New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Woolley Arguments.

This is what Teddy Roosevelt called a Fair Deal and what FDR renamed as the New Deal. Now, admittedly, Paul Ryan calls his vision the "opportunity society" but the opportunity society seems to be a casino in which the opportunities are rigged to favor the oligarchs (i.e. the private sector elite).

And so the alternative is to take away some of the "winnings" and give it to the "losers" in some form? How is that sustainable?

trap said above said that J.P. Morgan (and John D. Rockefellar, and Andrew Mellon) did not destory democracy or the United States. And I would agree that each of them provided some benefits to the United States. The problem was the possibility of them amassing unchecked/unregulated power.

None of them were able to stop Theodore Roosevelt's anti-trust legislation. If they had the overweening power attributed to them, surely the could have bought up enough legislative interests to stall such laws. It looks to me lik there must have been some check on their power.
What trap won't admit is that FDR, Lyndon Johnson, Bill Clinton, and Barack Obama and the SCOUTS since 1937 have not "destroyed" the U.S. either and have - in fact - done much good.

And that is not a true statement of my position. I think FDR, especially, LBJ and Barack Obama exceeded the authority given to the federal government via the Constitution. I think Bill Clinton is a lying, slimy snake, but except for the assault weapons bans, I'd give him fair marks as president. And I think SCOTUS, under pressure from FDR, opened the door to the abuse of federal power, making the excesses of LBJ and Barack Obama possible.


Now, he will claim that the Federal government is unchecked and power hungry relative to the private oligarchs. He is entitled to his opinion. I think that trap is wrong on that score.

So you like the Patriot Act?
 
Oh bullsh!t. You yourself have pointed out that for example Obama's daughters have far more opportunity than you ever did, simply by accident of birth. That's hardly "believing in Meritocracy". And given that there is much less opportunity for economic mobility in the USA than say in Europe, the evidence on the ground for this is hardly there.

Degs, I said my background makes me believe in meritocracy, not that such a meritocracy currently exists.

You make the mistake of conflating "success" with "wealth" the two are not the same.

You make the mistake of not realizing that for most people, achieving wealth means a higher level of personal freedom -- in short, success. I had a former NBA player-turned-successful-real-estate agent tell me one time that he didn't care much about money, what he liked was the freedom to do his own thing, and money gave him that freedom. In any case, if you would prefer, I'll change the statement. "I see no reason to take from the wealthy to give to the non-wealthy." That eliminates the equation of wealth with success and puts a stop to that debate.

Except it isn't. Not unless regulated with that goal. Without regulating for a Bell curve distribution Capital allocation in pure "market capitalism" quickly devolves to an assymptotic distribution.

I'd have to see some sort of proof of that. Typically, any distribution of anything falls into a bell curve -- so something that behaves in a different way indicates some sort of phenomena is present.


And no one is suggesting that.

Perhaps no one here, in this discussion, is suggesting that. It is clear that the current president thinks that anyone who makes over $250,000 a year is getting to keep too much of their own money. His goal is to reduce their take home of their own earnings, be that salary or profit.


That is EXACTLY what lower tax rates and fewer regulations have already done The USA has LESS INCOME MOBILITY THAN THE EU.

How does lowering a person's tax rate make them less likely to succeed financially? Yes, there is less mobility in the U.S. today, and I attribute that to entry costs. It's much more difficult to set up a small business today because of the regulations on businesses, at the local, state and federal levels. We're a nation of bartenders in part because it's easier to meet the safety code for a restaurant than it is for a machine shop.

Then ALL Society is "servitude" because Wealth Redistribution is one of the fundamental basis for society. Secondly, since the USA does not force anyone to remain a citizen, there is no "forcing" occuring.

You're life is going to improve if you ever quit reading that damn book, whichever book it is. Society is one thing, government another. Our government was not created as a device for taxing the rich so it could distribute alms to the poor. It's the United States of America, not the Federal Almoner of America.



For all practical purposes it has. Basically up through the early 1900s. And it resulted in a very slow growing economy despite vast tracts of resource wealth.

The Gilded Age did not represent unchained capitalism. Post-Soviet Russia might, but it's more of a cleptocracy than a capitalist system. How did our growth compare with, say, France in the period? I think you'll find that the rest of the world was amazed by American industry at the time.
 
It does not mean that you subsidize childbirth.

Would you feel the same way about a white single parent with rich parents? Why do you focus so much on the fact that she was black?


What if she could fly? What if she came from mars? We can stack what ifs to the moon, and we end up right back on earth. As to your question about me, I drained my own resources, my family's resources and a county journalism scholarship (a princely $400 per semester) four two years, and then I joined the Army for four years, and at the time under discussion, I was returning to school with zero income. If I was enrolled in school, full time, the Montgomery G.I. Bill would pay me $350 a month, but the college's tuition was $1600 a semester and had to be paid in full, up front. What I had as far as resources at that point was about $300 remaining out of my last Army paycheck, which yes, I spent on tuition.



And I think that basically means that we subsidize childbirth. But at the end of the day, this is about the allocation of resources, and she clearly had more than I did. She had a $30,000 car, just for openers. I had an eight-year-old Ford Mustang that was, thankfully, paid for. Which of us had more in assets? Who had more need for financial aid?



I don't know, but I don't think so. She had a part time job, and as I said, her father paid her an allowance.
 
And so the alternative is to take away some of the "winnings" and give it to the "losers" in some form? How is that sustainable?

The alternative is to keep Paul Ryan and his oligarchic SuperPac backers from creating a rigged scheme whose sole purpose is to entrench the 1% and keep them powerful where the very rich get richer and the middle class gets poorer.

None of them were able to stop Theodore Roosevelt's anti-trust legislation. If they had the overweening power attributed to them, surely the could have bought up enough legislative interests to stall such laws. It looks to me lik there must have been some check on their power.

Did you read what I wrote? The reason that anti-trust legislation was created in the first place was to act as a check on private power. It was not a sure thing. But it seems to me that your logic would lead you to oppose anti-trust legislation as well and support unfettered oligarchical power. You always poo-poo that.

And that is not a true statement of my position. I think FDR, especially, LBJ and Barack Obama exceeded the authority given to the federal government via the Constitution. I think Bill Clinton is a lying, slimy snake, but except for the assault weapons bans, I'd give him fair marks as president. And I think SCOTUS, under pressure from FDR, opened the door to the abuse of federal power, making the excesses of LBJ and Barack Obama possible.

And I disagree with your constitutional analysis. But, apparently you admit that the world was not destroyed because FDR, LBJ, and Obama "exceeded" their authority. I think that if version 1 of Hillarycare (circa 1993-4) had passed, you would put Clinton in the same company. And I see that you give a pass to Republicans. Why is that?

So you like the Patriot Act?

No, I do not like the Patriot Act. Do you think that Mitt Romney will get rid of the Patriot Act? Dick Cheney was the world's biggest supporter of the Patriot Act. What makes you think that Republicans are civil libertarians? Are you a member of the ACLU? If so, you could fool me? Do you think that the Patriot Act is unconstitutional? Would you bitch slap Scalia for stomping on civil liberties?
 
And so the alternative is to take away some of the "winnings" and give it to the "losers" in some form? How is that sustainable?
Its more sustainable than taking from the "middle class losers" and "giving to the winners". Why? Because "winners" under-reinvest in the economy. And thus over time you get fewer and fewer "winners".

THAT'S HOW ECONOMIES WORK.

None of them were able to stop Theodore Roosevelt's anti-trust legislation.
By the time TR's anti-trust legislation had kicked in, the moguls had already amassed huge amounts of wealth, and essentially the Law of Decreasing Marginal Utility of Income had kicked in. IOW they were no longer that focussed on expanding their wealth. And even so it took almost 10 years after passage for the bill to be first used to any real effect. Precisely because of the political pressure the wealthy brought to bear. And it did nothing to prevent Carnegie's sale of Carnegie Steel to JP Morgan. A sale that arguebly in the long run hurt US manufacturing competitiveness by overly concentrating the steel industry.

And that is not a true statement of my position. I think believe FDR, especially, LBJ and Barack Obama exceeded the authority given to the federal government via the Constitution. ... And I thinkbelieve SCOTUS, under pressure from FDR, opened the door to the abuse of federal power, making the excesses of LBJ and Barack Obama possible.
No Trap you do not THINK about these things, you BELIEVE them. You've never provided a consistent, supportable and logically valid arguement to support these beliefs.

You have not shown that General Welfare as interpreted by FDR and the Courts was incorrectly interpreted (particularly given Franklin's and Hamilton's views on the subject). You have not shown how that view of General Welfare does what you claim it does, namely removes all limits on Foederal Authority, and you have not shown that anything LBJ or Obama has done is Constitutionally excessive.

You have not even shown that SS is a "mandatory retirement" program as you claim it to be. Heck even the "switch in Time" arguement you make is not supported by the actual history of the time period.

Now, he will claim that the Federal government is unchecked and power hungry relative to the private oligarchs. He is entitled to his opinion. I think that trap is wrong on that score.

So you like the Patriot Act?

Actually the PATRIOT ACT derives from that part of the Constitution you believe has essentially unlimited authority, namely POTUS' role as CinC. So your invocation of PATRIOT is doubly ironic

  1. It has nothing to do with General Welfare clause and instead derives from Common Defense powers
  2. It is the area of The Constitution that you have essentially consistently said the Courts have gotten it wrong in Prize Cases http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/historics/USSC_CR_0067_0635_ZO.html

 
"As those high-paying jobs aren't likely to return, how do you build a system of increasing social programs financed on the backs of people making $10 an hour? Because that's who will be the ones paying for it. "

You keep taking more from the folks with all the money. Why is this so hard to figure out for you? If you win every hand sooner or later you are going to have to give me back some of my money to survive or arm yourself because I am going to take it back from you. You are way too smart not to know how every civilization that ended up with a vastly unequal distribution of power or money came to its demise. Our tax rates are the lowest in a 100 years. Stop your moaning and groaning and pay up. It really gets tiresome listening to the wailing and gnashing of teeth from people with your point of view. Bring back the high tax rates. Start repealing free trade acts that are between unequal economies. Split the banks up. Drop the spending on the military. Socialize medicine. Increase educational opportunities. Ignore the right wing for the next 100 years and we may have a chance to survive the coming war between the winners of Reaganomics and the rest of the nation, you know, the 99% of us who will end up losing over and over again.
 
I'm actually more focused on trying to make you see why I feel they're misguided. Forums like these seldom make large changes in people's opinions. I'm happy if I can get a few away from the "all conservatives are evil" meme.
Trap - your view is predictable. But it is internally inconsistent. The reality is that your views are easily predicted. I can't remember a single case in all the years you and I have argued where your view was not predictable (except when you started distorting english grammar to try and make an arguement - that I never expected of you).

Yet consistently you have failed to accurately assess, predict or argue against most of the points I or IRP have raised. You invariably fall back to a set of strawmen that are not what we actually have written or argued. Essentially you seem unable to get out of your own frame of reference and see how others reason.

a great example is this comment of yours
How can you favor something that can be redefined tomorrow? I asked a question earlier -- if we can use a living constitution definition of general welfare to do anything, what's the purpose of the rest of the Constitution?
We get that you are somehow afraid of language magically changing overnight. But that's not how language or the human brain works. So this is not a LOGICAL CONSEQUENCE of anything IRP or I have proposed. It is instead a strawman you have constructed. and the fallacies in it have been repeatedly explained to you. And you have not actually identified any flaws in those explanations. Instead you just run back to the strawman.


BTW, why should I believe you vis a vis Ryan's willingness to "compromise." I have seen no evidence that he would not do exactly what he says he would do.
I expressed an opinion based on what I see as the political realities.
You've not explained in a logical manner what those "realities" are or what is motivating them. The political "reality" is that if Ryan backs off on his plan, he loses the Tea Party. And if he loses the Tea Party - which is twice the size of the margin that the GOP needs to control the House, he loses the ability to get the bill passed.

And since Romney has ENDORSED THE PLAN, there is no backing off. In the case of Romney being elected, that has to get passed. In the case of Obama being re-elected, its THE ONLY bill that the House will pass.

Romney will get my vote, if only because of Obamacare.
And another case where Trap votes against his own best interests - just as he did with Reagan in 84. And this is the sad thing.

Personally, I don't think that Republicans have genuinely tried to find common ground with Obama and the Democrats. Neither side is doing that.
Where was the common ground in the strong-arming of Obamacare? There wasn't one.
Well first off, there was LESS strongarming than when GWB was elected with a minority votein 2000. In 2000 the Dems basically let GWB govern and the GOP instead in 2009 engaged in an unprecedented rate of filibuster

Secondly, there was compromise. Initially Obama pushed a Public Option. Public Option was pulled to try and get Olympia Snowe and some other moderate Senators on board. And it was never put back in the bill. So there was no "ramming through".

As for bipartisanship on Education with Ted Kennedy - that's an intersting example since Kennedy afterwards expressed that he felt lied to by the GWB white house on that bill. AGain, you see where the Dems with GWB WORKED WITH HIM even though he had not even won the majority of the vote. No record setting filibusters.

If Romney is elected President, I fully expect him to be totally divisive and partisan and to try to impose his very conservative agenda on the nation. He will not represent my views. Period. Romney is not a man who can "heal" this country. Anyone who thinks that he can is fooling themselves in my opinion.
Is healing what we need? Above you mentioned principle -- personally I think we could do with a deal more of that.

Please... Romney is about as "principled" as a starving wolf in an unwatched sheeps' pen.

And yes we need healing more than "principle". Because we need governance, not posturing. "principle" is posturing - it is irrational intransigence in the face of contravening facts. It is in essence bigotry wrapped up in a perfume box.






I expressed an opinion based on what I see as the political realities. I have no special insight on Ryan's attitudes, but he's been kicking around Congress since the late 1990s, and I figure he knows the difference between what he'd like to achieve and what he can actually achieve. There's nothing there, in other words, to "believe."



Well, I'm no member of the religious right, and I'd have rather seen almost any republican candidate other than Romney, but Romney will get my vote, if only because of Obamacare.



Neither side is doing that. Where was the common ground in the strong-arming of Obamacare? There wasn't one. The last truly bipartisan action was the education thing that GWB did with Ted Kennedy -- political ancient history in other words.


Is healing what we need? Above you mentioned principle -- personally I think we could do with a deal more of that.[/QUOTE]
 
Trap, you have been the one saying that you advocate an increase in liberty and democracy. So if I can point to a an attentuation of such, its an arguement I will wield as relevant to the discussion.

Name a nation, society or culture ANyWHERE in the world where large concentrations of wealth did not reduce levels of democracy.
Impossible to do. The democratic form of government isn't practiced everywhere, so you'd have to have a country where it had been established, and then was "attenuated" by income inequality. I suppose you could look to Argentina in the Peron era, but it was closer to fascist than democratic even before Peron took office.
And that's the point Trap. Large concentrations of wealth INVARIABLY PRECLUDE expansions of democracy in any form. And that applies to nations that seek to practice democracy formally or ones where democratic practices are nascent and seeking to grow. Precisely becuase concentrations of wealth are ANTITHETICAL TO DEMOCRACY for the pragmatic reasons I've eumerated in my previous post.

And poorer people can pool their resources, increasing their influence.
But that's not an answer the the ANTI-DEMOCRATIC force of wealth. Because in essence you are saying that MULTIPLE poorer people equal ONE wealthier person. And that is the antithesis to "one person one vote" which is the hallmark of democratic action.

but it works for a lot of groups in our country, and it helps to ameliorate the disparity of influence held by rich people
No it does not. Because it REDUCES the individuated democratic liberty of the poor by making One Wealthy equal multiple poor.

Not true -- a farm's efficiency is determined by a lot of factors, not the least of which is the efficiency of the farmer. Generally speaking, when a farm is sold it doesn't remain a farm -- it becomes real estate and turns into a bunch of three-acre "residential ranchettes."
No this is not "generally true". That is ONLY true in residential peripheries, which is the minority of farmland. Most sold off farmland goes into the hands of larger corporate ag busineses that can produce more efficiently on the same land. THAT is the "generally speaking" case.

And in cases where it is true, that's just fair market forces reallocating resources exactly the same way scrapping old steam locomotives to be replaced by Diesel and Diesel-Electrics did in RRs or laptops replacing Desktops in IT, or cars mfg replacing buggy whip Mfg. You are in essence saying we should distort this market reallocation. Why?

Easy to pay off, but impossible to get the loan
Nope it isn't. If you can show a solid ROI the loan is not hard to get. Sorry wrong. Loans against tax encumbered property happen ALL THE TIME.

Road apples. You die, and your property is taxed because you died
Simply not true. Your property is taxed based on WHO RECEIVES IT.

It is not income -- it is value that has already arrived.
TO THE PERSON WHO DIED. Not to the heirs. To the heirs it is new income. It is assets they did not control or own prior to the death. Notice that the forms associated with the Estate tax are all about The beneficiary http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1041sk1.pdf

Taxation is about revenue, not behavior. The progressive tax system WAS NOT put in place in the name of "marginal utility" -- read the debates about it from 1913. It was put in place because what today you'd call "red" states wanted rich coastal states and the people who lived there (the Rockefellers, Hiltons, Morgans and Carnegies), to pay more of the freight, and because followers of William Jennings Bryan thought taxing the rich more was "more fair."

Trap, "Marginal Utility if Income" is simply the formal econometric way of describing the innate PRIMATE perception of fairness. Experiments with chimps have shown that this sort of redistribution is considered "fair" even by chimps. So you just contradicted your own claim. From the outset, progressive taxation has to do with the idea that "the rich can afford to pay more" and at the core of the notion of "affordability" is that the adverse impact on the lifestyle of someone wealthy paying 70% Marginal rate, means they buy 2 Porsche's instead of 3 vs. having or not having housing.

IOW the "utility" of the income taken in taxes is lower for the higher earner than for the lower earner. That is the very definition of "diminishing marginal utility of income".

st inherited money STAYS OUT OF VC funds. VC money typically comes from active investors who are looking to build their own wealth. Which would include people who have wealth, and want more.
It does. But it typically does not include heirs. And as I pointed out with my link, it INCLUDES pension funds. And the reality is that CALPERS, which is ONE pension fund, in ONE industry, in ONE state - HAS MORE invested in "job creation" than the ten wealthiest individuals COMBINED.

And MOST WEALTH is inherited. Thus it is not a "reward for success" but rather the reward for the genetic lotto. That's simply the factual data.

Re-read what I wrote. I said "the sky appears blue to most human viewers." The viewers in your attachment have had unusual perspectives, but most people looking at a daylight sky see blue, still "most" and "universal" are not the same thing.
What's unusual about a sunset, or a cloudy day, or nightime. Notice how suddenly you constrained your time period to a "daylight unclouded sky"? Which frankly is LESS THAN 50% of the Earth's coverage at any point in time. And yet that's the "general case" you cited.

Sorry no. its not the general case. CONTEXT turns out.. matters. Even to your example.

No it does not. It is not a "penalty" to tax folks in a way that the "pain" ie the "adverse impact preceived" is equal. That's not a penalty of any sort.[/quote] Penalty, pain, or just "disincentive," it's all the same.[/quote]
Except that we know that the ECONOMIC ACTIONS of lower income individuals is more productive than that of the wealthy . So why do you want to incentivize less efficient economic activity?

And we know what that point is. 90% marginal tax rates .

People start cheating well below that level.
Your claim was not about cheating but about LEAVING THE USA.

And people "cheat" at all levels. What we KNOW from direct statistical experience is that

  • At 90% of above levels of marginal taxation, MORE money is spent avoiding taxes and collecting them than is collected and there is a net outflow of investment from the nation
  • At between 70% and 90% of marginal income taxation rates, additional revenue collection efforts are offset by additional efforts to avoid taxation and you have the "laffer plateau"
  • At rates of 70% and Below, there is no meaningful leakage out of the economy

And we also know that When Reagan cut taxes from 70% to 50% Marginal Rates - for every $1 in reduced taxes to the upper quintile, almost 1/3 disappeared from the US Domestic economy

IOW Cutting taxes to the wealthy REDUCED GROWTH.
 
He seems to revere stasis more than anything else. First we have The Word, then everything else follows. As we have debated here and on The Fray, the notion of a static version of The Word as intended by any person in any era is really a fantasy. The more important driver should be the process. Is the process proper, does it serve the interests of the people and can it reliably produce a positive outcome? Arguing semantics defined or partially defined by fallible human beings is an endless argument better saved for teaching critical thinking skills than it is for running a nation. Will we learn from the past and use it to proceed or must we constantly revert to an imaginary state of being stuck in 1790 every time we come across a new problem? The founders did not think so themselves so why in the world should we bother? The answer lies in the outcomes. Trap does not like the outcomes of the modern process so he wants to slow it down, paralyze it to the point where it can no longer even move or govern effectively. This is the core of his belief system IMHO. I just read a great book on the flaws in the constitution by Levinson. It addresses the major flaws that are relics of the past and calls for a new constitutional convention to address them. The current system provides too much power to smaller groups and states. It is completely skewed towards taking power away from as many people as possible in order to preserve the Republic. Every read Julius Ceasars arguments about the Roman Senate and the Republic? Augustus made much the same argument. They paid the price for Empire during some reigns but they never returned to the Republic again did they?
 
You make the mistake of not realizing that for most people, achieving wealth means a higher level of personal freedom -- in short, success
Well so would achieving the status of autocrat. After all, having no restraints on your action is "a higher level of personal freedom" - even though it means everyone else has lesser or effectively no rights. So clearly it is a question of the balance of such benefits, their distribution through society, and how it fits with the goals of the society. Turns out we KNOW a fair amount about this.
http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/aea/jel/2008/00000046/00000001/art00003
http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/2094626?uid=3739960&uid=2&uid=4&uid=3739256&sid=21100957622933

And it turns out that there is a DRAMATIC plateuing of "increased personal freedom" and "happiness" after an income of $70,000 (in today's dollars).

Furthermore as someone who claims to believe in Meritocracy - it seems to me that you would argue that EVERYONE should be responsible for equally making their own way, thus inheritance SHOULD NOT be a factor.

Except it isn't. Not unless regulated with that goal. Without regulating for a Bell curve distribution Capital allocation in pure "market capitalism" quickly devolves to an assymptotic distribution.
I'd have to see some sort of proof of that. Typically, any distribution of anything falls into a bell curve
No that simply is not so. You clearly have not done enough maths to understand that "gaussian" distributions are actually not as common as it would seem. The easiest intro into this for you might be the concept of The Long Tail http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Long_Tail as discussed in the fairly easy to read The Black Swan http://www.amazon.com/The-Black-Swa...43925701&sr=8-2&keywords=fooled+by+randomness

Non-Gaussian distributions are quite common in self-amplifying/self-attenuating systems. Gaussian Distros only exist commonly for random non-correlative effects. But Capital accumulation is anything but that. The phrase "Money Begets Money" or "you need money to make money" actually has mathematical bases. Essentially the tool you need is Bayesian distribution http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayesian_probability not Gaussian. Because how you invest after Event A is driven by the outcomes of Event A. It is not a random decorrellated effect.

Your whole notion here is simply wrong.

(For the easiest intro read THIS even though it has to do with MFG and not population: http://www.qualitydigest.com/dec99/html/nonnormal.html)


In fact wealth accumulation, is most likely to follow Pareto Optimal distribution (ie distributed so that at any point on the curve, there is nothing you can do to improve your particular situation) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_distribution And Pareto Optimal turns out to be... Assymptotic.

Perhaps no one here, in this discussion, is suggesting that. It is clear that the current president thinks that anyone who makes over $250,000 a year is getting to keep too much of their own money.
Its not "their own money". That's the point. They are getting too large a share of the redistribution function and it is

  • Economically detrimental
  • Democratically detrimental
  • A detriment to the maximization of liberty and justice FOR ALL
  • not sustainable econometrically

IOW it is bad policy.

That is EXACTLY what lower tax rates and fewer regulations have already done The USA has LESS INCOME MOBILITY THAN THE EU.
How does lowering a person's tax rate make them less likely to succeed financially?
Huh? Lowering the tax rate on the wealthy AMPLIFIES the benefits they get from their wealth. Thus those in the middle class and lower have LESS chance of improving their financial status since they then have LESS ACCESS TO CAPITAL.

Meanwhile the wealthy have less incentive to act in a way that optimizes their use of their income. And thus growth drops. And when growth drops, income mobility drops.

.You're life is going to improve if you ever quit reading that damn book, whichever book it is. Society is one thing, government another.
Your life is going to improve if you ever quit reading that damn book, whatever book it is. Society and government are inextricably linked. And our governemnt was created as a device for redistributing the benefits of our society in a manner that "Promotes the General Welfare" and "secures the blessings of liberty" to WE THE PEOPLE not to a small elite oligarchy.

As for "my life improving"? Trap, Wooley, IRP and myself have - by your own standards - a much more successful life than you do. YOU are the one who voted for the guy who cut your earnings abilities by OVER $1 Million Dollars.

The Gilded Age did not represent unchained capitalism.
You asserted this before. You have offered ZERO evidene of any restriction on capitalism at that time. And yes, it very much was like the post-soviet cleptocracy. Leland Stanford made his dollars by misrepresenting the terrain he was surveying for the RRs. The RRS were given other peoples' land (in a land transfer more noxious than kelo) because of their political connections.

As for comparing us to the growth of France - when you normalize for how far BEHIND our economy was, it did more poorly. Its like comparing the PRC's growth rate to that of a mature economy. Its an invalid comparison
 
Trap, my sister worked as a small business banker in Silicon valley in the 1990s (before moving onto the VC business). Her conclusion was that very very few businesses were built "playing by the rules". There are ALWAYS outliers. And your annecdote is intersting in a couple of ways


  1. What the bankers were doing was somewhat unethical. Because from really your uncles lacked the information to be able to invest in an informed way. So these bankers were encouraging what amounted to a gamble, with their houses as the likely collateral. I don't think you'd relate the story the same way if the lenders were "Vinny's Boys" and the "investment" was a "hot tip at the track".
  2. you also demostrate how the middle class has a much greater incentive to "invest well" than the wealthy". They essentially borrowed a year's income to make this investment. How many people earing $350,000/yr are going to borrow $350,000 to make what amounts to a gamble? The answer is statisitcally very few. Instead precisely because they already have about $100-$150k in disposable income, they will invest THAT in much less risky (read lower growth) investments like TBills. That REDUCES GDP GROWTH.

    And your example of your uncles underscores this - they made their money in a risky way, and then GOT OUT AND GOT SAFE.
  3. to some extent,your uncles WERE fleecing the public. They were trading on the information and knowledge of the company that THEY had that others in the marketplace did not have. This is commonly known as "insider trading". In their case it did not amount to illegal activity since they theoreticaly were not "insiders", but it is a less than ethical act since they were taking advantage of information others did not have


And in fact that's a large part of what Walton would do. I was in a startup that was on the receiving end from similar behaviour from Microsoft. They came to our company and said

"We would like to license your technology for our next release of MSDOS - but we don't want to pay you a per-unit license. Instead we want to give you a flat fee and the opportunity to have literature for your next product 'in the box'"
​

To which we asked? Well how is this in our interests? IN essence you are asking us to give away our older product for free and live on the reduced revenue of upgrades? We already have 70% marketshare in this niche, and you are asking us to cut the size of the niche in half.

MSFT's response was

Well we would prefer to make the deal with you, the market leader. And we are willing to pay a small premium for that. BUT if you don't sign the deal, we will go to your next nearest competitor, and sign with them. And the niche will still go away".
​
Essentially they said: You can have

  • 70% of a market that is 50% smaller

    OR
  • 55% of a market that is 50% smaller


Now was that illegal? its borderline. Because they are using THEIR monopoly power to reduce OUR profit margins. Had there been an OS competititve with MS-DOS at the time, we would have had the option of negotiating back and saying - well ok we'll just go to DRI and make a better deal for us. Good luck with the #2 vendor.
 
It does not mean that you subsidize childbirth.

Would you feel the same way about a white single parent with rich parents? Why do you focus so much on the fact that she was black?

I'm not "focusing" on it, but the fact remains that she was, as she called herself, a "twofer" -- doubly "disadvantaged" according the programs because she was a single mother and a minority member. But yes, I'd have been just as disappointed with the programs if a rich white person received unneeded benefits, while a needy person got none.


 
The alternative is to keep Paul Ryan and his oligarchic SuperPac backers from creating a rigged scheme whose sole purpose is to entrench the 1% and keep them powerful where the very rich get richer and the middle class gets poorer.

Lowering taxes for everyone entrenches only the 1 percent? That seems unlikely to this member of the 57 percent (the portion of the population which pays federal income tax).



Did you read what I wrote? The reason that anti-trust legislation was created in the first place was to act as a check on private power. It was not a sure thing. But it seems to me that your logic would lead you to oppose anti-trust legislation as well and support unfettered oligarchical power. You always poo-poo that
.

And if the people who HAD private power were as powerful as you portray them, there would have been no way the legislation made it out of committee for a floor vote, much less that it would be voted and signed into law. That was what I was getting at. No, I don't oppose the anti-trust legislation. At least it's constitutional.



And I disagree with your constitutional analysis. But, apparently you admit that the world was not destroyed because FDR, LBJ, and Obama "exceeded" their authority. I think that if version 1 of Hillarycare (circa 1993-4) had passed, you would put Clinton in the same company. And I see that you give a pass to Republicans. Why is that?

The world was not "destroyed" -- our system of government was damaged. How can you tell this? By the dearth of federal agencies prior to the era, and the exponential increase in the size and scope of federal government since. So much for the concept of a limited government of few and enumerated powers. Yes, I opposed Hillarycare. Who said I gave a free pass to Republicans? You didn't mention any Republicans, so I didn't. Grant was incompetent, Harding crooked, and Nixon was a snake. I disagreed with George H.W. Bush's new taxes, and with George W. Bush's Medicare Part B. You've got me down as a Republican, and I'm really not. I'm more of a "lower case L" libertarian -- but I vote Republican in national elections so that my vote isn't wasted. I decided a long time ago that I'd vote for a Democrat in those races (President, U.S. House, U.S. Senate) when affirmative action and gun control are removed from the Democratic Party's platform. As that hasn't changed, neither has my voting pattern.



No, I do not like the Patriot Act. Do you think that Mitt Romney will get rid of the Patriot Act?

I doubt it, but I think there's a better chance of it happening on his watch than in a new Obama administration.

Are you a member of the ACLU?

Not currently. I used to be. I dropped them because they didn't support one of the key civil rights I favor.

Do you think that the Patriot Act is unconstitutional?
Absolutely.

Would you <img src=images/smilies/animated/censored.gif> slap Scalia for stomping on civil liberties?

Yes, if I felt strongly enough.
 
"
As those high-paying jobs aren't likely to return, how do you build a system of increasing social programs financed on the backs of people making $10 an hour? Because that's who will be the ones paying for it. "

You keep taking more from the folks with all the money.

How much is enough? The top five percent pay most of the income taxes in this country now. It's unrealistic to expect them to pay to support the entire country -- it's perfectly legitimate to call this a form of class warfare.

Why is this so hard to figure out for you? If you win every hand sooner or later you are going to have to give me back some of my money to survive or arm yourself because I am going to take it back from you.

If you can't stand the pressure, don't gamble. Degs is very fond of pointing out that none of our programs are involuntary because we, as citizens, don't have to stay here. Well, that being the case, there are plenty of other nations that have cradle-to-grave health care, high taxation and all the benefices of modern "social democracy." Why don't people go to those countries (and leave mine the hell alone, I like it here).

You are way too smart not to know how every civilization that ended up with a vastly unequal distribution of power or money came to its demise.

I keep seeing people say this has happened, but I've yet to see an actual example of it.

Our tax rates are the lowest in a 100 years. Stop your moaning and groaning and pay up.

Oh, Obama's tax increases wouldn't impact me. I don't make more than $250K a year. I merely realize that the people who do don't have enough money to pay the freight for the people who don't -- and eventually good ol' beneficent Uncle Sam is going to come after the rest of us.

It really gets tiresome listening to the wailing and gnashing of teeth from people with your point of view. Bring back the high tax rates. Start repealing free trade acts that are between unequal economies.

It is similarly tiring to hear someone say, essentially "tax the rich, feed the poor, till there are no, rich no more," but I don't expect that mantra to stop, either. It may surprise you to find that I agree whole heartedly that some of our free trade acts should go -- I'd never have given China MFN status.

Split the banks up. Drop the spending on the military.

When there's less need for the military, we can drop spending below current levels. My local command has experienced 30 percent revenue cuts over the past three years (10 percent per year) with more coming. Yes, this has had an impact on how well our mission gets done -- but who cares, right? All we do is provide the artillery ammo and uniforms for Soldiers, and what good is support like that, anyway?

Socialize medicine.

Amend the Constitution to make that possible.

Increase educational opportunities.

I'm in favor of this -- where will you get the money?

Ignore the right wing for the next 100 years and we may have a chance to survive the coming war between the winners of Reaganomics and the rest of the nation, you know, the 99% of us who will end up losing over and over again.

Or ignore the left wingers for 100 years, and we might live in a free nation where people are not reliant on the government for their every need. That would be a real tragedy, wouldn't it?
 
Trap, my sister worked as a small business banker in Silicon valley in the 1990s (before moving onto the VC business). Her conclusion was that very very few businesses were built "playing by the rules". There are ALWAYS outliers. And your annecdote is intersting in a couple of ways



[*]What the bankers were doing was somewhat unethical. Because from really your uncles lacked the information to be able to invest in an informed way. So these bankers were encouraging what amounted to a gamble, with their houses as the likely collateral. I don't think you'd relate the story the same way if the lenders were "Vinny's Boys" and the "investment" was a "hot tip at the track".

I want to clear something up, and it's my fault for not making it clearer -- the men in question weren't my uncles. They were co-workers of my father, and they were brother's too each other. That's really not important to the anecdote, or to your point, except that it might clarify that I don't have any rich uncles that are going to leave me a million, or anything like that.

In all honesty, I somewhat agree that the banking practices here were unethical - but this was a bank tied to the Teamster's union (which is why they were allowed on the dock in the first place) so that isn't a riveting shock. Still, all you had to do to "be informed" about the condition of Yellow Freight was to work there, and have the ability to read the stock report in the daily newspaper -- not beyond most 10th graders.

[*]you also demostrate how the middle class has a much greater incentive to "invest well" than the wealthy". They essentially borrowed a year's income to make this investment. How many people earing $350,000/yr are going to borrow $350,000 to make what amounts to a gamble? The answer is statisitcally very few. Instead precisely because they already have about $100-$150k in disposable income, they will invest THAT in much less risky (read lower growth) investments like TBills. That REDUCES GDP GROWTH.

More like half a year's salary. These were teamster's off casual status, but not yet having enough seniority for driving jobs. I'm guessing that at that time they made about $7 per hour -- roughly the equivalent of a $50,000 a year job today. And I think you're wrong on the pattern of someone with more income -- more means you want more. The rich people I know are much more likely to take risks than their poorer friends. Why? Because they figure they can afford them.


And your example of your uncles underscores this - they made their money in a risky way, and then GOT OUT AND GOT SAFE.

Dad's friends retired -- I'm not certain that opening a couple of burger joints was a great investment, but it might have looked good in the early 1970s, especially before the OPEC embargos. I'll stipulate they were lucky.

[*] to some extent,your uncles WERE fleecing the public. They were trading on the information and knowledge of the company that THEY had that others in the marketplace did not have. This is commonly known as "insider trading". In their case it did not amount to illegal activity since they theoreticaly were not "insiders", but it is a less than ethical act since they were taking advantage of information others did not have

Nah -- the only "insider" knowledge they would have had would have involved the company's negotiation with the Teamsters local (later in his life, my Dad found the qualifications that had been imposed on the Commercial Driver's License almost laughable -- "they broke the unions by deregulating to where independents can operate -- and then they found out hopheads and cowboys (deragatory trucker's term) can't deliver safely, and put all these requirements in place. We already had those requirements in the union, and someone who has them now will demand higher pay for having them). They wouldn't have had any knowledge about the stocks other than what they read in the paper.

I found your anecdote about Microsoft interesting. It wouldn't be the first time that company had played hardball. I'm not certain, however, that it's the same thing as Walmart entering a town. Walmart operates a business. Since Sam Walton died, that business has been operated in deplorable ways -- but it is neither illegal nor unethical for Walmart to set up in a small town, even if that destroys other retailers in that town.

In small town in Missouri where I used to live, a big supermarket chain opened a store. Someone complained that an older supermarket was being driven out of business. I heard an old-timer in the barbershop say, "Well, you don't remember when that local store opened, and it put to other storefront's out of business. That's life."
 
trap,

Well, we can just agree to disagree on the merits/demerits of the Ryan plan and the constitution. You are not evil. I am not evil. Our principles and philosophies of the constitution are different. We both vote.

I absolutely disagree that Romney will get rid of the Patriot Act. I think that it is much more likely that - Cheney style - he will double down on it. Of course, he will leave folks like you alone. And I suspect that as long as your personal freedom is not infringed, you won't care.

On gun control and affirmative action, if those are hot-button issues to you, you should vote your conscience. I am not helped by the second amendment because I am not a gun collector. In my opinion, the proliferation of guns makes me less safe and less secure. I am more threatened by strangers with a ton of guns than I am protected by the second amendment. That is just the reality to me (whatever is in the constitution.) On affirmative action, I favor "levelling the playing field" to offer opportunities to folks who are disadvantaged (needy) or meritorious. But I think that my definition of disadvantaged and meritorious is a little wider than yours is. Just my opinion.

Anyway, I don't think that this discussion is just going around in circles at this point. :ciao:

Lowering taxes for everyone entrenches only the 1 percent? That seems unlikely to this member of the 57 percent (the portion of the population which pays federal income tax).



.

And if the people who HAD private power were as powerful as you portray them, there would have been no way the legislation made it out of committee for a floor vote, much less that it would be voted and signed into law. That was what I was getting at. No, I don't oppose the anti-trust legislation. At least it's constitutional.





The world was not "destroyed" -- our system of government was damaged. How can you tell this? By the dearth of federal agencies prior to the era, and the exponential increase in the size and scope of federal government since. So much for the concept of a limited government of few and enumerated powers. Yes, I opposed Hillarycare. Who said I gave a free pass to Republicans? You didn't mention any Republicans, so I didn't. Grant was incompetent, Harding crooked, and Nixon was a snake. I disagreed with George H.W. Bush's new taxes, and with George W. Bush's Medicare Part B. You've got me down as a Republican, and I'm really not. I'm more of a "lower case L" libertarian -- but I vote Republican in national elections so that my vote isn't wasted. I decided a long time ago that I'd vote for a Democrat in those races (President, U.S. House, U.S. Senate) when affirmative action and gun control are removed from the Democratic Party's platform. As that hasn't changed, neither has my voting pattern.





I doubt it, but I think there's a better chance of it happening on his watch than in a new Obama administration.



Not currently. I used to be. I dropped them because they didn't support one of the key civil rights I favor.

Do you think that the Patriot Act is unconstitutional?
Absolutely.



Yes, if I felt strongly enough.
 
The good thing is that this thread is being controlled by the quality posters and the riff raff are long gone. This is why I spend time here and Trap remains my favorite right wing poster of all time even if I think he is dead wrong. Thank you everyone yet again.
 
Lowering taxes for everyone entrenches only the 1 percent? That seems unlikely to this member of the 57 percent (the portion of the population which pays federal income tax).
FICA is a Federal Tax.
FICA is a tax on income.

All but a tiny handful of individuals do not pay FICA. So please stop making this ludicrous claim

Secondly that it seems unlikely to you is hardly a compelling point. You are ignoring that this "entrenching" is a threshold issue. In economics it is known as "barrier to entry". If you enable the wealthy to create higher barriers to entry (and transfering net wealth to them in the aggregate does exactly that), you REDUCE the ability for the rest of society to have income mobility.

And in fact we see EXACTLY THAT. Whereas in other industrialized nations income mobility has INCREASED of the last 30 years in the USA it has not. And in fact since the wealthy started getting a disproporitonate share of the tax cuts, we have seen a steady DECREASE in the rate of income mobility in the USA. This is exactly what was predicted at the time the first Reagan cuts went into effect, and the predicitons have worked out. In fact after GWB instituted the lowest tax rates since WWII

  • Our Economy stagnated at 22% below historic average GDP Growth rate
  • Capital reinvestment reached the lowest levels since WWII
  • Wealth disparity INCREASED
  • Economic Mobility DECREASED

Now of that's what you want - go ahead and vote for the guy who says he will "double down" on this.

The world was not "destroyed" -- our system of government was damaged. How can you tell this? By the dearth of federal agencies prior to the era, and the exponential increase in the size and scope of federal government since. So much for the concept of a limited government of few and enumerated powers.
That the scope of government EXPANDS is not a refutation of either limited government nor of enumerated powers. Your underlying presumption, that the government was at its FULL EXERCISE OF POWERS prior that point, simply is not supportable by any factual or logical analsis.

No, I do not like the Patriot Act. Do you think that Mitt Romney will get rid of the Patriot Act?
I doubt it, but I think there's a better chance of it happening on his watch than in a new Obama administration.
Based on what? It was

  • A conservative GOP Congress and WH that put the PATRIOT Act into force
  • A Conservative GOP and WH that INCREASED the power of the Defense Dept in part via PATRIOT Act
and Romney has PROMISED to INCREASE THE POWER OF THE DEFENSE DEPARTMENT

So on that basis alone, the EXACT OPPOSITE is likely to happen.




.

And if the people who HAD private power were as powerful as you portray them, there would have been no way the legislation made it out of committee for a floor vote, much less that it would be voted and signed into law. That was what I was getting at. No, I don't oppose the anti-trust legislation. At least it's constitutional.





The world was not "destroyed" -- our system of government was damaged. How can you tell this? By the dearth of federal agencies prior to the era, and the exponential increase in the size and scope of federal government since. So much for the concept of a limited government of few and enumerated powers. Yes, I opposed Hillarycare. Who said I gave a free pass to Republicans? You didn't mention any Republicans, so I didn't. Grant was incompetent, Harding crooked, and Nixon was a snake. I disagreed with George H.W. Bush's new taxes, and with George W. Bush's Medicare Part B. You've got me down as a Republican, and I'm really not. I'm more of a "lower case L" libertarian -- but I vote Republican in national elections so that my vote isn't wasted. I decided a long time ago that I'd vote for a Democrat in those races (President, U.S. House, U.S. Senate) when affirmative action and gun control are removed from the Democratic Party's platform. As that hasn't changed, neither has my voting pattern.





I doubt it, but I think there's a better chance of it happening on his watch than in a new Obama administration.



Not currently. I used to be. I dropped them because they didn't support one of the key civil rights I favor.

Do you think that the Patriot Act is unconstitutional?
Absolutely.



Yes, if I felt strongly enough.[/QUOTE]
 
FICA is a Federal Tax.
FICA is a tax on income.

All but a tiny handful of individuals do not pay FICA. So please stop making this ludicrous claim

Income tax other than FICA is the primary source of governmental revenue. About half the population doesn't pay that income tax. The "claim" stands because it is not only not ludicrous, it is a documented fact.

Secondly that it seems unlikely to you is hardly a compelling point. You are ignoring that this "entrenching" is a threshold issue. In economics it is known as "barrier to entry". If you enable the wealthy to create higher barriers to entry (and transfering net wealth to them in the aggregate does exactly that), you REDUCE the ability for the rest of society to have income mobility.

And if you increase government regulations on health, safety, handicap access, etc., you have erected very large barriers to entry, meaning only someone who is already rich can afford to start a business. If you enable the government to create ever higher barriers to entry, no one not already rich can ever expect to get that way.

And in fact we see EXACTLY THAT. Whereas in other industrialized nations income mobility has INCREASED of the last 30 years in the USA it has not. And in fact since the wealthy started getting a disproporitonate share of the tax cuts, we have seen a steady DECREASE in the rate of income mobility in the USA. This is exactly what was predicted at the time the first Reagan cuts went into effect, and the predicitons have worked out. In fact after GWB instituted the lowest tax rates since WWII


In other countries mobility is better? It seems to me that if you look at "other countries in the Western World," other than Germany, what you see is mobility, downward. The creation of the Eurozone means that none of these countries (Spain, France, Italy, Greece...) can follow their post WWII pattern, which was to create large debts, and then inflate their currencies to pay the debts. Someone poor in Spain may have a better chance to move up than someone poor in the U.S., but "move up" to what? Having a million dollars that is now worth a penny on the dollar is hardly mobility.




That the scope of government EXPANDS is not a refutation of either limited government nor of enumerated powers. Your underlying presumption, that the government was at its FULL EXERCISE OF POWERS prior that point, simply is not supportable by any factual or logical analsis.

An ever expanding government cannot be said to be limited. Where are the limits?


Based on what? It was

  • A conservative GOP Congress and WH that put the PATRIOT Act into force
  • A Conservative GOP and WH that INCREASED the power of the Defense Dept in part via PATRIOT Act
and Romney has PROMISED to INCREASE THE POWER OF THE DEFENSE DEPARTMENT

I didn't say it WOULD happen, I said it was more likely to happen -- what that is based on is the fact that the current president has a history we can study -- that history does not include making any changes to the Patriot Act.
 
Income tax other than FICA is the primary source of governmental revenue.
Only if you exclude Medicare and SS from being Governmental Programs. Now if you want to limit your discussions about an "overintrusive Federal Government" to NON SS and NON Medicare programs, THEN and ONLY THEN can you make this claim. But of course you don't. You conflate the programs. Which means to be logically consistent, you must also include the relevant taxes on income as well.

Secondly that it seems unlikely to you is hardly a compelling point. You are ignoring that this "entrenching" is a threshold issue. In economics it is known as "barrier to entry". If you enable the wealthy to create higher barriers to entry (and transfering net wealth to them in the aggregate does exactly that), you REDUCE the ability for the rest of society to have income mobility.
And if you increase government regulations on health, safety, handicap access, etc., you have erected very large barriers to entry, meaning only someone who is already rich can afford to start a business.[/quote]
THREE problems with your claims here.

FIRST and most significant, is that small businesses, particularly sole-propriatorships, are largely exempt from these regs and thus it is NOT a "large barrier to entry".

SECOND, the single most common cause of startup failure is access to adequate capital in startup. Since the Chamber of Commerce (Hardly a "liberal org")puts regulatory costs at about 11% of COGS INCLUDING regulations like protection of private property, the impact of Regulations vs. Concentration of Wealth as a "barrier to Entry" is about 9:1.

THIRDLY is the notion of "parity". Since EVERYONE is subject to regulations, there is no actual differentiated barrier to entry. That is NOT the case in access to capital when you have large concentrations of wealth.

So your analysis basically is wrong on three basic issues.

In other countries mobility is better? It seems to me that if you look at "other countries in the Western World," other than Germany, what you see is mobility, downward.
Wrong. simply wrong. Yes in Greece and Spain you see downward mobility, but in France, and even the UK you see upward mobility, and evenin places like Ireland, excepting for the current downturn, over the last 3 decades you have seen MORE mobility. You are simply wrong on the data.

An ever expanding government cannot be said to be limited. Where are the limits?
Sure it can. You seem to be having problems with the notion of a limited infinite set. It actually is very common in nature. Consider the set of Positive Integers. Starts at 1 and goes onto infinity. But it is inherently limited. It is limited to integers: fractions, decimals, imaginary numbers are all excluded. Thus it is a MORE LIMITED SET than the "set of all possible numbers" even though both sets are limited.

Same with The Government. A government that is precluded from even ONE domain of control, is by definition a "limited government". One that is limited from 10 "bill of Rights" domains, from the Habeas, immigration, Blood Libel, Slavery, unequal treatment, domains is EVEN MORE LIMITED.

Being limited does not mean that it cannot "ever expand". Because the Universe is infinite, as long as it applies to a subset of Real Life, it is by definition "limited.

I didn't say it WOULD happen, I said it was more likely to happen -- what that is based on is the fact that the current president has a history we can study -- that history does not include making any changes to the Patriot Act.

First you are wrong on the changes to PATRIOT act. Obama voted for the changes to the original PATRIOT ACT as a Senator, ones that restricted the "unlimited wire tap" claims that GWB put forth. And as POTUS he has opted to follow the MORE LIMITED FISA based wiretaps. Another example is Obama's MORE LIMITED use of military tribunals that PATRIOT enabled. Both are clear REDUCTIONS of authority under PATRIOT Act. That these have not been attempted in Congress because of the highly partisan nature of the House is a different issue

Secondly you have offered ZERO REASONS to expect Romney - who has announced he wants an EXPANSION of PATRIOT act RELATED activities over what Obama has done - would be MORE LIKELY to cut back on PATRIOT ACT. Everything Romney has said, including his "letter of the law" arguements about his own taxes, indicates Romney would be MORE LIKELY to drive right to the edge of what PATRIOT permits.

So while I don't doubt you BELIEVE that "Romney is more likely" the concrete evidence for this points in EXACTLY THE OPPOSITE WAY:

  • Obama has voluntarily REDUCED the use of PATRIOT Act Authority.
    Romney in most other cases has taken the authority to act "to the limit of the law"
  • Obama has sought to REDUCE government activity around PATRIOT Act domains in general
    Romney has stated he will INCREASE government activity in PATRIOT ACT domains

Sorry there just isn't any "reasoned" basis for your belief.
 
Back
Top