New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

When disagreeing becomes intolerance

BobbyT

Governor
The idea that people are free to say whatever they want and anyone disagreeing with them is intolerant is absurd and a waste of conversational space; disagreeing =/= intolerance. What’s important is when disagreeing morphs into intolerance and is codified into law or expressed through violence.

Tolerance is the willingness to accept others’ feelings, habits, or beliefs. But what does willingness to accept mean? It doesn’t mean agreeing, because one can accept without agreement. It means not taking action to thwart another’s feelings, habits, or beliefs. It is tolerant to “agree to disagree.” It is not tolerant to make laws to limit another’s legal activities. It is not an example of intolerance to tell someone you think their religious ideas are stupid (rude, yes, but not intolerant). Intolerant would be burning your religious institutions or books or murdering your religious leaders. It is not an example of intolerance to tell a woman that getting an abortion is murder (cruel, yes, but not intolerant). Intolerant would be passing laws to limit her access to legal abortion services or access to the birth control of her choice or murdering abortion service providers or standing in front of an abortion clinic and blocking access to the front door.
 
The idea that people are free to say whatever they want and anyone disagreeing with them is intolerant is absurd and a waste of conversational space; disagreeing =/= intolerance. What’s important is when disagreeing morphs into intolerance and is codified into law or expressed through violence.

Tolerance is the willingness to accept others’ feelings, habits, or beliefs. But what does willingness to accept mean? It doesn’t mean agreeing, because one can accept without agreement. It means not taking action to thwart another’s feelings, habits, or beliefs. It is tolerant to “agree to disagree.” It is not tolerant to make laws to limit another’s legal activities. It is not an example of intolerance to tell someone you think their religious ideas are stupid (rude, yes, but not intolerant). Intolerant would be burning your religious institutions or books or murdering your religious leaders. It is not an example of intolerance to tell a woman that getting an abortion is murder (cruel, yes, but not intolerant). Intolerant would be passing laws to limit her access to legal abortion services or access to the birth control of her choice or murdering abortion service providers or standing in front of an abortion clinic and blocking access to the front door.

Tolerance doesn't mean agreeing with someone on everything.
Tolerance doesn't even mean accepting others' feelings, habits or beliefs.

Tolerance means not making their lives miserable because you don't like their lifestyle choices.
Tolerance means not personally attacking or devaluing someone because you don't agree with them.
 
Tolerance doesn't mean agreeing with someone on everything.
Tolerance doesn't even mean accepting others' feelings, habits or beliefs.

Tolerance means not making their lives miserable because you don't like their lifestyle choices.
Tolerance means not personally attacking or devaluing someone because you don't agree with them.
Tolerance means willingness to accept others' feelings, habits, or beliefs. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/tolerance
 
Tolerance doesn't mean agreeing with someone on everything.
Tolerance doesn't even mean accepting others' feelings, habits or beliefs.

Tolerance means not making their lives miserable because you don't like their lifestyle choices.
Tolerance means not personally attacking or devaluing someone because you don't agree with them.

Like not calling someone stupid for disagreeing with you? Sounds right...
 
The whole "Tolerance" movement is a load of bunk you ask me, if you go by what how Bobby defined it, which is the modern liberal definition.

The problem, of course, is the word "accept". I don't expect Muslims to "accept" my Christian views. We can certainly respect each other, agree to disagree, and recognize diversity within the world. We can all "tolerate" each other.

However, to "tolerate" someone and "Tolerance" are two different things.
 
The whole "Tolerance" movement is a load of bunk you ask me, if you go by what how Bobby defined it, which is the modern liberal definition.

The problem, of course, is the word "accept". I don't expect Muslims to "accept" my Christian views. We can certainly respect each other, agree to disagree, and recognize diversity within the world. We can all "tolerate" each other.

However, to "tolerate" someone and "Tolerance" are two different things.
Bobby's interpretation of the definition is warped.

Tolerance means I disagree with something but I don't need to pass a law banning it.

Leftists disagree with our use of trans fats, so they are banning them by law. Next they will disagree with our use of sugar and will want to ban that. Their Leftist mayor tried to ban the sale of large carbonated drinks. The Leftist solution is to make a law for anything they don't like so they don't have to worry about tolerating it.

Conservatives, if they don't like the nasty jokes on a tv show (for example) change the channel. Leftists don't like Rush Limbaugh so they try to push him off the air.

That is the difference between tolerance and intolerance. Being tolerant means changing the channel, being intolerant means passing a law against it or throwing it off the air.

Of course there are far right people who are intolerant. But it seems we have more far lefties here than far righties because the push back from the left here is of pretty extreme intolerance. I pushed back against their bullying today........... and will continue to do that.
 
Bobby's interpretation of the definition is warped.

Tolerance means I disagree with something but I don't need to pass a law banning it.

Leftists disagree with our use of trans fats, so they are banning them by law. Next they will disagree with our use of sugar and will want to ban that. Their Leftist mayor tried to ban the sale of large carbonated drinks. The Leftist solution is to make a law for anything they don't like so they don't have to worry about tolerating it.

Conservatives, if they don't like the nasty jokes on a tv show (for example) change the channel. Leftists don't like Rush Limbaugh so they try to push him off the air.

That is the difference between tolerance and intolerance. Being tolerant means changing the channel, being intolerant means passing a law against it or throwing it off the air.

Of course there are far right people who are intolerant. But it seems we have more far lefties here than far righties because the push back from the left here is of pretty extreme intolerance. I pushed back against their bullying today........... and will continue to do that.

Got an example of being bullied?
 
Bobby's interpretation of the definition is warped.

Tolerance means I disagree with something but I don't need to pass a law banning it.

Leftists disagree with our use of trans fats, so they are banning them by law. Next they will disagree with our use of sugar and will want to ban that. Their Leftist mayor tried to ban the sale of large carbonated drinks. The Leftist solution is to make a law for anything they don't like so they don't have to worry about tolerating it.

Conservatives, if they don't like the nasty jokes on a tv show (for example) change the channel. Leftists don't like Rush Limbaugh so they try to push him off the air.

That is the difference between tolerance and intolerance. Being tolerant means changing the channel, being intolerant means passing a law against it or throwing it off the air.

Of course there are far right people who are intolerant. But it seems we have more far lefties here than far righties because the push back from the left here is of pretty extreme intolerance. I pushed back against their bullying today........... and will continue to do that.

Interesting statistical proof that the left is certainly not the tolerant bunch:

Do the data support the claim that conservatives are haters, while liberals are tolerant of others?
  • A handy way to answer this question is with what political analysts call “feeling thermometers,” in which people are asked on a survey to rate others on a scale of 0-100.
  • A zero is complete hatred, while 100 means adoration.
  • In general, when presented with people or groups about which they have neutral feelings, respondents give temperatures of about 70.
  • Forty is a cold temperature
  • 20 is absolutely freezing.
In 2004, the University of Michigan’s American National Election Studies (ANES) survey asked about 1,200 American adults to give their thermometer scores of various groups.
  • The score conservatives gave Liberals: average thermometer score of 39.
  • The score that liberals give conservatives: average thermometer score of 38.
Looking only at people who said they are “extremely conservative” or “extremely liberal,”?
  • the right gave the left a score of 27
  • the left gives the right an icy 23.
  • So much for the liberal tolerance edge.
When Bush was in office:
  • Those on the extreme left give President Bush an average temperature of 15
  • They gave Vice President Cheney a 16.
  • Sixty percent of this group gives both men the absolute lowest score: zero.
To put this into perspective
  • even Saddam Hussein (when he was still among the living) got an average score of eight from Americans.
  • The data tell us that, for six in ten on the hard left in America, literally nobody in the entire world can be worse than George W. Bush and Dick Cheney.
Compare to Conservative views of Bill Clinton and Al Gore:
  • In 1998, Clinton and Gore both received a perfectly-respectable average temperature of 45 from those who called themselves extremely conservative.
  • While 28% of the far right gave Clinton a temperature of zero, Gore got a zero from just 10%.
The bottom line is that there is simply no comparison between the current hatred the extreme left has for Bush and Cheney, and the hostility the extreme right had for Clinton and Gore in the late 1990s.

http://michellemalkin.com/2008/01/17/the-statistical-proof-of-liberal-intolerance/
 
The whole "Tolerance" movement is a load of bunk you ask me, if you go by what how Bobby defined it, which is the modern liberal definition.

The problem, of course, is the word "accept". I don't expect Muslims to "accept" my Christian views. We can certainly respect each other, agree to disagree, and recognize diversity within the world. We can all "tolerate" each other.

However, to "tolerate" someone and "Tolerance" are two different things.
The definition I used came from Webster's.
 
Bobby's interpretation of the definition is warped.

Tolerance means I disagree with something but I don't need to pass a law banning it.

Leftists disagree with our use of trans fats, so they are banning them by law. Next they will disagree with our use of sugar and will want to ban that. Their Leftist mayor tried to ban the sale of large carbonated drinks. The Leftist solution is to make a law for anything they don't like so they don't have to worry about tolerating it.

Conservatives, if they don't like the nasty jokes on a tv show (for example) change the channel. Leftists don't like Rush Limbaugh so they try to push him off the air.

That is the difference between tolerance and intolerance. Being tolerant means changing the channel, being intolerant means passing a law against it or throwing it off the air.

Of course there are far right people who are intolerant. But it seems we have more far lefties here than far righties because the push back from the left here is of pretty extreme intolerance. I pushed back against their bullying today........... and will continue to do that.
The definition I used came from Webster's.

My post said what you are saying: a manifestation of intolerance is passing laws to ban other people's beliefs. Another is using violence against people of a different beliefs, feelings, or habits.
 
Bobby's interpretation of the definition is warped.

Tolerance means I disagree with something but I don't need to pass a law banning it.

Leftists disagree with our use of trans fats, so they are banning them by law. Next they will disagree with our use of sugar and will want to ban that. Their Leftist mayor tried to ban the sale of large carbonated drinks. The Leftist solution is to make a law for anything they don't like so they don't have to worry about tolerating it.

Conservatives, if they don't like the nasty jokes on a tv show (for example) change the channel. Leftists don't like Rush Limbaugh so they try to push him off the air.

That is the difference between tolerance and intolerance. Being tolerant means changing the channel, being intolerant means passing a law against it or throwing it off the air.

Of course there are far right people who are intolerant. But it seems we have more far lefties here than far righties because the push back from the left here is of pretty extreme intolerance. I pushed back against their bullying today........... and will continue to do that.

Rightists disagree with abortion....Instead of deciding that since they don't like abortion they won't have one....they pass laws to make sure nobody can have one...

Righties don't like unions so they want to pass laws making it harder for unions to organize or even exist.

Lefties don't like pollution and pass laws to stop it....

Righties don't mind so they work to repeal those laws....
 
Interesting statistical proof that the left is certainly not the tolerant bunch:

Do the data support the claim that conservatives are haters, while liberals are tolerant of others?
  • A handy way to answer this question is with what political analysts call “feeling thermometers,” in which people are asked on a survey to rate others on a scale of 0-100.
  • A zero is complete hatred, while 100 means adoration.
  • In general, when presented with people or groups about which they have neutral feelings, respondents give temperatures of about 70.
  • Forty is a cold temperature
  • 20 is absolutely freezing.
In 2004, the University of Michigan’s American National Election Studies (ANES) survey asked about 1,200 American adults to give their thermometer scores of various groups.
  • The score conservatives gave Liberals: average thermometer score of 39.
  • The score that liberals give conservatives: average thermometer score of 38.
Looking only at people who said they are “extremely conservative” or “extremely liberal,”?
  • the right gave the left a score of 27
  • the left gives the right an icy 23.
  • So much for the liberal tolerance edge.
When Bush was in office:
  • Those on the extreme left give President Bush an average temperature of 15
  • They gave Vice President Cheney a 16.
  • Sixty percent of this group gives both men the absolute lowest score: zero.
To put this into perspective
  • even Saddam Hussein (when he was still among the living) got an average score of eight from Americans.
  • The data tell us that, for six in ten on the hard left in America, literally nobody in the entire world can be worse than George W. Bush and Dick Cheney.
Compare to Conservative views of Bill Clinton and Al Gore:
  • In 1998, Clinton and Gore both received a perfectly-respectable average temperature of 45 from those who called themselves extremely conservative.
  • While 28% of the far right gave Clinton a temperature of zero, Gore got a zero from just 10%.
The bottom line is that there is simply no comparison between the current hatred the extreme left has for Bush and Cheney, and the hostility the extreme right had for Clinton and Gore in the late 1990s.

http://michellemalkin.com/2008/01/17/the-statistical-proof-of-liberal-intolerance/
This doesn't surprise me at all.
 
Rightists disagree with abortion....Instead of deciding that since they don't like abortion they won't have one....they pass laws to make sure nobody can have one...

Righties don't like unions so they want to pass laws making it harder for unions to organize or even exist.

Lefties don't like pollution and pass laws to stop it....

Righties don't mind so they work to repeal those laws....


Provably false.
 
The definition I used came from Webster's.

My post said what you are saying: a manifestation of intolerance is passing laws to ban other people's beliefs. Another is using violence against people of a different beliefs, feelings, or habits.

Your definition was from Websters.
Your interpretation was from Librulville.
 
Your definition was from Websters.
Your interpretation was from Librulville.
You agree with my interpretation: tolerance isn't about agreeing or disagreeing, it's about doing something (like passing laws) based on intolerance. You've said that a couple times in this thread. How is my interpretation any different than yours?
 
Back
Top