New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

An ACA question for smart Conservatives

Spamature

President
How is it better for a person who has a health condition to work more hours and there by shorten their life and lower the quality of their life in order to be able to pay for the health care needed to treat their condition ?

Than it would be for that person to be able to decided to work less if they choose. If they believe working less will help extend their lives and improve the quality of the same.
 
How is it better for a person who has a health condition to work more hours and there by shorten their life and lower the quality of their life in order to be able to pay for the health care needed to treat their condition ?

Than it would be for that person to be able to decided to work less if they choose. If they believe working less will help extend their lives and improve the quality of the same.

It is not better for that person.

It is however better for the other taxpayers who get to keep more of their money. Thus possibly - lowering the hours they have to work to achieve the standard of living they want.
 
It is not better for that person.

It is however better for the other taxpayers who get to keep more of their money. Thus possibly - lowering the hours they have to work to achieve the standard of living they want.

So if you had a medical condition that was aggravated when you performed your job. It would not be better for you to work less and avoid that if you had the opportunity ?

Why so ?

Also as I posted to in another thread the taxpayer who are taxed more are people with an income from investment of more than $250k and even up to $450k before they start to kick in. That is not money from WORKING.
 
So if you had a medical condition that was aggravated when you performed your job. It would not be better for you to work less and avoid that if you had the opportunity ?

Why so ?

It would be better for me if I had such a condition.

It is not better for the people who will then have to support or subsidize me so that I can have my better life - who would be providing me that opportunity. It matters not to anyone else, if I am sick and work is painful or hard for me. Their life is not impacted at all by whether or not I can work. but, it is impacted by the inevitable increase in their tax obligations which go to fund me for sitting on my ass. Even if that may be better for me and may be what I want to do and provide me with a happier life.

connie
 
How is it better for a person who has a health condition to work more hours and there by shorten their life and lower the quality of their life in order to be able to pay for the health care needed to treat their condition ?

Than it would be for that person to be able to decided to work less if they choose. If they believe working less will help extend their lives and improve the quality of the same.

Good for them, probably sucks for the people paying for them.
 
It would be better for me if I had such a condition.

It is not better for the people who will then have to support or subsidize me so that I can have my better life - who would be providing me that opportunity. It matters not to anyone else, if I am sick and work is painful or hard for me. Their life is not impacted at all by whether or not I can work. but, it is impacted by the inevitable increase in their tax obligations which go to fund me for sitting on my ass. Even if that may be better for me and may be what I want to do and provide me with a happier life.

connie

Wow ?!?!?

I suppose a fire fighter should be just concerned with putting out the fire and shouldn't run into a burning building to save a child that is not theirs. Why should they care. Maybe a stranger shouldn't concern themselves with a person whose car has flipped over in a ditch on a deserted back road or help search for a missing child.

But people do that kind of stuff and its a better world because others are not completely consumed by their own well being and aspirations for material wealth.
 
Good for them, probably sucks for the people paying for them.

You do understand how insurance works right. A person gets treated with a million dollars worth of cancer treatments While all those other suckers paying in foot the bill. Of course all of you conservative are completely invincible and know you will never actually need dip into the insurance pool yourselves. So it is in no way hypocritical to have this attitude towards others.
 
How is it better for a person who has a health condition to work more hours and there by shorten their life and lower the quality of their life in order to be able to pay for the health care needed to treat their condition ?

Than it would be for that person to be able to decided to work less if they choose. If they believe working less will help extend their lives and improve the quality of the same.

There financially more stable alternatives.

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/a-viable-alternative-to-the-affordable-care-act.57028/
 
It is not better for that person.

It is however better for the other taxpayers who get to keep more of their money. Thus possibly - lowering the hours they have to work to achieve the standard of living they want.
Guess what? If someone with a malady is able to retire earlier, someone healthy finds a good job and starts paying taxes. How does that raise your tax burden?
 
You do understand how insurance works right. A person gets treated with a million dollars worth of cancer treatments While all those other suckers paying in foot the bill. Of course all of you conservative are completely invincible and know you will never actually need dip into the insurance pool yourselves. So it is in no way hypocritical to have this attitude towards others.

You do understand how subsidies work, right? Who do you think pays to subsidize all these losers getting these killer plans for little to nothing while the rest of us see our premiums continue to rise? Furthermore, do you understand how car insurance works? It's called paying for risk. Lots of tickets? You pay more? If one voluntarily does things detrimental, they should pay more. Fat people should pay up. Smokers should pay up.

Hope that helps.
 
Wow ?!?!?

I suppose a fire fighter should be just concerned with putting out the fire and shouldn't run into a burning building to save a child that is not theirs. Why should they care. Maybe a stranger shouldn't concern themselves with a person whose car has flipped over in a ditch on a deserted back road or help search for a missing child.

But people do that kind of stuff and its a better world because others are not completely consumed by their own well being and aspirations for material wealth.


Piss poor analogy, sport.

First of all a firefighter should be concerned with saving any/everyone that he can because, pay attention here, this is where so many of you loons on the left get lost...........he should because it is something that HE asked to do, something HE agreed to do in exchange for "X" amount of dollars that others would give TO him for what he provides.

Now...................Compare THAT to your beloved obamicare.........

SOME of YOU are demanding that OTHER PEOPLE be assigned the duty of "saving" EVERYONE. Themselves AND any who can/do not do for themselves.

Is THIS "saving" everyone they can something those other people ASKED to do as the fire fighter did in YOUR analogy?

NOPE.......

Is this "saving" everyone they can something that those you want to be responsible for doing agreed to do for "X" amount of dollars?

NOPE..........

Matter of fact, many have ASKED to NOT do this AND not only are they forced to do so anyway, they will NOT receive pay for doing it, they will instead ALSO be forced to fund the "saving" of everyone, themselves.

So to use your firefighter/obamicare analogy properly as a society we would all get to not ONLY vote to force SOME among us to "save" everyone, we would also get to force them to PAY for it themselves.

Isn't the same, sorry, try again.
 
Wow ?!?!?

I suppose a fire fighter should be just concerned with putting out the fire and shouldn't run into a burning building to save a child that is not theirs. Why should they care. Maybe a stranger shouldn't concern themselves with a person whose car has flipped over in a ditch on a deserted back road or help search for a missing child.

But people do that kind of stuff and its a better world because others are not completely consumed by their own well being and aspirations for material wealth.

Well, i guess it depends on what you determine is a better world. Yes, thankfully there are brave men and women who risk their lives for others. That is a complete strawman argument against the ever increasing requests for wealth redistribution.
 
Guess what? If someone with a malady is able to retire earlier, someone healthy finds a good job and starts paying taxes. How does that raise your tax burden?

Because its unlikely that that person getting the job and paying taxes - is paying in MORE than that old person is now taking out.

But, its pathetic that this is what your argument is down to... its acutally good to have all these people on the dole - it frees up other jobs. Hey how about this - we find ways to increase jobs AND keep people off the dole.
 
How is it better for a person who has a health condition to work more hours and there by shorten their life and lower the quality of their life in order to be able to pay for the health care needed to treat their condition ?

Than it would be for that person to be able to decided to work less if they choose. If they believe working less will help extend their lives and improve the quality of the same.

Kind of broad..isnt it..

What sort of medical condition.. are there alternative types of work
how is the condition exacerbated.. can the cause of exacerbation be limited or avoided... what if working helps from a mental health perspective..combat depression and all..

or is working the condition? ;-)
 
Because its unlikely that that person getting the job and paying taxes - is paying in MORE than that old person is now taking out.

But, its pathetic that this is what your argument is down to... its acutally good to have all these people on the dole - it frees up other jobs. Hey how about this - we find ways to increase jobs AND keep people off the dole.
Clever. We were talking about someone near retirement age deciding to take it earlier because of a health problem, Slick.

Your "translation" is that I was saying everyone should go on the dole to open up some jobs.

Y'all do great with your straw men. They always say what Rush tells you they will. Doesn't really work that well when you respond to what's actually written. Just makes you look reeeeeeeally phony and intellectually bankrupt.
 
Kind of broad..isnt it..

What sort of medical condition.. are there alternative types of work
how is the condition exacerbated.. can the cause of exacerbation be limited or avoided... what if working helps from a mental health perspective..combat depression and all..

or is working the condition? ;-)
The sort that conforms to the description. Unlikely to be every one you can think of. How about a 62 year old painter with a lung condition? Is that an obscure example? Would you like to pay to retrain him to become a computer analyst? Many people in office jobs are dying from stress. Might they feel that they'd live longer if they retired earlier?

I took SS early because no one would hire me. I don't resent the younger guy who they all hired instead. Doubt that he resents me drawing SS, either. And I'm not even sick.
 
Clever. We were talking about someone near retirement age deciding to take it earlier because of a health problem, Slick.

Your "translation" is that I was saying everyone should go on the dole to open up some jobs.

Y'all do great with your straw men. They always say what Rush tells you they will. Doesn't really work that well when you respond to what's actually written. Just makes you look reeeeeeeally phony and intellectually bankrupt.

And, that person near retirement age - is costing money. And, that money will likely not be fully repaid by the person who is now taking their job. Are you saying he can retire with no additional cost on the system - well... okey dokey - awesome, he should retire and give a young person a job.

You all are the funny ones, trotting out Rush Limbaugh every time. I have never actually listened to the man more than what you see occasionally linked here or played on the news. But by all means continue to blame him. I am sure he is happy about the effect on his ratings.
 
what health condition, specifically?

this is the problem with left wing approaches to entitlements - every situation seems to require extreme government intervention or subsidy
 
The sort that conforms to the description. Unlikely to be every one you can think of. How about a 62 year old painter with a lung condition? Is that an obscure example? Would you like to pay to retrain him to become a computer analyst? Many people in office jobs are dying from stress. Might they feel that they'd live longer if they retired earlier?

I took SS early because no one would hire me. I don't resent the younger guy who they all hired instead. Doubt that he resents me drawing SS, either. And I'm not even sick.


Why would I pay for him to become a computer analyst?
What shouldnt he pursue another occupationif he so desired? one that doesnt exacerbate his condition?
Many people die from the feeling of uselessness..and lack of purpose that a job provides..

many sides to it...
 
How is it better for a person who has a health condition to work more hours and there by shorten their life and lower the quality of their life in order to be able to pay for the health care needed to treat their condition ?

Than it would be for that person to be able to decided to work less if they choose. If they believe working less will help extend their lives and improve the quality of the same.
"smart conservatives" in this forum? You can count 'em all on one hand.
 
Back
Top