New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

What's the Fed Thinking?

Arkady

President
The stock market has been retreating in recent days --the DOW's now under 15,000-- based on indications that the Fed is ready to dial back stimulus. The Fed has made a number of signals in that direction. The question is why.

To recap, the Fed, by law, has a dual mandate. They're supposed to keep both unemployment and inflation low. If inflation is too high, they're supposed to tighten money supply. If unemployment is too high, they're supposed to loosen it.

Right now, inflation is low. In fact, it's arguably too low. Economists argue about what an optimal inflation rate is -- somewhere between deflation (less than 0% inflation), which is wildly destructive to an economy, and around 10%, where accelerating price increases can create hyperinflation which can also be a huge problem. Central banks tend to target around 2% these days, but longer-term averages are over 3% (3.22% in the US since 1919). Right now, inflation is just 1.1%, and the market is betting on it staying well below historical averages for at least 30 years (the 30-year TIPs spread it about 2.2 points). So, right now we're much closer to the deflationary risk than the hyperinflationary one, below the typical Fed inflation target, and the market is expecting unusually low inflation for three decades to come.

Meanwhile, unemployment is well above so-called "full employment" (often estimated to be around 5%) and vastly above the sub-4% rates we've enjoyed on numerous occasions. The unemployment rate would need to fall by nearly half just to get us back to where we were at the end of the Clinton era.

With persistently high unemployment and a dangerously low rate of inflation, projected to stay unusually low far into the future, the legal mandate of the Fed is clear. They're supposed to be providing more stimulus, by loosening money supply. Instead, they're signalling they'll be providing less at some point in the near future. Why? Why are they so very sensitive to criticisms by inflation hawks, and nearly indifferent to the suffering of millions of unemployed people?
 
Maybe it's just a case of saber rattling?

An empty threat in the hopes of getting the attention of those who are sitting on huge piles of capital, rather than investing in real world activity that might actually, you know, create jobs?
 
Maybe it's just a case of saber rattling?

An empty threat in the hopes of getting the attention of those who are sitting on huge piles of capital, rather than investing in real world activity that might actually, you know, create jobs?



Why would they? They're making PLENTY off the 'stimulus' money.

Why risk their own?
 
Maybe it's just a case of saber rattling?

An empty threat in the hopes of getting the attention of those who are sitting on huge piles of capital, rather than investing in real world activity that might actually, you know, create jobs?

It would be a very bad bit of saber rattling. The whole idea is that we want those sitting on huge piles of capital to put that money to work, right? If they think the Fed will tolerate some inflation in the future, and that capital will remain extremely easy to get in the future, they have every incentive to put that capital at risk (they can get more easily to replace it), and every disincentive to sit on it (since it'll soon be eroding if they do). If the Fed instead signals that they will keep inflation at ultra-low levels, and that they'll make it harder to get your hands on capital in coming months or years, then they just encourage people to keep sitting on piles of capital, rather than to risk it. I don't know what the hell Bernanke could be thinking.
 
It would be a very bad bit of saber rattling. The whole idea is that we want those sitting on huge piles of capital to put that money to work, right? If they think the Fed will tolerate some inflation in the future, and that capital will remain extremely easy to get in the future, they have every incentive to put that capital at risk (they can get more easily to replace it), and every disincentive to sit on it (since it'll soon be eroding if they do). If the Fed instead signals that they will keep inflation at ultra-low levels, and that they'll make it harder to get your hands on capital in coming months or years, then they just encourage people to keep sitting on piles of capital, rather than to risk it. I don't know what the hell Bernanke could be thinking.


Right...why risk YOUR money when you can risk the 'stimulus' money instead.
 
I don't gamble and neither do I grasp what any of this babble has to do with the Federal Reserve.



What do you not grasp?

The people who are 'sitting' on money have found it easier to gamble with the $85 BILLION being injected into the markets each month, than to gamble with their own.

They're getting 'richer' without the risk of their own capital.

It's not that hard to understand, is it?
 
Right...why risk YOUR money when you can risk the 'stimulus' money instead.

If you expect rising inflation and easy access to capital in the future, there's plenty of reason to risk your money. If you just sit on it, it'll erode out from under you.

By comparison, if you expect low inflation and tight access to capital in the future, there's a lot less reason to risk your money. You can sit on it without inflation decreasing its value much, and you'll be worried that if you spend it you won't have access to it when you need it later.
 
What do you not grasp?

The people who are 'sitting' on money have found it easier to gamble with the $85 BILLION being injected into the markets each month, than to gamble with their own.

They're getting 'richer' without the risk of their own capital.

It's not that hard to understand, is it?
No. The problem is that they're soaking up much of that money being injected, to improve their balance sheets, rather than spending it. That seems like a decent strategy if you expect low inflation and tighter money supply in the future (when a fat balance sheet will be a big asset). So, the Fed should be signalling it'll allow higher inflation and looser money supply in the future. Then padding one's balance sheet with cash is less enticing, since that added liquidity doesn't hedge against any expected future shortage, but does risk a decline in real value.
 
Back
Top