Arkady
President
The stock market has been retreating in recent days --the DOW's now under 15,000-- based on indications that the Fed is ready to dial back stimulus. The Fed has made a number of signals in that direction. The question is why.
To recap, the Fed, by law, has a dual mandate. They're supposed to keep both unemployment and inflation low. If inflation is too high, they're supposed to tighten money supply. If unemployment is too high, they're supposed to loosen it.
Right now, inflation is low. In fact, it's arguably too low. Economists argue about what an optimal inflation rate is -- somewhere between deflation (less than 0% inflation), which is wildly destructive to an economy, and around 10%, where accelerating price increases can create hyperinflation which can also be a huge problem. Central banks tend to target around 2% these days, but longer-term averages are over 3% (3.22% in the US since 1919). Right now, inflation is just 1.1%, and the market is betting on it staying well below historical averages for at least 30 years (the 30-year TIPs spread it about 2.2 points). So, right now we're much closer to the deflationary risk than the hyperinflationary one, below the typical Fed inflation target, and the market is expecting unusually low inflation for three decades to come.
Meanwhile, unemployment is well above so-called "full employment" (often estimated to be around 5%) and vastly above the sub-4% rates we've enjoyed on numerous occasions. The unemployment rate would need to fall by nearly half just to get us back to where we were at the end of the Clinton era.
With persistently high unemployment and a dangerously low rate of inflation, projected to stay unusually low far into the future, the legal mandate of the Fed is clear. They're supposed to be providing more stimulus, by loosening money supply. Instead, they're signalling they'll be providing less at some point in the near future. Why? Why are they so very sensitive to criticisms by inflation hawks, and nearly indifferent to the suffering of millions of unemployed people?
To recap, the Fed, by law, has a dual mandate. They're supposed to keep both unemployment and inflation low. If inflation is too high, they're supposed to tighten money supply. If unemployment is too high, they're supposed to loosen it.
Right now, inflation is low. In fact, it's arguably too low. Economists argue about what an optimal inflation rate is -- somewhere between deflation (less than 0% inflation), which is wildly destructive to an economy, and around 10%, where accelerating price increases can create hyperinflation which can also be a huge problem. Central banks tend to target around 2% these days, but longer-term averages are over 3% (3.22% in the US since 1919). Right now, inflation is just 1.1%, and the market is betting on it staying well below historical averages for at least 30 years (the 30-year TIPs spread it about 2.2 points). So, right now we're much closer to the deflationary risk than the hyperinflationary one, below the typical Fed inflation target, and the market is expecting unusually low inflation for three decades to come.
Meanwhile, unemployment is well above so-called "full employment" (often estimated to be around 5%) and vastly above the sub-4% rates we've enjoyed on numerous occasions. The unemployment rate would need to fall by nearly half just to get us back to where we were at the end of the Clinton era.
With persistently high unemployment and a dangerously low rate of inflation, projected to stay unusually low far into the future, the legal mandate of the Fed is clear. They're supposed to be providing more stimulus, by loosening money supply. Instead, they're signalling they'll be providing less at some point in the near future. Why? Why are they so very sensitive to criticisms by inflation hawks, and nearly indifferent to the suffering of millions of unemployed people?