New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Affirmative Action

And why were the same liberal trolls silent when a Muslim bakery refused to do a gay wedding cake?

Liberals are the most bigoted people around.
I didn't hear about any such thing, but the issue is the same. If we're going to have rules against discriminating with a business of that sort, it should apply equally regardless of who is being discriminated against and what the religion of the period doing the discriminating is.
 
At the time my position was that if you're going to have rules limiting who businesses can discriminate against (e.g., you can't deny service to blacks, Jews, veterans, etc.), it's wrong to deny that protection for an equally vulnerable group, gays, simply to placate religious right-wingers.

Completely leaving out the 1st Amendment which not only protects free speech but RELIGION specifically. The anti-discriminations laws are unconstitutional especially when applied in this case given:

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof"

You laws are unconstitutional period.
 
Tilting a playing field the opposite way as the initial tilt can make it level.

An unconstitutional remedy for prior unconstitutional acts by the states visited upon the citizens, the vast majority having done nothing untoward to any minorities. It's done its job. Time to turn the lights off of the matter and close the door.
 
This isn't about federally mandated affirmative action. It's about whether the federal government should interfere in a private college's admissions in order to halt affirmative action.

Re-read my post:

I'm against federally mandated affirmative action of any kind. Colleges, corporations, businesses, and yes, federal agencies should be free from any coerced diversity.

Let the best man or woman win. Skin color shouldn't enter the equation at all. Period.
 
Word is the Trump administration is preparing to wade into the affirmative action issue by taking a stance against racial preferences by colleges. There are conflicting reports about whether this will be a more generalized effort, or just an effort related to the Harvard case (where some Asians sued about being passed over for lower-scoring applicants based in part on Harvard's effort to create a racially diverse student body).

I'm curious what people here think of this. It's an issue that should, in theory, divide libertarian conservatives from social conservatives. From a libertarian perspective, at least when it comes to private universities like Harvard, the government should butt out. Harvard is offering a product, and if they think their product is best situated in the market if what they're offering includes a student body with a fair number of blacks and Latinos, then the government shouldn't overrule them: let the market decide for itself by way of students deciding which colleges to go to. But, for social conservatives --which, let's be honest, is largely a euphemism for white supremacists-- this might look like an opportunity to reduce the number of the less-favored minorities at elite schools, while opening up more slots for white people, so they may be comfortable with the government intervening in the market, in this case.

For my own part, I'm conflicted about race-based affirmative action. On the one hand, if the choice were between race-based affirmative action and no affirmative action, I might come down in favor of it. It's a very blunt tool, but I can still see it serving the goal of making the student body more diverse in a real sense, thereby improving education in some ways, while, on average, lessening injustices more often than exacerbating them. But, I'd rather see class-based affirmative action, which I think accomplishes the same things with greater precision. There's more real diversity represented by having a broad spectrum of class background in a student body than merely having a pretty mix of melanin levels. And if it's about trying to counter historical injustices, you're going to target that a lot better if you give special consideration to those whose personal background actually shows they had more to overcome, rather than people whose race merely makes it statistically more likely that they did.

Looking at the example of Harvard, it's a private university. I am no libertarian, but for the government to demand that a private institution set up white-supremacist policies shocks the conscience. Harvard is also one of the few schools that actually uses standardized tests scores to discriminate among otherwise qualified applicants. (Most schools require them, but use them, if at all, to set a minimum score requirement, a use inconsistent with the manufacturer's recommendations.) Treating the scores of the rich and the poor, whites and Blacks, or men and women equally when the circumstances in which the scores are achieved are unequal allows the rich, whites, and men to get an unmerited advantage ... the main reason for elite schools' use of the SAT, a money-making racket that is less predictive of college success than high school grades.

It would take a social revolution to turn Harvard into anything but the finishing school of the upper class. They have always and will always recruit exceptionally talented people from poor backgrounds too, but their social function is to revitalize bourgeois culture and maintain the appearance of meritocracy. But a "class - based affirmative action" that didn't take into account differences in advantage at every class level due to racism would mean a lot of admissions of upper-class whites, middle-class whites, and lower-case whites. The issue is not whether a given student "deserves" to go to Harvard. There is no "best" Harvard student, only the mix of students that best serves Harvard. Harvard is a social institution that best serves society by, among other things, helping undercut the pervasive white supremacy by inserting racial diversity into the next crop of elites. And it's not as if they lack for promising applicants of any race.

Therefore, I support racial admissions quotas.
 
First off, you need to get over the fact that Harvard didn't want you. Man up.

Second, your equating of social conservatism with white supremacy is one of the reasons why no one here takes you seriously.

Regarding affirmative action, it comes directly from the mindset of people like you, who believe minorities are incapable of achieving on a level playing field. It's a symptom of your virulent racism, and a disgrace to American ideals.

If the playing field consistently advantages one race, that shows it's not level. Affirmative action is an effort to compensate for that unevenness.
 
I couldn't care less what a private business or institution uses as a metric for who it will, and will not do business with. The market will sort that one out pretty well. If you want to cut out a certain percentage of people from your profits, go for it.

But when it comes to government, there should never, ever, be codified racism, sexism or discrimination. Which is exactly what so-called 'Affirmative Action' is. The government is for all the people and should never favor one over the other regardless of minority or majority status.

A citizen is a citizen is a citizen. And all citizens should have the same rights, privileges and responsibilities as all other citizens in the government's eyes.

It's not about majority or minority. It's about oppressed and privileged, and whether groups are made more or less so by state intervention.

"A society that has done something special against the Negro for hundreds of years must now do something special for the Negro."-Martin Luther King
 
Completely leaving out the 1st Amendment which not only protects free speech but RELIGION specifically. The anti-discriminations laws are unconstitutional especially when applied in this case given:

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof"

You laws are unconstitutional period.

Free exercise isn't a license to disobey a law drafted for legitimate reasons having nothing to do with your religion.
 
An unconstitutional remedy for prior unconstitutional acts by the states visited upon the citizens, the vast majority having done nothing untoward to any minorities. It's done its job. Time to turn the lights off of the matter and close the door.

It's not just "prior unconstitutional acts by the states." It's an ongoing and pervasive set of interlocking white-supremacist institutions.
 
Re-read my post:

I'm against federally mandated affirmative action of any kind. Colleges, corporations, businesses, and yes, federal agencies should be free from any coerced diversity.

Let the best man or woman win. Skin color shouldn't enter the equation at all. Period.

Your assumption is that whites are twice as likely as Blacks to be admitted to elite colleges with inferior SAT scores and grades because they are "the best" and not because of the racial advantages they haven't received their entire lives.
 
Free exercise isn't a license to disobey a law drafted for legitimate reasons having nothing to do with your religion.

Actually, it is.

Evidently laws are made that are unconstitutional. One such example were the separate but equal laws. Another two are Affirmative Action and non-discrimination laws. The last two unconstitutional laws were a remedy for what the state did and it is now being imposed on individual citizens and it is time for individual freedom to be re-instated before it is too late.
 
Word is the Trump administration is preparing to wade into the affirmative action issue by taking a stance against racial preferences by colleges. There are conflicting reports about whether this will be a more generalized effort, or just an effort related to the Harvard case (where some Asians sued about being passed over for lower-scoring applicants based in part on Harvard's effort to create a racially diverse student body).

I'm curious what people here think of this. It's an issue that should, in theory, divide libertarian conservatives from social conservatives. From a libertarian perspective, at least when it comes to private universities like Harvard, the government should butt out. Harvard is offering a product, and if they think their product is best situated in the market if what they're offering includes a student body with a fair number of blacks and Latinos, then the government shouldn't overrule them: let the market decide for itself by way of students deciding which colleges to go to. But, for social conservatives --which, let's be honest, is largely a euphemism for white supremacists-- this might look like an opportunity to reduce the number of the less-favored minorities at elite schools, while opening up more slots for white people, so they may be comfortable with the government intervening in the market, in this case.

For my own part, I'm conflicted about race-based affirmative action. On the one hand, if the choice were between race-based affirmative action and no affirmative action, I might come down in favor of it. It's a very blunt tool, but I can still see it serving the goal of making the student body more diverse in a real sense, thereby improving education in some ways, while, on average, lessening injustices more often than exacerbating them. But, I'd rather see class-based affirmative action, which I think accomplishes the same things with greater precision. There's more real diversity represented by having a broad spectrum of class background in a student body than merely having a pretty mix of melanin levels. And if it's about trying to counter historical injustices, you're going to target that a lot better if you give special consideration to those whose personal background actually shows they had more to overcome, rather than people whose race merely makes it statistically more likely that they did.
you do know it's racist for thinking minorities are incapable of achieving anything without the assistance of a Helping hand.
 
It's not about majority or minority. It's about oppressed and privileged, and whether groups are made more or less so by state intervention.

"A society that has done something special against the Negro for hundreds of years must now do something special for the Negro."-Martin Luther King

When will the negro start doing something special for themselves? A drive through most black neighborhoods will tell any reasonable person blacks don't care much if at all about doing something special. Shouldn't they be expending some effort?
 
Word is the Trump administration is preparing to wade into the affirmative action issue by taking a stance against racial preferences by colleges. There are conflicting reports about whether this will be a more generalized effort, or just an effort related to the Harvard case (where some Asians sued about being passed over for lower-scoring applicants based in part on Harvard's effort to create a racially diverse student body).

I'm curious what people here think of this. It's an issue that should, in theory, divide libertarian conservatives from social conservatives. From a libertarian perspective, at least when it comes to private universities like Harvard, the government should butt out. Harvard is offering a product, and if they think their product is best situated in the market if what they're offering includes a student body with a fair number of blacks and Latinos, then the government shouldn't overrule them: let the market decide for itself by way of students deciding which colleges to go to. But, for social conservatives --which, let's be honest, is largely a euphemism for white supremacists-- this might look like an opportunity to reduce the number of the less-favored minorities at elite schools, while opening up more slots for white people, so they may be comfortable with the government intervening in the market, in this case.

For my own part, I'm conflicted about race-based affirmative action. On the one hand, if the choice were between race-based affirmative action and no affirmative action, I might come down in favor of it. It's a very blunt tool, but I can still see it serving the goal of making the student body more diverse in a real sense, thereby improving education in some ways, while, on average, lessening injustices more often than exacerbating them. But, I'd rather see class-based affirmative action, which I think accomplishes the same things with greater precision. There's more real diversity represented by having a broad spectrum of class background in a student body than merely having a pretty mix of melanin levels. And if it's about trying to counter historical injustices, you're going to target that a lot better if you give special consideration to those whose personal background actually shows they had more to overcome, rather than people whose race merely makes it statistically more likely that they did.

Well, by the same token, if Harvard is offering a product and wants to make its own racial choices, the local hole-in-the-wall bar should be able to make its own choices by excluding members of this or that race, too. That reasoning was, of course, rejected by the courts a half century ago.

Unlike you, I'm not conflicted about race-based affirmative action. I recognize it for what it is -- a racist practice put in place to assuage white guilt after Jim Crow. But you're a "racist" if you say this anywhere in a genuine public forum. "But, but, but," sputter the nattering class of liberals, "a colorblind process ignores the ongoing structural racism in society."

To which my response is simple. I don't care. Denying a race admission because of its race, or favoring a race's admission because of its race, is discrimination based on race. Racial discrimination is wrong, no matter how laudable the intent. Further, I think it is ludicrous that Obama's children are eligible for affirmative action, but the children of my blue collar friends are told "you're white, hence privileged, shut up and pay the bills."

I tend to agree with you that any affirmative action should include a large amount determination based on class.
 
Back
Top