New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Which is more divisive?

What is the root cause of our divided nation?

  • Skin colors

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • Cultural differences

    Votes: 2 16.7%
  • Political Parties

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Ideological extremes

    Votes: 3 25.0%
  • One side is invested in having a divided nation so it uses the media to make it happen

    Votes: 4 33.3%
  • The Media wants us divided

    Votes: 2 16.7%

  • Total voters
    12
  • Poll closed .

Jen

Senator
We can all agree that our nation is divided.
What do you think is the root cause of this divisiveness?
 
We can all agree that our nation is divided.
What do you think is the root cause of this divisiveness?
People who believe, and say, that those on the other side of the political divide are "evil," as you do frequently. You are part of the root cause. Don't fret; you're not alone.
 
People who believe, and say, that those on the other side of the political divide are "evil," as you do frequently. You are part of the root cause. Don't fret; you're not alone.
Why would I fret?
I am right.
Anyone who overtly does actions that destroy property or shows that they hate our flag and our national anthem...........and anyone who calls for an overthrow of our government hates our nation and that is evil.

I vehemently disagreed with Obama. But I never once called for his impeachment nor did I wish for anyone to assassinate him and had anyone held what appeared to be his bloody head out with a smirk on her face........I would have said about that the same as what I said about the nasty gal who did it with Trump's head.

Evil is evil. There is no right or left about it. And there are a whole lot of people on the left right now who are calling for or doing evil things.

No fretting about it.
What I've said is true.
 
The real answer: it's about the haves and the have-nots.
No. It is not the answer. It's not even a question.

There are people who have a lot.................. filthy rich............who are not offering a cent of their money to help out those "have nots". What they are doing is convincing the have nots that the middle class, people working their butts off for a place to live and raise their families ........is selfish.

Rich people like the Democrats in Congress......some of the richest people in this nation, look it up............... haven't offered to spread their own wealth. They want to spread someone else's wealth.

That's evil.
It's just wrong.
And if you like having your aristocracy tell you to give up your hard-earned money (while they keep theirs) then you are stupid.
 
We can all agree that our nation is divided.
What do you think is the root cause of this divisiveness?

I am sorry I have to get all partisan on you.

One side is basically one skin color. There are about 3 or four people in all of their elected members who are not that same skin color. The other side does not seem to have a problem with skin color, They have leaders that come in all different colors.

If we narrow what culture is. America to everyone outside of it is considered a culture. Maybe it has something to do with not accepting that we, all of us together, ARE the culture and our differences are as well.

One party JUMPED to work with the President of the Opposition party last week on DACA. Under the previous administration the opposition party's mantra was to see him fail. They wouldn't even vote for a tax cut because he proposed it.

The most extreme politician in one party was Bernie Sanders. I don't know how many people from the opposition party said if we had only nominated Bernie they would have voted for him over the other guy.

Now you're making me really pour it on.

One side used the media to gin up anger over the current healthcare plan when we now know that it was only purely to divide the country and win elections. So much so that foreign enemy glommed on to that effort and started putting out media of their own to support it.

The Russian media surely does.
 
No. It is not the answer. It's not even a question.

There are people who have a lot.................. filthy rich............who are not offering a cent of their money to help out those "have nots". What they are doing is convincing the have nots that the middle class, people working their butts off for a place to live and raise their families ........is selfish.

Rich people like the Democrats in Congress......some of the richest people in this nation, look it up............... haven't offered to spread their own wealth. They want to spread someone else's wealth.

That's evil.
It's just wrong.
And if you like having your aristocracy tell you to give up your hard-earned money (while they keep theirs) then you are stupid.

Even your rebuttal attempt is shot through with class - warfare themes.
 
Why would I fret?
I am right.
Anyone who overtly does actions that destroy property or shows that they hate our flag and our national anthem...........and anyone who calls for an overthrow of our government hates our nation and that is evil.

I vehemently disagreed with Obama. But I never once called for his impeachment nor did I wish for anyone to assassinate him and had anyone held what appeared to be his bloody head out with a smirk on her face........I would have said about that the same as what I said about the nasty gal who did it with Trump's head.

Evil is evil. There is no right or left about it. And there are a whole lot of people on the left right now who are calling for or doing evil things.

No fretting about it.
What I've said is true.
Then don't wonder about the divisiveness in the country. If you can't see the common ground among Americans, but continue to accuse the left of being evil and "hating the country," you are why the country is divided. You don't narrow your accusations to anyone who may destroy property, you include the entire left in your frequent diatribes.

Protesting police violence against black men is not hating the flag or the anthem. It's protesting police violence against black men. You just characterize it that way to demonize their protest. It wouldn't matter what form their protest to bring attention to their cause would take, you'd demonize whatever form it took.
 
We can all agree that our nation is divided.
What do you think is the root cause of this divisiveness?
GIMP-Top-1p-Share-of-Total-PTI.png

Economic inequality drives the divide in the US, and "choosing" between Republican or Democrat in the voting booth will do absolutely nothing to change that reality.

http://inequality.stanford.edu/publications/20-facts-about-us-inequality-everyone-should-know
 
Hateful, racist, disgusting, vile, rhetoric:

Blond blue-eyed white people are typically more competent and willing to do the job they were elected to do...look out for their citizens. Democrats are incompetent, lazy, greedy thieves and basically just worthless pieces of shit. This is true whether they are black, brown, or blond, blue-eyed white Democrats.
 
Why would I fret?
I am right.
Anyone who overtly does actions that destroy property or shows that they hate our flag and our national anthem...........and anyone who calls for an overthrow of our government hates our nation and that is evil.

I vehemently disagreed with Obama. But I never once called for his impeachment nor did I wish for anyone to assassinate him and had anyone held what appeared to be his bloody head out with a smirk on her face........I would have said about that the same as what I said about the nasty gal who did it with Trump's head.

Evil is evil. There is no right or left about it. And there are a whole lot of people on the left right now who are calling for or doing evil things.

No fretting about it.
What I've said is true.

And did you condemn those who made up things like the Kenyan Birth certificate or the edited interview with his grandmother to say that Obama was not the legitimate president? Did you bother to listen to the lies Trump told about his investigators in Hawaii finding evidence to support the lie about Obama's birth certificate being fake?

Nah...you didn't see that as divisive at all, didja?
 
None of the above. All of the above. Others.

You left out important ones such as religious intolerance (exemplified by a senate candidate Roy Moore) and the wealth gap. There are many more I am sure.

Use of the media to divide isn't one sided by any means. The best and most prominent example is our POTUS who uses media to attack and divide.

While my two specific examples are conservative, it certainly isn't limited to conservatives but they are the two most prominent dividers in the news at this time.
 
None of the above. All of the above. Others.

You left out important ones such as religious intolerance (exemplified by a senate candidate Roy Moore) and the wealth gap. There are many more I am sure.

Use of the media to divide isn't one sided by any means. The best and most prominent example is our POTUS who uses media to attack and divide.

While my two specific examples are conservative, it certainly isn't limited to conservatives but they are the two most prominent dividers in the news at this time.
Religious intolerance? Wouldn't that be a violation of a person's first amendment right if you wouldn't allow them to follow their religious teaching? Who are you to say if they are intolerant?
 
Religious intolerance? Wouldn't that be a violation of a person's first amendment right if you wouldn't allow them to follow their religious teaching? Who are you to say if they are intolerant?

Roy Moore objects to anything other than Christian religion. He objected that a congressman, Keith Ellison, was sworn in using a Koran rather than a bible. That is religious intolerance.

I also think it is religious intolerance for a government to allow one religion to dominate over all others in a governmental setting. For example, allowing a large monument to the 10 commandments but not allowing any monuments for other religions.

Another would be attempts to prevent mosques to be built in close proximity to the location where the twin towers fell. Close proximity being arbitrary of course. There are other examples, some against Christians.

I am a person with an opinion, just like you. That gives me the right to say I think someone is intolerant.
 
Roy Moore objects to anything other than Christian religion. He objected that a congressman, Keith Ellison, was sworn in using a Koran rather than a bible. That is religious intolerance.

I also think it is religious intolerance for a government to allow one religion to dominate over all others in a governmental setting. For example, allowing a large monument to the 10 commandments but not allowing any monuments for other religions.

Another would be attempts to prevent mosques to be built in close proximity to the location where the twin towers fell. Close proximity being arbitrary of course. There are other examples, some against Christians.

I am a person with an opinion, just like you. That gives me the right to say I think someone is intolerant.
You never answered my question
 
the major differences between "our nations founding" and today:

  1. more extremes between wealth and poverty. in the 18th century there wasn't a permanent class of entertainers, business moguls, and millionaire media stars shoving their exclusiveness and bling in the faces of everyone else. yes George Washington and Thomas Jefferson had estates. No they did not have fleets of chauffer driven cars, aircraft and yatchs.
  2. narcotics addiction
  3. the divide between skilled jobs and unskilled jobs. most 18th century jobs could be learned in short order as an apprentice. today you attend college for 4-6-8 years, and still be unemployed, or fail to get a license as an attorney or some other regulated trade.
 
You never answered my question

If someone is denied the ability to follow their religion when it had no impact on others, it would be a violation of their rights. If they use their 1st amendment right to force someone to do or not do something that denied them their freedoms, it would be a violation of the other people's rights.

I absolutely believe that it is impossible to have freedom of religion without freedom from someone else's religion.
 
The real answer: it's about the haves and the have-nots.
Yes, that's a core problem. But it may not be the ultimate root problem. I think you could argue that most Western European countries are less divided than the US, and they all have more aggressive policy measures in place to try to combat the spread of the haves and have nots. Why is the US such an outlier among major wealthy nations when it comes to so very many things (our tattered social safety net, our neglect of public transit and urban planning, our low taxes, our for-profit approach to healthcare, our lack of gun control, our reliance on draconian criminal law, etc.)? I think it may have a lot to do with race.

My theory is that when the working class looks a lot like the upper class, the people in charge tend to think of the poor as just unlucky people who are otherwise like themselves. Thus, the leaders tend to support a lot of policies they'd want pursued if they were the poor ones.... if they were the ones living in unsafe inner cities with lousy schools and few economic opportunities.

But when the working class looks physically quite different from the upper class, the people in charge tend to think of the poor as lesser human beings, who are suffering for their faults. Thus, the leaders tend to support policies that isolate and subjugate the poor, and they tend to shun policies they see as giving "those people" a potential way to cheat the system (because they assume that's just what most of "those people" will do, if given half the chance).

I think that's part of why you see a difference even within the US between places where the lower class looks a lot like the upper class (e.g., Massachusetts), and places where they look very different (e.g., Mississippi). Here in Massachusetts, most poor folks are white, just like the leaders. And so the leaders tend to favor the kinds of policies they would want to see if in less fortunate shoes. In Mississippi, most leaders are white and most poor people are black, so policy isn't driven by empathy; it's driven by distrust.
 
Back
Top