New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

"We Don't Stereotype!"

how about globally?
I don't have those stats. However, I wouldn't be surprised if they were similar. Radical Islamic terrorism may be the single most common variety, and the deadliest, but in almost any country you look to, there are other kinds of terrorists active, especially in the third world (where independence movements and tribal wars involve a lot of terrorism). It's also tough to classify some acts of terrorism -- for example, if there's a terrorist attack in Afghanistan directed at the government, that could be Islamic terrorism, if the goal is establishing Shariah or empowering religious leaders, but it could also be tribal, if the goal is trying to undermine the government to bolster the strength of regional warlords, etc.
 
I assume the "terrorist" designation is based around the purpose of the attack. The FBI's website says that for something to be terrorism, it needs not only be illegal and dangerous to human life, but also that it be intended (i) to intimidate or coerce a civilian population; (ii) to influence the policy of a government by intimidation or coercion; or (iii) to affect the conduct of a government by mass destruction, assassination. or kidnapping. So, if you kill a rival drug cartel's leaders, that assassination wouldn't be terrorism, since it probably didn't have any of those listed intents, but if you assassinate a political leader in order to scare other political leaders away from taking certain steps you oppose, that would be terrorism.


I see.......

"..but also that it be intended (i) to intimidate or coerce a civilian population;"

And this intent that is referred to here, that is established how exactly?

As you may suspect i ask because I am, well..........suffice it to say, a tad bit cynical when I read or here about ANYTHING involving differing crime and punishment based upon something as subjective as "intent". You know how I feel about the way we as a society just dearly LOVE to view the exact same crimes in differing manners depending upon nothing more than the different "civilian population" who are involved.

This, to me, is no different.

The percentage of terrorism involving muslims will naturally be low when any crimes against blacks, women, hispanics, muslims, gays/bi-sexuals, and any other number of PC protected sub-sets of our society could be deemed to be "terrorism" based on someones feelings of the "intent" at the time.
 
I see.......

"..but also that it be intended (i) to intimidate or coerce a civilian population;"

And this intent that is referred to here, that is established how exactly?

As you may suspect i ask because I am, well..........suffice it to say, a tad bit cynical when I read or here about ANYTHING involving differing crime and punishment based upon something as subjective as "intent". You know how I feel about the way we as a society just dearly LOVE to view the exact same crimes in differing manners depending upon nothing more than the different "civilian population" who are involved.

This, to me, is no different.

The percentage of terrorism involving muslims will naturally be low when any crimes against blacks, women, hispanics, muslims, gays/bi-sexuals, and any other number of PC protected sub-sets of our society could be deemed to be "terrorism" based on someones feelings of the "intent" at the time.
One way to think about different punishments for crimes that have different intents is in terms of the indirect victims. Here's an example I've used before:

(1) You've got a dispute with your neighbor about his dog crapping on your lawn. You finally get fed up, gather up the poop, pile it in his front yard, and light it on fire.

(2) You despise black people and want to keep them from moving into your neighbor. So, when a black couple moves next door, you erect a cross in their yard and set it on fire, hoping to scare them into moving away, or at least to scare other black families from moving into the neighborhood.

On the face of it, those are similar crimes: minor trespassing and some relatively physically harmless arson. Yet, I think, most people would see why the second scenario would be a lot more harmful to the society. The first scenario might scare your neighbor, but probably not a whole bunch, and probably won't worry anyone whose dog hasn't been crapping on your lawn. The second scenario, on the other hand, carries with it the implications of an ugly history of burning crosses being the precursors to racially motivated murders, and it's likely to terrify both your neighbor and other blacks in the area. One can argue that the greater social harm, based on the intent, gives society a stronger incentive to prevent such behavior, and thus justifies more severe punishment.

Granted, in a lot of cases, intent will be subjective. But in others, such as where the crime contains a clear implicit message (like a burning cross), or where it's accompanied by a message (e.g., terrorists taking credit and explaining their demands), that won't be as much an issue.
 
I don't have those stats. However, I wouldn't be surprised if they were similar. Radical Islamic terrorism may be the single most common variety, and the deadliest, but in almost any country you look to, there are other kinds of terrorists active, especially in the third world (where independence movements and tribal wars involve a lot of terrorism). It's also tough to classify some acts of terrorism -- for example, if there's a terrorist attack in Afghanistan directed at the government, that could be Islamic terrorism, if the goal is establishing Shariah or empowering religious leaders, but it could also be tribal, if the goal is trying to undermine the government to bolster the strength of regional warlords, etc.


i bet their not simular at all,,not even close...

but then,,,you know that...
 
Yes...when an agency is tasked with something, it should proceed on that task.

The task was to make sure the (c)(4) designations were being used properly. As they were supposed to be non political, political terminology in the names of the agencies was a RED flag...

The were not supposed to be "non-political" in terms of having nothing to do with politics. They were not supposed to fund raise for candidates. But, educating the public on various social issues -such as against the ACA and other "political" issues - was not, is not and never was a violation of being 501C4.

The left likes to act like they were not supposed to have anything to do with politics at all. Which is a complete misstatement of the truth.
 
I don't have those stats. However, I wouldn't be surprised if they were similar. Radical Islamic terrorism may be the single most common variety, and the deadliest, but in almost any country you look to, there are other kinds of terrorists active, especially in the third world (where independence movements and tribal wars involve a lot of terrorism). It's also tough to classify some acts of terrorism -- for example, if there's a terrorist attack in Afghanistan directed at the government, that could be Islamic terrorism, if the goal is establishing Shariah or empowering religious leaders, but it could also be tribal, if the goal is trying to undermine the government to bolster the strength of regional warlords, etc.




MUSLIM WARS AROUND THE WORLD

WARS IN THE WORLD.COM (UPDATED 1/8/2015)
ASIA:Afghanistan (war against islamist militants),Burma-Myanmar (war against rebel groups),Pakistan (war against islamist militants),Philippines (war against islamist militants)Bangladesh (al-Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent)India (war against Islamic separatists)China (East Turkestan Islamist Movement)Kazakhstan (Kazakh Mujahedeen)Kyrgyzstan (Hizb ut-Tahrir – islamist group)Tajikistan (Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan)AFRICA:Libya (war against islamist militants),Mali (war against tuareg and islamist militants),Nigeria (war against islamist militants),Somalia (war against islamist militants)Algeria (al-qaida)Cameroon (Boko Haram)Nigeria (Boko Haram)Uganda (Al-Shabbab)EUROPE:Chechnya (war against islamist militants),Dagestan (war against islamist militants)Russia (Caucuses islamists)MIDDLE EAST:Iraq (war against Islamic State islamist militants),Israel (war against islamist militants in Gaza Strip),Syria (civil war),Yemen (war against and between islamist militants)http://www.michaelsavage.wnd.com/201...und-the-world/
 
MUSLIM WARS AROUND THE WORLD

WARS IN THE WORLD.COM (UPDATED 1/8/2015)
ASIA:Afghanistan (war against islamist militants),Burma-Myanmar (war against rebel groups),Pakistan (war against islamist militants),Philippines (war against islamist militants)Bangladesh (al-Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent)India (war against Islamic separatists)China (East Turkestan Islamist Movement)Kazakhstan (Kazakh Mujahedeen)Kyrgyzstan (Hizb ut-Tahrir – islamist group)Tajikistan (Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan)AFRICA:Libya (war against islamist militants),Mali (war against tuareg and islamist militants),Nigeria (war against islamist militants),Somalia (war against islamist militants)Algeria (al-qaida)Cameroon (Boko Haram)Nigeria (Boko Haram)Uganda (Al-Shabbab)EUROPE:Chechnya (war against islamist militants),Dagestan (war against islamist militants)Russia (Caucuses islamists)MIDDLE EAST:Iraq (war against Islamic State islamist militants),Israel (war against islamist militants in Gaza Strip),Syria (civil war),Yemen (war against and between islamist militants)http://www.michaelsavage.wnd.com/201...und-the-world/
The topic was terrorism, not war, wasn't it?
 
The topic was terrorism, not war, wasn't it?

Terrorism WAS the topic, yes.

And these "wars" you wish to ignore, by chance did you note against whom each was being waged? Look carefully, the information is there for all to see.

All who actually care to see I mean......

"ASIA:
Afghanistan (war against islamist militants),
Burma-Myanmar (war against rebel groups),
Pakistan (war against islamist militants),
Philippines (war against islamist militants)
Bangladesh (al-Qaeda)
India (war against Islamic separatists)
China (East Turkestan Islamist Movement)
Kazakhstan (Kazakh Mujahedeen)
Kyrgyzstan (Hizb ut-Tahrir – islamist group)
Tajikistan (Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan)

AFRICA:

Libya (war against islamist militants),
Mali (war against tuareg and islamist militants),
Nigeria (war against islamist militants),
Somalia (war against islamist militants)
Algeria (al-qaida)
Cameroon (Boko Haram)
Nigeria (Boko Haram)
Uganda (Al-Shabbab)

EUROPE:

Chechnya (war against islamist militants),
Dagestan (war against islamist militants)
Russia (Caucuses islamists)

MIDDLE EAST:

Iraq (war against Islamic State islamist militants),
Israel (war against islamist militants),
Syria (civil war),
Yemen (war against and between islamist militants)


Note that NONE of these "wars" are being waged against other countries as a war is traditionally thought of................... Why do you believe that might be?

ALL of these "wars" are against a common enemy and it ain't a country, is it now? If theses wars are ALL being fought against "militants" is that not terrorist?

Look, I know that as a dem/lib you are not permitted to allow anyone to speak of your precious PC protected radical islamic muslims in anything but a glowing manner but this is one fight you should just let go............
 
I don't have those stats. However, I wouldn't be surprised if they were similar. Radical Islamic terrorism may be the single most common variety, and the deadliest, but in almost any country you look to, there are other kinds of terrorists active, especially in the third world (where independence movements and tribal wars involve a lot of terrorism). It's also tough to classify some acts of terrorism -- for example, if there's a terrorist attack in Afghanistan directed at the government, that could be Islamic terrorism, if the goal is establishing Shariah or empowering religious leaders, but it could also be tribal, if the goal is trying to undermine the government to bolster the strength of regional warlords, etc.

I think you're missing the bigger picture here.

Just like Airplane deaths get way more press than everyday car deaths, Radical Islam's terror attacks will certainly be put in the forefront because it's not some local issue, it's an attack on all of Western Civilization, core values that we believe should be given to all human beings.

Thus, it's such a larger issue.
 
Are terrorist organizations incapable declaring their own wars?

Is the Extremist Islamic state a country?
I'm not seeing the relevance of those questions. We were discussing terrorism. I admit it's possible that most international terrorism is Islamist, but I haven't seen evidence for that, yet. Citing some wars is not only anecdotal, but off-topic.
 
terrorism is war..
No. Terrorism isn't war and war isn't terrorism. There are overlaps between the two, obviously, but it's possible to come up with instances of war that don't rely on terrorist tactics, and also instances of terrorist tactics that aren't a part of war.
 
No. Terrorism isn't war and war isn't terrorism. There are overlaps between the two, obviously, but it's possible to come up with instances of war that don't rely on terrorist tactics, and also instances of terrorist tactics that aren't a part of war.

semanatics..
 
I'm not seeing the relevance of those questions. We were discussing terrorism. I admit it's possible that most international terrorism is Islamist, but I haven't seen evidence for that, yet. Citing some wars is not only anecdotal, but off-topic.

You're using the term "war" incorrectly, historically.

Wars are started by established governments. This Radical Islamic State has no recognized government. They might have a cause, but until they are an established nation, they can't start a "war" as we know it.

Thus, they are a terrorist organization, committing acts of terror.

And you, with your claims of questioning, would, by definition, be required to address them.

Only dishonesty or lack of intellect would prevent you from doing so.
 
You're using the term "war" incorrectly, historically.

Wars are started by established governments. This Radical Islamic State has no recognized government. They might have a cause, but until they are an established nation, they can't start a "war" as we know it.

Thus, they are a terrorist organization, committing acts of terror.

And you, with your claims of questioning, would, by definition, be required to address them.

Only dishonesty or lack of intellect would prevent you from doing so.


guess he never heard of.....

the war on terror...
 
You're using the term "war" incorrectly, historically.

Wars are started by established governments. This Radical Islamic State has no recognized government. They might have a cause, but until they are an established nation, they can't start a "war" as we know it.

Thus, they are a terrorist organization, committing acts of terror.

And you, with your claims of questioning, would, by definition, be required to address them.

Only dishonesty or lack of intellect would prevent you from doing so.
Just to be sure I understand properly, would you likewise characterize the Minutemen at Lexington and Concord as terrorists? Those who died at the Alamo? By whom does a movement's leadership need to be recognized as a government for it to be an "established nation."
 
guess he never heard of.....

the war on terror...
If the existence of the term "war on terror" makes terrorism and war identical, then does the existence of the terms "war on drugs" and "war on poverty" make drugs, poverty, and war identical, as well?
 
If the existence of the term "war on terror" makes terrorism and war identical, then does the existence of the terms "war on drugs" and "war on poverty" make drugs, poverty, and war identical, as well?


That is RICH.........

" does the existence of the terms "war on drugs" and "war on poverty" make drugs, poverty, and war identical, as well?"

THAT IS a point that COULD be made, sport.

You dems/l ibs DO oppose any "war" on any of them after all.
 
Back
Top