New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Wealth over work

I think good policy is based on what will encourage the most people to accumulate what they can and take the strain off of public resources. It being "right" or moral - has nothing to do with it.

But your position is the one considered right and moral by many. Especially in the past. The past that built this present but which has an endangered future.
 
How is that?

You PRODUCE $1M in value and SAVE $100k, your wealth is $100k.

If you MULTIPLY times 12 months, you have created $1.2M in wealth through production x savings.
I'm using your formula exactly. You said:

PRODUCTION X SAVINGS = WEALTH

If you're now saying that
PRODUCTION X SAVINGS ≠WEALTH, that's good, but then you should remember not to provide that false formula again, as the error was pointed out to you previously but you offered it up again.
 
That is why everybody should pay a flat 15% Federal income tax. It is the fairest way to get around loop holes for big business and make sure all voters have skin in the game. It is unjust to hold 49% hostage and liable for the 47% of filers who don't pay into the system.
A 15% flat federal income tax, if it's meant to replace all household taxes (i.e., payroll as well as income), would create a massive revenue shortfall, since effective rates have been well over that (ranging between 17.4% and 22.7%, in recent years), so you'd be creating a big increase in the deficit. At the same time, you'd be hammering 80% of Americans with a giant tax hike:

http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/displayafact.cfm?Docid=456

If on the other hand, you mean to replace only the income tax with the 15% flat tax, while preserving payroll taxes, you wouldn't have the deficit problem, but you'd be subjecting just about everyone to a big tax hike.
 
Has it ever occurred to you that the more corps pay in taxes, the less that corp is going to have for wage increases, capital equipment, new employees, not to mention HIGHER PRICES for the consumer?
Look at wages and then at profits that go to the Stockholders and tell me who is getting the increases in profits! And many of the most profitable corporations, i.e. oil companies pay litte of nothing in taxes and even get money from the government.
 
I've always been on the side of the working man on this issue.

Investment money shouldn't trump money truly earned through actual work.

Yet, there's always suggestions of lowering the capital gains tax...

That's why there's such an income gap... the only people who can benefit from this setup are those who HAVE money already.
 
I'm using your formula exactly. You said:

PRODUCTION X SAVINGS = WEALTH

If you're now saying that
PRODUCTION X SAVINGS ≠WEALTH, that's good, but then you should remember not to provide that false formula again, as the error was pointed out to you previously but you offered it up again.

Maybe you should look up the definition of savings or does everybody produce and save for only one month in your socialist utopia?

PRODUCTION X SAVINGS = WEALTH.

Unless you have a better formula, I'm sticking with what is proven to work.
 
Last edited:
I do certainly feel more drawn to wealth building when the relative tax rates are low.
I honestly can't imagine why. But, given the decline in the average rate of wealth accumulation after Reagan cut taxes, compared to the prior high-tax era, and the way the average rate of wealth accumulation rose in the Clinton era after he hiked taxes, and then fell in the Bush era after tax cuts, I think the historical record supports the idea more people are of my mind about it. Increases in real GDP per capita were markedly lower in the Reagan/Bush era than in the run from FDR through Carter, and were markedly lower in the GW Bush era than they'd been under Clinton.

Even among middle class people the discouragements to wealth build are built into the system - for instance, you will likely qualify for less student aid for your kids if you are sitting on some net worth.
My experience has been very different. Yes, it's true, that by moving up the income ladder I've moved out of most benefits given to poorer people. The first one I hit was when I earned too much to write off interest on my student loans (it never made sense to me, by the way, that I couldn't write off interest on my student loans, but ultra-rich people could write off the interest on the mortgages on their yachts, by calling those second homes!). But the way the income structure starts to go vertical the higher you go makes up for that by an enormous margin. Yes, I now fail to qualify for nearly every tax benefit and government program that has an income test. But I also earn as much as six ordinary families, so I'm not going to complain about it. When you're lower on the income ladder, you scrape for every tiny gain in income. Do enough to move past a full 10% of the population in earnings, and it's still only a chump-change improvement. But if you get up to, say, the 88th percentile, and then do enough to move past a full 10% of the population, the increase in wealth is gigantic.

As for student aid, I fully expect to get none. I won a few merit-based scholarships, myself, when I went to school, but the only needs-based aid I got were subsidized loans, and my parents were far from rich. So, I assume my daughter won't get a penny of needs-based help. And that encourages me to save and invest more than I otherwise would.

As far as the working class attitude - you are essentially saying that what you support as economic policy has something to do with your own personal biases.
My personal biases would be in favor of Republican-style tax cuts for the rich, which benefit people like me. I'm at around the 97th percentile of all earners, and even with the Republicans being less interested in serving me than they would be if I didn't pollute my income with actual labor, they still serve my personal interests. But I favor policies that I think will be good for the vast majority of Americans, based on evidence that such policies have been good, historically, in this country, and produce good results in other leading countries.
 
Maybe you should look up the definition of savings or does everybody produce and save for only one month in your socialist utopia?
I'm not sure what you're trying to say. I'm merely using your formula and showing what the result would be if it were correct. If wealth equaled savings times production, then a thousand dollars of savings and a thousand dollars of production would be a million dollars of wealth. Don't blame me if you don't like the mathematical result of the formula YOU provided. Get a better formula.
 
Maybe you should look up the definition of savings or does everybody produce and save for only one month in your socialist utopia?

Month, year...whatever...It's the equation that is wacky.

Production times savings equals wealth.

There isn't a time frame in the equation. If the figures are for a year or a lifetime...produce $1,000 and save $1,000 over a year...the product of the equation remains the same.

1,000 times 1,000 equals 1,000,000.
 
Look at wages and then at profits that go to the Stockholders and tell me who is getting the increases in profits! And many of the most profitable corporations, i.e. oil companies pay litte of nothing in taxes and even get money from the government.

Your right.. Big global corporations like Google/Facebook/GE pay no taxes because of their political connections. However, raising taxes is not going to increase wages as has been proven the last 5 years.
 
Month, year...whatever...It's the equation that is wacky.

Production times savings equals wealth.

There isn't a time frame in the equation. If the figures are for a year or a lifetime...produce $1,000 and save $1,000 over a year...the product of the equation remains the same.

1,000 times 1,000 equals 1,000,000.

Saving is over time, you produce over time and Wealth is the sum.

But, I wasnt expecting hyper Marxist to grasp the concept of wealth creation anyways.
 
Saving is over time, you produce over time and Wealth is the sum.

But, I wasnt expecting hyper Marxist to grasp the concept of wealth creation anyways.

The equation remains the same no matter the time...

1,000 times 1,000 is 1,000,000...That's YOUR equation and the example given. Time doesn't appear...and like I said...whether it's a month, a year or a lifetime the result is the same.

Change the figures however you like. Let's say I produce $10,000 in a year and save $50.

10,000 (p) x 50(s) = 50,000(w)

The equation is goofy.
 
The equation remains the same no matter the time...

1,000 times 1,000 is 1,000,000...That's YOUR equation and the example given. Time doesn't appear...and like I said...whether it's a month, a year or a lifetime the result is the same.

Change the figures however you like. Let's say I produce $10,000 in a year and save $50.

10,000 (p) x 50(s) = 50,000(w)

The equation is goofy.

Look up the definition of savings.

But go ahead and tell me the Marxist formula for wealth creation. I bet it will 1000 pages long and make perfect sense to a PhD and a Nobel laureate.
 
Saving is over time, you produce over time and Wealth is the sum.

But, I wasnt expecting hyper Marxist to grasp the concept of wealth creation anyways.
Put time in the equation and it's still wrong. If production*savings*time=wealth, it's still nonsense. Production doesn't belong in your equation. What you're really trying to say is that savings times time equals wealth. If I save $1000 per month for twelve months, I've increased my wealth by $12,000. That's true regardless of whether I produced something or not.
 
Look up the definition of savings.

But go ahead and tell me the Marxist formula for wealth creation. I bet it will 1000 pages long and make perfect sense to a PhD and a Nobel laureate.


Income not spent...Savings.

All I know is your equation makes no sense. And...you make no attempt to explain it.
 
Income not spent...Savings.

All I know is your equation makes no sense. And...you make no attempt to explain it.

Ok.. assuming one produces/saves for ONE WEEK , wealth was still created.

Even if only $2 was produced and a dollar was saved...Wealth was still created. So fundamentaly transform that bitchez.
 
Put time in the equation and it's still wrong. If production*savings*time=wealth, it's still nonsense. Production doesn't belong in your equation. What you're really trying to say is that savings times time equals wealth. If I save $1000 per month for twelve months, I've increased my wealth by $12,000. That's true regardless of whether I produced something or not.

While it is possible to inherit/win wealth, the money still came from someone else's production/savings.

I work at a factory making $20 hr ($800 wk). Would I have better chance of increasing my wealth by working overtime (producing more goods), or waiting for a family member to die or win the lottery?
 
I honestly can't imagine why. But, given the decline in the average rate of wealth accumulation after Reagan cut taxes, compared to the prior high-tax era, and the way the average rate of wealth accumulation rose in the Clinton era after he hiked taxes, and then fell in the Bush era after tax cuts, I think the historical record supports the idea more people are of my mind about it. Increases in real GDP per capita were markedly lower in the Reagan/Bush era than in the run from FDR through Carter, and were markedly lower in the GW Bush era than they'd been under Clinton.


My experience has been very different. Yes, it's true, that by moving up the income ladder I've moved out of most benefits given to poorer people. The first one I hit was when I earned too much to write off interest on my student loans (it never made sense to me, by the way, that I couldn't write off interest on my student loans, but ultra-rich people could write off the interest on the mortgages on their yachts, by calling those second homes!). But the way the income structure starts to go vertical the higher you go makes up for that by an enormous margin. Yes, I now fail to qualify for nearly every tax benefit and government program that has an income test. But I also earn as much as six ordinary families, so I'm not going to complain about it. When you're lower on the income ladder, you scrape for every tiny gain in income. Do enough to move past a full 10% of the population in earnings, and it's still only a chump-change improvement. But if you get up to, say, the 88th percentile, and then do enough to move past a full 10% of the population, the increase in wealth is gigantic.

As for student aid, I fully expect to get none. I won a few merit-based scholarships, myself, when I went to school, but the only needs-based aid I got were subsidized loans, and my parents were far from rich. So, I assume my daughter won't get a penny of needs-based help. And that encourages me to save and invest more than I otherwise would.


My personal biases would be in favor of Republican-style tax cuts for the rich, which benefit people like me. I'm at around the 97th percentile of all earners, and even with the Republicans being less interested in serving me than they would be if I didn't pollute my income with actual labor, they still serve my personal interests. But I favor policies that I think will be good for the vast majority of Americans, based on evidence that such policies have been good, historically, in this country, and produce good results in other leading countries.


Your personal bias was that you don't think its "right' that people who work - get taxed more than those who have their money work for them. That is a bias.

As far as the wealth building you are still viewing what I am saying through the lense of a working class person. I do not really have the time go to into detail of the complete opposite spectrum of ideas. But, really - read Rich Dad/Poor Dad. Honestly, because your theories of human behavior are only correct, when you view them through the prism of someone who sees themseleves as part of the working class and or a cog in the wheel of society.

To really understand how people use and leverage tax rates to actually build wealth - you have got to begin to think of building wealth outside of being comfortable and having a little bit of savings. That is not building wealth - that is saving. Entirely different concept.

Republican tax structures are designed to benefit the Entrepreneur and the wealth builder. They do so, often at the detriment to the cog in the wheel. Which is why they do not benefit high wage earners like ourselves, because for all our high salary - we are still just cogs, part of the rat race.... nothing more than a worker bee who is highly compensated. And, we bear the brunt of both the Republican and Democrat tax structures, because we are highly compensated - thus "rich" to democrats, but we are still just a working stiff - to the Republicans.

There was a point in our society where the majority of people were intersted in building wealth. But, now I think the majority are interested in having a good job until retirement and a little pink house with a white picket fence. They think that is wealth - or that it means they have arrived - but in reality - they have traded their opportunity to build real wealth by taking the safe and easy route. THAT is why Republicans favor investing and why they think those who make money by investing should pay less taxes - to encourage others to take that risky route - thus providing them with the best opportunity to really really build wealth.

If you think building wealth means going to work and saving some money you are sadly mistaken. But, if that is the attitude of those who decry we lack income mobility - it is obvious why . You will not have any income mobility as long as you insist on taking the safe and easy route.

connie
 
Your personal bias was that you don't think its "right' that people who work - get taxed more than those who have their money work for them. That is a bias.

As far as the wealth building you are still viewing what I am saying through the lense of a working class person. I do not really have the time go to into detail of the complete opposite spectrum of ideas. But, really - read Rich Dad/Poor Dad. Honestly, because your theories of human behavior are only correct, when you view them through the prism of someone who sees themseleves as part of the working class and or a cog in the wheel of society.

To really understand how people use and leverage tax rates to actually build wealth - you have got to begin to think of building wealth outside of being comfortable and having a little bit of savings. That is not building wealth - that is saving. Entirely different concept.

Republican tax structures are designed to benefit the Entrepreneur and the wealth builder. They do so, often at the detriment to the cog in the wheel. Which is why they do not benefit high wage earners like ourselves, because for all our high salary - we are still just cogs, part of the rat race.... nothing more than a worker bee who is highly compensated. And, we bear the brunt of both the Republican and Democrat tax structures, because we are highly compensated - thus "rich" to democrats, but we are still just a working stiff - to the Republicans.

There was a point in our society where the majority of people were intersted in building wealth. But, now I think the majority are interested in having a good job until retirement and a little pink house with a white picket fence. They think that is wealth - or that it means they have arrived - but in reality - they have traded their opportunity to build real wealth by taking the safe and easy route. THAT is why Republicans favor investing and why they think those who make money by investing should pay less taxes - to encourage others to take that risky route - thus providing them with the best opportunity to really really build wealth.

If you think building wealth means going to work and saving some money you are sadly mistaken. But, if that is the attitude of those who decry we lack income mobility - it is obvious why . You will not have any income mobility as long as you insist on taking the safe and easy route.

connie
I don't think you know what the word bias means. I also think you are deeply confused as to what it means to build wealth. Productive labor builds wealth -- it doesn't necessarily accumulate wealth. You're focusing on the accumulation of title to wealth, regardless of how it was actually created, whereas I'm focusing on what actually creates the value, regardless of who happens to take title to it. The distinction may be clearer to you if you think in terms of a more obviously unjust system, like a feudal aristocracy where those who get title to the wealth are often nothing but leeches on the value actually created by the efforts of others. You treat as virtuous the rent-seeking race to accumulate title to wealth, where I have far greater respect for activities that actually generate wealth, which are nearly always a matter of labor: teaching, building, inventing, etc., rather than simply using title to property to acquire title to more property.

I also laugh heartily at the Republic talk of "risk taking." Risk isn't investing some of your money in hopes you can sit on your ass and live off the returns. Risk is going out to sea as a commercial fisherman, or manning the convenience store counter in a rough neighborhood, or driving a taxi, or going into a burning building to save lives, or going down in a mine shaft to pull value from the earth. There are lots of people in our society who take real risks that create real value for the society, but they nearly all work for salaries or wages, rather than living off investment gains. And it's morally wrong, economically inefficient, and socially risky to treat their real contributions as worthy of less favorable tax treatment that those of people whose idea of "risk" is placing a phone call to buy some stuff.

As for your idea that there was a time when most in our culture was interested in building wealth: when, exactly, are you thinking of?
 
Back
Top