New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

who mentioned guns?

JuliefromOhio

President
Supporting Member
rightwingworld is upset that Bob Costas dared talk about guns.

Costas took quotes from a Jason Whitlock article:

"Our current gun culture simply ensures that more and more domestic disputes will end in the ultimate tragedy…

"if Jovan Belcher didn’t possess/own a gun, he and his girlfriend would both be alive today.


http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/story/...phan-daughter-why-still-playing-sunday-120112

[video=youtube;uOi7If0zW9s]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOi7If0zW9s&feature=player_embedded[/video]
 
rightwingworld is upset that Bob Costas dared talk about guns.

Costas took quotes from a Jason Whitlock article:

"Our current gun culture simply ensures that more and more domestic disputes will end in the ultimate tragedy…

"if Jovan Belcher didn’t possess/own a gun, he and his girlfriend would both be alive today.


http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/story/...phan-daughter-why-still-playing-sunday-120112

[video=youtube;uOi7If0zW9s]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOi7If0zW9s&feature=player_embedded[/video]


HUH??????????

"who mentioned guns?"

Uhhhhhhhhhhh................well, based upon your post YOU, Costas and Whitlock did. It is fairly obvious, should be noticed quite easily, even by YOU.

I mean, according to YOUR post here, "rightwingworld is upset that Bob Costas dared talk about guns.", correct?

Then, again, according to YOUR post, "Costas took quotes from a Jason Whitlock article: "Our current gun culture simply ensures that more and more domestic disputes will end in the ultimate tragedy…

"if Jovan Belcher didn’t possess/own a gun, he and his girlfriend would both be alive today
."

So you are, in one post, both quoting 2 different people speaking of guns concerning this matter, AND questioning "who mentioned guns?"????????????

Why is that? What is the point of this post?



And by the way, care to comment on exactly how it is the good Mr. Whitlock can make the assertation that "if Jovan Belcher didn’t possess/own a gun, he and his girlfriend would both be alive today" and it go not ONLY completely unchallenged by, but actually silently promoted by, all of our "facts matter" lovin' libs on here?

Any ideas?
 
Costas has a right to his opinion, but in expressing his opinion in a national forum he bears the responsibility of being criticized.
 
"if Jovan Belcher didn’t possess/own a gun, he and his girlfriend would both be alive today."

A very presumptive statement but typical of a large part of the uninformed knee jerkers and Monday morning quarterbacks, Belcher was a big strong man and had the capability to kill in many ways. Yes a handgun, if available, is easy and quick albeit noisy, but then there are many different was that could have been used to kill. Knife, baseball bat, strangulation, garrote, poison, bludgeoning with a faggot and so on.

So what's your point?
 
"if Jovan Belcher didn’t possess/own a gun, he and his girlfriend would both be alive today."

A very presumptive statement but typical of a large part of the uninformed knee jerkers and Monday morning quarterbacks, Belcher was a big strong man and had the capability to kill in many ways. Yes a handgun, if available, is easy and quick albeit noisy, but then there are many different was that could have been used to kill. Knife, baseball bat, strangulation, garrote, poison, bludgeoning with a faggot and so on.

So what's your point?

strangle, knife, baseball bat as opposed to a gun --> more time for the perp to think about what he's doing, more time and chances for the victim to escape.
 
Usually the first one to mention guns and gun control after one of these killings is of course the NRA. They start right away to scream about the second Amendment and their rights and suggest we would be a lot safer with no rules or regulations about guns. I can just hear them saying that if his girlfriend would have been carrying, she could have shot him before he got her. LOL
 
Usually the first one to mention guns and gun control after one of these killings is of course the NRA. They start right away to scream about the second Amendment and their rights and suggest we would be a lot safer with no rules or regulations about guns. I can just hear them saying that if his girlfriend would have been carrying, she could have shot him before he got her. LOL

yeah, even better if the mother-in-law and 3 month old had been packing.
 
Usually the first one to mention guns and gun control after one of these killings is of course the NRA. They start right away to scream about the second Amendment and their rights and suggest we would be a lot safer with no rules or regulations about guns. I can just hear them saying that if his girlfriend would have been carrying, she could have shot him before he got her. LOL

Nonsense. No one deplores a murder where a firearm was used more than he active gun hobbyists that make up the NRA membership (I've been a life member for more than a decade, and I'm currently a Patron member). Why would we deplore it? Because we inevitably bear the blame for someone elses' bad behavior. Most gun control measures are effectively the same fighting drunken driving by taking the driving privilege away from people who don't drive while intoxicated. Most gun owners neither harm anyone else nor harm themselves in many years of owning firearms.

After this incident: http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/201...then-shot-arrow-at-dad-in-class-cops-say?lite should we institute a ban on bow and arrows? Kitchen knives?
 
I don't think the criticism is unwarranted. Even if you agree with Costas' opinion, his choice of venue is questionable.

the entire NFL was still in shock from the homicide/suicide. Costas just addressed the elephant in the room. I'm glad he did.
 
Usually the first one to mention guns and gun control after one of these killings is of course the NRA. They start right away to scream about the second Amendment and their rights and suggest we would be a lot safer with no rules or regulations about guns. I can just hear them saying that if his girlfriend would have been carrying, she could have shot him before he got her. LOL

LOL all you like but that will do nothing to alter the FACT that our cities and states with the most strict gun laws also lead the country in gun related deaths and crimes while the states with the easiest concealed weapons laws are at the bottom in the same crimes.

So while I know of no one who has so much as even insinuated let alone openly stating that if his girlfriend would have been carrying, she could have shot him before he got her, IF anyone DID it would be a harder thing to put down IF the actual facts were reviewed as opposed to your "feelings" on the matter.
 
the entire NFL was still in shock from the homicide/suicide. Costas just addressed the elephant in the room. I'm glad he did.

Why would that be the elephant in the room? Current reports out of Kansas City indicate the shooter spent the night getting drunk with a different woman before coming home and shooting his girlfriend. Maybe the elephant in the room is that behavior, not gun ownership. Or perhaps this young man has taken enough head impacts that he is emotionally unstable, and the elephant in the room becomes concussions. Costas didn't bring up either subject (he probably didn't know about the other girlfriend as that was breaking news today). When it comes to concussions, that won't be brought up by a reporter as embedded with the NFL as Costas because he won't bite the hand that feeds him. So gun ownership becomes an easy target -- it is not the obvious one.

Of course, Costas was mostly quoting the former Kansas City Start columnist Jason Whitlock. Whitlock is a skilled writer, but his knowledge of anything outside football or basketball is extremely limited.
 
I don't think the criticism is unwarranted. Even if you agree with Costas' opinion, his choice of venue is questionable.

I don't see why. Sports have always been used as a launching point for discussing broader political issues. Consider, for example, the story of Jackie Robinson. Or Joe Louis v. Max Schmelling.
 
Why would that be the elephant in the room? Current reports out of Kansas City indicate the shooter spent the night getting drunk with a different woman before coming home and shooting his girlfriend. Maybe the elephant in the room is that behavior, not gun ownership. Or perhaps this young man has taken enough head impacts that he is emotionally unstable, and the elephant in the room becomes concussions. Costas didn't bring up either subject (he probably didn't know about the other girlfriend as that was breaking news today). When it comes to concussions, that won't be brought up by a reporter as embedded with the NFL as Costas because he won't bite the hand that feeds him. So gun ownership becomes an easy target -- it is not the obvious one.

Of course, Costas was mostly quoting the former Kansas City Start columnist Jason Whitlock. Whitlock is a skilled writer, but his knowledge of anything outside football or basketball is extremely limited.

Costa has, of course, discussed concussions on many occasions, notwithstanding your false assumptions.

http://blog.fora.tv/2012/05/bob-costas-football-is-unacceptably-brutal/

Possibly concussions factored in. But I'd be surprised if that was a big factor in violent crime, generally. The nations of Western Europe also have sports with high concussion risks (soccer concussions are rampant, from heading the ball, and there are all sorts of other sports like hurling and rugby to consider). Yet they have immensely lower violent crime rates than the US. Why are Americans five times as likely to kill each other as Western Europeans?

There are a lot of answers to that question, no doubt, ranging from more broken families to larger income inequality. But guns almost certainly factor in. The presence of a handy firearm reduces the practical distance between a murderous impulse and an actual murder. That results in some people crossing that distance who would otherwise have turned back.

I don't think guns are the number one factor that explains why our murder rate is so sharply higher than that of most of our peer nations. I'm not even sure they're in the top ten. But all the data I've seen suggests they are a meaningful factor. To see what I mean, compare the non-firearm homicide rate of various countries to the overall homicide rate in those countries. What you'll see is that the US has a non-firearm homicide rate that is elevated above other nations, but not elevated as much as its overall homicide rate. That's consistent with the theory that the US has underlying socio-economic conditions that are driving its homicide rate up, but that gun prevalence/gun culture is driving it up further from there. If we could reproduce the gun prevalence/gun culture present in countries like Japan and Western Europe, we'd probably wind up with a homicide rate that was still elevated over theirs, but only to the extent our non-firearm rates currently are, which would mean a lot of lives would be saved.

That doesn't, of course, mean that we have to restrict guns more than we do. We can see gun fetishism as something worth preserving (or, if you prefer, as something that is enshrined in the Constitution regardless of how worthy it is), even if it's resulting in thousands of preventable deaths. We needn't always pick the safer path. But we should be honest with ourselves about the choice. We shouldn't pretend that guns aren't a likely contributing factor to our nation's violence problems when all serious analysis suggests they are.
 
You are assuming there is some rationality in the person attempting to do the killing, people who are attempting to kill another are not rational
 
"if Jovan Belcher didn’t possess/own a gun, he and his girlfriend would both be alive today."

A very presumptive statement but typical of a large part of the uninformed knee jerkers and Monday morning quarterbacks, Belcher was a big strong man and had the capability to kill in many ways. Yes a handgun, if available, is easy and quick albeit noisy, but then there are many different was that could have been used to kill. Knife, baseball bat, strangulation, garrote, poison, bludgeoning with a faggot and so on.

So what's your point?

Yes. It's quite possible to kill other people and oneself without a gun. It's just a lot quicker, easier, more convenient, safer, surer, and less intimate with a gun. For many potential murderers/suicides, the added difficulties without a gun won't matter. They are sufficiently motivated, and psychologically formed in such a way that even if they have to bludgeon someone to death (with a slyly inserted slur or anything else), they'll do so. But for some meaningful portion of potential murderers/suicides, if you increase the degree of delay, difficulty, hassle, risk, uncertainty, and intimacy of the act, they'll lose their nerve, or have time to cool down.

So, if your point is that even without guns some people will still kill their girlfriends and themselves, and for all we know Belcher might have been one of them, you're right. We can't be sure that if he didn't have a gun he and she would still be alive. But if you mean to suggest that they'd definitely still be dead, that's also wrong. We can't be sure what kind of killer/suicide he was: the kind who would have been dissuaded if the murder and suicide hadn't been so conveniently at hand, or the kind who wouldn't. But it sure would be nice if potential murderers and suicides did need to pass that threshold psychological test before killing, so we'd weed out a lot of these avoidable tragedies.
 
Guns don't kill people...It is people that kill people...Unless of course it is Fast and Furious...Then Guns kill people...Oh wait a minute...Nevermind....Bravo for Costas telling those Second Amendment Ass Holes to stick it where the sun don't shine
 
Why would that be the elephant in the room? Current reports out of Kansas City indicate the shooter spent the night getting drunk with a different woman before coming home and shooting his girlfriend. Maybe the elephant in the room is that behavior, not gun ownership. Or perhaps this young man has taken enough head impacts that he is emotionally unstable, and the elephant in the room becomes concussions. Costas didn't bring up either subject (he probably didn't know about the other girlfriend as that was breaking news today). When it comes to concussions, that won't be brought up by a reporter as embedded with the NFL as Costas because he won't bite the hand that feeds him. So gun ownership becomes an easy target -- it is not the obvious one.

Of course, Costas was mostly quoting the former Kansas City Start columnist Jason Whitlock. Whitlock is a skilled writer, but his knowledge of anything outside football or basketball is extremely limited.

there's no need to be afraid of the country having this discussion of our "gun culture."
 
LOL all you like but that will do nothing to alter the FACT that our cities and states with the most strict gun laws also lead the country in gun related deaths and crimes while the states with the easiest concealed weapons laws are at the bottom in the same crimes.

So while I know of no one who has so much as even insinuated let alone openly stating that if his girlfriend would have been carrying, she could have shot him before he got her, IF anyone DID it would be a harder thing to put down IF the actual facts were reviewed as opposed to your "feelings" on the matter.

There are a lot of factors at work in gun related deaths.... one of the very most important being population density. Population density obviously means greater risk of accidental shootings (more likely to be someone in your line of fire), but more importantly it means: (1) more of the kinds of intense social interactions that can spark a violent confrontation (nobody cares whether their neighbor is playing his music too loud if he's half a mile down a country road, vs. in the apartment upstairs), and (2) more densely packed income inequality (the dirt poor on the same streets as the mega rich, which is a recipe for muggings).

That's why, if you look at the US throughout its history, and really all of human history, you'll see higher violent crime rates associated with cities. The analysis you're trying to get would reverse cause and effect. Densely packed cities have predictable violent crime issues, which then encourages gun control, which can give rise to a correlation between gun crime and gun control (when analyzed in a simple-minded fashion). But it's the crime causing the control, not vice versa.

The way to control for that is easy enough. Simply compare populations with similar settlement patterns but different gun laws. For example, compare red-state big cities (state level gun control matters than city level, since it's so easy to travel outside the city to get a gun) to blue-state big cities. For example, compare St. Louis to San Francisco. Or, alternately, compare rural blue states to rural red states, like Maine to Alaska. Or compare whole countries with different gun cultures but similar overall population patterns (e.g., the US v. Germany).

Doing that in a one-off way is, of course, problematic, since one could be accused of cherry-picking. Maybe comparing Maine to Alaska is unfair and we should be comparing Vermont to Mississippi, or something. But that's why professional criminologists and sociologists study these things in a much more rigorous way, to try to use regression analysis and various control methods to tease out exactly what's going on with large, complex data sets. It turns out, when you do that, a picture emerges of gun control being a meaningful factor in reducing crime.
 
Back
Top