Trap, you have been the one saying that you advocate an increase in liberty and democracy. So if I can point to a an attentuation of such, its an arguement I will wield as relevant to the discussion.
Name a nation, society or culture ANyWHERE in the world where large concentrations of wealth did not reduce levels of democracy.
Impossible to do. The democratic form of government isn't practiced everywhere, so you'd have to have a country where it had been established, and then was "attenuated" by income inequality. I suppose you could look to Argentina in the Peron era, but it was closer to fascist than democratic even before Peron took office.
And that's the point Trap. Large concentrations of wealth INVARIABLY PRECLUDE expansions of democracy in any form. And that applies to nations that seek to practice democracy formally or ones where democratic practices are nascent and seeking to grow. Precisely becuase concentrations of wealth are ANTITHETICAL TO DEMOCRACY for the pragmatic reasons I've eumerated in my previous post.
And poorer people can pool their resources, increasing their influence.
But that's not an answer the the ANTI-DEMOCRATIC force of wealth. Because in essence you are saying that MULTIPLE poorer people equal ONE wealthier person. And that is the antithesis to "one person one vote" which is the hallmark of democratic action.
but it works for a lot of groups in our country, and it helps to ameliorate the disparity of influence held by rich people
No it does not. Because it REDUCES the individuated democratic liberty of the poor by making One Wealthy equal multiple poor.
Not true -- a farm's efficiency is determined by a lot of factors, not the least of which is the efficiency of the farmer. Generally speaking, when a farm is sold it doesn't remain a farm -- it becomes real estate and turns into a bunch of three-acre "residential ranchettes."
No this is not "generally true". That is ONLY true in residential peripheries, which is the minority of farmland. Most sold off farmland goes into the hands of larger corporate ag busineses that can produce more efficiently on the same land. THAT is the "generally speaking" case.
And in cases where it is true, that's just fair market forces reallocating resources exactly the same way scrapping old steam locomotives to be replaced by Diesel and Diesel-Electrics did in RRs or laptops replacing Desktops in IT, or cars mfg replacing buggy whip Mfg. You are in essence saying we should distort this market reallocation. Why?
Easy to pay off, but impossible to get the loan
Nope it isn't. If you can show a solid ROI the loan is not hard to get. Sorry wrong. Loans against tax encumbered property happen ALL THE TIME.
Road apples. You die, and your property is taxed because you died
Simply not true. Your property is taxed based on WHO RECEIVES IT.
It is not income -- it is value that has already arrived.
TO THE PERSON WHO DIED. Not to the heirs. To the heirs
it is new income. It is assets they did not control or own prior to the death. Notice that the forms associated with the Estate tax are all about
The beneficiary http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1041sk1.pdf
Taxation is about revenue, not behavior. The progressive tax system WAS NOT put in place in the name of "marginal utility" -- read the debates about it from 1913. It was put in place because what today you'd call "red" states wanted rich coastal states and the people who lived there (the Rockefellers, Hiltons, Morgans and Carnegies), to pay more of the freight, and because followers of William Jennings Bryan thought taxing the rich more was "more fair."
Trap, "Marginal Utility if Income" is simply the formal econometric way of describing the innate PRIMATE perception of fairness. Experiments with chimps have shown that this sort of redistribution is considered "fair" even by chimps. So you just contradicted your own claim. From the outset, progressive taxation has to do with the idea that "the rich can a
fford to pay more" and at the core of the notion of "affordability" is that the adverse impact on the lifestyle of someone wealthy paying 70% Marginal rate, means they buy 2 Porsche's instead of 3 vs. having or not having housing.
IOW the "u
tility" of the income taken in taxes is
lower for the higher earner than for the
lower earner. That is the very definition of "diminishing marginal utility of income".
st inherited money STAYS OUT OF VC funds. VC money typically comes from active investors who are looking to build their own wealth. Which would include people who have wealth, and want more.
It does. But it typically does not include heirs. And as I pointed out with my link, it INCLUDES pension funds. And the reality is that CALPERS, which is ONE pension fund, in ONE industry, in ONE state - HAS MORE invested in "job creation" than the ten wealthiest individuals COMBINED.
And MOST WEALTH is inherited. Thus it is not a "reward for success" but rather the reward for the genetic lotto. That's simply the factual data.
Re-read what I wrote. I said "the sky appears blue to most human viewers." The viewers in your attachment have had unusual perspectives, but most people looking at a daylight sky see blue, still "most" and "universal" are not the same thing.
What's unusual about a sunset, or a cloudy day, or nightime. Notice how suddenly you constrained your time period to a "daylight unclouded sky"? Which frankly is LESS THAN 50% of the Earth's coverage at any point in time. And yet that's the "general case" you cited.
Sorry no. its not the general case. CONTEXT turns out.. matters. Even to your example.
No it does not. It is not a "penalty" to tax folks in a way that the "pain" ie the "adverse impact preceived" is equal. That's not a penalty of any sort.[/quote] Penalty, pain, or just "disincentive," it's all the same.[/quote]
Except that we know that the ECONOMIC ACTIONS of lower income individuals
is more productive than that of the wealthy . So why do you want to
incentivize less efficient economic activity?
And we know what that point is. 90% marginal tax rates .
People start cheating well below that level.
Your claim was not about cheating but about LEAVING THE USA.
And people "cheat" at all levels. What we KNOW from direct statistical experience is that
- At 90% of above levels of marginal taxation, MORE money is spent avoiding taxes and collecting them than is collected and there is a net outflow of investment from the nation
- At between 70% and 90% of marginal income taxation rates, additional revenue collection efforts are offset by additional efforts to avoid taxation and you have the "laffer plateau"
- At rates of 70% and Below, there is no meaningful leakage out of the economy
And we also know that
When Reagan cut taxes from 70% to 50% Marginal Rates - for every $1 in reduced taxes to the upper quintile, almost 1/3 disappeared from the US Domestic economy
IOW Cutting taxes to the wealthy REDUCED GROWTH.