Arkady
President
A video has gone viral showing a radical right-wing gun nut threatening to start killing people if Obama implements gun control:
http://www.salon.com/2013/01/11/radical_right_well_start_killing_people_if_obama_enacts_gun_control/
Some comments to the video characterized it as a terrorist threat, and wondered whether he could be jailed for it. I think probably not, at least using a traditionally wide reading of the first amendment. This wasn't a death threat against anyone in particular, and as far as we know he's made no concrete plans towards carrying out the threat.
However, I think it does point to a real double-standard in America. Picture if instead of being a WASPy conservative with a gun fetish, he were an Arab Muslim with a grudge against Israel. Picture if his threat were that he'd start killing people if Obama met with Netanyahu. I think there's a real chance the guy would be "disappeared" to Gitmo and that the right-wing press would regard that as a perfectly appropriate response to someone who was a clear and present danger to our national security.
"Terrorism" should have an even-handed definition, based around its methods, rather than a circumstantial definition based around the identity of those accused. Yet, there's little doubt that in practice we, as a culture, prefer the circumstantial definition. We're incredibly quick to label something terrorist when it's Arab or Muslim, especially when it's concerned with US or Israeli Middle East policy. Even a radical preacher can wind up being summarily executed for terrorism, based on unproven allegations of connections with those who oppose our policies in that part of the world. But we're a lot more reluctant to use the term when we're talking about white people, Christians, and those who advocate violence in support of things that Republicans like.
http://www.salon.com/2013/01/11/radical_right_well_start_killing_people_if_obama_enacts_gun_control/
Some comments to the video characterized it as a terrorist threat, and wondered whether he could be jailed for it. I think probably not, at least using a traditionally wide reading of the first amendment. This wasn't a death threat against anyone in particular, and as far as we know he's made no concrete plans towards carrying out the threat.
However, I think it does point to a real double-standard in America. Picture if instead of being a WASPy conservative with a gun fetish, he were an Arab Muslim with a grudge against Israel. Picture if his threat were that he'd start killing people if Obama met with Netanyahu. I think there's a real chance the guy would be "disappeared" to Gitmo and that the right-wing press would regard that as a perfectly appropriate response to someone who was a clear and present danger to our national security.
"Terrorism" should have an even-handed definition, based around its methods, rather than a circumstantial definition based around the identity of those accused. Yet, there's little doubt that in practice we, as a culture, prefer the circumstantial definition. We're incredibly quick to label something terrorist when it's Arab or Muslim, especially when it's concerned with US or Israeli Middle East policy. Even a radical preacher can wind up being summarily executed for terrorism, based on unproven allegations of connections with those who oppose our policies in that part of the world. But we're a lot more reluctant to use the term when we're talking about white people, Christians, and those who advocate violence in support of things that Republicans like.