New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

well regulated

The definitions of well, regulated, and militia have not changed. What do you believe each word means? If 'the people' were the militia, in what way are they well regulated?

There is a lot going on in that excerpt of Federalist 29 but it is very informative so let's parse it down into digestible, more easily discussed / understood parts.

The primary theme for Hamilton is that any future regulation of the militia would be problematic.

"The project of disciplining all the militia of the United States is as futile as it would be injurious, if it were capable of being carried into execution."​

"All the militia" is discussing 25% of the population then, somewhere between 500,000 and 600,000 men.

"A tolerable expertness in military movements is a business that requires time and practice. It is not a day, or even a week, that will suffice for the attainment of it."​

Here is the first contextual definition of "well regulated" as used to describe militia. Being "well regulated" is the attainment of a high degree of military order and discipline. Of course that can not be obtained with part-time drill.

"To oblige the great body of the yeomanry, and of the other classes of the citizens, to be under arms for the purpose of going through military exercises and evolutions, as often as might be necessary to acquire the degree of perfection which would entitle them to the character of a well-regulated militia, would be a real grievance to the people, and a serious public inconvenience and loss."​

Here is a treasure trove of info . . . The yeomanry were the landholders, presumably farmers, who would be taken from their essential work for training. He also recognizes such training could only be achieved through an objectionable mandate "To oblige the great body" from government. The adding of, "and of the other classes of citizens" is a direct refutation and condemnation of the exclusions outlined in English common law and bill of rights that the Colonists held in contempt. That general inclusion, of every class of citizen, told the people that no exclusions or qualifications attached to a citizen's status (religion, landholding, title) were to be enacted or inferred by the proposed constitution.

It is also clear that well regulated, as used to describe the militia, does not mean controlled by any legislative body. Well regulated is merely an accolade; it describes a quality; "the character of" the unit and the men. That description is earned. It is earned only after demonstrating military readiness and order ("acquire the degree of perfection"). It is a description that is bestowed ("entitle them to"), not an formal, rigid condition that can be ordered to exist or legislated into being from Washington.

Hamilton then begins expounding on the costs and inconvenience that would be incurred in requiring all the people capable of bearing arms to achieve this characteristic.

Disagreeing analysis is more than welcome.

More to come . . .
 
"Definitions" are in a dictionary.
You want to know a definition, that's easy to look up.

You want to understand case law and Supreme Court decisions that have been handed down. This is best explained the way interested people have done it for decades- read it.

The interpretations of the 2nd amendment are found in certain cases. Look them up and you'll see that "militia" does not refer to state-run groups, but is interpreted as "the people".

Look into it.
Who defines militia as 'the people'? What is 'people'? Everyone? No, it isn't everyone, clearly, as there are those who are disallowed the privilege of owing guns. What case law are you referring to specifically?
 
There is no "conservative Supreme Court".

What I think the definition of those words are?

In a nutshell, if a thing is an enumerated right - be careful as heck to touch any aspect of it. If a thing is not an enumerated right, caution is still prudent...but the standard for interference or regulation is considerably lower.

I have a concealed carry permit and I live in Oregon. I've done the coursework and have obtained concealed carry for the states of Oregon, Arizona, and Utah - because, for whatever reason, that particular combination of states offers interstate reciprocity that allows me to carry in a majority of the states.

Guess what I've done with that?

Nothing.

And it's not just because my preferred handgun is S&W 686+ (pretty big to conceal/carry).

It's because I don't feel the need to carry. It's a right. I have that ability "in my pocket". I'm a big guy, comparatively athletic, and - frankly - I think I could rush/disarm many (if needed). I'm not a fearful person.

So, where does all of this leave us? Heck if I know. I'm no gun "extremist". Guns don't scare me. Fellow citizens having gun rights doesn't scare me. Neither terrorist nutcases nor thug criminals scare me.

A nation of sheep which are readily stampeded into surrendering their rights under the thumb of an increasingly controlling authoritarian government? Well, that doesn't "scare me", but it's a point of concern.

Our citizens are increasingly idiotic (in my humble opinion). :)
The enumerated right starts with 'a well regulated militia.' It is the 'well' and 'regulated' and 'militia' that I am referring to.
 
The Court has been boringly consistent for 140 years.

The right to keep and bear arms is not granted, given, created or otherwise established by the 2nd Amendment thus it is not in any manner dependent on the words of the Constitution for its existence.

That means the words of the 2nd can not be legitimately read to modify / condition / qualify / restrict the right.
Or, then, allow the right to bear arms?
 
Federalist 29 explains it:

"The project of disciplining all the militia of the United States is as futile as it would be injurious, if it were capable of being carried into execution. A tolerable expertness in military movements is a business that requires time and practice. It is not a day, or even a week, that will suffice for the attainment of it. To oblige the great body of the yeomanry, and of the other classes of the citizens, to be under arms for the purpose of going through military exercises and evolutions, as often as might be necessary to acquire the degree of perfection which would entitle them to the character of a well-regulated militia, would be a real grievance to the people, and a serious public inconvenience and loss. It would form an annual deduction from the productive labor of the country, to an amount which, calculating upon the present numbers of the people, would not fall far short of the whole expense of the civil establishments of all the States. To attempt a thing which would abridge the mass of labor and industry to so considerable an extent, would be unwise: and the experiment, if made, could not succeed, because it would not long be endured. Little more can reasonably be aimed at, with respect to the people at large, than to have them properly armed and equipped; and in order to see that this be not neglected, it will be necessary to assemble them once or twice in the course of a year."​
Is that codified in the Constitution?
 
There is a lot going on in that excerpt of Federalist 29 but it is very informative so let's parse it down into digestible, more easily discussed / understood parts.

The primary theme for Hamilton is that any future regulation of the militia would be problematic.

"The project of disciplining all the militia of the United States is as futile as it would be injurious, if it were capable of being carried into execution."​

"All the militia" is discussing 25% of the population then, somewhere between 500,000 and 600,000 men.

"A tolerable expertness in military movements is a business that requires time and practice. It is not a day, or even a week, that will suffice for the attainment of it."​

Here is the first contextual definition of "well regulated" as used to describe militia. Being "well regulated" is the attainment of a high degree of military order and discipline. Of course that can not be obtained with part-time drill.

"To oblige the great body of the yeomanry, and of the other classes of the citizens, to be under arms for the purpose of going through military exercises and evolutions, as often as might be necessary to acquire the degree of perfection which would entitle them to the character of a well-regulated militia, would be a real grievance to the people, and a serious public inconvenience and loss."​

Here is a treasure trove of info . . . The yeomanry were the landholders, presumably farmers, who would be taken from their essential work for training. He also recognizes such training could only be achieved through an objectionable mandate "To oblige the great body" from government. The adding of, "and of the other classes of citizens" is a direct refutation and condemnation of the exclusions outlined in English common law and bill of rights that the Colonists held in contempt. That general inclusion, of every class of citizen, told the people that no exclusions or qualifications attached to a citizen's status (religion, landholding, title) were to be enacted or inferred by the proposed constitution.

It is also clear that well regulated, as used to describe the militia, does not mean controlled by any legislative body. Well regulated is merely an accolade; it describes a quality; "the character of" the unit and the men. That description is earned. It is earned only after demonstrating military readiness and order ("acquire the degree of perfection"). It is a description that is bestowed ("entitle them to"), not an formal, rigid condition that can be ordered to exist or legislated into being from Washington.

Hamilton then begins expounding on the costs and inconvenience that would be incurred in requiring all the people capable of bearing arms to achieve this characteristic.

Disagreeing analysis is more than welcome.

More to come . . .
Yes, without a standing army, it would be difficult for the tradesman or farmers to maintain the appropriate level of training. We no longer live in the 18th century. We have a very well trained Army, as well as National Guard and the other services standing at the ready for National defense, being 'necessary to the security of a free state.'
 
Or, then, allow the right to bear arms?

????

The government (or the 2nd Amendment) doesn't "allow" the citizens to possess or exercise the right. The right is possessed because "We the People" never conferred to government any power to allow it to dictate to the citizen or to have any interest whatsoever in the personal arms of the private citizen.
 
Is that codified in the Constitution?

It explained what the powers of the federal government would be to a concerned population. In the case of #29, the powers over the militia.

Well regulated does not infer or confer any powers, it is not a requirement nor a qualification. It is an ideal to strive for.

In other words, a thousand volumes of regulations could not ever make the militia "well regulated". While regulations issued by Congress could establish the organizational structure and regimen for training, only the action of those enrolled and their expertness in military affairs allows the awarding of the characterization of "well regulated".
 
Yes, without a standing army, it would be difficult for the tradesman or farmers to maintain the appropriate level of training. We no longer live in the 18th century. We have a very well trained Army, as well as National Guard and the other services standing at the ready for National defense, being 'necessary to the security of a free state.'


Are those goal posts heavy?
 
????

The government (or the 2nd Amendment) doesn't "allow" the citizens to possess or exercise the right. The right is possessed because "We the People" never conferred to government any power to allow it to dictate to the citizen or to have any interest whatsoever in the personal arms of the private citizen.
So we the people can.
 
It explained what the powers of the federal government would be to a concerned population. In the case of #29, the powers over the militia.

Well regulated does not infer or confer any powers, it is not a requirement nor a qualification. It is an ideal to strive for.

In other words, a thousand volumes of regulations could not ever make the militia "well regulated". While regulations issued by Congress could establish the organizational structure and regimen for training, only the action of those enrolled and their expertness in military affairs allows the awarding of the characterization of "well regulated".
I disagree. We have replaced militia with standing Army (and Air Force, and National Guard, and Police,and Sheriffs, etc.) and we regulate them.
 
I disagree. We have replaced militia with standing Army (and Air Force, and National Guard, and Police,and Sheriffs, etc.) and we regulate them.

That the greatest fear of the framers has come to pass is not a reason to abrogate the 2nd Amendment, ratified to avoid the circumstance you describe and dilute if not negate the power of a standing army.
 
Article V
You want to recommend an amendment to the constitution for something you claim 'we the people' control and that the government doesn't? What do you think the government is charged with upholding if not the constitution? Do you think they are separate? The 2nd amendment is part of the constitution, including the well regulated militia part. We have that. It's called the military.
 

You asked what do those terms mean as used in the 2nd.

Now you are bringing in all sorts of unrelated objects and announcing them as if they were material to the definitions. The modern circumstance does not alter the words or their meaning or action in law.
 
You want to recommend an amendment to the constitution for something you claim 'we the people' control and that the government doesn't? What do you think the government is charged with upholding if not the constitution? Do you think they are separate? The 2nd amendment is part of the constitution, including the well regulated militia part. We have that. It's called the military.

You really have no idea how any of this works do you?
 
That the greatest fear of the framers has come to pass is not a reason to abrogate the 2nd Amendment, ratified to avoid the circumstance you describe and dilute if not negate the power of a standing army.
You think the 2nd amendment was written to protect us from ourselves???? We are the government, that is what the republic was created to be. As long as we have the opportunity to 'vote the bums out,' that is still intact.
 
You think the 2nd amendment was written to protect us from ourselves???? We are the government, that is what the republic was created to be. As long as we have the opportunity to 'vote the bums out,' that is still intact.

You really have no idea how any of this works do you?
 
You asked what do those terms mean as used in the 2nd.

Now you are bringing in all sorts of unrelated objects and announcing them as if they were material to the definitions. The modern circumstance does not alter the words or their meaning or action in law.
No I didn't, I asked what those terms mean. But of course modern meanings hold sway. We don't live in a time before the standing military existed. We don't need to call up the farmers and tradesmen to protect us from marauders.
 
Back
Top