New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A line-crossing issue.

Arkady

President
This issue interested me, because it seems like one where people wouldn't fall into predictable left-right camps:

http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2011/04/19/159771/jan-brewer-tea-party-flag/?mobile=nc

I'm not so much interested in this decision to protect a particular Tea-Party-associated flag, but rather the broader question of whether the government should be overriding homeowner's associations to allow residents to fly certain flags the government likes.

This seems like something where neither a liberal, nor a conservative, nor a libertarian has a comfortable place to come down reflexively. For example, a libertarian would certainly object to rules against flying flags at your own home if the rules were made by the government. But in this case, the rules are made by a privatized government -- a democratically-elected homeowner's association leadership, which have legal force only because the homeowner submitted to them, contractually, as part of joining the association or buying into the neighborhood. So, where does the libertarian come down? Does he condemn the actual government for interfering in a private contractual matter? Or does he condemn the quasi-government for interfering in an individual's use of his own property? Or both?

It's also legally problematic, when you have government creating special rights, trumping private contracts, for some kinds of free speech and not others. What if I form an anti-Tea Party group that emphasizes the importance of a strong central government, and I use as a symbol a flag including another famous symbol from the revolutionary era:

http://www.earlyamerica.com/earlyamerica/firsts/cartoon/snake.jpg

Can the government say the Tea Party flag can be displayed despite homeowner's association rules, but the anti-Tea Party flag doesn't get to trump that contractual arrangement? In other words, is it OK for government to control the public debate by way of allowing private corporations and organizations to censor some ideas, while preventing them from censoring others? Is that any better, in effect, than the government censoring things directly?

To put it in an even more controversial light, what if the government were to pass a law saying corporations can't bar their workers from displaying Christian symbols at work, but they say nothing about corporations barring their workers from displaying Jewish or Muslim symbols at work? Would that favoritism be OK? I'd argue no, on the basis of the establishment clause of the First Amendment, but it's not as clear in a context where we're talking about other first amendment rights.

I find the whole area interesting, because it's so hard to come up with intellectually consistent rules.
 
I guess the question some might ask is, what did the members of the original Tea Party represent in 1773, who and what were they protesting and why, as compared to 2013 or any of the period the current "Tea Party" has been around?

The current "Tea Party" lives under the Republican Party umbrella and both seem to be claiming they represent the "conservative" end of the politial pole and have complaints against the very system the original Tea Party members came to symoblize as a catalyst for putting IN place as the response to the "Don't Tread On Me" suppression they were feeling from a unitary parliamentary constitutional monarchy.

The irony seems to be that the current Tea Party is protesting the very thing the original Tea Party event became a catalyst for and the "Don't Tread On Me" flag of today has come to represent a protest of the very government system the original Tea Party event helped put into place.

Additionally, in 1773, who were the "conservatives" and what did they represent?

More Bizzaro world.
 
This seems like something where neither a liberal, nor a conservative, nor a libertarian has a comfortable place to come down reflexively.

Since I don't fit very comfortably in either of those three niches, I'll offer my opinion. The contract that the homeowners voluntarily entered rules the situation and the state should keep their noses out of it.

Now, I'll go read the article and see if my assumption as to it's content was correct. ;)
 
Now, I'll go read the article and see if my assumption as to it's content was correct. ;)

Pretty close. More "small government" -- Republican style. I wouldn't even support an out for Old Glory. No flags means no flags. If you don't like it, either renegotiate the contract or move.
 
This issue interested me, because it seems like one where people wouldn't fall into predictable left-right camps:

http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2011/04/19/159771/jan-brewer-tea-party-flag/?mobile=nc

I'm not so much interested in this decision to protect a particular Tea-Party-associated flag, but rather the broader question of whether the government should be overriding homeowner's associations to allow residents to fly certain flags the government likes.

This seems like something where neither a liberal, nor a conservative, nor a libertarian has a comfortable place to come down reflexively. For example, a libertarian would certainly object to rules against flying flags at your own home if the rules were made by the government. But in this case, the rules are made by a privatized government -- a democratically-elected homeowner's association leadership, which have legal force only because the homeowner submitted to them, contractually, as part of joining the association or buying into the neighborhood. So, where does the libertarian come down? Does he condemn the actual government for interfering in a private contractual matter? Or does he condemn the quasi-government for interfering in an individual's use of his own property? Or both?

It's also legally problematic, when you have government creating special rights, trumping private contracts, for some kinds of free speech and not others. What if I form an anti-Tea Party group that emphasizes the importance of a strong central government, and I use as a symbol a flag including another famous symbol from the revolutionary era:

http://www.earlyamerica.com/earlyamerica/firsts/cartoon/snake.jpg

Can the government say the Tea Party flag can be displayed despite homeowner's association rules, but the anti-Tea Party flag doesn't get to trump that contractual arrangement? In other words, is it OK for government to control the public debate by way of allowing private corporations and organizations to censor some ideas, while preventing them from censoring others? Is that any better, in effect, than the government censoring things directly?

To put it in an even more controversial light, what if the government were to pass a law saying corporations can't bar their workers from displaying Christian symbols at work, but they say nothing about corporations barring their workers from displaying Jewish or Muslim symbols at work? Would that favoritism be OK? I'd argue no, on the basis of the establishment clause of the First Amendment, but it's not as clear in a context where we're talking about other first amendment rights.

I find the whole area interesting, because it's so hard to come up with intellectually consistent rules.



See, it's a homeowner's association. Something you voluntarily join and pay dues to. If you agree to the rules at the outset, you must follow these rules.

This would (and should) apply to ANY flag.
 
See, it's a homeowner's associationSomething you voluntarily join and pay dues to. . If you agree to the rules at the outset, you must follow these rules.

This would (and should) apply to ANY flag.

Not entirely arguing with you CB...but look at your response-

"Something you voluntarily join and pay dues to. If you agree to the rules at the outset, you must follow these "

Why couldn't that be applied to a nation-state? Anyone can emigrate AWAY from the US....so you're "voluntarily joining". You're paying taxes or "dues". And if the rules say "Government can make decisions regarding public displays" (for instance we have laws against public nudity)....then you're "agreeing to the rules at the outset and must follow them"???

((Not picking a fight....strictly an academic exercise. Okay?))
 
Pretty close. More "small government" -- Republican style. I wouldn't even support an out for Old Glory. No flags means no flags. If you don't like it, either renegotiate the contract or move.

Yes, "small government" has stepped in, rather than stepped out.
 
Not entirely arguing with you CB...but look at your response-

"Something you voluntarily join and pay dues to. If you agree to the rules at the outset, you must follow these "

Why couldn't that be applied to a nation-state? Anyone can emigrate AWAY from the US....so you're "voluntarily joining". You're paying taxes or "dues". And if the rules say "Government can make decisions regarding public displays" (for instance we have laws against public nudity)....then you're "agreeing to the rules at the outset and must follow them"???

((Not picking a fight....strictly an academic exercise. Okay?))



I think I get your gist...but don't we do that already...with laws? I mean we MUST obey the nation-state's laws, right?
 
The stars 'n stripes are afforded unique status, as distinct from ALL other flags. We can agree to disagree as to whether that should be the case. Nevertheless, it IS the case.

So, we need to ask ourselves WHY we've not just been accepting of this distinction, but encouraging of it - especially as it relates to the flag's uniqueness (from our perspective).

And having arrived at that list of unique "whys", we need to ask ourselves not just if ANY of them apply to the Teabagger's flag, but how Brewer's ruling diminishes the value of the stars 'n stripes?
 
Since I don't fit very comfortably in either of those three niches, I'll offer my opinion. The contract that the homeowners voluntarily entered rules the situation and the state should keep their noses out of it.

;)

My feelings exactly.
 
My feelings exactly.

I think the idea of the U.S. Flag's exceptionalism, first goes to the idea of that flag being an avatar for the United States of America and second, that the U.S.A. is the source of all American contracts and therefore, supersedes them.
 
Pretty close. More "small government" -- Republican style. I wouldn't even support an out for Old Glory. No flags means no flags. If you don't like it, either renegotiate the contract or move.

That strikes me as intellectually consistent, but it's still problematic. We wouldn't say "if you don't like free speech limits imposed by the federal government, leave the country" (at least we wouldn't say that if we're not loons). And we wouldn't say "if you don't like free speech rules imposed by the state government, leave the state." Nor would we say, "if you don't like free speech rules imposed by the town government, leave the town." Yet, we're OK with saying "if you don't like free speech rules imposed by the government of your neighborhood homeowner's association, leave the neighborhood." Why?

One could argue the difference is that you CHOSE to join that association. But that's not necessarily true. Let's say you grew up in the house and then inherited it, and the homeowner's association rules attach to it. You can, of course, choose to leave. But, in the same sense, if you're born into a country with rules you don't like, you could leave that, too, and that's not an argument against preventing governments from censoring speech.

So, the differences between the two types of censorship, public and private, aren't as clear as they might seem at first. Both are governments to which you're voluntarily choosing to remain beholden, by not moving away, and both are limiting your ability to express yourself politically. There are, of course, practical differences (it's a lot easier to buy a house in a different neighborhood than move to a different country), but I think this still underscores how strange our double-standard is about the "freedom of contract" within private contracts vs. the social contract.
 
See, it's a homeowner's association. Something you voluntarily join and pay dues to. If you agree to the rules at the outset, you must follow these rules.

This would (and should) apply to ANY flag.

See my comments above. Yes, you might have voluntarily joined, just as you might have voluntarily moved to a particular state or town or to the US. But that, in itself, doesn't justify ignoring the individual rights once there, does it? For example, if someone immigrated to the American South at a time when blacks were legally segregated from whites, would it have then been OK to say "by moving there, you agreed to those rules, so you must follow those rules?" Or, to go even farther back, would it have been a dispositive argument of the Crown to tell the American colonists that by immigrating to those colonies they had agreed to all the laws they were now complaining about, so if they didn't like those laws, they should leave? That manner of thinking would be contrary to our deepest political traditions.

Now, of course, the majority of colonists at the time of the Revolution, and the majority of people living under the boot of Jim Crow were born into it, so that is admittedly a bit different. But there were some immigrants. And there are some people who are born into homeowners' associations -- raised in those communities, where the rule attaches to the house, and then they inherit the house. That doesn't seem terribly different from being born into the colonies, under the rule of the King, and then being told that if you don't like kissing his sovereign ass, you should leave.
 
That strikes me as intellectually consistent, but it's still problematic. We wouldn't say "if you don't like free speech limits imposed by the federal government, leave the country" (at least we wouldn't say that if we're not loons). And we wouldn't say "if you don't like free speech rules imposed by the state government, leave the state." Nor would we say, "if you don't like free speech rules imposed by the town government, leave the town." Yet, we're OK with saying "if you don't like free speech rules imposed by the government of your neighborhood homeowner's association, leave the neighborhood." Why?

One could argue the difference is that you CHOSE to join that association. But that's not necessarily true. Let's say you grew up in the house and then inherited it, and the homeowner's association rules attach to it. You can, of course, choose to leave. But, in the same sense, if you're born into a country with rules you don't like, you could leave that, too, and that's not an argument against preventing governments from censoring speech.

So, the differences between the two types of censorship, public and private, aren't as clear as they might seem at first. Both are governments to which you're voluntarily choosing to remain beholden, by not moving away, and both are limiting your ability to express yourself politically. There are, of course, practical differences (it's a lot easier to buy a house in a different neighborhood than move to a different country), but I think this still underscores how strange our double-standard is about the "freedom of contract" within private contracts vs. the social contract.


You'll notice, if you read my responses carefully, that "just leave" wasn't the only option. I also allowed for re-negotiation of the contract.
 
I have no problem with the government overturning the wishes of the homeowners association in this case. Flying the Gadsden flag is without a doubt political speech and therefore protected. I could understand if the association took exception with the dimensions or placement of a flag but it's not their job to dictate how a homeowner expresses his political views and I think reasonable people would see that any attempt to do so by a homeowners association is reaching far beyond their domain. Voluntarily signing a contract or not, this is exactly the sort of thing the government should get involved in.
 
All the homeowners association cares about is property value being diminished by garish decoration. When they see a teabagger flag, they ask themselves, "What will the neighborhood look like if everyone has a teabagger flag? Worse yet, what if half the neighborhood starts flying flags in response or opposition?"

I'd just egg his house.
 
I have no problem with the government overturning the wishes of the homeowners association in this case. Flying the Gadsden flag is without a doubt political speech and therefore protected. I could understand if the association took exception with the dimensions or placement of a flag but it's not their job to dictate how a homeowner expresses his political views and I think reasonable people would see that any attempt to do so by a homeowners association is reaching far beyond their domain. Voluntarily signing a contract or not, this is exactly the sort of thing the government should get involved in.

So then, you support the government stepping in to exclusively carve out an exception for a flag that you personally like, while simultaneously allowing all other flags to remain verboten?
 
Not entirely arguing with you CB...but look at your response-

"Something you voluntarily join and pay dues to. If you agree to the rules at the outset, you must follow these "

Why couldn't that be applied to a nation-state? Anyone can emigrate AWAY from the US....so you're "voluntarily joining". You're paying taxes or "dues". And if the rules say "Government can make decisions regarding public displays" (for instance we have laws against public nudity)....then you're "agreeing to the rules at the outset and must follow them"???

((Not picking a fight....strictly an academic exercise. Okay?))

I'll had one to this angle. IF when you sign the contract, the law is that the U.S. flag is exempt, doesn't that override anything in the contract that's to the contrary?
 
Back
Top