New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A Modest Proposal

You should have titled it an immodest proposal.
Nah. If I were being ambitious, I'd propose reforms like a public option, or Medicare for all, or transforming the private insurers into something more along a utility or non-profit model, similar to what they have in Germany. But that would be a lot for the current crop of Republicans to swallow, even if all those things would be a marked improvement. So I stuck with the modest proposal of a little tune-up of the individual market, plus a proposal regarding drug costs that Trump supported during the campaign. That's pretty modest.
 
As you know, I'm fine with you practicing your religious customs around diet, sexual practices, and personal dress/transportation, etc. Where I have a problem is when you try to force your Utopian theocracy upon me and other free peoples, where we, too, would be compelled to participate in your weather-panic religion (likely at gunpoint, as you people have tried to do with medical insurance).
I don't want you to participate in any panic-based religion, whether that's a weather-based one, or the cult of the market that says any government tinkering will lead directly to Ragnorok. I'm simply proposing a rational set of policy adjustments based on a level-headed interpretation of the best available science on the topic, consistent with what most leading experts advocate. I get that runs afoul of your faith, but I'm not a faith-based person, so my perspective is very different from yours.
 
Perfect analogy, except you forgot the part where your neighbors get stuck with the tab for the entire cost of you driving (and repairing) that old car. Other than that it was spot on...
If you want to extend the analogy that way, then it would be more like a public street system. The majority of people support the public street, but a vocal minority want to move to a system where there are only unregulated private streets with whatever tolls the owners feel like charging. Currently, the minority don't have the votes for that. But, in the meantime, the question is whether we should keep filling the potholes and doing other upkeep on the public streets, using public funds, or should we neglect them, in hopes that they'll fall apart so badly that any alternative, no matter how ugly, will look good by comparison? I'd say let's keep them well-maintained. If someone comes up with a better alternative in the future, great, but in the meantime, we'll have something decent.
 
Last edited:
So you're so self-important you think I keep track of what car you drive

No. What would be self-important would be assuming that you spend so much time thinking about me that you try to imagine what car I'm driving...... though, I guess, that ended up being true. Weird.
 
We could ask around among our neighbors in the world if any of them have a tried and tested used car at a bargain price instead of buying new.
Hehe. Good analogy. Essentially, Republicans want to go back to the nightmare clunker we used to have before we upgraded to Obamacare. Back then, we had a car that broke down far more often than normal and cost twice as much to maintain as anything else on the road. Better, instead, to upgrade to a better vehicle that will both save money and improve our driving experience.... any of the many other models driven by our neighbors would do it. But it's like the Republicans have an irrational aversion to fuel injection, and all the good vehicles have it, and so they're insisting we return to the trash heap of a vehicle we used to drive.
 
Last edited:
To take one specific example, imagine a harrowing scenario for Japan's healthcare system. Faced with their demographic crisis (an average age far above ours, with the corresponding healthcare costs) imagine if their per capita healthcare spending were to rise swiftly by 50% and their life expectancies were to plummet by a full two years. I know, that kind of apocalyptic scenario is a little unrealistic in light of the relatively manageable problems they have today, but just play along for the sake of argument. Where would they be after that unprecedented short-term explosion of healthcare costs and collapse in public health outcomes?

Well, where they'd be is that they'd have a system that was STILL costing a third less than ours, while still producing lifespans 2.4 years longer than ours. The US's system is the "post-apocalyptic" one. Even imagining fairly absurd crises for countries like Japan doesn't leave them in as bad a situation as we are today. And that's even AFTER Obamacare, which helped the US crawl a couple spots up the international life expectancy rankings while slowing the pace of our healthcare spending growth. Before Obamacare, we compared even more unfavorably to other countries.
 
No. What would be self-important would be assuming that you spend so much time thinking about me that you try to imagine what car I'm driving...... though, I guess, that ended up being true. Weird.
Eh. . .'scuze me but YOU brought up your car in the top post. Doesn't take a whole lotta creativity or time to imagine you driving a Prius.
 
I don't want you to participate in any panic-based religion, whether that's a weather-based one, or the cult of the market that says any government tinkering will lead directly to Ragnorok. I'm simply proposing a rational set of policy adjustments based on a level-headed interpretation of the best available science on the topic, consistent with what most leading experts advocate. I get that runs afoul of your faith, but I'm not a faith-based person, so my perspective is very different from yours.
Yes yes. It's all very level headed. Calm, sober, and approved by the leading experts. Even as it goes off the rails and plunges into the ravine it does so in an incredibly level headed manner.
 

Yeah because if there is one thing the private market is just itching to do is to insure old people. So Japan and Europe represent the exact problem the private market will not solve. Canada's problem is one the private market definitely won't solve because it's based upon better quality coverage for some over others.
 
Back
Top