New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

12 Vs. 2000

seems you post that same script daily, especially when you are getting your ass handed to you on a broom pole.............

that explains more of why you have no clients and are here 24/7......................
I gladly reply to things that are close enough to English that I can puzzle through them. Sometimes the errors/text ratio gets high enough, though, that it just comes across as gibberish to me.
 
I didn't claim they had. But Christians have attacked women's health clinics and OB/Gyns, and are carrying out terror campaigns in central Africa.
Yeah, make a moral equivalent between cartoons and murder via abortions.

Is a fetus human? Yes.
Is a fetus alive? Yes.
Does abortion terminate a human life? Yes.
 
Yeah, make a moral equivalent between cartoons and murder via abortions.

Is a fetus human? Yes.
Is a fetus alive? Yes.
Does abortion terminate a human life? Yes.
I had an ugly mole taken off my back. I assume it was a human mole and it certainly was alive before it was removed and dead afterward. So it goes.
 
I had an ugly mole taken off my back. I assume it was a human mole and it certainly was alive before it was removed and dead afterward. So it goes.

I see! Your mole had a brain and when it was removed all that you had in that department went with it.

Nevermind that your mole has your complete and distinct DNA while your fetus has its own DNA as property unto itself.
 
I see! Your mole had a brain and when it was removed all that you had in that department went with it.

Nevermind that your mole has your complete and distinct DNA while your fetus has its own DNA as property unto itself.
Who cares if it has its own DNA or not? If someone were to clone me, and raise the clone to adulthood, the lack of distinct DNA would not reduce his right to life one little bit. And if someone showed that my mole was cancerous, as a result of some mutations in the genes, giving it distinct DNA, that wouldn't create a right to life for it.
 
Who cares if it has its own DNA or not? If someone were to clone me, and raise the clone to adulthood, the lack of distinct DNA would not reduce his right to life one little bit. And if someone showed that my mole was cancerous, as a result of some mutations in the genes, giving it distinct DNA, that wouldn't create a right to life for it.
You missed the part about a brain being part of the equation? Because it was hidden in your mole joke?

You have more in common genetically with your cancerous mole than your clone believe it or not. lol. Keep trying though.

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/identical-twins-genes-are-not-identical/

http://www.themarysue.com/identical-twin-difference/
 
I'm not saying that adding energy always leads to a more ordered state. I'm saying that there's nothing about the concept of entropy that prevents systems from becoming more ordered when they can draw on an external energy source. Crystals are an obvious example. Every time it snows, the process happens countless times, with disordered water molecules forming into exquisitely complex snowflakes. Throw together a planet's worth of chemical reactions, plenty of energy, and run the experiment for a billion years, and there's nothing at all improbable about the idea that one of those interactions will produce a self-reproducing organic molecule that could form the basis for later life. The exact details of how that would play out is still being studied by scientists, who don't have the advantage of a planetary scale lab and a billion years to find the answer by random trial and error. It's possible we'll never know. It's even possible that the original molecules didn't form on Earth. But none of those mysteries in any way require or suggest the existence of a god or leprechauns or flying spaghetti monsters to set the whole thing in motion. In fact, injecting such hypothetical players into the process merely introduces the new mystery of where they came from.

I love how evo-theists all speak to the biochemistry of life just all falling into place with a wave of the hand. That the life dominoes are evidently inevitable . As easy as a cascading domino stunt for mother nature. And despite all that innate natural law that drives towards life forms, humans cannot set up those dominoes in a simplistic greatly abstracted fashion. Evo-theist by their own reckoning should be able to put a life force creating slinky at the top of the stairs and start it down towards an evolution of life and all sans dieux.
 
I love how evo-theists all speak to the biochemistry of life just all falling into place with a wave of the hand.

You're exactly wrong. It is theists who think of biochemistry as a result of a wave of the Almighty's hand. Scientists, on the other hand, think of it as something that came about in small stages over many millions of years, through innumerable combinations.

Evo-theist by their own reckoning should be able to put a life force creating slinky at the top of the stairs and start it down towards an evolution of life and all sans dieux.

Scientists have, in fact, demonstrated how some of the earliest precursors to life could form. However, you simply don't grasp the scale of the historical events. We're talking, essentially, about a planetary-scale (or larger, if some components of life came from space) experiment conducted over hundreds of millions of years, where all you need is just one self-replicating process to start in all that time and space. It would be remarkable if scientists stumbled across the correct solution to that problem with their vastly smaller and shorter experiments. An extremely low -probability combination might happen with a planetary scale experiment and yet not happen in a few Petri dishes.
 
You're exactly wrong. It is theists who think of biochemistry as a result of a wave of the Almighty's hand. Scientists, on the other hand, think of it as something that came about in small stages over many millions of years, through innumerable combinations.



Scientists have, in fact, demonstrated how some of the earliest precursors to life could form. However, you simply don't grasp the scale of the historical events. We're talking, essentially, about a planetary-scale (or larger, if some components of life came from space) experiment conducted over hundreds of millions of years, where all you need is just one self-replicating process to start in all that time and space. It would be remarkable if scientists stumbled across the correct solution to that problem with their vastly smaller and shorter experiments. An extremely low -probability combination might happen with a planetary scale experiment and yet not happen in a few Petri dishes.

No, theists as knowledge has increased believe a guiding hand provided for the catalyst/enzymes for life.

Scientist have stumbled around how the earliest precursors to life could have formed despite their and your belief that life is a natural inevitable consequence of this physical reality.

Hilarious really.
 
No, theists as knowledge has increased believe a guiding hand provided for the catalyst/enzymes for life.

There are three problems with that idea:

(1) There's no evidence to support it at all.
(2) It's an unnecessary complication -- it's both plausible and simpler to hypothesize that those things came together without a guiding hand.
(3) It just creates a bigger mystery -- if we invent a "Guiding Hand" to explain the existence of enzymes, how do we explain the existence of this "Guiding Hand"? That's moving in the wrong direction... towards much greater complexity. If we aren't comfortable with the idea that mere enzymes could come together, why would be be comfortable with the idea that some sort of higher intelligence could?
 
ahahahahahahahahaha.

I now know how little you've thought or know about these topics. Go back to your economic debates with Lukey. Thank you.
You can try to laugh away your failure, but it's still there. I spoke of cloning. You linked to articles about identical twins. If you want to establish that there are actually genetic differences among artificial clones, you'd want to link to articles about that. It's possible such difference do exist, thanks to limits in the cloning process. I don't know. But, either way, it doesn't alter the point I was making -- the the genetic individuality of an organism would be a stupid thing on which to ground its right to life. Even if an absolutely genetically identical clone were only a hypothetical possibility, surely you can still see that if might still be worthy of a right to life, despite that lack of unique genes.
 
You can try to laugh away your failure, but it's still there. I spoke of cloning. You linked to articles about identical twins. If you want to establish that there are actually genetic differences among artificial clones, you'd want to link to articles about that. It's possible such difference do exist, thanks to limits in the cloning process. I don't know. But, either way, it doesn't alter the point I was making -- the the genetic individuality of an organism would be a stupid thing on which to ground its right to life. Even if an absolutely genetically identical clone were only a hypothetical possibility, surely you can still see that if might still be worthy of a right to life, despite that lack of unique genes.

Take a moment to take a deep breath and think.
 
Done. Now you do the same. Do you see your error now?
Twins are clones. They come form the same fertilized egg that split. If I needed your clone I'd be better off with your twin than taking your skin cell and making it pluripotent and sticking it into an incubator (and hope to get your more identical twin than the one you were born with). Try not to rely on your science fiction reading here.
 
Twins are clones. They come form the same fertilized egg that split. If I needed your clone I'd be better off with your twin than taking your skin cell and making it pluripotent and sticking it into an incubator (and hope to get your more identical twin than the one you were born with). Try not to rely on your science fiction reading here.
The natural twinning process, obviously, results in some genetic variation between the twins. Is there similar variation between artificial clones? I don't know. It's at least hypothetically possible to have a genetically identical clone.... and the relevant point, in this context, is that if such clones did exist, you wouldn't regard them as lacking a right to life on the basis of lacking unique genetic code. Understand you mistake yet?
 
The natural twinning process, obviously, results in some genetic variation between the twins. Is there similar variation between artificial clones? I don't know. It's at least hypothetically possible to have a genetically identical clone.... and the relevant point, in this context, is that if such clones did exist, you wouldn't regard them as lacking a right to life on the basis of lacking unique genetic code. Understand you mistake yet?
We can't even agree on your mistake. lol.
 
We can't even agree on your mistake. lol.
Here, I'll recount your error in a way that is simple enough that even you might understand it:

(1) You cited the fact a fetus has its own DNA (as opposed to my mole sharing mine) as part of the reason a fetus has a right to life.

(2) I pointed out that whether or not it has its own DNA is irrelevant to the question, and I pointed out that if someone were to clone me, and raise the clone to adulthood, his lack of distinct DNA would not reduce his right to life one little bit.

(3) You brought up natural identical twins, which have some genetic differentiation from each other.

Do you see how you've charged off in a random direction there? My hypothetical was specifically about cloning me, not about natural identical twins. And even if it winds up being true that even artificial clones, as a practical matter, have some genetic variation (I don't know if that's true), it still doesn't change my argument. If somehow a perfect artificial cloning process resulted in a perfect clone who is completely genetically identical to some other person, you would not regard this as depriving the clone (or the original) of a right to life, would you? Assuming the answer is no, then just admit that the DNA argument was a red herring, and that having distinct DNA is not the basis for a right to life.
 
Here, I'll recount your error in a way that is simple enough that even you might understand it:

(1) You cited the fact a fetus has its own DNA (as opposed to my mole sharing mine) as part of the reason a fetus has a right to life.

(2) I pointed out that whether or not it has its own DNA is irrelevant to the question, and I pointed out that if someone were to clone me, and raise the clone to adulthood, his lack of distinct DNA would not reduce his right to life one little bit.

(3) You brought up natural identical twins, which have some genetic differentiation from each other.

Do you see how you've charged off in a random direction there? My hypothetical was specifically about cloning me, not about natural identical twins. And even if it winds up being true that even artificial clones, as a practical matter, have some genetic variation (I don't know if that's true), it still doesn't change my argument. If somehow a perfect artificial cloning process resulted in a perfect clone who is completely genetically identical to some other person, you would not regard this as depriving the clone (or the original) of a right to life, would you? Assuming the answer is no, then just admit that the DNA argument was a red herring, and that having distinct DNA is not the basis for a right to life.

I said you have more genetic similarity to your own cancerous mole than to your real world clone. You insist the theoretical (science fiction) clone is more exact than the real world clone. Once again a cell taken from you and grown in a petri dish to be your clone - its genetic variance to you would be similar to that of your natural born twin. Look it up.
 
Back
Top