New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Airline Collusion?

Arkady

President
Anyone check out airfares lately? I was expecting to find some bargains, since fuel costs have nose-dived, and when fuel costs move in the other direction the airlines use it as an excuse to hike prices. To my surprise, there isn't a bargain to be found. The airlines have all somehow coordinated a decision to pocket the savings (which have cut almost 50% from their costs), rather than passing them along to my consumers. I'd like the government to start investigating this for anti-trust violations. In a properly functioning market, we'd expect at least a couple of the airlines to decide they're actually better served by using the lower costs to cut prices and grab market share. The absence of that kind of pricing strategy is suggestive of some illegal back-room deal among the airline bosses.
 
Anyone check out airfares lately? I was expecting to find some bargains, since fuel costs have nose-dived, and when fuel costs move in the other direction the airlines use it as an excuse to hike prices. To my surprise, there isn't a bargain to be found. The airlines have all somehow coordinated a decision to pocket the savings (which have cut almost 50% from their costs), rather than passing them along to my consumers. I'd like the government to start investigating this for anti-trust violations. In a properly functioning market, we'd expect at least a couple of the airlines to decide they're actually better served by using the lower costs to cut prices and grab market share. The absence of that kind of pricing strategy is suggestive of some illegal back-room deal among the airline bosses.


Really? I found a few bargains. It depends on things like.....Where you want to go, and how far in advance you book, and day of the week you fly on.

I don't think we need to hit the panic button just yet. And I certainly don't think we need the government to come on in and "fix it". Yikes!
 
Anyone check out airfares lately? I was expecting to find some bargains, since fuel costs have nose-dived, and when fuel costs move in the other direction the airlines use it as an excuse to hike prices. To my surprise, there isn't a bargain to be found. The airlines have all somehow coordinated a decision to pocket the savings (which have cut almost 50% from their costs), rather than passing them along to my consumers. I'd like the government to start investigating this for anti-trust violations. In a properly functioning market, we'd expect at least a couple of the airlines to decide they're actually better served by using the lower costs to cut prices and grab market share. The absence of that kind of pricing strategy is suggestive of some illegal back-room deal among the airline bosses.

Mergers. Over the past decade or so, we've lost much of the competitive arena. From KLM and AirFrance to American and US Air, it's sheer madness.

There are, quite simply, far fewer airlines operating than previously. Southwest bought AirTran, their largest competitor. In just the last few years: United buys Continental; Delta and Northwest merge; Republic buys Midwest and Frontier; American and US Air merge; British Airways and Iberia merge.

In some cases, the names and livery remain in order to appear as separate entities to the public eye.
 
Last edited:
Anyone check out airfares lately? I was expecting to find some bargains, since fuel costs have nose-dived, and when fuel costs move in the other direction the airlines use it as an excuse to hike prices. To my surprise, there isn't a bargain to be found. The airlines have all somehow coordinated a decision to pocket the savings (which have cut almost 50% from their costs), rather than passing them along to my consumers. I'd like the government to start investigating this for anti-trust violations. In a properly functioning market, we'd expect at least a couple of the airlines to decide they're actually better served by using the lower costs to cut prices and grab market share. The absence of that kind of pricing strategy is suggestive of some illegal back-room deal among the airline bosses.

CNN had an "expert" on about airline fares before Christmas. He said airline prices would not drop due to lower fuel costs. He claims that most U.S. cities and the hotels in them subsidize airfare so those subsidies would just disappear or be reduced to keep the flight prices the same.

He appears to be right.
 
Really? I found a few bargains. It depends on things like.....Where you want to go, and how far in advance you book, and day of the week you fly on.

I don't think we need to hit the panic button just yet. And I certainly don't think we need the government to come on in and "fix it". Yikes!
I'm looking for a flight in late May, to Europe, and bargain-hunting hasn't turned up anything decent. Prices are the same as they were last year, even though the fuel costs of the airlines are vastly lower.
 
Mergers. Over the past decade or so, we've lost much of the competitive arena. From KLM and AirFrance to American and US Air, it's sheer madness.

There are, quite simply, far fewer airlines operating than previously. Southwest bought AirTran, their largest competitor. In just the last few years: United buys Continental; Delta and Northwest merge; Republic buys Midwest and Frontier; American and US Air merge; British Airways and Iberia merge.

In some cases, the names and livery remain in order to appear as separate entities to the public eye.
I think that's factoring in, but there are still, for most routes (including the ones I'm looking at), several independent airlines competing, so there should still be price competitiveness. That's why I suspect that what's happening here is that the decrease in the number of companies is making it easier to collude. The fewer conspirators, the more likely an industry is to be able to pull off a conspiracy. If all you need are five or ten CEOs doing a "nudge, nudge, wink wink," rather than twenty or thirty, price-fixing is a real possibility.
 
I'm looking for a flight in late May, to Europe, and bargain-hunting hasn't turned up anything decent. Prices are the same as they were last year, even though the fuel costs of the airlines are vastly lower.

Boston to Paris, about $850 round trip.

Is that unreasonable?
 
I think that's factoring in, but there are still, for most routes (including the ones I'm looking at), several independent airlines competing, so there should still be price competitiveness. That's why I suspect that what's happening here is that the decrease in the number of companies is making it easier to collude. The fewer conspirators, the more likely an industry is to be able to pull off a conspiracy. If all you need are five or ten CEOs doing a "nudge, nudge, wink wink," rather than twenty or thirty, price-fixing is a real possibility.

I agree the rates do not reflect the steep decline in fuel costs.

collusion? perhaps. a gouge? likely..
 
This article claims airlines hedge against fuel price swings and all seats are full so dropping prices won't happen. I fly a lot so I am always searching for airfare.

http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/breaking/chi-airlines-cheaper-fuel-20150120-story.html
I'm aware of the hedging mechanisms. It's actually something that has been part of my practice in the past -- ISDAs, which are the contracts used for hedging fuel pries. But, when fuel prices go up, the airlines consistently cite those rises, notwithstanding the hedging instruments, as the reason fares have to be increased. That suggests that they do pricing in a way that fuel cost swings aren't fully hedged against... the airline shares in the upside cost, and so it is almost certainly sharing in the downside savings.

You can see what's going on here pretty easily, just by comparing the airline index (blue line) against the S&P 500 (yellow).

charts.dll


Since mid-October, the airlines have had their stock prices diverge greatly from the overall market. Where the market is up around 6%, the airlines are up about 27%. By not using the lower fuel costs to lower their fares, they're padding their balance sheets. Ordinarily, in such a situation, we'd expect someone to decide to break ranks and offer discount fares, to build market share against their competitors, and that competition would force others to cut costs, too. Instead, they're all keeping their fares suspiciously high.
 
Boston to Paris, about $850 round trip.

Is that unreasonable?
It's consistent with what the prices were last year, when the airlines' costs were much lower. The difference is showing up in big stock gains for the airlines.
 
Ever sit in a plane and think about what the cost of fuel,maintenance,insurance and labor are for each flight from point A to point B is? Airlines are not non-profit businesses. Think they were turning much profit when a gallon of gas was $3.75?
 
Ever sit in a plane and think about what the cost of fuel,maintenance,insurance and labor are for each flight from point A to point B is? Airlines are not non-profit businesses. Think they were turning much profit when a gallon of gas was $3.75?

I agree 100%.

One article I read said the airlines are finally able to pay down some debt recently.
 
I agree 100%.

One article I read said the airlines are finally able to pay down some debt recently.
I'm more concerned about the major airlines discontinuing routes to regional airports than the price of airfare.
 
Anyone check out airfares lately? I was expecting to find some bargains, since fuel costs have nose-dived, and when fuel costs move in the other direction the airlines use it as an excuse to hike prices. To my surprise, there isn't a bargain to be found. The airlines have all somehow coordinated a decision to pocket the savings (which have cut almost 50% from their costs), rather than passing them along to my consumers. I'd like the government to start investigating this for anti-trust violations. In a properly functioning market, we'd expect at least a couple of the airlines to decide they're actually better served by using the lower costs to cut prices and grab market share. The absence of that kind of pricing strategy is suggestive of some illegal back-room deal among the airline bosses.

I don't think it is collusion. But, certainly they are checking out each other's prices and pricing accordingly. And, the internet makes that very easy to do. The info is all there.

The reality is - many airlines have had some substantial losses when fuel was high, and they are highly leveraged. They need some big profit years. They need it so they can continue to get financing, to build a nest egg for when fuel prices go back up, for additional regulations, etc. They need to pay down their debt, etc. Moreover, prices don't respond that quickly. Depending on how they purchase and store their fuel or existing contracts for fuel supplies - they could be locked in to prices from 6 months ago or more. They can't just change that on a dime, just like it is months of higher fuel costs before you see it in the prices.

I would imagine if fuel stays the same or goes lower the prices for flights that start to come available in the spring will have lower prices. But, they aren't going to speculate that 5 months from now fuel will still be down, so they will lower their price.

connie
 
I don't think it is collusion. But, certainly they are checking out each other's prices and pricing accordingly. And, the internet makes that very easy to do. The info is all there.

The reality is - many airlines have had some substantial losses when fuel was high, and they are highly leveraged. They need some big profit years. They need it so they can continue to get financing, to build a nest egg for when fuel prices go back up, for additional regulations, etc. They need to pay down their debt, etc. Moreover, prices don't respond that quickly. Depending on how they purchase and store their fuel or existing contracts for fuel supplies - they could be locked in to prices from 6 months ago or more. They can't just change that on a dime, just like it is months of higher fuel costs before you see it in the prices.

I would imagine if fuel stays the same or goes lower the prices for flights that start to come available in the spring will have lower prices. But, they aren't going to speculate that 5 months from now fuel will still be down, so they will lower their price.

connie
When fuel prices rose, fares went up quickly.

Maybe it's not collusion. It's so tough to tell. If the airline execs are smart about it, it leaves no traces. It can literally be a matter of a few CEOs at an industry conference button-holing each other and signalling that they'll avoid passing along the savings if the others do, and then the CEOs return to their companies and set the strategy of building up the balance sheet, as if it was an individual strategy, rather than coordinated price-fixing, and the only way the anti-competitive action can be proven is if one of the CEOs breaks ranks and rats the others out, which he has no incentive to do (since his own stock options will pay off bigger if the conspiracy holds together).

It certainly wouldn't be the first time the airlines have faced price-fixing claims. In the early 90s, airlines settled a huge class action claim about price fixing. Other examples:

http://www.dw.de/deutsche-bahn-sues-airlines-over-price-fixing/a-18103348
http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/09/24/usa-airlines-antitrust-idUSL2N0RP22G20140924
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/07/airline-price-fixing-fine_n_832133.html

That third link indicates 9 executives have been charged with wrongdoing, and four have gone to prison, and 21 airlines have paid over $1.7 billion in fines as part of that criminal antitrust investigation. That one only succeeded because two of the airlines ratted out their co-conspirators. If they'd kept their mouth shuts, it never could have been proven.
 
I'm looking for a flight in late May, to Europe, and bargain-hunting hasn't turned up anything decent. Prices are the same as they were last year, even though the fuel costs of the airlines are vastly lower.

There may be a little hope for you. I'm guessing the airlines are still amortizing the higher price fuel they locked up last year. I suggest we keep an eye on what Southwest does (of course SW won't take you to Europe!) I'm not in bed with SW. I willingly duped myself into an Alaska Visa card with airline miles. BUT, SW has always presented as sort of an outlier helping to keep all the other airlines honest.
 
There may be a little hope for you. I'm guessing the airlines are still amortizing the higher price fuel they locked up last year. I suggest we keep an eye on what Southwest does (of course SW won't take you to Europe!) I'm not in bed with SW. I willingly duped myself into an Alaska Visa card with airline miles. BUT, SW has always presented as sort of an outlier helping to keep all the other airlines honest.
Unfortunately, I have to lock in my airline ticket shortly. The best deal, at the moment, is Emirates, which flies some flights through Europe en route to Dubai.
 
Unfortunately, I have to lock in my airline ticket shortly. The best deal, at the moment, is Emirates, which flies some flights through Europe en route to Dubai.

Fortunately for me, I've never had to pay for my own bidness flights. But, as to personal/entertainment flights...my trick is to choose vacation sites around some sort of civil unrest. That seems to drive prices down. For instance all of Mexico and South America are pretty good values right about now, because the average American is scared shitless of the drug cartels. Add that to the fact that the average American can't seem to separate Islamicist terrorism in Europe, from goings on south of our border and you've got a double bonanza.
 
Fortunately for me, I've never had to pay for my own bidness flights. But, as to personal/entertainment flights...my trick is to choose vacation sites around some sort of civil unrest. That seems to drive prices down. For instance all of Mexico and South America are pretty good values right about now, because the average American is scared shitless of the drug cartels. Add that to the fact that the average American can't seem to separate Islamicist terrorism in Europe, from goings on south of our border and you've got a double bonanza.
I've used similar strategies in the past. For example, book a cruise right after there's lots of news about problems on cruise ships, and you get a great bargain. I had an awesome cruise on the sister ship of the Costa Concordia, shortly after that accident, at an extremely low price, because people were wary of the perceived risk, even though it was probably safer then than ever, since people were exceptionally focused on safety.
 
Back
Top