New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

About all this "red line" stuff...

Bugsy McGurk

President
Where Pugs and the so-called news media claim that Obama's talk of a "red line" means that he promised war if there was a gas attack....

Has ANYBODY come up with ANYTHING backing up the notion that referring to a "red line" means a promise of war, and nothing else?

Anybody?
 
Where Pugs and the so-called news media claim that Obama's talk of a "red line" means that he promised war if there was a gas attack....

Has ANYBODY come up with ANYTHING backing up the notion that referring to a "red line" means a promise of war, and nothing else?

Anybody?

Ok. If not a military response, what did the President mean by the statement?
 
Ok. If not a military response, what did the President mean by the statement?

It can obviously mean anything - it's vague. It could mean massively suppyling the rebels with arms. It could mean a naval blockade. It could mean increased sanctions. It could mean taking the matter to the UN. It could mean anything.

It certainly does NOT necessarily mean a promise of war by the USA. If he had meant to promise war upon signficant gassing of people, he could have said precisely that. He did not.

Agreed?
 
It can obviously mean anything - it's vague. It could mean massively suppyling the rebels with arms. It could mean a naval blockade. It could mean increased sanctions. It could mean taking the matter to the UN. It could mean anything.

It certainly does NOT necessarily mean a promise of war by the USA. If he had meant to promise war upon signficant gassing of people, he could have said precisely that. He did not.

Agreed?

Agreed with the bolded. Those can be seen as diplomatic measures.

However,
Lets define our terms. A naval blockade is an act of war, so lets admit that outright. Supplying weapons to the rebel army is a military involvement. Not officially a war, but....

Fair enough?
 
It can obviously mean anything - it's vague. It could mean massively suppyling the rebels with arms. It could mean a naval blockade. It could mean increased sanctions. It could mean taking the matter to the UN. It could mean anything.

It certainly does NOT necessarily mean a promise of war by the USA. If he had meant to promise war upon signficant gassing of people, he could have said precisely that. He did not.

Agreed?

"It's vague" pretty much describes Obama's foreign policy -- but the point of putting down a red line is that a red line is NOT vague.

Nor was Obama's statement. He was asked about military intervention and he responded, ""We have communicated in no uncertain terms with every player in the region that that's a red line for us and that there would be enormous consequences if we start seeing movement on the chemical weapons front or the use of chemical weapons," he said. "That would change my calculations significantly."
 
Agreed with the bolded. Those can be seen as diplomatic measures.

However,
Lets define our terms. A naval blockade is an act of war, so lets admit that outright. Supplying weapons to the rebel army is a military involvement. Not officially a war, but....

Fair enough?

I won't quibble. My point is that it's daft for Pugs and the media to claim that Obama must now launch some attack on Syria to "preserve our credibility" because he said using gas was a red line. You seem to agree with that.
 
Where Pugs and the so-called news media claim that Obama's talk of a "red line" means that he promised war if there was a gas attack....

Has ANYBODY come up with ANYTHING backing up the notion that referring to a "red line" means a promise of war, and nothing else?

Anybody?

I have no idea what he meant by "red line", but I would say that HE should have known what he meant by red line... and well.. it doesn't seem like he thought that far ahead... Maybe he thought that Syria would just listen to him. Par for the course with him.. he thought that he would just be able to get Republicans to like him. I think he overestimates his people skills.

connie
 
"It's vague" pretty much describes Obama's foreign policy -- but the point of putting down a red line is that a red line is NOT vague.

Nor was Obama's statement. He was asked about military intervention and he responded, ""We have communicated in no uncertain terms with every player in the region that that's a red line for us and that there would be enormous consequences if we start seeing movement on the chemical weapons front or the use of chemical weapons," he said. "That would change my calculations significantly."

Again, you're simply pretending that he promised war by using the words "red line." Using those words (as opposed to simply threatening war expressly) was for the purpose of preserving flexibility. You now seem to argue that he should have expressly threatened war and not used language preserving flexibility, but that still does not convert the words "red line" to a promise to attack.
 
I have no idea what he meant by "red line", but I would say that HE should have known what he meant by red line... and well.. it doesn't seem like he thought that far ahead... Maybe he thought that Syria would just listen to him. Par for the course with him.. he thought that he would just be able to get Republicans to like him. I think he overestimates his people skills.

connie

Again, the words "red line" were used to preserve flexibility - I personally think that it's wise to defer a definitive decision on something (especially war) until all the facts come in. You think he should have "known" months ago that an outright attack was going to be the best response, but that seems daffy to me.
 
Again, the words "red line" were used to preserve flexibility - I personally think that it's wise to defer a definitive decision on something (especially war) until all the facts come in. You think he should have "known" months ago that an outright attack was going to be the best response, but that seems daffy to me.

Yes, I realize that planning ahead and developing contingency plans based on a variety of reasonably assumed variables would be "daffy" to you. You are a liberal..afterall...

connie
 
Yes, I realize that planning ahead and developing contingency plans based on a variety of reasonably assumed variables would be "daffy" to you. You are a liberal..afterall...

connie

You just admitted that Obama should have had a variety of approaches in mind when he used the "red line" words, after your prior post bashes him for using those words because he should have known back then what the best course would be now.

The full 180.

;-)
 
Again, you're simply pretending that he promised war by using the words "red line." Using those words (as opposed to simply threatening war expressly) was for the purpose of preserving flexibility. You now seem to argue that he should have expressly threatened war and not used language preserving flexibility, but that still does not convert the words "red line" to a promise to attack.

Only if you ignore that he was being asked, specifically, about military intervention. Then there's nothing vague about the response at all.
 
You just admitted that Obama should have had a variety of approaches in mind when he used the "red line" words, after your prior post bashes him for using those words because he should have known back then what the best course would be now.

The full 180.

;-)

Yes, he should have had a variety of different approaches. But, if this stunning lack of a reaction was one of them... he should have thought a little harder for another option.
 
Only if you ignore that he was being asked, specifically, about military intervention. Then there's nothing vague about the response at all.

Jeez, a politician who answers a different question than the one asked in order to advance his agenda and preserve flexibility....

Shocking!

;-)
 
I won't quibble. My point is that it's daft for Pugs and the media to claim that Obama must now launch some attack on Syria to "preserve our credibility" because he said using gas was a red line. You seem to agree with that.

If the President was ambiguous about what his intentions were, than he put himself in this position. No one is forcing the Commander in Chief to take action in Syria.
 
Yes, he should have had a variety of different approaches. But, if this stunning lack of a reaction was one of them... he should have thought a little harder for another option.

Huh? I'm not quite sure what your "refined whine" is.

He should have expressly threatened war back then? He should not have? He should not have decided to start a war back then? He should have?

Ya gotta work on those Obama-hate talking points for some truly coherent Obama-hating.

;-)
 
Jeez, a politician who answers a different question than the one asked in order to advance his agenda and preserve flexibility....

Shocking!

;-)

Please -- you'd be harshly critical of that viewpoint if the one imposing the red line had been George W. Bush. You don't get to set a double standard because you like this president and you didn't like George "Bring it On" Bush.
 
Back
Top