New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Why does the present administration PROTECT

Jen

Senator
Muslim extremists such that they leap to give this guy his Miranda rights before even checking him out enough to see if he might be termed an "enemy combatant" so we can get information from him before he lawyers up?????? WTH?????

Under the law that Lindsey Graham wrote, the Obama administration could deem Jokar an "enemy combatant" and get the information and still try him in a civilian court. He is not eligible to be tried by a military tribunal since he is a USA citizen. But he can be given enemy combatant status if he meets certain criteria and at this point it looks like he might meet that criteria.

What has been done will get him lawyered up and shut him up thus giving us NO information that we may need to remain safe.

This LINK will explain what I am trying to say.
 
Check out the law, Jen, and how it applies to American citizens. Hamdi v Rumsfeld. And if they violated the law would you then be screaming WTH???
 
Muslim extremists such that they leap to give this guy his Miranda rights before even checking him out enough to see if he might be termed an "enemy combatant" so we can get information from him before he lawyers up?????? WTH?????

Under the law that Lindsey Graham wrote, the Obama administration could deem Jokar an "enemy combatant" and get the information and still try him in a civilian court. He is not eligible to be tried by a military tribunal since he is a USA citizen. But he can be given enemy combatant status if he meets certain criteria and at this point it looks like he might meet that criteria.

What has been done will get him lawyered up and shut him up thus giving us NO information that we may need to remain safe.

This LINK will explain what I am trying to say.

You're entitled to your (borrowed) opinion of course. Mine is that I prefer the administration protect American citizens rather than further erode our rights. Further, they didn't "rush" to mirandize him. Finally, unless he's been living in a cave and has never seen a single Law&Order, he already knows he has a right to remain silent. Apparently from reports, he has not been completely silent.
 
Who gives a shit what he says? They never have to use a word he utters from now til the end of his miserable existence and still get him thrown behind bars for multiple lifetimes.
 
Discussing anything that requires intelligent thought is a waste of time with you. That wind that just blew over your head? Never mind, it's way past your common sense threshold.
 
Constitutional rights don't apply to Native Americans, Blacks, Catholics, Mormons, Chinese, Irish, Jehovah's Witnesses, Jews, Japanese, anarchists, Germans, Italians, communists, queers, Wiccans, Latinos, Satanists, or Muslims. Other than that, it's liberty and justice for all. Except hippies. :hippie:
 
Great insults, with no grip on the subject matter.

Typical. That's why I end up correcting you and then just moving on. You can't stay on topic, don't remember who you're even debating and seldom have the facts accurate. Just a waste of time.
 
I understand the process that would have to be followed. But there needed to be time between the moment he was apprehended and the time where he lawyers up to find out about certain things: [1] who was financing the brothers; [2]what happened in the older brother's trip overseas; [3] how did they learn to make those bombs; [4]info regarding future bombings in the works (if they were part of a group); and probably a few more things I haven't thought of.

If he gets a lawyer now, there is no chance at getting this information. He still gets due process of law, but if he is deemed an enemy combatant, those questions will be able to be asked and just maybe some answers might save others.

It is quite possible that this young man was bullied by his obviously controlling older brother and if he isn't bullied by his new lawyer he will talk to those questioning him. He may not. But it looks like we won't find out.

My initial question was why does this administration seem to protect enemy combatants (especially if they are of Middle Eastern or Muslim origins)? THAT is the question I would like to have answered.

And really, I don't think you are in a position to make a good guess about what I might scream about so let's just leave the personal comments out of it. I tend not to even validate posts that go straight to personal commentary with a response (but you don't do that, so I always try to respond to you. Thanks for that).

Jen

Check out the law, Jen, and how it applies to American citizens. Hamdi v Rumsfeld. And if they violated the law would you then be screaming WTH???
 
Yes. Under that law, even if he gives answers they are inadmissible in his trial. I am fine with that. He is protected as he should be. And they have enough on him that they don't need anything he has to say to convict him. Getting him to talk just might save a few people. It won't affect his trial at all.

And I just must comment.......... apparently ALL of BT's ideas are completely and totally original. Have you ever known anyone who never ever thought anything anyone else thought.........who was 100% original? I haven't. Wow. That BT is impressive. :eyebrows:

And if they don't mirandize him, whatever he says is inadmissible.
 
I was going to your "WHT". First of all, he was in no condition to even be questioned. but when they did question him they say he openly responded to their inquiries. I don't see him as someone who intends to hide anything, but I coiuld be wrong. But the simple fact is he is an American citizen, and is guaranteed rights whether we like it or not. And he can not be classified as an enemy combatant, so it is not this administrations place to determine how he will be handled. The judicial system is a separate power of government.
 
The administration may have to make that call (that's information I am not certain of). And it would be more a formality to allow him to be questioned without a lawyer than anything else. Once he has a lawyer, that lawyer's duty is to tell him not to speak. But if he gets the enemy combatant designation, he can be questioned (without a lawyer); what he says can't be used against him in the trial;and he can (and would be expected to) contest the designation and possibly get it removed.

It is the right thing to do. But for some reason the administration doesn't seem to want to cooperate and get the information that is so much needed.

I was going to your "WHT". First of all, he was in no condition to even be questioned. but when they did question him they say he openly responded to their inquiries. I don't see him as someone who intends to hide anything, but I coiuld be wrong. But the simple fact is he is an American citizen, and is guaranteed rights whether we like it or not. And he can not be classified as an enemy combatant, so it is not this administrations place to determine how he will be handled. The judicial system is a separate power of government.
 
Jen, you're going in circles. He was questioned, and he's been responding. I don't know how you see the present administration was obstructing that.
 
I understood that he was questioned and then Mirandized thus stopping any questioning until he got a lawyer.
And it appears to be the administration that makes the designation or not.........

Things are still falling into place. I don't think anything is written in stone and I hope this administration does the right thing if it is their place to make that designation.

I withdraw any perceived judgment against the administration, but I stand by what I've said.........that he needs to be given the designation (without obstruction) and questioned before he gets a lawyer.

Can you agree with that at all?

Jen, you're going in circles. He was questioned, and he's been responding. I don't know how you see the present administration was obstructing that.
 
Yes. Under that law, even if he gives answers they are inadmissible in his trial. I am fine with that. He is protected as he should be. And they have enough on him that they don't need anything he has to say to convict him. Getting him to talk just might save a few people. It won't affect his trial at all.

And I just must comment.......... apparently ALL of BT's ideas are completely and totally original. Have you ever known anyone who never ever thought anything anyone else thought.........who was 100% original? I haven't. Wow. That BT is impressive. :eyebrows:

He WAS questioned without being advised of his Miranda rights (for hours) under the "public safety exception," under which statements made CAN be admitted according to the Supreme Court.
 
Let me understand. You say 'given the designation', you mean enemy combatant? And do you further mean detention and torture in order to get more than what he's already volunteered? If that's the case, no I don't. That only opens a worse can of worms, in my estimation. He's already volunteered that they were not connected to any international group, and that they planned the plot and carried it out themselves. He claims it was their own idea, and learned to make the bombs by searching the internet. To me this is just another Timothy McVeigh. You do understand the history behind him, don't you.

Now you might think he was lying, but how often does a terrorist group deny involvement in some incident?
 
Detention. Not torture.
And please don't be condescending to me.


Let me understand. You say 'given the designation', you mean enemy combatant? And do you further mean detention and torture in order to get more than what he's already volunteered? If that's the case, no I don't. That only opens a worse can of worms, in my estimation. He's already volunteered that they were not connected to any international group, and that they planned the plot and carried it out themselves. He claims it was their own idea, and learned to make the bombs by searching the internet. To me this is just another Timothy McVeigh. You do understand the history behind him, don't you.

Now you might think he was lying, but how often does a terrorist group deny involvement in some incident?
 
It may be just another Timothy McVeigh. But there are questions that need to be answered to know that. And we haven't dealt with Chechnyan terrorists enough to know if they will own up to what they've done or not. I think our safety is important that we shouldn't just assume things.

Good night Wahbooz.
I've enjoyed this.

Let me understand. You say 'given the designation', you mean enemy combatant? And do you further mean detention and torture in order to get more than what he's already volunteered? If that's the case, no I don't. That only opens a worse can of worms, in my estimation. He's already volunteered that they were not connected to any international group, and that they planned the plot and carried it out themselves. He claims it was their own idea, and learned to make the bombs by searching the internet. To me this is just another Timothy McVeigh. You do understand the history behind him, don't you.

Now you might think he was lying, but how often does a terrorist group deny involvement in some incident?
 
Back
Top