can come to a fairly weak and rebuttable assumption that they love each other, based on the totality of the evidence I've seen. Faith is something different.

Faith is strong belief based on no evidence at all. It's not rebuttable. Something could pop up tomorrow to convince me the Clintons don't love each other. In fact, if they were to announce tomorrow they were getting divorced, and each said it's because they were no longer in love, I'd assume they were not, in fact, in love. They might, of course, be lying, but their words and actions would be more consistent with the idea they weren't in love, and so the balance of the evidence would go that way. By comparison, what evidence could come out tomorrow to convince you there's no God? None. It's faith, and so evidence is immaterial to the belief. That's the hallmark of faith.

Thomas Aquinas said that there is a God because we ask the question, "Is there a God."

Is there a sentient unicorn living in your rectum and forcing you to recount such nonsense? I've asked the question, so I guess there must be.
 
Faith is strong belief based on no evidence at all.
Again it's a problem with definition. You have a faulty definition of faith as well as evidence.

By comparison, what evidence could come out tomorrow to convince you there's no God? None.

Don't be so quick to assume. Even Mother Theresa had severe challenges put to her faith. Many priests lose their faith.

Is there a sentient unicorn living in your rectum and forcing you to recount such nonsense?

The evidence would suggest otherwise.

Again, your definitions are jacked up.
 
Back
Top