New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Affirmative Action

If the playing field consistently advantages one race, that shows it's not level. Affirmative action is an effort to compensate for that unevenness.
And with the word "compensate" you have admitted your own racism as well. Thank you.
 
It's not about majority or minority. It's about oppressed and privileged, and whether groups are made more or less so by state intervention.

"A society that has done something special against the Negro for hundreds of years must now do something special for the Negro."-Martin Luther King

The government has no mandate in the Constitution to do anything about oppressed or privileged. It does have a mandate to treat everyone equally. Equality...remember that?
 
It's not just "prior unconstitutional acts by the states." It's an ongoing and pervasive set of interlocking white-supremacist institutions.

No, it's an ongoing and pervasive culture of victim-hood established by laws like Affirmative Action and the Civil Rights act.
 
Thank you for finally admitting your racism. It's a first step.

I've always *loved* the "leveling the playing field" meme. In reality, it's the players who get leveled, not the field.

Leveling the field would mean things like liberals releasing blacks kept on the plantation of failing schools and government dependence. But of course, blacks independent of government aid are a leftist's worst nightmare.
 
Completely leaving out the 1st Amendment which not only protects free speech but RELIGION specifically. The anti-discriminations laws are unconstitutional especially when applied in this case given:

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof"

You laws are unconstitutional period.
A court attempting to a create a special rule just for those holding state-favored religious beliefs would be exactly the kind of government intervention in religion that the Founders were attempting to avoid. For example, it would be wrong to say that evangelical Christians are allowed to discriminate against gays, if they cite their religion, but that others aren't allowed to discriminate against, say, veterans based on pacifistic religious beliefs, or Jews, based on anti-Semitic religious beliefs, or women, based on misogynistic religious beliefs. Unless we want to go all in and allow any discrimination if a person cites his religion, then it's problematic to have courts deciding that some religions get to trump our laws and others don't.
 
An unconstitutional remedy for prior unconstitutional acts by the states visited upon the citizens, the vast majority having done nothing untoward to any minorities. It's done its job. Time to turn the lights off of the matter and close the door.
Certainly it's been doing its job, in the sense that it almost certainly played a part in the huge decline in the gap between disadvantaged minorities and the majority when it comes to socioeconomic indicators. But that gap is still quite substantial. So, the opponents of affirmative action need to focus on explaining why it's too broad a brush for the "fine strokes" we still need to do. They'd do better if they also explained what instrument they'd rather see us using.
 
you do know it's racist for thinking minorities are incapable of achieving anything without the assistance of a Helping hand.
Nobody has argued that minorities are incapable of achieving anything without such policies. Obviously, a policy could be a good way for making the system more equitable overall without that meaning that minorities are completely helpless without it.
 
Well, by the same token, if Harvard is offering a product and wants to make its own racial choices, the local hole-in-the-wall bar should be able to make its own choices by excluding members of this or that race, too. That reasoning was, of course, rejected by the courts a half century ago.

Unlike you, I'm not conflicted about race-based affirmative action. I recognize it for what it is -- a racist practice put in place to assuage white guilt after Jim Crow. But you're a "racist" if you say this anywhere in a genuine public forum. "But, but, but," sputter the nattering class of liberals, "a colorblind process ignores the ongoing structural racism in society."

To which my response is simple. I don't care. Denying a race admission because of its race, or favoring a race's admission because of its race, is discrimination based on race. Racial discrimination is wrong, no matter how laudable the intent. Further, I think it is ludicrous that Obama's children are eligible for affirmative action, but the children of my blue collar friends are told "you're white, hence privileged, shut up and pay the bills."

I tend to agree with you that any affirmative action should include a large amount determination based on class.
There are at least three ways to come out on this:
(1) private organizations can discriminate however they want
(2) private organizations can't discriminate at all
(3) private organizations can discriminate, but only in ways that are consistent with public policy objectives (e.g., the objective of diminishing overall disadvantage of disadvantaged minorities in the society)

Conservatives want to present it as a choice between the first two options, but there is the third one, as well.
 
I've always *loved* the "leveling the playing field" meme. In reality, it's the players who get leveled, not the field.

Leveling the field would mean things like liberals releasing blacks kept on the plantation of failing schools and government dependence. But of course, blacks independent of government aid are a leftist's worst nightmare.
I'm a lefty and I'd love to believe that traditionally disadvantaged groups like blacks would be better served by the broader society taking no active steps to mitigate that situation. After all, I'm wealthy and white, and it would be nice if I could lower my taxes, improve my kid's chance of getting into a good college (and my chances of getting a promotion), and yet still feel I was doing the right thing by those who've gotten a raw deal from our system. It's a very tempting picture for someone like me. Blacks being independent from government aid would be a dream. But I'm level-headed enough to understand that just because I'd like something to be true doesn't mean it is.
 
There are at least three ways to come out on this:
(1) private organizations can discriminate however they want
(2) private organizations can't discriminate at all
(3) private organizations can discriminate, but only in ways that are consistent with public policy objectives (e.g., the objective of diminishing overall disadvantage of disadvantaged minorities in the society)

Conservatives want to present it as a choice between the first two options, but there is the third one, as well.

I have no objection to your third option, per se, but it seems unlikely to be ever offered as an actual public policy. Given that, the real world options do come down to a choice between the first and second options you list. And given those two real-world options, I'd frankly choose option 1. It might not have worked 60 years ago, but given the changed climate we see today, I think it would work. If not, at the very least, it provides choices instead of mandates.
 
I'm a lefty and I'd love to believe that traditionally disadvantaged groups like blacks would be better served by the broader society taking no active steps to mitigate that situation. After all, I'm wealthy and white, and it would be nice if I could lower my taxes, improve my kid's chance of getting into a good college (and my chances of getting a promotion), and yet still feel I was doing the right thing by those who've gotten a raw deal from our system. It's a very tempting picture for someone like me. Blacks being independent from government aid would be a dream. But I'm level-headed enough to understand that just because I'd like something to be true doesn't mean it is.

The overall picture looks like this to me: blacks continue to whine and complain while the rest of us are supposed to open our wallets, forgive and ignore horrible behavior, keep blaming whitey and keep our wallets open to the people doing a lot of whining and little doing.

In general, I am willing to help others in proportion to what I see them doing for themselves.
 
I have no objection to your third option, per se, but it seems unlikely to be ever offered as an actual public policy. Given that, the real world options do come down to a choice between the first and second options you list. And given those two real-world options, I'd frankly choose option 1. It might not have worked 60 years ago, but given the changed climate we see today, I think it would work. If not, at the very least, it provides choices instead of mandates.
I think the third option is essentially what we have in place right now -- private universities are permitted to discriminate in favor of traditionally disadvantaged minorities (which is seen as benefiting the society overall, as well as benefiting them by way of the market advantage of being seen as diverse), but they aren't permitted to discriminate against such groups.
 
I think the third option is essentially what we have in place right now -- private universities are permitted to discriminate in favor of traditionally disadvantaged minorities (which is seen as benefiting the society overall, as well as benefiting them by way of the market advantage of being seen as diverse), but they aren't permitted to discriminate against such groups.

I confess I sort of misread your third option. I'd say you're right that It's largely what is in existence now, and if it were satisfactory, we wouldn't be having the conversation we're having now. It fails for exactly the reason you outlined above -- it treats races differently while ignoring class. Rich black people get affirmative action, poor whites get told to shut up and pay the bills.
I don't know the answer. There was a time when we had no affirmative action, but it was basically a time when we also had Jim Crow laws and I'm not advocate of returning to that.
My girlfriend is Asian and has two children in college. They get no benefit from affirmative action -- it doesn't apply to Vietnamese. Racial discrimination is racial discrimination, in my view.
 
The overall picture looks like this to me: blacks continue to whine and complain while the rest of us are supposed to open our wallets, forgive and ignore horrible behavior, keep blaming whitey and keep our wallets open to the people doing a lot of whining and little doing.

In general, I am willing to help others in proportion to what I see them doing for themselves.

There has been a lot of stuff on our local news lately about the Ravens checking out Kaepernick. Ray Lewis like Michael Vick a few weeks before him - basically said Kaepernick needs to shut his yapper, clean up his image and be serious about football.

Of course, social media and comments on articles was full of the people calling our formerly LOVED player - a house negro - just like Vick before.

Until within their own culture blacks and other disadvantaged groups stop looking at figuring out how to play the game, how to get ahead, how to get what you want for your share out of life, as "sell outs", house n!ggers, etc.. they will never get ahead. Its a culture problem... not an actual access problem.

They rightly pointed out that teams welcomed back Lewis and Vick.. with open arms after their actual criminal problems. WHY? Because they did and said all the right things. I am sorry, I will be better - I will conform.

It is not as if whites don't have these pressures too. If you want to mingle with and ingratiate yourself with those who have what you want.. you need to model your behavior, mannerisms and language - after theirs. But the downward pressure within the black community and other ethnic communities to "stay true to their roots" - prohibits their full assimilation - as it did every other group of disadvantaged whites among other whites. And those that have done so... like the poor in Appalachia have remained - poor, disadvantaged and excluded. And why so many people who came here- changed their names to anglo sounding ones - denying their lesser origins. They knew - that they needed to loose their "roots" to embrace opportunities offered by another culture.

As long as your culture of origin and your "roots" are more important to you than embracing the norms, ideals and patterns of success you will not ever actually live up to your full potential. Yes of course there is racism, there is on both sides, there always will be on both sides. But, I think the vast majority of people - even if initially influenced by some supressed racism are willing to give anyone a chance. The problem is - that those in power and with money generally want someone - willing to model their behavior - OR be such an original that you are entertaining. Otherwise, no they don't want you. But then don't whine when you refuse to make yourself fit in as well as possible - that you are still left out.
 
the "quota system" mandated percentages of population be given "special consideration" in hiring, education, grants, loans etc. it was the forerunner to AA..when it was rightly ruled to be unconstitutional and rescinded, the wording was tweaked and AA was implemented.

AA is racist, sexist and discriminatory. just as the failed quota system was. [if it looks, waddles and quacks like a duck, its a duck]

the "level the playing field" meme is nonsense.

the left has never realized you cannot correct racism, sexism and discrimination from their past by shifting those same things onto others.

that just makes those targeted angry.
 
I confess I sort of misread your third option. I'd say you're right that It's largely what is in existence now, and if it were satisfactory, we wouldn't be having the conversation we're having now. It fails for exactly the reason you outlined above -- it treats races differently while ignoring class. Rich black people get affirmative action, poor whites get told to shut up and pay the bills.
I don't know the answer. There was a time when we had no affirmative action, but it was basically a time when we also had Jim Crow laws and I'm not advocate of returning to that.
My girlfriend is Asian and has two children in college. They get no benefit from affirmative action -- it doesn't apply to Vietnamese. Racial discrimination is racial discrimination, in my view.
I'm certainly very conscious of the class issue. There's one particular co-worker I always think of when race-based affirmative action comes up. He identifies as Hispanic, based on his father being Argentinian, and he gets special consideration from that, in the name of "diversity." Yet the truth is, he does almost nothing to add to the diversity of the department, since he's about as stereotypical for an elite lawyer as you'll find. His father is a top doctor at MGH, his mother serves on the board of various local non-profits, his siblings are all doctors and lawyers, he attended Phillips Exeter and then private universities and law schools, his background includes all the usual unpaid internships and prestige enrichment programs that rich kids use to build their resumes. He has a typical upper-class American accent and doesn't speak a word of Spanish and you'd never peg him as Hispanic based on name or appearance. Yet, from the employer's perspective, he's a member of an underrepresented and traditionally disadvantaged group, and deserves extra help, even though he's one of the most advantaged people working there. Meanwhile, a non-Hispanic white lawyer who grew up in poverty and worked his way through college and law school at night is treated as privileged and needs to be extra good to hope to compete.

And I know just what you're talking about with Vietnamese people -- they're characterized as "Asian" and get no special help, even though as a community they tend to be disadvantaged. The same thing happens to most Muslims -- they fall into the Asian bucket and get no help-- which is especially ironic, since they're probably one of the most disadvantaged groups in modern America, given the amount of open hostility against them.

Still, you could make an argument in favor of racial affirmative action, despite those individual injustices, if you saw it as a choice between race-based affirmative action and no affirmative action. Basically, if race-based affirmative action diminishes inequities three times for every two times it exacerbates them, the argument would be that it's a net positive. I can see the allure of that argument, but I'd counter that it needn't be a choice between race-based affirmative action or no affirmative action, since we could do class-based affirmative action, instead, and get a much better ratio of inequity-reduction to inequity-exacerbation.
 
Nobody has argued that minorities are incapable of achieving anything without such policies. Obviously, a policy could be a good way for making the system more equitable overall without that meaning that minorities are completely helpless without it.
You are the one who started this thread and affirmative action is racist because you are saying Blacks cannot achieve anything without assistance. So you are saying it. RACIST.
 
You are the one who started this thread and affirmative action is racist because you are saying Blacks cannot achieve anything without assistance. So you are saying it. RACIST.
Please, identify where, exactly, you imagine you saw me say blacks can't achieve anything without assistance. When you realize I never actually said anything like that, let me know and we can continue.
 
Back
Top