New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Affirmative Action

This originates from a lawsuit by 64 Asians who allege they were discriminated against by Harvard, to make room for less qualified African American/Hispanic applicants.

I guess Asians don't like to be told to go to the back of the bus any more than the rest off us do, eh?
 
\ok there is no need for it.
Why do you imagine it's all or nothing?

Let's think of it in terms of a sport. Let's say you're holding a race, where some competitors show up with the best running shoes money can buy, and others have worn out or ill-fitting shoes, or no shoes at all. One could argue that the fairest way to hold the race would be to distribute decent shoes to those who don't already have them, so that people are on more or less an even playing field at the start. Taking that position would not mean you think that those without decent shoes are incapable of running without help. They'll be able to run even without decent shoes, and some may run so well they'll beat those who had a big footwear advantage over them. But pointing that out doesn't mean there's no need to address the shoe situation. If you want the highest quality competition, on the fairest basis, you should prevent one set of competitors from having an unfair advantage over another set at the starting line. That's how supporters of affirmative action see the question. They acknowledge that some who have had to deal with racial disadvantage in this country may, nevertheless, do even better than those who had white privilege on their side. But that doesn't mean you just ignore that unfair advantage, if you can do something to counter it and create a more even playing field.
 
Why do you imagine it's all or nothing?

Let's think of it in terms of a sport. Let's say you're holding a race, where some competitors show up with the best running shoes money can buy, and others have worn out or ill-fitting shoes, or no shoes at all. One could argue that the fairest way to hold the race would be to distribute decent shoes to those who don't already have them, so that people are on more or less an even playing field at the start. Taking that position would not mean you think that those without decent shoes are incapable of running without help. They'll be able to run even without decent shoes, and some may run so well they'll beat those who had a big footwear advantage over them. But pointing that out doesn't mean there's no need to address the shoe situation. If you want the highest quality competition, on the fairest basis, you should prevent one set of competitors from having an unfair advantage over another set at the starting line. That's how supporters of affirmative action see the question. They acknowledge that some who have had to deal with racial disadvantage in this country may, nevertheless, do even better than those who had white privilege on their side. But that doesn't mean you just ignore that unfair advantage, if you can do something to counter it and create a more even playing field.
Why do you support a racist agenda such as affirmative action? it's giving preference of once race over another.
 
Why do you support a racist agenda such as affirmative action? it's giving preference of once race over another.
I suppose this is a semantic thing, but many define racism only has racial prejudice against a disadvantaged group. Regardless of what term you want to use, though, the idea would be that racial preferences that are designed to enforce white supremacy are very different, morally, from racial preferences that are designed to counteract an existing inequity. To go back to the analogy I used, it would be very different if you, say, gave people who showed up to that race with good shoes a head start as well, versus if you provided free loaner shoes to the people who showed up with bad shoes or no shoes. In each case, you're conferring a benefit to a group of people based on their shoe situation, but from a fairness perspective, they're very different things -- it's a matter of whether you're diminishing a pre-existing unfairness, or making one even worse.
 
I suppose this is a semantic thing, but many define racism only has racial prejudice against a disadvantaged group. Regardless of what term you want to use, though, the idea would be that racial preferences that are designed to enforce white supremacy are very different, morally, from racial preferences that are designed to counteract an existing inequity. To go back to the analogy I used, it would be very different if you, say, gave people who showed up to that race with good shoes a head start as well, versus if you provided free loaner shoes to the people who showed up with bad shoes or no shoes. In each case, you're conferring a benefit to a group of people based on their shoe situation, but from a fairness perspective, they're very different things -- it's a matter of whether you're diminishing a pre-existing unfairness, or making one even worse.
You can suppose til the cows come home it's not going to change. IT'S RACIST TO THINK ONE RACE CANNOT ACHIEVE WHAT THEY SEEK WITHOUT ASSISTANCE.
 
When will the negro start doing something special for themselves? A drive through most black neighborhoods will tell any reasonable person blacks don't care much if at all about doing something special. Shouldn't they be expending some effort?

You assume that the state of "black neighborhoods" ... or the very fact that there are "black neighborhoods" ... reflects Black apathy rather than white supremacy.
 
There has been a lot of stuff on our local news lately about the Ravens checking out Kaepernick. Ray Lewis like Michael Vick a few weeks before him - basically said Kaepernick needs to shut his yapper, clean up his image and be serious about football.

Of course, social media and comments on articles was full of the people calling our formerly LOVED player - a house negro - just like Vick before.

Until within their own culture blacks and other disadvantaged groups stop looking at figuring out how to play the game, how to get ahead, how to get what you want for your share out of life, as "sell outs", house n!ggers, etc.. they will never get ahead. Its a culture problem... not an actual access problem.

They rightly pointed out that teams welcomed back Lewis and Vick.. with open arms after their actual criminal problems. WHY? Because they did and said all the right things. I am sorry, I will be better - I will conform.

It is not as if whites don't have these pressures too. If you want to mingle with and ingratiate yourself with those who have what you want.. you need to model your behavior, mannerisms and language - after theirs. But the downward pressure within the black community and other ethnic communities to "stay true to their roots" - prohibits their full assimilation - as it did every other group of disadvantaged whites among other whites. And those that have done so... like the poor in Appalachia have remained - poor, disadvantaged and excluded. And why so many people who came here- changed their names to anglo sounding ones - denying their lesser origins. They knew - that they needed to loose their "roots" to embrace opportunities offered by another culture.

As long as your culture of origin and your "roots" are more important to you than embracing the norms, ideals and patterns of success you will not ever actually live up to your full potential. Yes of course there is racism, there is on both sides, there always will be on both sides. But, I think the vast majority of people - even if initially influenced by some supressed racism are willing to give anyone a chance. The problem is - that those in power and with money generally want someone - willing to model their behavior - OR be such an original that you are entertaining. Otherwise, no they don't want you. But then don't whine when you refuse to make yourself fit in as well as possible - that you are still left out.

So, as you see it, it's not OK for Bob down the street to punish Chick-fil-A for encouraging discrimination against gay people buy choosing not to buy their chicken ... but it is OK for the NFL owners to punish Kaepernick for discouraging the serial murder of unarmed Black people by blacklisting him?
 
Last edited:
In practice, ffirmative action doesn't give systemic advantages to Blacks and Latinos. It merely likits the extent to which whites receive systemic advantages.

Negative...........affirmative action demanded a Woman be on every construction team or company would not get the contract.......and allows blacks with grades that couldn't get them into college, entrance or else!

AA is both sexist and racist..........
 
So, as you see it, it's not OK for Bob down the street to punish Chick-fil-A for encouraging discrimination against gay people buy choosing not to buy their chicken ... but it is OK for the NFL owners to punish Kaepernick for discouraging the serial murder of unarmed Black people by blacklisting him?

Blacks kill blacks at alarming rates and Kae learned Americans don't like players that hate our flag..............your excuse is pure bullshit.
 
You assume that the state of "black neighborhoods" ... or the very fact that there are "black neighborhoods" ... reflects Black apathy rather than white supremacy.

Yes. Because white people are not making them trash their own neighborhoods. White people are not making them not pick up trash or going in there and vandalize things. They don't need to put up bars to keep white people out.
 
So, as you see it, it's not OK for Bob down the street to punish Chick-fil-A for encouraging discrimination against gay people buy choosing not to buy their chicken ... but it is OK for the NFL owners to punish Kaepernick for discouraging the serial murder of unarmed Black people by blacklisting him?

He was paid to show up on the football field but to have an opinion. That is why he is being punished.
 
A court attempting to a create a special rule just for those holding state-favored religious beliefs would be exactly the kind of government intervention in religion that the Founders were attempting to avoid. For example, it would be wrong to say that evangelical Christians are allowed to discriminate against gays, if they cite their religion, but that others aren't allowed to discriminate against, say, veterans based on pacifistic religious beliefs, or Jews, based on anti-Semitic religious beliefs, or women, based on misogynistic religious beliefs. Unless we want to go all in and allow any discrimination if a person cites his religion, then it's problematic to have courts deciding that some religions get to trump our laws and others don't.

Discrimination should not be unlawful anymore because the anti-discrimination laws are plainly unconstitutionally applied to individuals. I.e. religious excuse not needed.
 
Back
Top