Arkady
President
Having now seen the e-mails that were the basis of Woodward's claim about being "threatened" by the White House, it's clear not only that he wasn't threatened, but that he didn't perceive the comment as a threat at the time.
Here's what happened. After apologizing for the tone of an earlier exchange, a White House aide said the following:
In context, the "you will regret staking out that claim" is clearly not a threat, but rather advice -- essentially saying that, as a friend, I think you'll be hurting your reputation by saying something that isn't supported by the facts. And Woodward, not being a moron, had the basic reading comprehension skills to realize that, at the time, and responded as someone would when receiving such friendly advice, not as one would respond to a threat:
He welcomes the "personal advice" graciously, but then effectively insists he's not worried about his reputation, because he's talked extensively with everyone involved (in other words, he's confident he's got the facts right, and so he won't regret staking out that position.)
At that point, there's nothing wrong with the exchange. What goes wrong is when publicity-hound Bob goes on Blitzer and pretends he thinks he was threatened, based on a deliberately out-of-context paraphrasing of the exchange. He tries to avoid actually slandering the guy by refusing to name him (which also, he might hope, makes it less likely people will eventually see the actual e-mails and realize he clearly invented the threat.) Fortunately, the e-mails were then leaked (presumably by the White House, which realized that context would fully exonerate them).
So, now that Woodward has been revealed to be a liar, who invented a threat in order to get himself some of the press he so desperately desires, will he apologize? I hope so. There is little left of this once well-regarded journalist's reputation, but anything he could do to preserve its last tattered remnants would be a good thing.
Here's what happened. After apologizing for the tone of an earlier exchange, a White House aide said the following:
But I do truly believe you should rethink your comment about saying saying that Potus asking for revenues is moving the goal post. I know you may not believe this, but as a friend, I think you will regret staking out that claim. The idea that the sequester was to force both sides to go back to try at a big or grand bargain with a mix of entitlements and revenues (even if there were serious disagreements on composition) was part of the DNA of the thing from the start. It was an accepted part of the understanding — from the start. Really.
In context, the "you will regret staking out that claim" is clearly not a threat, but rather advice -- essentially saying that, as a friend, I think you'll be hurting your reputation by saying something that isn't supported by the facts. And Woodward, not being a moron, had the basic reading comprehension skills to realize that, at the time, and responded as someone would when receiving such friendly advice, not as one would respond to a threat:
Gene: You do not ever have to apologize to me. You get wound up because you are making your points and you believe them. This is all part of a serious discussion. I for one welcome a little heat; there should more given the importance. I also welcome your personal advice. I am listening. I know you lived all this. My partial advantage is that I talked extensively with all involved.... Best, Bob
He welcomes the "personal advice" graciously, but then effectively insists he's not worried about his reputation, because he's talked extensively with everyone involved (in other words, he's confident he's got the facts right, and so he won't regret staking out that position.)
At that point, there's nothing wrong with the exchange. What goes wrong is when publicity-hound Bob goes on Blitzer and pretends he thinks he was threatened, based on a deliberately out-of-context paraphrasing of the exchange. He tries to avoid actually slandering the guy by refusing to name him (which also, he might hope, makes it less likely people will eventually see the actual e-mails and realize he clearly invented the threat.) Fortunately, the e-mails were then leaked (presumably by the White House, which realized that context would fully exonerate them).
So, now that Woodward has been revealed to be a liar, who invented a threat in order to get himself some of the press he so desperately desires, will he apologize? I hope so. There is little left of this once well-regarded journalist's reputation, but anything he could do to preserve its last tattered remnants would be a good thing.
