Arkady
President
This issue interested me, because it seems like one where people wouldn't fall into predictable left-right camps:
http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2011/04/19/159771/jan-brewer-tea-party-flag/?mobile=nc
I'm not so much interested in this decision to protect a particular Tea-Party-associated flag, but rather the broader question of whether the government should be overriding homeowner's associations to allow residents to fly certain flags the government likes.
This seems like something where neither a liberal, nor a conservative, nor a libertarian has a comfortable place to come down reflexively. For example, a libertarian would certainly object to rules against flying flags at your own home if the rules were made by the government. But in this case, the rules are made by a privatized government -- a democratically-elected homeowner's association leadership, which have legal force only because the homeowner submitted to them, contractually, as part of joining the association or buying into the neighborhood. So, where does the libertarian come down? Does he condemn the actual government for interfering in a private contractual matter? Or does he condemn the quasi-government for interfering in an individual's use of his own property? Or both?
It's also legally problematic, when you have government creating special rights, trumping private contracts, for some kinds of free speech and not others. What if I form an anti-Tea Party group that emphasizes the importance of a strong central government, and I use as a symbol a flag including another famous symbol from the revolutionary era:
http://www.earlyamerica.com/earlyamerica/firsts/cartoon/snake.jpg
Can the government say the Tea Party flag can be displayed despite homeowner's association rules, but the anti-Tea Party flag doesn't get to trump that contractual arrangement? In other words, is it OK for government to control the public debate by way of allowing private corporations and organizations to censor some ideas, while preventing them from censoring others? Is that any better, in effect, than the government censoring things directly?
To put it in an even more controversial light, what if the government were to pass a law saying corporations can't bar their workers from displaying Christian symbols at work, but they say nothing about corporations barring their workers from displaying Jewish or Muslim symbols at work? Would that favoritism be OK? I'd argue no, on the basis of the establishment clause of the First Amendment, but it's not as clear in a context where we're talking about other first amendment rights.
I find the whole area interesting, because it's so hard to come up with intellectually consistent rules.
http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2011/04/19/159771/jan-brewer-tea-party-flag/?mobile=nc
I'm not so much interested in this decision to protect a particular Tea-Party-associated flag, but rather the broader question of whether the government should be overriding homeowner's associations to allow residents to fly certain flags the government likes.
This seems like something where neither a liberal, nor a conservative, nor a libertarian has a comfortable place to come down reflexively. For example, a libertarian would certainly object to rules against flying flags at your own home if the rules were made by the government. But in this case, the rules are made by a privatized government -- a democratically-elected homeowner's association leadership, which have legal force only because the homeowner submitted to them, contractually, as part of joining the association or buying into the neighborhood. So, where does the libertarian come down? Does he condemn the actual government for interfering in a private contractual matter? Or does he condemn the quasi-government for interfering in an individual's use of his own property? Or both?
It's also legally problematic, when you have government creating special rights, trumping private contracts, for some kinds of free speech and not others. What if I form an anti-Tea Party group that emphasizes the importance of a strong central government, and I use as a symbol a flag including another famous symbol from the revolutionary era:
http://www.earlyamerica.com/earlyamerica/firsts/cartoon/snake.jpg
Can the government say the Tea Party flag can be displayed despite homeowner's association rules, but the anti-Tea Party flag doesn't get to trump that contractual arrangement? In other words, is it OK for government to control the public debate by way of allowing private corporations and organizations to censor some ideas, while preventing them from censoring others? Is that any better, in effect, than the government censoring things directly?
To put it in an even more controversial light, what if the government were to pass a law saying corporations can't bar their workers from displaying Christian symbols at work, but they say nothing about corporations barring their workers from displaying Jewish or Muslim symbols at work? Would that favoritism be OK? I'd argue no, on the basis of the establishment clause of the First Amendment, but it's not as clear in a context where we're talking about other first amendment rights.
I find the whole area interesting, because it's so hard to come up with intellectually consistent rules.