New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

YES! It's about time...

Right? Kind of like when the Biden administration omitted housing, gas and food from the economic measure during his regime. It did give the media an opportunity to redefine what a recession was.

Yep, a lot like that. Amazing how alike the two sides are once you look past the empty rhetoric
 
Of course it will, that is why they are doing it.

Why else do you think they want to do it?

How?

Government is one of the largest spenders of any entity in the US. How will taking their part in the measure out help the numbers?

Simply declaring it is not a reasonable argument.
 
How?

Government is one of the largest spenders of any entity in the US. How will taking their part in the measure out help the numbers?

Simply declaring it is not a reasonable argument.

Because they are not really taking it out, they are just [Unwelcome language removed] around with the formula to hide the coming recession.

The Govt gives a contract to Boeing, will the output by Boeing still be counted? Yes it will...thus the Govt spending will still be counted.

The Govt pay my salary, I spend that money and it gets counted towards the GPD.

The Govt pays my pension, I spend that money and it gets counted towards the GPD.
 
Because they are not really taking it out, they are just [Unwelcome language removed] around with the formula to hide the coming recession.

The Govt gives a contract to Boeing, will the output by Boeing still be counted? Yes it will...thus the Govt spending will still be counted.

The Govt pay my salary, I spend that money and it gets counted towards the GPD.

The Govt pays my pension, I spend that money and it gets counted towards the GPD.

But that is always the case. It's spending that is always going on. It's just now the contract isn't counted anymore.

The government isn't adding anything. It's deleting its participation. Again, how does that help the numbers?
 
Because they are not really taking it out, they are just [Unwelcome language removed] around with the formula to hide the coming recession.

The Govt gives a contract to Boeing, will the output by Boeing still be counted? Yes it will...thus the Govt spending will still be counted.

The Govt pay my salary, I spend that money and it gets counted towards the GPD.

The Govt pays my pension, I spend that money and it gets counted towards the GPD.

It's GDP, but whatever. The fact is the "government" doesn't "pay" you anything. The taxpayers do. And you bureaucrats' tax payments don't count, because they are made by the private sector as part of your salary.
 
It's GDP, but whatever. The fact is the "government" doesn't "pay" you anything. The taxpayers do. And you bureaucrats' tax payments don't count, because they are made by the private sector as part of your salary.

Sorry for the typo.

Since the tax payers (of which I am one and yes my tax payments count just as much as yours) are paying it then it should be included in the GDP since it is the tax payers doing the paying.

Glad we worked that out!
 
you hide a recession by changing the math to make the recession go away

but it will not work.
Great. Now show your homework and share your math to making the point that removing the money spent by govt. from the reported GDP is going to hide a recession. Please make this make sense with some concrete examples.
 
Sorry for the typo.

Since the tax payers (of which I am one and yes my tax payments count just as much as yours) are paying it then it should be included in the GDP since it is the tax payers doing the paying.

Glad we worked that out!

Yeah, except I'm paying my taxes and YOURS. The government doesn't actually "earn" money to pay you with. It takes it from the private sector.
 
Right? Kind of like when the Biden administration omitted housing, gas and food from the economic measure during his regime. It did give the media an opportunity to redefine what a recession was.
The facts don't quite agree with you. The media doesn't define recessions. The NBER does. We had a major recession in 2007 thru 2010...and inflation was pretty low...

List of recessions in the United States - Wikipedia
 
Back
Top