Arkady
President
The Keynesians have a clear explanation for what is causing the current economic weakness: a shortfall of aggregate demand. That is consistent with their models, and it fits with the observable data, all of which is the opposite of what we'd predict if it was a supply-side problem. Interest rates are low (the opposite of what would happen if we had an excess of demand for capital -- e.g., if government spending were crowding out private sector spending). Unemployment is high and wages are stagnant (the opposite of what would happen if we had a shortage of labor supply). And inflation is low (not what we'd expect if there were high demand for goods and services, which would bid up the prices for them).
Keynesians also have an explanation for why there is a shortfall of demand, though it's harder to explain without graphs and math. It's not hard to grasp the basics, though, once you realize that one person's spending is another person's income. That can become a self-reinforcing negative trend when everyone is trying to fix their balance sheets at the same time (including, in an austerity environment, governments).
Presumably, though, right-wingers, who typically despise Keynesian economics (Bruce Bartlett notwithstanding), must have some other explanation of what's going on here. What is it, for you conservatives, that explains the cluster of symptoms here (low inflation and interest rates, high unemployment, poor income and GDP growth)? I've been able to follow the Keynesian reasoning, which is clear and intellectually consistent, and I've been impressed by how reliable their predictions are. But I quite honestly haven't been able to follow the reasoning of the Austrian and Chicago economic schools, so I was hoping someone here could explain one or both. We need to understand the nature of a problem to address it correctly.
Keynesians also have an explanation for why there is a shortfall of demand, though it's harder to explain without graphs and math. It's not hard to grasp the basics, though, once you realize that one person's spending is another person's income. That can become a self-reinforcing negative trend when everyone is trying to fix their balance sheets at the same time (including, in an austerity environment, governments).
Presumably, though, right-wingers, who typically despise Keynesian economics (Bruce Bartlett notwithstanding), must have some other explanation of what's going on here. What is it, for you conservatives, that explains the cluster of symptoms here (low inflation and interest rates, high unemployment, poor income and GDP growth)? I've been able to follow the Keynesian reasoning, which is clear and intellectually consistent, and I've been impressed by how reliable their predictions are. But I quite honestly haven't been able to follow the reasoning of the Austrian and Chicago economic schools, so I was hoping someone here could explain one or both. We need to understand the nature of a problem to address it correctly.