New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Why doesn't innocence matter

Citizen

Council Member
Seriously, when one is INNOCENT it should matter:



Thomas Arthur is on Alabama’s death row, convicted of a crime that another man has since confessed to committing. Despite this confession and many other irregularities that have surfaced, the state has set his execution date for March 29, just weeks away.

Write Governor Robert Bentley and urge him to allow Thomas Arthur’s legal team to conduct the DNA testing that could spare his life.

After the confession, the Alabama Supreme Court stayed Mr. Arthur’s execution and remanded his case to the trial court for an evidentiary hearing. The court ordered limited DNA testing of the wig that all parties agree was worn by the perpetrator. Although DNA was found on the wig, the Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences lacks the technology to develop a profile. Thomas Arthur and his attorneys want to re-test the wig, using more advanced DNA technology. But the state of Alabama won’t allow it, even though the defense is willing to pay for the testing!

It is unacceptable that the state of Alabama is prepared to put a potentially innocent man to death rather than let him conduct a simple test that could prove his innocence.

Write Governor Robert Bentley and urge him to allow Thomas Arthur’s legal team to conduct the DNA testing that could spare his life.

Yours in justice,

Jason Kreag
Staff Attorney
The Innocence Project
 
Seriously, when one is INNOCENT it should matter:



Thomas Arthur is on Alabama’s death row, convicted of a crime that another man has since confessed to committing. Despite this confession and many other irregularities that have surfaced, the state has set his execution date for March 29, just weeks away.

Write Governor Robert Bentley and urge him to allow Thomas Arthur’s legal team to conduct the DNA testing that could spare his life.

After the confession, the Alabama Supreme Court stayed Mr. Arthur’s execution and remanded his case to the trial court for an evidentiary hearing. The court ordered limited DNA testing of the wig that all parties agree was worn by the perpetrator. Although DNA was found on the wig, the Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences lacks the technology to develop a profile. Thomas Arthur and his attorneys want to re-test the wig, using more advanced DNA technology. But the state of Alabama won’t allow it, even though the defense is willing to pay for the testing!

It is unacceptable that the state of Alabama is prepared to put a potentially innocent man to death rather than let him conduct a simple test that could prove his innocence.

Write Governor Robert Bentley and urge him to allow Thomas Arthur’s legal team to conduct the DNA testing that could spare his life.

Yours in justice,

Jason Kreag
Staff Attorney
The Innocence Project

It is ironic, isn't it? The Justice System delivering what is arguably the very antithesis of justice...

Then again, justice is largely accidental and often illusory -- maybe most especially within the confines of our Justice System. Mostly what our system delivers is social control -- per the dictates of the majority -- and institutionalized vengeance. In that context, what matters most is reliability and a sufficient measure of efficiency. Justice receives her due deference, but is usually forced to take a seat in the back nonetheless.

Cheers.
 
Seems like a sad case. I'm not familiar with all the facts of the case, and I don't know if he's innocent or guilty. But if we're going to make and error, I have always said I prefer to err on the side of life. He's not going anywhere, let's make sure we get it right before we do anything we can't undo.
 
It is ironic, isn't it? The Justice System delivering what is arguably the very antithesis of justice...

Then again, justice is largely accidental and often illusory -- maybe most especially within the confines of our Justice System. Mostly what our system delivers is social control -- per the dictates of the majority -- and institutionalized vengeance. In that context, what matters most is reliability and a sufficient measure of efficiency. Justice receives her due deference, but is usually forced to take a seat in the back nonetheless.

Cheers.

you buy justice just like you buy toilet paper,,go cheap,,you get burned....
 
Look -- I don't disagree. I think the testing should be allowed. Let's get that straight up front.

Now -- look at it from the prosecution standpoint. You have presented evidence to a jury, the jury has ruled the suspect guilty. It's a death penalty case, so there have been multiple appeals, and all of them have gone against the suspect.

Then you have the word of a criminal that your seemingly valid verdict is untrue, and you have scientific evidence that you can't confirm. Do you overturn an already multiply contested conviction? At what point is enough trial enough?
 
It DOES "work," Citizen.

You just need Money and/or Power to go along with it.

See, it is like this: In the American INjustice system, in order to "win" a court case, one needs to be at least Two of the following Three: Guilty. Rich. Politically Powerful.

Now, if you have ALL THREE, then, more than likely, you skate.

If you have only TWO, then, it might be a bit tougher, but, you have a fighting chance.

Have only ONE, and, you are likely going to get convicted.

If you are "innocent," and, have neither Money, or Political Connections...go ahead and prepare for whatever punishment our Legal Masters wish to deliver upon you.

Seriously, it's that simple.......
 
No, it isn't that simple. No matter what name we hang on it, we don't have a "justice system" we have a legal system. It promises "due process of law" not perfect justice.

Under the laws that run that system, this man has received due process and a verdict has been rendered -- at least that's the argument any state government or prosecutor would make. How many appeals are enough appeals to render a final verdict?
 
Back
Top