New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

War Crime?

Zam-Zam

Senator
Someone has some explaining to do:

Why did the US launch an airstrike on a hospital run by Doctors Without Borders in Afghanistan, killing 22 people, including three children?

The Pentagon changed its story today, and the humanitarian group demanded an independent international inquiry.


Doctors Without Borders is calling the incident a war crime, an assertion that rankles some experts and has provoked a spirited discussion on Reddit.

“Under the rules of international humanitarian law, a hospital is a hospital and the people inside are patients — to target a medical facility in this way is a violation of that, whatever the circumstances,” Vickie Hawkins, executive director of the UK branch of Doctors Without Borders, tells The Takeaway. “The statements that have been coming out of the Afghan government in the past 24 hours would lead us to believe that there was some kind of intent behind the attack. We can only presume, on this basis, that that constitutes a war crime.”


Complete text: http://www.pri.org/stories/2015-10-...s-bombing-its-hospital-crime-against-humanity
 
DemocracyNow! has a video and transcript available that provides the testimony of Dr. Bart Janssens, director of operations for Doctors Without Borders:

"DR. BART JANSSENS:
We now know an aerial attack, of which carries very clearly the signature of being—a lot of indication that it’s been carried out by the international coalition forces in Afghanistan.

"What happened is that a plane arrived, and in several ways, they came four or five times over the hospital and every time extremely precisely hit with a series of impacts on the main building of the hospital. This led to the horrible results of what we see. ...

"The hospital is there since four years.

"It’s a large hospital.

"The compound is larger than a football ground. And we have several times communicated, through the GPS coordinates, the exact location of the hospital to all warring parties in Afghanistan.

"So we really don’t understand, and we definitely do not accept denotification of 'collateral damage' as we heard in the beginning, in the first reaction.
http://www.democracynow.org/2015/10/5/war_crime_in_afghanistan_outrage_after
 
Someone has some explaining to do:

Why did the US launch an airstrike on a hospital run by Doctors Without Borders in Afghanistan, killing 22 people, including three children?

The Pentagon changed its story today, and the humanitarian group demanded an independent international inquiry.


Doctors Without Borders is calling the incident a war crime, an assertion that rankles some experts and has provoked a spirited discussion on Reddit.

“Under the rules of international humanitarian law, a hospital is a hospital and the people inside are patients — to target a medical facility in this way is a violation of that, whatever the circumstances,” Vickie Hawkins, executive director of the UK branch of Doctors Without Borders, tells The Takeaway. “The statements that have been coming out of the Afghan government in the past 24 hours would lead us to believe that there was some kind of intent behind the attack. We can only presume, on this basis, that that constitutes a war crime.”


Complete text: http://www.pri.org/stories/2015-10-...s-bombing-its-hospital-crime-against-humanity
Horrifying stuff. There will be an urge to sweep this under the rug, but I hope they don't. While I assume it was negligence rather than deliberate targeting, getting to the bottom of why it happened is critical for preventing future tragedies of this kind... and also critical for maintaining our credibility as defenders of international law.
 
Here's what "Doctors Without Borders" has to say about it:

"Today the U.S. government has admitted that it was their airstrike that hit our hospital in Kunduz and killed 22 patients and MSF staff," the statement read. "Their description of the attack keeps changing -- from collateral damage, to a tragic incident, to now attempting to pass responsibility to the Afghanistan government.

"The reality is the U.S. dropped those bombs. The U.S. hit a huge hospital full of wounded patients and MSF staff. The U.S. military remains responsible for the targets it hits, even though it is part of a coalition," it continued. "There can be no justification for this horrible attack. With such constant discrepancies in the U.S. and Afghan accounts of what happened, the need for a full transparent independent investigation is ever more critical."

White House spokesman Josh Earnest defended the U.S. military on Monday, saying that protecting civilians is a priority.



http://www.cnn.com/2015/10/05/asia/afghanistan-doctors-without-borders-hospital/
 
its only a war crime if the hospital was deliberately targeted after intelligence identified it as a hospital.

otherwise its a tragic error
 
I saw a report that jihadis were using the hospital as a hideout (which wouldn't surprise me one bit). But the rules are the rules and an attack on a hospital, even one used by fighters as a hideout, appears to be against the rules. Someone has some 'splaining to do...
 
I'm sure it will eventually be blamed on the lowest-ranking person that can reasonably be attached to it. It always rolls down hill.
 
Back
Top