New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

What's causing the economic weakness?

Arkady

President
The Keynesians have a clear explanation for what is causing the current economic weakness: a shortfall of aggregate demand. That is consistent with their models, and it fits with the observable data, all of which is the opposite of what we'd predict if it was a supply-side problem. Interest rates are low (the opposite of what would happen if we had an excess of demand for capital -- e.g., if government spending were crowding out private sector spending). Unemployment is high and wages are stagnant (the opposite of what would happen if we had a shortage of labor supply). And inflation is low (not what we'd expect if there were high demand for goods and services, which would bid up the prices for them).

Keynesians also have an explanation for why there is a shortfall of demand, though it's harder to explain without graphs and math. It's not hard to grasp the basics, though, once you realize that one person's spending is another person's income. That can become a self-reinforcing negative trend when everyone is trying to fix their balance sheets at the same time (including, in an austerity environment, governments).

Presumably, though, right-wingers, who typically despise Keynesian economics (Bruce Bartlett notwithstanding), must have some other explanation of what's going on here. What is it, for you conservatives, that explains the cluster of symptoms here (low inflation and interest rates, high unemployment, poor income and GDP growth)? I've been able to follow the Keynesian reasoning, which is clear and intellectually consistent, and I've been impressed by how reliable their predictions are. But I quite honestly haven't been able to follow the reasoning of the Austrian and Chicago economic schools, so I was hoping someone here could explain one or both. We need to understand the nature of a problem to address it correctly.
 
Well, for one thing, they will simply dispute the government statistics that show very low inflation. It's all a gigantic conspiracy, don't you know?
 
"No massive tax cut for the rich....ergo, no boom."

Besides that...what else is there to Rightwing "economic thought"???
 
Well, for one thing, they will simply dispute the government statistics that show very low inflation. It's all a gigantic conspiracy, don't you know?

Central govt announced they are changing the way GDP is calculated in the next quarter, giving it a +3% boost. Of course the number will be a fraud, but you will hail it as historic.
 
The real reason why the economy is doing so poorly is because we as a nation are broke.

USGov/FRB are trying to pretend we are not broke by printing money/bubbles, hoping to create a "Wealth Effect", that will trickle down to the middle-class. Problem is... This has been tried a hundred times before spanning several centuries and always failing.

But this time is going to be different because we have a black president and gosh darn it's AmericAA-!
 
what happened? Last week the Demkkkratics were touting the success of the American economy.
 
Central govt announced they are changing the way GDP is calculated in the next quarter, giving it a +3% boost. Of course the number will be a fraud, but you will hail it as historic.

Naturally, there will be (and already has been) a great deal of discussion about the change in methodology for calculating GDP. Most of it, thankfully, has been a lot more sophisticated than your economic reasoning.
 
Naturally, there will be (and already has been) a great deal of discussion about the change in methodology for calculating GDP. Most of it, thankfully, has been a lot more sophisticated than your economic reasoning.

Yes, but at the end of the day the economists who oppose changing the measure regard it as cooking the books.

While I don't claim the "economist" as part of my pedigree, the "demand shortage" that you say Keynesianism explains is caused by a non-theoretical real-world problem. That problem is a lack of jobs. Whether you like it or not, most jobs come from small companies owned by people whose incomes are in the 1 percent. It is unsurprising, given that the biggest backers of Keynesianism are in the Democratic Party, that these "1 percenters" are holding on to their cash -- waiting to do investments for a more favorable political and economic climate. Alternatively, they are taking their money overseas.

All of this contributes to a smaller generation of tax revenues, which in turn means the government has too little money and must use artificial means to create money. Right now our inflation level is not too high, but even Ben Bernanke has said that too much loose money policy could cause the pendulum to swing too far in the opposite direction.
 
Yes, but at the end of the day the economists who oppose changing the measure regard it as cooking the books.

While I don't claim the "economist" as part of my pedigree, the "demand shortage" that you say Keynesianism explains is caused by a non-theoretical real-world problem. That problem is a lack of jobs. Whether you like it or not, most jobs come from small companies owned by people whose incomes are in the 1 percent. It is unsurprising, given that the biggest backers of Keynesianism are in the Democratic Party, that these "1 percenters" are holding on to their cash -- waiting to do investments for a more favorable political and economic climate. Alternatively, they are taking their money overseas.

All of this contributes to a smaller generation of tax revenues, which in turn means the government has too little money and must use artificial means to create money. Right now our inflation level is not too high, but even Ben Bernanke has said that too much loose money policy could cause the pendulum to swing too far in the opposite direction.

Money is ALWAYS 'artificial', Trap. Money is something that humans INVENTED, in some of the earliest civilizations, because they found it to be much more efficient than barter.

You had your 'more favorable political and economic climate' for the '1 percenters' during the Bush II administration. They were the recipients of large tax cuts that were targeted at them like a laser beam. So where were all the jobs? If your theory was correct, the economy should have been BOOMING during the Bush years, with new factories sprouting up like mushrooms.
 
Money is ALWAYS 'artificial', Trap. Money is something that humans INVENTED, in some of the earliest civilizations, because they found it to be much more efficient than barter.

I'd call that an oversimplification. In any case, fiat money can always be manipulated in non-market-based ways by the entity holding the power of fiat -- in this case the U.S. government.

You had your 'more favorable political and economic climate' for the '1 percenters' during the Bush II administration. They were the recipients of large tax cuts that were targeted at them like a laser beam. So where were all the jobs? If your theory was correct, the economy should have been BOOMING during the Bush years, with new factories sprouting up like mushrooms.

Yes, and for seven of eight years of that presidency, the one thing the president couldn't be criticized about was the health of the economy. The jobs went away after the housing collapse, when Bush had fewer than six months left in office. If we're going to judge presidents by the economies experienced under their management, in a vaccuum, then Bush's economic record stands out as a huge success story compared to his successor.
 
I'd call that an oversimplification. In any case, fiat money can always be manipulated in non-market-based ways by the entity holding the power of fiat -- in this case the U.S. government.

Money is always man-made, so it is not an oversimplification to call it 'artificial'. And yes, there's a difference between fiat money and commodity money, but governments have also manipulated commodity money. The later stages of the Roman Empire saw several emperors 'debasing' their coinage by adding less valuable impurities.
 
Yes, and for seven of eight years of that presidency, the one thing the president couldn't be criticized about was the health of the economy. The jobs went away after the housing collapse, when Bush had fewer than six months left in office. If we're going to judge presidents by the economies experienced under their management, in a vaccuum, then Bush's economic record stands out as a huge success story compared to his successor.

For a differing view on the economic legacy of the Bush II administration, I recommend this article which appeared in late 2009 in The Atlantic. This is only the first part of this article. The new PJ evidently won't allow me to post anything longer than 10 thousand words:
Closing The Book On The Bush Legacy

Ronald Brownstein Sep 11 2009, 10:41 AM ET



1
inShare​
More
Thursday's annual Census Bureau report on income, poverty and access to health care-the Bureau's principal report card on the well-being of average Americans-closes the books on the economic record of George W. Bush.
It's not a record many Republicans are likely to point to with pride.
On every major measurement, the Census Bureau report shows that the country lost ground during Bush's two terms. While Bush was in office, the median household income declined, poverty increased, childhood poverty increased even more, and the number of Americans without health insurance spiked. By contrast, the country's condition improved on each of those measures during Bill Clinton's two terms, often substantially.


The Census' final report card on Bush's record presents an intriguing backdrop to today's economic debate. Bush built his economic strategy around tax cuts, passing large reductions both in 2001 and 2003. Congressional Republicans are insisting that a similar agenda focused on tax cuts offers better prospects of reviving the economy than President Obama's combination of some tax cuts with heavy government spending. But the bleak economic results from Bush's two terms, tarnish, to put it mildly, the idea that tax cuts represent an economic silver bullet.
Economists would cite many reasons why presidential terms are an imperfect frame for tracking economic trends. The business cycle doesn't always follow the electoral cycle. A president's economic record is heavily influenced by factors out of his control. Timing matters and so does good fortune.
But few would argue that national economic policy is irrelevant to economic outcomes. And rightly or wrongly, voters still judge presidents and their parties largely by the economy's performance during their watch. In that assessment, few measures do more than the Census data to answer the threshold question of whether a president left the day to day economic conditions of average Americans better than he found it.
If that's the test, today's report shows that Bush flunked on every relevant dimension-and not just because of the severe downturn that began last year.
Consider first the median income. When Bill Clinton left office after 2000, the median income-the income line around which half of households come in above, and half fall below-stood at $52,500 (measured in inflation-adjusted 2008 dollars). When Bush left office after 2008, the median income had fallen to $50,303. That's a decline of 4.2 per cent.
That leaves Bush with the dubious distinction of becoming the only president in recent history to preside over an income decline through two presidential terms, notes Lawrence Mishel, president of the left-leaning Economic Policy Institute. The median household income increased during the two terms of Clinton (by 14 per cent, as we'll see in more detail below), Ronald Reagan (8.1 per cent), and Richard Nixon and Gerald Ford (3.9 per cent). As Mishel notes, although the global recession decidedly deepened the hole-the percentage decline in the median income from 2007 to 2008 is the largest single year fall on record-average families were already worse off in 2007 than they were in 2000, a remarkable result through an entire business expansion. "What is phenomenal about the years under Bush is that through the entire business cycle from 2000 through 2007, even before this recession...working families were worse off at the end of the recovery, in the best of times during that period, than they were in 2000 before he took office," Mishel says.
Bush's record on poverty is equally bleak. When Clinton left office in 2000, the Census counted almost 31.6 million Americans living in poverty. When Bush left office in 2008, the number of poor Americans had jumped to 39.8 million (the largest number in absolute terms since 1960.) Under Bush, the number of people in poverty increased by over 8.2 million, or 26.1 per cent. Over two-thirds of that increase occurred before the economic collapse of 2008.
 
The Keynesians have a clear explanation for what is causing the current economic weakness: a shortfall of aggregate demand. That is consistent with their models, and it fits with the observable data, all of which is the opposite of what we'd predict if it was a supply-side problem. Interest rates are low (the opposite of what would happen if we had an excess of demand for capital -- e.g., if government spending were crowding out private sector spending). Unemployment is high and wages are stagnant (the opposite of what would happen if we had a shortage of labor supply). And inflation is low (not what we'd expect if there were high demand for goods and services, which would bid up the prices for them).

Keynesians also have an explanation for why there is a shortfall of demand, though it's harder to explain without graphs and math. It's not hard to grasp the basics, though, once you realize that one person's spending is another person's income. That can become a self-reinforcing negative trend when everyone is trying to fix their balance sheets at the same time (including, in an austerity environment, governments).

Presumably, though, right-wingers, who typically despise Keynesian economics (Bruce Bartlett notwithstanding), must have some other explanation of what's going on here. What is it, for you conservatives, that explains the cluster of symptoms here (low inflation and interest rates, high unemployment, poor income and GDP growth)? I've been able to follow the Keynesian reasoning, which is clear and intellectually consistent, and I've been impressed by how reliable their predictions are. But I quite honestly haven't been able to follow the reasoning of the Austrian and Chicago economic schools, so I was hoping someone here could explain one or both. We need to understand the nature of a problem to address it correctly.



Economic weakness? Weren't there several posts just last week on the robust 'recovery'?
 
Economic weakness? Weren't there several posts just last week on the robust 'recovery'?

It's not as contradictory as you are implying. Yes, we are in an economic recovery. Consumer confidence is at its highest level in more than five years. Ditto with automobile sales. And the stock market is still at near all-time record levels. Corporate profits continue to be near all-time high levels. The housing market is quite definitely in a sustainable recovery.

But yes, on the other hand, unemployment is still far too high. And yes, everyone would have liked to see a stronger recovery, one generating more middle-class jobs.

Arkady is quite right that if you want a stronger recovery, one that is generating more job opportunities, you need a higher level of aggregate demand.
 
Back
Top