New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

wow. Remember, folks

like I am always talking about similarities between commies, maoists and modern con movement. More Americans are coming to the same thought.
Please, read. That was put way better than I do:
NYRB article makes the comparison explicit.

An excerpt :

The problem with this sort of economic determinism is that it is Marxism in reverse, with the problems of the original kind. Planning by finance capitalists replaces planning by the party elite. Marx’s old dream, the “withering away” of the state, is the centerpiece of the Ryan budget: cut taxes on the rich, claim that cutting government functions and the closing of unspecified loopholes will balance budgets, and thereby make the state shrink. Just like the Marxists of another era, the Republican ticket substitutes mythical thinking about the economy for loyalty to the nation.
​
Another taste:
Hayek’s Road to Serfdom, which in its better passages is a paean to modesty in economics, is read by leading Republicans as the formula that intervention in the free market must lead to totalitarianism. This is a nice confident story, with a more than superficial resemblance to the nice confident Marxist story that a free market without intervention would bring revolution. Like Marxism, the Hayekian ideology is a theory of everything, which has an answer for everything. Like Marxism, it allows politicians who accept the theory to predict the future, using their purported total knowledge to create and to justify suffering among those who do not hold power. Ayn Rand is appealing in a more private way because she celebrates unbridled anarchic capitalism: it magnifies inequality and brings pleasure to the wealthy, who deserve it for being so wonderful, and pain to the masses, who deserve it for being so stupid. Hayek thought that we should hesitate to intervene in the market because certainty about economic matters was impossible; Rand thought that the law of the jungle was itself a rather good (and sexy) thing.


more:
Hayek and Rand are comfortable intellectual company not because they explain reality, but because, like all effective ideologists, they remove the need for any actual contact with it. They were reacting to real historical experience, Hayek with National Socialism and Rand with Soviet communism. But precisely because they were reacting, they flew to extreme interpretations. Just as untethered capitalism did not bring proletarian utopia, as the Marxists thought, intervention and redistribution did not bring totalitarianism, as anti-Marxists such as Hayek claimed.


Hayek’s native Austria was vulnerable to radicalism from the right in the 1930s precisely because it followed the very policies that he recommended. It was one of the least interventionist states in Europe, which left its population hugely vulnerable to the Great Depression—and to Hitler. Austria became a prosperous democracy after World War II because its governments ignored Hayek’s advice and created a welfare state. As Americans at the time understood, making provisions for citizens in need was an effective way to defend democracy from the extreme right and left.



And :
The way to national prosperity in the twenty-first century is surely to think non-ideologically, to recognize that politics is a choice among constraints and goods rather than a story about a single good that would triumph if only evil people would allow it to function without constraints. The market works very well for some things, the government is desperately needed for others, and stories that dismiss either one are nothing more than ideology.
 
Or another way of putting it...

The Right always mocks the supposed "Liberals who dream of a Utopia"....yet their entire ideology is based on a UTOPIAN premise. That an almost non-existant government and zero burdens on the wealthy will produce endless prosperity for EVERYBODY and that "individuals" will be able to reverse corporate abuse, pollution, tainted food, etc.

And we KNOW that their "Utopia" won't work...because we HAD IT...it was called the 1890s and people revolted against it.
 
No need, I get it. You're saying that capitalists owning and directing the means of production that they produce is bad, while government facilitating the transfer of ownership of the means of production that other people created to the workers is good.

That is the crux of your complaint
 
Or another way of putting it...

The Right always mocks the supposed "Liberals who dream of a Utopia"....yet their entire ideology is based on a UTOPIAN premise. That an almost non-existent government and zero burdens on the wealthy will produce endless prosperity for EVERYBODY and that "individuals" will be able to reverse corporate abuse, pollution, tainted food, etc.

And we KNOW that their "Utopia" won't work...because we HAD IT...it was called the 1890s and people revolted against it.

yes, GG. But as I stated numerous times and the author did not mentioned it.
Modern cons even borrowed Maoist/communist methods to advance their Utopia- constant lies , distortions and have designated network(like Pravda) for that purpose to brainwash week minded loyal idiots.
 
No need, I get it. You're saying that capitalists owning and directing the means of production that they produce is bad, while government facilitating the transfer of ownership of the means of production that other people created to the workers is good.

That is the crux of your complaint

wow, you continue to surprise me , when I thought your mental depravity reached bottom.

May be you can ask somebody to translate the article in plain con to you?
 
Well, since you're incapable of any form of interpretation, then maybe I should talk with someone with at least a rational mind.
 
Back
Top