New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Who's Your Daddy?

wobblies

Mayor
One of the biggest mistakes that rank and file Communist Partymembers made in the thirties was being led by the nose by the SovietUnion. Members had to eat crow whenStalin suddenly signed a treaty with Hitler and divided up Poland. It wasn’t until the ‘60s that regular membersbegan to speak for themselves. I metmany aged members of the party in my youth that I dearly respected; they were asincere, ethical lot. It’s not,therefore, from an anti-Communist position that I make this observation.
When a GOP talking head, however, says on Fox that he will deferto Israel about Iranian progress toward a nuclear arsenal, he is making a worsemistake: both the old CP and the current GOP are deferring to other countriesregarding foreign policy, but the GOP is surrendering our national security toa foreign power. They are saying that weshould defer a decision to go to war to another sovereign nation.
Both major parties have acted irresponsibly regarding Israeli behavior,but the GOP is so obsessed with beating the president in November that theywould blame fish for rain if it would get them a vote.

God Speed,
David

 
One of the biggest mistakes that rank and file Communist Partymembers made in the thirties was being led by the nose by the SovietUnion. Members had to eat crow whenStalin suddenly signed a treaty with Hitler and divided up Poland. It wasn’t until the ‘60s that regular membersbegan to speak for themselves. I metmany aged members of the party in my youth that I dearly respected; they were asincere, ethical lot. It’s not,therefore, from an anti-Communist position that I make this observation.
When a GOP talking head, however, says on Fox that he will deferto Israel about Iranian progress toward a nuclear arsenal, he is making a worsemistake: both the old CP and the current GOP are deferring to other countriesregarding foreign policy, but the GOP is surrendering our national security toa foreign power. They are saying that weshould defer a decision to go to war to another sovereign nation.
Both major parties have acted irresponsibly regarding Israeli behavior,but the GOP is so obsessed with beating the president in November that theywould blame fish for rain if it would get them a vote.

God Speed,
David


Mr. Wobblie,

That is a question that old, 1960s hippie socialist/communist and their fellow travelers tend to ask of each other.
 
Israel is directly threatened by an Iranian bomb, and their intelligence agencies are as good as any when it comes to certain avenues.

I for one have no problem with Jewish nukes.

Muslim pig humpers with the bomb????????


What's the worry right???? Listen to all the Democrats, anti semites, peaceniks, and communitarians, they are the mumpin authority on good taste afterall.
 
How can Israel be threatened by a bomb that doesn't exist? Are you aware that all of the 16 US intelligence services, plus the Israeli intelligence service, have stated that Iran does not have a nuclear weapons programme? The buzz word these days is "capability" - the capability to switch to a nuclear weapons programme if so desired.

You have no problem with a country that has attacked its neighbours several times against a country that has attacked no-one in centuries?

How can a non-nuclear weaponed country threaten one that has air, land, and sea, nuclear weapons delivery systems?
 
That's the first time I have ever heard ethical, sincere and Communist used in the same sentence
 
Muslim pig humpers with the bomb????????

This made me LOL.
Mostly because it's a beastiality reference that violates islamic beliefs. Goat or donkey humper would have scored just a little more credibility for your argument though. Mainly because that act does happen, and pretty often. But Idk about Iran, I've never been there, Iraq and Afghanistan it happens pretty often.:rolleyes:
 
Israel is directly threatened by an Iranian bomb, and their intelligence agencies are as good as any when it comes to certain avenues.

I for one have no problem with Jewish nukes.

Muslim pig humpers with the bomb????????


What's the worry right???? Listen to all the Democrats, anti semites, peaceniks, and communitarians, they are the mumpin authority on good taste afterall.

That wasn't the point of the post. I was pointing out that deferring to another country's analysis of foreign policy threats is unpatriotic and dangerous. Isreali foreign policy is geared to its own national security not ours. Israel is currently playing the GOP off of the president in an effort to influence our election, and they are playing both like puppets. George made the same mistake when he listened to Israel about Iraq, and we don't want to make the same mistake about Iran. By the way, bigotry is not the basis of foreign policy either.
 
I find it interesting that leftists are always so terribly concerned about Israel and it's supposed influence on U.S. foreign policy when it's Israel, population 8 million living in a tiny slice of sand (with no oil underneath) that is surrounded by 350 million Arabs, most of them insanely hostile to Israel. Iran's leaders have stated publicly and unequivocally that they intend to destroy Israel. Yes, much of that is probably hyperbole but it gets a bit more serious when you live in Israel, only 1000 miles from Iran, not the 7,000+ miles that the U.S. has between our country and Iran.

Israel is well protected out of necessity. The U.S. has supplied Israel with the latest technologically advanced weapons and warning systems available. The U.S. sends Israel aid worth about 3 billion per year, mostly for Israeli defense. That is less than 1% of the total U.S. foreign aid budget (approximately 50 billion). For years, Israel has been attacked almost daily by HAMAS and other Palestinian terror groups. Israel has been forced to fight 3 wars and 4 'mini-wars' their neighbors inflicted on them yet Israel has never requested American troops. Never. The barely-hidden animosity that some leftist politicians show toward tiny Israel, a functioning democracy since 1948, is troubling.

As always, it isn't the nuclear weapons that are the real problem but, who has their finger on the launch button. Israel acquired nuclear weapons almost 50 years ago. Its obvious that they have been cautious and responsible about having them, considering all the attacks Israel has endured. Iran has demonstrated it is more than willing to support Islamic terrorism and wants to acquire hegemony in the middle east. Having nuclear weapons would certainly go a long way to accomplishing that dubious goal. For Israel to be complacent about this threat would be irresponsible. A politician stating that he would 'defer' to Israel on Iran acquiring nuclear weapons means that if Israel decides to attack Iran's nuclear plants, the U.S. won't stop them because if Iran 'goes nuclear', it's Israelis that will be severely threatened, not Americans. That is hardly 'allowing' Israel to shape U.S. foreign policy but simply facing a harsh reality. Something Israelis do every day.
 
I find it interesting that leftists are always so terribly concerned about Israel and it's supposed influence on U.S. foreign policy when it's Israel, population 8 million living in a tiny slice of sand (with no oil underneath) that is surrounded by 350 million Arabs, most of them insanely hostile to Israel. Iran's leaders have stated publicly and unequivocally that they intend to destroy Israel. Yes, much of that is probably hyperbole but it gets a bit more serious when you live in Israel, only 1000 miles from Iran, not the 7,000+ miles that the U.S. has between our country and Iran.

Israel is well protected out of necessity. The U.S. has supplied Israel with the latest technologically advanced weapons and warning systems available. The U.S. sends Israel aid worth about 3 billion per year, mostly for Israeli defense. That is less than 1% of the total U.S. foreign aid budget (approximately 50 billion). For years, Israel has been attacked almost daily by HAMAS and other Palestinian terror groups. Israel has been forced to fight 3 wars and 4 'mini-wars' their neighbors inflicted on them yet Israel has never requested American troops. Never. The barely-hidden animosity that some leftist politicians show toward tiny Israel, a functioning democracy since 1948, is troubling.

As always, it isn't the nuclear weapons that are the real problem but, who has their finger on the launch button. Israel acquired nuclear weapons almost 50 years ago. Its obvious that they have been cautious and responsible about having them, considering all the attacks Israel has endured. Iran has demonstrated it is more than willing to support Islamic terrorism and wants to acquire hegemony in the middle east. Having nuclear weapons would certainly go a long way to accomplishing that dubious goal. For Israel to be complacent about this threat would be irresponsible. A politician stating that he would 'defer' to Israel on Iran acquiring nuclear weapons means that if Israel decides to attack Iran's nuclear plants, the U.S. won't stop them because if Iran 'goes nuclear', it's Israelis that will be severely threatened, not Americans. That is hardly 'allowing' Israel to shape U.S. foreign policy but simply facing a harsh reality. Something Israelis do every day.

I iterate: the point is allowing another country to determine our foreign policy. I heard a GOP talking head say that he would defer an analysis about Iran's status as a nuclear power, and I find such a comment unpatriotic. Do you agree with that comment being unpatriotic?
 
I iterate: the point is allowing another country to determine our foreign policy. I heard a GOP talking head say that he would defer an analysis about Iran's status as a nuclear power, and I find such a comment unpatriotic. Do you agree with that comment being unpatriotic?

No, I do not but unless it is a Republican U.S. president making that comment, it is not terribly important. I also iterate that Israel is far more affected by Iran developing a deliverable nuclear weapon than the U.S. Israel also has better intelligence in Iran than the U.S. due to their proximity and need for knowing how threatened they are at any given moment. That is probably why Israel has not attacked Iran's nuclear facilities...yet.

To elucidate: developing U.S. foreign policy regarding the use of military force against Iran to prevent them from developing a nuclear weapon by employing Israeli intelligence is hardly 'unpatriotic'. The canard that U.S. foreign policy is surreptitiously dictated by the interests of the Israeli government is rubbish. Had that been the case, the U.S. would have attacked Iran years ago. The 1979 kidnapping of U.S. embassy employees and holding them hostage in the U.S. embassy - legally neutral ground - for over a year would have given the U.S. all the excuse it needed to attack Iran and that would have certainly pleased Israel. We didn't. The canard that Israel 'controls' U.S. foreign policy has been bandied around for years by leftists but with little real evidence aside from the vivid imaginations of those hostile to Israels survival. Ironically, American Jews are some of the biggest supporters of the Democrat party. Go figure.

For some odd reason, the political left seems to hold a latent animosity toward Israel and bristles at any politician that is sensitive to their precarious situation as a country surrounded by enemies that threaten them with destruction on a regular basis. Recognizing Israel's unique position in the middle east and it's vulnerability as well as it's capability to gather intel on Iran's nuclear program is something U.S. officials - under both Republican and Democrat administrations - have been doing for decades. The Obama administration's distinct coolness toward Israel is something new for the U.S.
 
No, I do not but unless it is a Republican U.S. president making that comment, it is not terribly important. I also iterate that Israel is far more affected by Iran developing a deliverable nuclear weapon than the U.S. Israel also has better intelligence in Iran than the U.S. due to their proximity and need for knowing how threatened they are at any given moment. That is probably why Israel has not attacked Iran's nuclear facilities...yet.

To elucidate: developing U.S. foreign policy regarding the use of military force against Iran to prevent them from developing a nuclear weapon by employing Israeli intelligence is hardly 'unpatriotic'. The canard that U.S. foreign policy is surreptitiously dictated by the interests of the Israeli government is rubbish. Had that been the case, the U.S. would have attacked Iran years ago. The 1979 kidnapping of U.S. embassy employees and holding them hostage in the U.S. embassy - legally neutral ground - for over a year would have given the U.S. all the excuse it needed to attack Iran and that would have certainly pleased Israel. We didn't. The canard that Israel 'controls' U.S. foreign policy has been bandied around for years by leftists but with little real evidence aside from the vivid imaginations of those hostile to Israels survival. Ironically, American Jews are some of the biggest supporters of the Democrat party. Go figure.

For some odd reason, the political left seems to hold a latent animosity toward Israel and bristles at any politician that is sensitive to their precarious situation as a country surrounded by enemies that threaten them with destruction on a regular basis. Recognizing Israel's unique position in the middle east and it's vulnerability as well as it's capability to gather intel on Iran's nuclear program is something U.S. officials - under both Republican and Democrat administrations - have been doing for decades. The Obama administration's distinct coolness toward Israel is something new for the U.S.

I do not understand why anyone would defend suggesting that we should defer our foreign policy analysis to Israel from any talking head. Furthermore, you wrote, "To elucidate: developing U.S. foreign policy regarding the use of military force against Iran to prevent them from developing a nuclear weapon by employing Israeli intelligence is hardly 'unpatriotic'." I didn't write that.

I also don't understand how anyone can defend Israeli influence on American policy: virtually no one in any significant national political position dares criticizes Israeli aggression let alone acknowledge it. The only national figure with the courage to stand up to Israel has been President Carter. Zionism has a lock on the congressional leadership and the presidency. Zionists want to attack a country's nuclear facility even though we cannot destroy those facilities without an invasion. That is not a winnable war, and Zionist know it. GOP leaders know this also but want to jack up petroleum prices for their fat cat friends and to weaken the president's re-election chances.

Your comment about American hostages was ahistoric: we funded a war against Iran that included the use of weapons of mass destruction-poison gases. Ronnie even blew up an Iranian passenger plane with no apoligies.

Your comment about American Jews is irrelevant: the issue is Zionism not being a Jew. The bravest critics of Israel have always been Jewish, including Einstein. Jews have had the courage to stand up to taking land by force from Palestinians since the founding of Israel. Zionists that try to cover up that aggression as part of an effort to garner support for Israeli aggression pose a threat to our national security because of it.

Zionists that defend the barbarous Israeli attack on the USS Liberty or the murder of Rachel Corey are taking a side against America. It is that simple. Zionist that ape Israeli canards about Iraq or Iran want to spill American blood for another nation: that is unpatriotic and traitorous.

We have been fighting a proxy war against Iran for 3 decades. It is time to end the hostility and make peace with Iran. That is not going to be easy because there is some loopy leadership in that country, but we owe it to our children to try.

God Speed,
David
 
Obviously, you view Israel as an aggressor that the U.S. caters to. I find that absurd. Your use of the term 'Zionist' is telling because it's exactly the same term Muslim fanatics seeking to kill 8 million Israelis use on a regular basis. Its never about Jews, only 'Zionists'...meaning Israelis, who just happen to be predominately Jews. Who are you kidding? The comment about the U.S. making peace with Iran, who you apparently view as an aggrieved party in this situation demonstrates either a profound ignorance of the motivations and publicly stated goals of the entrenched Iranian theocracy to utterly destroy Israel and, if possible, do much harm to the U.S. or simply a deliberate disregard for reality. In any case, we are so far apart on this issue that it is futile to attempt to discuss it. Fortunately, most Americans do not share your views of an aggressor Israel that dictates U.S. foreign policy and a put-upon Iran, mistreated by the U.S. in the past, that deserves to be seen as a friend we just haven't made yet. That kind of fantasy may play well elsewhere - including in the Obama administration - but for me and many others Americans it is simply ridiculous and smacks of Iranian propaganda rather than a responsible position. We're all entitled to our opinions but on this issue, I simply cannot take yours very seriously.
 
That's the first time I have ever heard ethical, sincere and Communist used in the same sentence

I guess you've never had the pleasure of knowing a sincere, non-dogmatic Communist who defends Democracy and the rights of working people. I've read about and known some Communists that were aholes, but I respect most American Communists.
 
Ah, Jim. Israel Uber Alles eh?

Israel surrounded by countries that want to destroy them - name them. Egypt has a peace treaty. As do Jordan, and Saudi Arabia. Syria doesn't like Israel, mainly because Israel has continued to hold on to land that belongs to Syria. The Lebanon isn't that fond of Israel, maybe because Israel keeps attacking it. Iran has never stated, publicly, that it wants to destroy Israel, it has called for the removal of the Zionist regime in Israel, just as Israel constantly calls for a regime change in Iran. Condemn one, and you have to condemn the other.

As for all the wars you mentioned. Are you aware that Israel started most of them? The pre-emptive strikes on various countries that started the '67 war.

The term; Zionist, wasn't thought up by Jew haters, it was brought into being by extreme Jews who wanted to establish a "Greater Israel" stretching from the Nile to the Euphrates. They called themselves "Zionists".

As for no oil, or gas, under Israeli sands. Haven't you heard of the extremely large deposits of oil and gas off of the Israeli, Lebanon, Gaza, shores. Mind, the finding of those deposits will probably mean the end for those existing in the Gaza strip. I can see no way that Israel will allow Gaza to benefit from those deposits.

You believe that Israel has no influence on US policies! You must be mad, blind, or deaf. Never heard of AIPAC?
 
How can Israel be threatened by a bomb that doesn't exist? Are you aware that all of the 16 US intelligence services, plus the Israeli intelligence service, have stated that Iran does not have a nuclear weapons programme? The buzz word these days is "capability" - the capability to switch to a nuclear weapons programme if so desired.

You have no problem with a country that has attacked its neighbours several times against a country that has attacked no-one in centuries?

How can a non-nuclear weaponed country threaten one that has air, land, and sea, nuclear weapons delivery systems?

This is one time your avatar really works,Wulk!:eek:)
 
This made me LOL.
Mostly because it's a beastiality reference that violates islamic beliefs. Goat or donkey humper would have scored just a little more credibility for your argument though. Mainly because that act does happen, and pretty often. But Idk about Iran, I've never been there, Iraq and Afghanistan it happens pretty often.:rolleyes:

Spoken from one who knows:eek:) Welcome to the board, Cynabol86;302063. We may shorten your nic in later posts.
 
Back
Top