New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Which One Is It?

Trump slaps Steel tariffs on the EU because they are national security threat. Trump also want EU nations to increase military spending. In what world does it make sense to prod a national security threat to increase the size of their military?
 
Trump slaps Steel tariffs on the EU because they are national security threat. Trump also want EU nations to increase military spending. In what world does it make sense to prod a national security threat to increase the size of their military?
The following summarizes my views on the matter (frankly, I have no idea what Trump's actual reasoning is).

First off, I oppose tariffs in all cases except those in which fraud and theft of IP is involved. When someone is stealing technology and poses a potential national security threat, special considerations can be made. This would apply to China, who is consistently a miserable actor on the world stage. This would not apply to Europe, IMO...nor the vast majority of the world.

Second, where lack of reciprocity exists in funding mutual objectives/organizations...it is ALWAYS appropriate to insist that contributions are equitable and NOT disproportionately burdensome to one people. If this is not possible, then that entity is NOT sufficiently mutually beneficial and we should exit.

Third, one can make the argument that harming the USA steel industry poses a national security risk, because reducing or killing off that industry would place us in a position of being dependent upon IMPORTATION of foreign-made materials that we cannot control. If a foreign entity artificially reduces its own pricing below market value...or places tariffs on imports, that eliminates the ability to compete, rendering said industry unhealthy, that is a problem. Steel is a critical product.

Understanding the above, it could be said that calculated impairment of our infrastructure and capacity to produce steel presents a national security threat...without the government entity itself being a formal threat to our national security geo-politically. In other words, the calculation could readily be merely one of propping up an economic sector without intent to do harm and without hostile ambition.

I do not consider Europe to be a threat, other than its annoying station as incubator of liberty-crushing socialism and egalitarianism.

In any case, the USA should not be required to pay the lions share of NATO costs both in absolute terms and in terms of bare percentage (I understand our GDP is larger, so our dollar contribution will be higher). Any argument that someone may be a threat...so we should continue to let them take advantage of us and let them place a disproportionate burden on the American taxpayer is illogical.

These are my thoughts. As noted, I haven't any idea what the Trump Administration big picture assessment is. I definitely do not agree with tariffs though.
 
Third, one can make the argument that harming the USA steel industry poses a national security risk, because reducing or killing off that industry would place us in a position of being dependent upon IMPORTATION of foreign-made materials that we cannot control. If a foreign entity artificially reduces its own pricing below market value...or places tariffs on imports, that eliminates the ability to compete, rendering said industry unhealthy, that is a problem. Steel is a critical product.
1.)I have never understood why "dumping" is illegal. It's self-limiting. "Dumping" inventory below cost is a perfectly legitimate solution to a short term cash flow problem, it is not inherently unsustainable. Personally I don't consider it an unfair trade advantage.
2.) "Steel is a critical product." -Welsey Mouch
It's a pretty arbitrary determiniation. Why is steel and not copper? or lima beans for that matter?
The point is the free market best determines what constitutes critical product and the best means of production/acquistion.
3.) I do not think the EU is a national security threat and the rationale for the tariffs was completely bogus. I also think that the EU should be paying more for their own national defense. And that should commensurate with a draw down in our national defense spending. It won't though.
4.)Trump's big picture is purely political. Populism is terrible for government, doing what's right is not necessarily popular. I refuse to believe that Trump is dumb enough to believe that the tariffs are the right thing to do. I do believe he thinks they are popular. He cares more about popularity that being being right.
 
1.)I have never understood why "dumping" is illegal. It's self-limiting. "Dumping" inventory below cost is a perfectly legitimate solution to a short term cash flow problem, it is not inherently unsustainable. Personally I don't consider it an unfair trade advantage.

In some cases, what I described could conceivably be attributable to "dumping". In many, though, it takes the form of state subsidy of industry, thereby artificially lowering cost to compete. In others, it may be tariffs assigned to foreign products, inflating cost to markets. Even in cases where "dumping" occurs, it is often a harmful practice intended to harm competitors. Here is the USA, Samsung is famous for this. They routinely would do a mass dump of memory chips, releasing huge inventories and flooding the market, bringing prices to a free fall. They did this as calculated strategy to drive their competition out. They successfully killed off Infineon's participation in the space, and damaged Micron as well. I view this practice as akin to formation of monopolies. Consumers are robbed of competition.

2.) "Steel is a critical product." -Welsey Mouch
It's a pretty arbitrary determiniation. Why is steel and not copper? or lima beans for that matter?
The point is the free market best determines what constitutes critical product and the best means of production/acquistion.

You don't build ship's hulls and war machinery out of lima beans. Frankly, I'm a bit surprised I need to wade through the critical nature of steel to both national defense and fundamental national infrastructure. The capacity to produce it is a matter of autonomy, sovereignty, and self-sufficiency. It is a dangerous product in which to be foreign-sales and importation dependent
.

3.) I do not think the EU is a national security threat and the rationale for the tariffs was completely bogus. I also think that the EU should be paying more for their own national defense. And that should commensurate with a draw down in our national defense spending. It won't though.

Ok. I agree to an extent.

4.)Trump's big picture is purely political. Populism is terrible for government, doing what's right is not necessarily popular. I refuse to believe that Trump is dumb enough to believe that the tariffs are the right thing to do. I do believe he thinks they are popular. He cares more about popularity that being being right.

I have no idea whether Trump does what he does out of "popularity" or "populism". I agree with some of his policy stances and disagree with others, taking care not to divine his motivation or thinking on the matter. I try to judge actions. I agree, tariffs generally suck as a rule - with the rare exception of national security risks.
 
We should never surrender the means to make our own equipment for war fighting. To do so would be suicidal, much like Obama's scheme which gutted our space program and made us dependent on his Russian connections for space travel and exploration. Deplorable.
 
In some cases, what I described could conceivably be attributable to "dumping". In many, though, it takes the form of state subsidy of industry, thereby artificially lowering cost to compete. In others, it may be tariffs assigned to foreign products, inflating cost to markets. Even in cases where "dumping" occurs, it is often a harmful practice intended to harm competitors. Here is the USA, Samsung is famous for this. They routinely would do a mass dump of memory chips, releasing huge inventories and flooding the market, bringing prices to a free fall. They did this as calculated strategy to drive their competition out. They successfully killed off Infineon's participation in the space, and damaged Micron as well. I view this practice as akin to formation of monopolies. Consumers are robbed of competition.

If Samsung was receiving subsidies from the South Korean government I can see how that would be an unfair trade advantage. If they are a private corporation(they are) it doesn't strike as unethical to sell at any price. If they continue to sell below cost they will eventually go out of business. Accepting a lower profit margin is a perfectly legitimate form of competition. I believe that doesn't just stop at a profit margin of zero. accepting a negative profit margin is a legitmate form of competition. It isn't sustainable in the long term, but to me it's fair. I realize I am in the minority on this issue though.

You don't build ship's hulls and war machinery out of lima beans. Frankly, I'm a bit surprised I need to wade through the critical nature of steel to both national defense and fundamental national infrastructure. The capacity to produce it is a matter of autonomy, sovereignty, and self-sufficiency. It is a dangerous product in which to be foreign-sales and importation dependent.

What's critical to national security can change on a dime. And protectionism will lead to domestic overproduction. It's just asking for Soviet style problems, where we have a glut of steel and guns, but we can't feed our people

Ok. I agree to an extent.

did-we-just-become-best-friends-13968532.png


I have no idea whether Trump does what he does out of "popularity" or "populism". I agree with some of his policy stances and disagree with others, taking care not to divine his motivation or thinking on the matter. I try to judge actions. I agree, tariffs generally suck as a rule - with the rare exception of national security risks.
I think the definition of populism is governing by what's popular. Sometimes what's popular coincides with what right, other times it does not. I am not a big fan of populism.
 
We should never surrender the means to make our own equipment for war fighting. To do so would be suicidal, much like Obama's scheme which gutted our space program and made us dependent on his Russian connections for space travel and exploration. Deplorable.
If they are a national security threat why encourage them to increase military spending?
 
If they are a national security threat why encourage them to increase military spending?

You misunderstood. The security threat is in EU nations' predatory trade practices compromising our ability to make war equipment domestically. Getting these parasite nations to pay their fair share for their defense strengthens both them and us.

Much like raising your kids to be fiscally responsible and socially accountable, rather than as Democrats.
 
Trump slaps Steel tariffs on the EU because they are national security threat. Trump also want EU nations to increase military spending. In what world does it make sense to prod a national security threat to increase the size of their military?

You saying the same Euro's that depend on the U.S.A. to keep Russia off their backs(What created NATO) is going to attack the U.S. ?

Most of them are like you and Hitler...Socialists. Military strategy is not their best suit.

I call this a made up threat.
 
You misunderstood. The security threat is in EU nations' predatory trade practices compromising our ability to make war equipment domestically. Getting these parasite nations to pay their fair share for their defense strengthens both them and us.
Wut? Intuitively this doesn't even make sense. You are saying they want to use us for national security, but they also want to hamper our ability to do so?
Much like raising your kids to be fiscally responsible and socially accountable, rather than as Democrats.
When you supported the Republicans tax cuts which exploded the deficit nobody takes you serious when you talk about fiscal responsibility.
 
You saying the same Euro's that depend on the U.S.A. to keep Russia off their backs(What created NATO) is going to attack the U.S. ?

Most of them are like you and Hitler...Socialists. Military strategy is not their best suit.

I call this a made up threat.
So then you agree Trump rationale for the steel tariffs was bullsh*t.
 
Trump slaps Steel tariffs on the EU because they are national security threat. Trump also want EU nations to increase military spending. In what world does it make sense to prod a national security threat to increase the size of their military?

Remember when wingers ranted/lied about “Obama picking winners and losers”?

;-)
 
Trump slaps Steel tariffs on the EU because they are national security threat. Trump also want EU nations to increase military spending. In what world does it make sense to prod a national security threat to increase the size of their military?

Bring all our troops home from Germany

Your employer wants you to post less in frays
In what world does it make sense for employee to post in frays instead of what employed for, or are you another DNC paid poster?
 
If Samsung was receiving subsidies from the South Korean government I can see how that would be an unfair trade advantage. If they are a private corporation(they are) it doesn't strike as unethical to sell at any price. If they continue to sell below cost they will eventually go out of business. Accepting a lower profit margin is a perfectly legitimate form of competition. I believe that doesn't just stop at a profit margin of zero. accepting a negative profit margin is a legitmate form of competition. It isn't sustainable in the long term, but to me it's fair. I realize I am in the minority on this issue though.


What's critical to national security can change on a dime. And protectionism will lead to domestic overproduction. It's just asking for Soviet style problems, where we have a glut of steel and guns, but we can't feed our people


did-we-just-become-best-friends-13968532.png



I think the definition of populism is governing by what's popular. Sometimes what's popular coincides with what right, other times it does not. I am not a big fan of populism.
The problem with dumping is similar to the problem of competitor absorption. Just as monopolies can distort a free market by elimination of competing players, so too does product-dumping. I am not necessarily arguing for additional regulation here. I am merely making some experientially-derived observations of fact. In any case, the example of steel is not one I consider relevant to dumping.

Regarding protectionism, yes I agree, it is in bad form unless an overwhelming case for national security interest can be made. I hate tariffs.

Finally, I'll note that I am no populist either, and the sort of libertarian-conservative order I favor is increasingly falling out of favor with folks. There is an increasing sense of entitlement coupled with immediate gratification and collectivism that flies in the face (both functionally and culturally) of what I espouse. Hopefully the tide turns there one day, but I doubt it. Protracted prosperity and abundance virtually always manifests in a lazier, more entitled, less industrious citizenry. To be blunt, we were built to struggle and work hard. When there is less struggle, character and values suffer.

...or perhaps "idle hands are the devil's playthings/workshop".

:)
 
The problem with dumping is similar to the problem of competitor absorption. Just as monopolies can distort a free market by elimination of competing players, so too does product-dumping. I am not necessarily arguing for additional regulation here. I am merely making some experientially-derived observations of fact. In any case, the example of steel is not one I consider relevant to dumping.
:)
For the most I don't see the problem with free market monopolies. In the event a monopoly starts treating their customers like sh*t then competition is perfectly capable of rising from the ashes and stealing away dissatisfied customers. A monopoly isn't set in stone forever, They are fleeting. The government treats people who reach the top of mountain as people who can't be knocked off.
 
Back
Top