New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Why I support Snowden.

afella

Mayor
Regardless of what he reveals about black ops operations, with the exception of nuclear launch codes, or further technological advances, I support the actions that he has taken. Everything that he has revealed, so far, has been a simple, "Oh really, you don't say." moment. We hack China? Really? I never would have guessed. Our government stores our personal information, through an approved "court" system known as FISA to justify its legality? You don't say.


Nothing he has revealed is new knowledge, to some. However, to the mainstream US citizen, who is far to busy to read, research or contemplate legislation such as the patriot act, or the follow up NDAA's, this was starteling news. Not so much that it is going on, but the degree and volume it has become.


Some say snowden is a spy. If that is the case I would have some very strong moral objections to those serving our government today. If it would take a spy to release this type of information, and not a US citizen looking out for our nation and its best interests, then we have some serious ethical issues within our government (we do anyway regardless of this case) and how we view our government should operate in regards to the constitution and general respect for peoples privacy. Forget legality for a minute and focus on principle.


Then we have the FISA courts. The "oversight" of our governments outreach of the patriot act, and subsequent acts. Their record speaks for itself, at how effective it is. Either that or the Bush and Obama administrations have some lawyers who can adjust the rule of law so finely, that anything is legal for the government to do. As long as they go through the FISA courts. I think this is the real issue of this whole mess, which is being brought to the table.


I don't support the release of names by snowden, or much of the foreign intel he has revealed. His ability to push, to the forefront throughout the US, our governments keeping of private information is a very honorable thing to do, and supercedes and damage he may or already has done.
 
Why I do not support Snowden:

First off he's a coward that ran from this country asylum in Hong Kong and not standing his ground against the Tyranny he claims to be fighting... A real man would have stayed and fought our government on our shores and not over in Hong Kong while trying to get a happy ending in many ways...

Second, the leak information about spying on Americans is old news... After the passing of the patriot act and even before that it was expected our government spied on us by using the FISA courts and other means... Now when he leaked the fact we were and are hacking other countries computers, well that was not wise... Even though it is common knowledge that our government along with other countries like Israel have hacked countries like China and Iran, but giving them the intel about that we did do it and them finding out how is no longer whistleblowing but treason...

Finally, when he gave information and U.K. spy program that spied on other countries, well he damaged relations with the U.K. while giving Russia ammo to use against us... That action alone will get him killed by the U.K. and he should be sent to the afterlife...

So Snowden is not hero, whistleblow, and in fact is a traitor... I do not believe he works for China but I do believe that what he has done and will do is to gain fame and money which will happen from book deals and movies... So no he's not someone that I will support and he's a traitor to our fine nation and allies...
 
Why I do not support Snowden:

First off he's a coward that ran from this country asylum in Hong Kong and not standing his ground against the Tyranny he claims to be fighting... A real man would have stayed and fought our government on our shores and not over in Hong Kong while trying to get a happy ending in many ways...

Second, the leak information about spying on Americans is old news... After the passing of the patriot act and even before that it was expected our government spied on us by using the FISA courts and other means... Now when he leaked the fact we were and are hacking other countries computers, well that was not wise... Even though it is common knowledge that our government along with other countries like Israel have hacked countries like China and Iran, but giving them the intel about that we did do it and them finding out how is no longer whistleblowing but treason...

Finally, when he gave information and U.K. spy program that spied on other countries, well he damaged relations with the U.K. while giving Russia ammo to use against us... That action alone will get him killed by the U.K. and he should be sent to the afterlife...

So Snowden is not hero, whistleblow, and in fact is a traitor... I do not believe he works for China but I do believe that what he has done and will do is to gain fame and money which will happen from book deals and movies... So no he's not someone that I will support and he's a traitor to our fine nation and allies...

"Fight our government"? Our government....you know, the one with unlimited (taxpayer) funds?

Get real...you either end up in prison, or dead. What kind of lopsided "fight" is that?
 
I support Snowden. Have from day one.

Why?

You do understand what he is leaking has been going on before Obama became President so that mean you objected to the NSA spying when Bush was President or only when Obama became President???

Be honest and tell me is the true reason why you support Snowden is because he's giving Obama a black-eye, and before you call me a racist for using the word black with Obama just answer the question!?!

If Snowden had done this while Bush was President I would still call him a traitor, coward, and many other things, but it puzzles me how those that once supported the NSA abuse are now upset to find out Obama is no different than Bush when it come to spying on the entire world...
 
You can't half support him. He is judged on everything he did.


He has done nothing, as far as I know, that is actually detrimental to US national security. He reaffirmed our ability, to an extent, to make a difference as one person to ensure that our constitutional rights aren't trampled on by our government. He has done next to nothing, but provide proof of our governments overstepping on our basic rights, the rights that our country was founded on and should live by.
 
Why I do not support Snowden:

First off he's a coward that ran from this country asylum in Hong Kong and not standing his ground against the Tyranny he claims to be fighting... A real man would have stayed and fought our government on our shores and not over in Hong Kong while trying to get a happy ending in many ways...

Second, the leak information about spying on Americans is old news... After the passing of the patriot act and even before that it was expected our government spied on us by using the FISA courts and other means... Now when he leaked the fact we were and are hacking other countries computers, well that was not wise... Even though it is common knowledge that our government along with other countries like Israel have hacked countries like China and Iran, but giving them the intel about that we did do it and them finding out how is no longer whistleblowing but treason...

Finally, when he gave information and U.K. spy program that spied on other countries, well he damaged relations with the U.K. while giving Russia ammo to use against us... That action alone will get him killed by the U.K. and he should be sent to the afterlife...

So Snowden is not hero, whistleblow, and in fact is a traitor... I do not believe he works for China but I do believe that what he has done and will do is to gain fame and money which will happen from book deals and movies... So no he's not someone that I will support and he's a traitor to our fine nation and allies...


I wouldn't disagree that he is a coward, does not pertain to the point however.

Agreed that the information that he released is old news, the whole lot of it. It's why I support him. He provided evidence, other than government words, to the fact that it was happening. He has also forced groups like google, facebook, or yahoo to provide numbers, something we had no idea of before hand. He also shined the light on the Utah facility, which has been well known about since day one yet never formally admitted. IT IS good to know what our government has the ability to do, and what they are doing with their recently found freedoms since the patriot act was passed. While this operation has essentially been going on for sometime, the patriot act gave the government essentially free will to do what they please.


As far as I can tell from what I have read, the UK's actions were in their own "national interest" and betrayed the trust of other nations. Given the circumstances of that spying, it would have betrayed the concept of the meeting involved and the supposed trust involved.

As western nations we should hold ourselves to a higher standard, not the same standard as China or Russia. Our government can't provide that, so it's good that a citizen can.
 
He has done nothing, as far as I know, that is actually detrimental to US national security. He reaffirmed our ability, to an extent, to make a difference as one person to ensure that our constitutional rights aren't trampled on by our government. He has done next to nothing, but provide proof of our governments overstepping on our basic rights, the rights that our country was founded on and should live by.

The US information release he gave was already known.

I'm talking about him giving actual names and details of who in China the US was doing covert actions on and handing the data to China as well as informing Russia about the UK covert monitoring of Putin etc. You'll have to look it up. I see no reason to believe that if that is not bad enough he has not done more - and worse. He gives every indication of being a global spy. He is not a hero.
 
The US information release he gave was already known.

I'm talking about him giving actual names and details of who in China the US was doing covert actions on and handing the data to China as well as informing Russia about the UK covert monitoring of Putin etc. You'll have to look it up. I see no reason to believe that if that is not bad enough he has not done more - and worse. He gives every indication of being a global spy. He is not a hero.

I've read hear-say and possibilities, nothing more. Do you have any specific names of Chineese officials who have been targetted and now revealed through Snowdens admissions? I surely haven't. There is no proof to the arguement that he is a spy, other than possibilities, that is it.

Until then he has my full support. While I wish he would come home and face his 30 years in prison, per the charges, I wouldn't expect a person not to remain free.
 
I've read hear-say and possibilities, nothing more. Do you have any specific names of Chineese officials who have been targetted and now revealed through Snowdens admissions? I surely haven't. There is no proof to the arguement that he is a spy, other than possibilities, that is it.

Until then he has my full support. While I wish he would come home and face his 30 years in prison, per the charges, I wouldn't expect a person not to remain free.

Look up the info for the handover data he gave to the China news entity in Hong Kong. You'll get the story. If you haven't found it, I'll post it to this thread tomorrow.
 
Regardless of what he reveals about black ops operations, with the exception of nuclear launch codes, or further technological advances, I support the actions that he has taken. Everything that he has revealed, so far, has been a simple, "Oh really, you don't say." moment. We hack China? Really? I never would have guessed. Our government stores our personal information, through an approved "court" system known as FISA to justify its legality? You don't say.


Nothing he has revealed is new knowledge, to some. However, to the mainstream US citizen, who is far to busy to read, research or contemplate legislation such as the patriot act, or the follow up NDAA's, this was starteling news. Not so much that it is going on, but the degree and volume it has become.


Some say snowden is a spy. If that is the case I would have some very strong moral objections to those serving our government today. If it would take a spy to release this type of information, and not a US citizen looking out for our nation and its best interests, then we have some serious ethical issues within our government (we do anyway regardless of this case) and how we view our government should operate in regards to the constitution and general respect for peoples privacy. Forget legality for a minute and focus on principle.


Then we have the FISA courts. The "oversight" of our governments outreach of the patriot act, and subsequent acts. Their record speaks for itself, at how effective it is. Either that or the Bush and Obama administrations have some lawyers who can adjust the rule of law so finely, that anything is legal for the government to do. As long as they go through the FISA courts. I think this is the real issue of this whole mess, which is being brought to the table.


I don't support the release of names by snowden, or much of the foreign intel he has revealed. His ability to push, to the forefront throughout the US, our governments keeping of private information is a very honorable thing to do, and supercedes and damage he may or already has done.

I'd shoot him in the head if it were up to me.
 
You aren't well enough informed to have a valid opinion.

I suspect that you don't concern yourself with basing your opinions upon fact. Too much trouble. You already know how you feel.
 
Regardless of what he reveals about black ops operations, with the exception of nuclear launch codes, or further technological advances, I support the actions that he has taken. Everything that he has revealed, so far, has been a simple, "Oh really, you don't say." moment. We hack China? Really? I never would have guessed. Our government stores our personal information, through an approved "court" system known as FISA to justify its legality? You don't say.


Nothing he has revealed is new knowledge, to some. However, to the mainstream US citizen, who is far to busy to read, research or contemplate legislation such as the patriot act, or the follow up NDAA's, this was starteling news. Not so much that it is going on, but the degree and volume it has become.


Some say snowden is a spy. If that is the case I would have some very strong moral objections to those serving our government today. If it would take a spy to release this type of information, and not a US citizen looking out for our nation and its best interests, then we have some serious ethical issues within our government (we do anyway regardless of this case) and how we view our government should operate in regards to the constitution and general respect for peoples privacy. Forget legality for a minute and focus on principle.


Then we have the FISA courts. The "oversight" of our governments outreach of the patriot act, and subsequent acts. Their record speaks for itself, at how effective it is. Either that or the Bush and Obama administrations have some lawyers who can adjust the rule of law so finely, that anything is legal for the government to do. As long as they go through the FISA courts. I think this is the real issue of this whole mess, which is being brought to the table.


I don't support the release of names by snowden, or much of the foreign intel he has revealed. His ability to push, to the forefront throughout the US, our governments keeping of private information is a very honorable thing to do, and supercedes and damage he may or already has done.

Well said and I agree.

Jo
 
I support him...

I guess the government should just make EVERYTHING they do "National Security", and then throw the person in prison who reveals any possible shadiness.

Ron Paul praises Edward Snowden:

“We should be thankful for individuals like Edward Snowden and Glenn Greenwald who see injustice being carried out by their own government and speak out, despite the risk,” said Paul in a statement on the Web site of Campaign for Liberty, his nonprofit. “They have done a great service to the American people by exposing the truth about what our government is doing in secret.” Glenn Greenwald is a reporter for the Guardian, which first published the story revealing the scope of the U.S. government’s surveillance programs.
 
Back
Top