New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Wait just a minute...

Lukey

Senator
Isn't Lake Mead the reservoir behind the Hoover Dam?

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...nges-lowest-level-ever-problem-not-going-away

You know, the kind of public works project the Keynesian left likes to credit with all sorts of economic benefits?

So, like, wouldn't the west have been way more un-settled at this point if the Hoover Dam had never been built? That region never was designed by nature to support 70 (plus) million people, and it wouldn't have to if Hoovervelt (the original Bushbama) hadn't decided to interfere in nature (and the economy) to create this looming disaster in a Keynesian style (stimulus) make work orgy of government waste! Progressive big government depression era policies - still failing after 70 years...
 
Isn't Lake Mead the reservoir behind the Hoover Dam?

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...nges-lowest-level-ever-problem-not-going-away

You know, the kind of public works project the Keynesian left likes to credit with all sorts of economic benefits?

So, like, wouldn't the west have been way more un-settled at this point if the Hoover Dam had never been built? That region never was designed by nature to support 70 (plus) million people, and it wouldn't have to if Hoovervelt (the original Bushbama) hadn't decided to interfere in nature (and the economy) to create this looming disaster in a Keynesian style (stimulus) make work orgy of government waste! Progressive big government depression era policies - still failing after 70 years...

The dam was completed 80 years ago and brought tremendous growth to the west. Now...folks can argue as to whether that was a positive or not, but had it not been built, we'd be looking at about 45 million people living elsewhere.

One needs to remember the history of 7 states squabbling over water rights in a parched west.
 
Last edited:
The dam was completed 80 years and brought tremendous growth to the west. Now...folks can argue as to whether that was a positive or not, but had it not been built, we'd be looking at about 45 million people living elsewhere.

One needs to remember the history of 7 states squabbling over water rights in a parched west.

Yes, and a big government solution that just created an even bigger problem (which I would say is fairly typical).
 
Yes, and a big government solution that just created an even bigger problem (which I would say is fairly typical).
Is there ever a limitation to what you might consider failure...or success?

I mean...most folks consider the settlement of the west and our harnessing of resources a pretty spectacular achievement. You consider it a long standing failure.
 
Isn't Lake Mead the reservoir behind the Hoover Dam?

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-...nges-lowest-level-ever-problem-not-going-away

You know, the kind of public works project the Keynesian left likes to credit with all sorts of economic benefits?

So, like, wouldn't the west have been way more un-settled at this point if the Hoover Dam had never been built? That region never was designed by nature to support 70 (plus) million people, and it wouldn't have to if Hoovervelt (the original Bushbama) hadn't decided to interfere in nature (and the economy) to create this looming disaster in a Keynesian style (stimulus) make work orgy of government waste! Progressive big government depression era policies - still failing after 70 years...

LOL! I love this AP propaganda at your link:

"this problem is not going away and it is likely to get worse, perhaps far worse, as climate change unfolds."

Do these people EVER take a break from trying to indoctrinate????
 
LOL! I love this AP propaganda at your link:

"this problem is not going away and it is likely to get worse, perhaps far worse, as climate change unfolds."

Do these people EVER take a break from trying to indoctrinate????

Exactly! Leave it to the (leftist) MSM to ask the wrong questions, and ignore the profound - that this problem wouldn't exist if the government had never interfered and this Dam had never been built.
 
Is there ever a limitation to what you might consider failure...or success?

I mean...most folks consider the settlement of the west and our harnessing of resources a pretty spectacular achievement. You consider it a long standing failure.

I consider a "success" that which is sustainable. The west was never designed to hold 100 million residents. But our government "authorities" in the 30s decided they knew best. Unfortunately for those who are now running out of water, they apparently did not...
 
I consider a "success" that which is sustainable. The west was never designed to hold 100 million residents. But our government "authorities" in the 30s decided they knew best. Unfortunately for those who are now running out of water, they apparently did not...

80 years is a goodly long time to know exactly what the future holds in that time. Los Angeles became a powerhouse economy. You say it shouldn't have...because of what might have happened nearly a century into the future.

So consider, again...the 45 million or so folks living there now, in San Diego and Salt Lake and Los Angeles...and where they would be living otherwise. Consider Greater Pittsburgh with...say, 5 million residents instead of 3 million...
 
80 years is a goodly long time to know exactly what the future holds in that time. Los Angeles became a powerhouse economy. You say it shouldn't have...because of what might have happened nearly a century into the future.

So consider, again...the 45 million or so folks living there now, in San Diego and Salt Lake and Los Angeles...and where they would be living otherwise. Consider Greater Pittsburgh with...say, 5 million residents instead of 3 million...

At least we have the abundant (and high quality) water to support them. Maybe we'd have more density and better public transportation if the big government progressives had left it up to the states to figure out their own problems. You know, a sustainable civic model???
 
At least we have the abundant (and high quality) water to support them. Maybe we'd have more density and better public transportation if the big government progressives had left it up to the states to figure out their own problems. You know, a sustainable civic model???

Public transportation?
 
Yes, a perfectly appropriate local (and state) government enterprise. You know, the kinds of projects that promote sustainability rather than sprawl (like federal projects tend to do)?

Big government. Requires eminent domain to acquire the property for the right of ways, massive infrastructure improvements and operating subsidies.

While I am a proponent of public transportation, I have no illusion that any public transit system is self sustaining.
 
Big government. Requires eminent domain to acquire the property for the right of ways, massive infrastructure improvements and operating subsidies.

While I am a proponent of public transportation, I have no illusion that any public transit system is self sustaining.

I didn't say the public transportation system was "self sustaining." I said they tend to be "sustainable" (with perhaps some reasonable subsidies from tax revenues). And they are a LOT more "self sustaining" in the absence of (usually federal) super highways (which, um, require way more "eminent domain" usage than train, trolley and bus based systems). Plus they would have been built 50 years ago when the pathways would have been much easier to assemble without major community disruption.
 
I didn't say the public transportation system was "self sustaining." I said they tend to be "sustainable" (with perhaps some reasonable subsidies from tax revenues). And they are a LOT more "self sustaining" in the absence of (usually federal) super highways (which, um, require way more "eminent domain" usage than train, trolley and bus based systems). Plus they would have been built 50 years ago when the pathways would have been much easier to assemble without major community disruption.

Semantics.

Subsidies are required to promote this sustainability you desire. The pathways would then promote sprawl, which was what occurred when lines were expanded previously.

The Interstate System is a defense project. You do realize the United States is large enterprise, do you not?
 
Big government. Requires eminent domain to acquire the property for the right of ways, massive infrastructure improvements and operating subsidies.

While I am a proponent of public transportation, I have no illusion that any public transit system is self sustaining.

Yeah, look how great government is doing with AMTRAC-broke-broke always Broke
 
Semantics.

Subsidies are required to promote this sustainability you desire. The pathways would then promote sprawl, which was what occurred when lines were expanded previously.

The Interstate System is a defense project. You do realize the United States is large enterprise, do you not?

The sprawl would be in pockets clustered around rail lines. Think about the implications for the issue of climate change!

The interstate system was corporatism - you are old enough to remember "see the USA in your Chevrolet," right?

Haha! You are starting to sound like a neo-con or, at the very least, a defender of the MIC. And I sound like the hippy! Strange plot twist, eh?
 
The sprawl would be in pockets clustered around rail lines. Think about the implications for the issue of climate change!

The interstate system was corporatism - you are old enough to remember "see the USA in your Chevrolet," right?

Haha! You are starting to sound like a neo-con or, at the very least, a defender of the MIC. And I sound like the hippy! Strange plot twist, eh?

I have for years used the Preamble to The Constitution as my basic guide to the tasks the Feds are to engage in. I have no issue whatsoever with the common defense and recognize that troop and supply movement within the nation meet such criteria. The old US Highway System was insufficient for modern needs. The new system has reached that point as well, 60 years after its proposal.

That commerce was also used to sell the highway system, as well as promote tourism and the automobile industry also meets my Hamiltonian outlook. We also saw tv shows such as Route 66. That show also featured a Chevrolet. Automobiles were among the initial purveyors of product placement in shows, happily tossing a few vehicles a show's way for that little mention in the credits on top of the visual of the vehicle, right there in front of millions of eyes.
 
I have for years used the Preamble to The Constitution as my basic guide to the tasks the Feds are to engage in. I have no issue whatsoever with the common defense and recognize that troop and supply movement within the nation meet such criteria. The old US Highway System was insufficient for modern needs. The new system has reached that point as well, 60 years after its proposal.

That commerce was also used to sell the highway system, as well as promote tourism and the automobile industry also meets my Hamiltonian outlook. We also saw tv shows such as Route 66. That show also featured a Chevrolet. Automobiles were among the initial purveyors of product placement in shows, happily tossing a few vehicles a show's way for that little mention in the credits on top of the visual of the vehicle, right there in front of millions of eyes.

So would have an updated, improved and expanded rail system. Funny how I sound like the progressive here and you sound like a corporatist. Hhhhmmmmm...
 
So would have an updated, improved and expanded rail system. Funny how I sound like the progressive here and you sound like a corporatist. Hhhhmmmmm...

No..I sound like I always sound. You simply believe I'm a commie, so you've forgotten my actual outlook and beliefs.

I am a proponent of mass public transit, but I realize what the entire scope of that entails. I am also a proponent of a modern, high speed, rail system, like that continent over the Atlantic that you constantly deride as a marxistsocialistcommie disaster has. Even there, in that train filled culture, final stages of distribution of goods requires trucks, lorries and smaller delivery vehicles.

I am also a proponent of an interconnected highway system.
 
No..I sound like I always sound. You simply believe I'm a commie, so you've forgotten my actual outlook and beliefs.

I am a proponent of mass public transit, but I realize what the entire scope of that entails. I am also a proponent of a modern, high speed, rail system, like that continent over the Atlantic that you constantly deride as a marxistsocialistcommie disaster has. Even there, in that train filled culture, final stages of distribution of goods requires trucks, lorries and smaller delivery vehicles.

I am also a proponent of an interconnected highway system.

Yes, I know - you love anything that accrues to bigger (and more intrusive) government (and a smaller, weaker private sector). I was was just messing with you...
 
Back
Top